Scenario profile
- Business
- Example: Fallow Creek Orthopedic Associates (5 physicians)
- Industry
- Orthopedic surgery and sports medicine specialty practice
- Size
- Five orthopedic surgeons, two physician assistants, three practice nurses, a practice manager and four front-desk and scheduling staff
- Setting
- One suburban office open 8 am to 5 pm on weekdays; surgery at a community hospital and an outpatient surgery center, about 45 cases a week across the group
- Call volume
- About 85 calls a week outside office hours, roughly 12 a night
Key takeaways
- In this example about three in ten after-hours calls were office questions, yet every one became a message for a nurse to return the next morning.
- The modelled setup does not triage: emergency language gets the approved 911 line, and any call about how a patient is doing is offered the on-call physician.
- Post-op patients would reach the physician while still on the line, instead of waiting for a callback from a number they may not answer.
- The setup is built to keep health details out of the phone agent's part of the call; patient messages go to the practice's own voicemail line and portal.
- Every figure here is modelled from the sources listed, not measured at a real practice.
The practice in this example
Fallow Creek Orthopedic Associates is a fictional practice, built to show how the rules and the numbers would work. Five surgeons cover joints, sports injuries, spine, hand, and foot and ankle. They operate at a community hospital and an outpatient surgery center, about 45 cases a week, many of them joint replacements. More than 700,000 total knee replacements are performed in the US each year[1], and each of those patients goes home with a number to call.
In this example the practice takes about 85 calls a week outside office hours, roughly 12 a night. They bunch up where any orthopedic office would expect: the two nights after a heavy surgery day, Sunday evening and the hour after closing. For years the main number has rolled to a message-only answering service at 5 pm.
What the nights looked like before
The service did one job. Operators took a name, date of birth, callback number and reason from every caller, paged the on-call surgeon when a message matched the service's urgent list, and emailed every message, paged or not, to the practice in one batch at 7 am.
In this example the practice manager sorts four weeks of those messages. About 3 in 10 were office questions: the fax number for an FMLA form, directions to the surgery center, holiday hours. A quarter were appointments, forms, billing and records. About 3 in 10 were about how a patient was doing: pain, a dressing, swelling, a splint that felt too tight. The rest were hospitals, pharmacies, wrong numbers and sales calls.
The clinical calls took the slowest path. The page reached the surgeon as a secondhand note, and the surgeon called back from a personal mobile twenty minutes later. Eight in ten Americans say they don't generally answer their cellphone when an unknown number calls[2]. So the callback rang out, the surgeon left a voicemail that could say almost nothing, and the patient, now more worried, was getting in the car.
The office questions had the opposite problem: each became a message a nurse returned the next morning, between post-op callbacks. And the page list said “any post-op patient”, so operators paged for a work note because the caller mentioned surgery. With 41.9% of physicians in the AMA's 2025 data reporting at least one symptom of burnout[3], these surgeons wanted fewer pages that did not need a surgeon, and faster contact on the ones that did.
The rules the physicians signed
The first decision in the modelled setup is what the SI Employee will not do. It does not triage: it asks nothing about symptoms, never decides that something can wait, gives no advice and takes no health details. It answers office questions from approved facts, gives the approved 911 line for emergency language and puts clinical calls through to a physician.
In this example the five surgeons sign one page of rules. The 911 list is written in caller words and includes the warning signs their own knee patients are taught at discharge: OrthoInfo lists sudden shortness of breath and sudden chest pain as signs that a blood clot may have reached the lung after a knee replacement[1].
- Emergency language first. A caller who describes a sign on the signed list hears the approved line, “Please hang up and call 911 now”, and no follow-up questions.
- Any call about how a patient is doing is offered a physician. Pain, a wound, a cast, swelling, fever, a medicine: the phone agent asks nothing more and offers the on-call physician now or the nurses' message line. A caller who is unsure or does not choose is put through.
- Hospitals, emergency departments, urgent care centers and pharmacies are put straight through to the on-call physician.
- No pain-medication refills after hours. The approved line says the nurses handle refill requests from 8 am, and offers the on-call physician to anyone whose pain cannot wait.
- Appointments, forms, billing and records wait for the morning: the caller hears the scheduling line hours and the portal, and nothing is taken down.
- Office questions are answered from the approved list, and the call ends there.
Transfers go to one tested number: the on-call line, which the practice's phone system points at whoever holds call that week. Nothing on that path may end in voicemail, surgeons' mobiles included: a transfer that reaches a voicemail box counts as answered, so the fallback never runs. If nobody picks up, the caller returns to the phone agent, hears the physicians' fallback line (if it cannot wait, go to the nearest emergency department or call 911) and leaves only a name and callback number, emailed to the shared on-call inbox. A surgeon who answers gets the patient cold, which the physicians prefer to a secondhand note.
- Caller
- SI Employee
- Your team
01Caller
Call at 11:40 pm
Eight days after knee surgery, a patient says her dressing looks wrong and she is worried.
02SI Employee
Greeting and 911 line
Practice name, automated-assistant and recording notice, then the standard 911 reminder.
03SI Employee
No symptom questions
Hears the call is about her recovery, stops, and asks nothing about the wound.
04SI Employee
Offers doctor or morning
On-call physician now, or the nurses' message line overnight; she picks the physician.
05Your team
On-call physician answers
The transfer rings the on-call line and she talks to the surgeon while still on the call.
06Your team
Nurses see it at 7:45
The surgeon's chart note opens the morning huddle and a nurse books a wound check.
Example: fictional practice and rules. A real setup follows the rules the physicians sign.
Example clinical-call script, approved by the physicians: “I can't give medical advice or take medical details, but I can get you to someone who can. I can put you through to the on-call doctor now, or give you the nurses' message line, which takes voicemail overnight and is cleared from 8 in the morning. If you're not sure, I'll put you through. Which would you like?”
The nurses' message line is a direct number in the practice's own phone system, so whatever a patient says about their recovery stays with the practice. The old answering service handled protected health information under a business associate agreement, which HIPAA requires before a vendor creates, receives, maintains or transmits it for a practice[4]. AssistCall does not sign those agreements today, so the SI Employee's part of the call is built to keep health details out. The portal is the other route: 65% of US individuals were offered and accessed a patient portal or online record in 2024[5].
Before and after, call by call
| After-hours moment | Before (message-only answering service) | After (modelled setup) |
|---|---|---|
| Fax number for an FMLA form at 9:10 pm | Message taken; a nurse returns it the next morning | Answered from the approved office facts; call closed |
| Post-op patient worried about a dressing at 11:40 pm | Surgeon paged, then calls back from a number the patient may not pick up | Offered the on-call physician and put through while still on the line |
| Caller describes sudden chest pain and breathlessness | Operator's script varies; message taken and surgeon paged | Approved 911 line at once, no follow-up questions; on the physician lead's Friday review list |
| Emergency department physician calling about a patient | Message and page; the surgeon calls the department back | Put straight through to the on-call physician |
| Pain-medication refill request at 10 pm | Message, sometimes paged, depending on the operator | Physicians' refill line read; on-call physician offered if the pain cannot wait |
| Request to move a post-op visit | Message in the 7 am batch for a nurse to sort | Scheduling line hours and portal given; nothing left to return |
| Nurses arrive at 7:45 am | One emailed batch of every message, in no order | On-call chart notes first, then missed transfers, then the message line |
The number of patients who need a surgeon at night would not change. The route would: live instead of by callback, and office questions answered on the call instead of turned into messages.
What the numbers would look like
The worked example models nurse time each weekday morning spent returning overnight messages that were office questions, wrong numbers or sales calls, which the modelled setup would close at night. The hourly figure is the May 2025 median pay for US registered nurses[6]; the volume, minutes and share are invented. Appointment and billing messages are left out: those callers would ring the scheduling line in the morning, so that work would move, not disappear.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Overnight messages per weekday morning | 17 |
| Nurse minutes to return one message | 6 |
| Share the new setup would close at night | 35% |
| Hourly pay of a registered nurse | $46.90 |
| Calls a month | 369 |
| Staff hours on these calls | 37 |
| Hours handed off | 13 |
| Monthly value of that staff time | $606 |
How it is worked out: Calls a day × 21.7 working days × minutes per call ÷ 60 × share handled = hours; hours × hourly cost.
Assumptions
- Hourly cost of $46.90, the May 2025 median pay for US registered nurses, before benefits.[6]
- Benefits would add about half again: private health care and social assistance employers' total cost for registered nurses was $79.02 an hour worked in June 2026, $52.14 of it wages.[7]
- Seventeen messages a weekday morning (85 a week over five mornings) and six nurse minutes to return and note each one are invented for this example.
- Office questions, wrong numbers and sales calls made up a little under four in ten messages in this example; the model rounds down to 35% because not every office question will be on the approved list.
Example only: modelled, not measured. Wages before benefits, so the modelled cost is on the low side.
In this example that comes to about 13 nurse hours a month, roughly $600 at that rate. The money is small. The timing is not: those hours sit at the start of the morning, when post-op patients are waiting for their first callback, and clearing them would move every clinical callback earlier.
The bigger change would be on the on-call phone: the patient still on the line when the surgeon answers, and no more pages about work notes.
The morning handoff to the nurses
In the modelled setup the nurses would work three sources in a fixed order instead of one emailed batch.
7:45 On-call notes
Read the on-call surgeon's chart notes and book any same-day visit or wound check asked for.
8:00 Missed transfers
Call every name left after an unanswered transfer, unless the surgeon already has.
8:10 Message line
Clear the nurses' voicemail, post-op patients first, with every callback started by 10 am.
8:40 Call list
Skim the overnight call list for the time and outcome of each call. Anything clinical belongs in the chart, not the call log.
Friday review
Every 911 line and missed transfer goes to the physician lead's weekly review, with the signed rules beside it.
Missed transfers come first because they are the only calls where a patient asked for a surgeon and may not have reached one. The daily voicemail routine covers the rest.
The first 30 days in this example
Day 1
Surgeons sign the one-page rules: 911 words, what goes to on-call, refills, fallback line.
Day 5
Practice manager and privacy officer approve the greeting, the office facts and which staff can open call transcripts.
Day 9
Fictional test calls: a dressing worry, chest pain mid-refill, an ED physician, a missed transfer.
Day 12
Weeknights forward to the new setup; the answering service keeps weekends for now.
Day 26
Weekends switch over after the physician lead reviews every transfer and 911 line.
Day 30
Practice reviews every missed transfer and compares the 8 am queue and first-callback time with the month before.
Example timeline; a real rollout follows the practice's own schedule.
Through the first month the physician lead keeps two lists: transfers a surgeon felt could have waited, and morning voicemails that should have been a transfer. The first costs sleep. The second is a safety problem, so any entry on it changes the script wording that week.
Lessons from the scenario
- Decide what the phone agent will not do before deciding what it will. Here that meant no triage, on any call.
- Write the 911 list in the words patients use, and include the warning signs your own discharge sheets teach.
- Keep voicemail off everything a transfer can ring, or a missed transfer looks like a connected one.
- Judge the month by missed transfers, the size of the 8 am queue and how early the first post-op callback starts, not by how many calls were answered.
The rules borrow from on-call escalation rules, when to tell a caller to dial 911, answering service vs in-house after-hours coverage and questions to ask about AI phone agents and HIPAA. The current feature list for an SI Employee is on what it does.
Frequently asked questions
Is Fallow Creek Orthopedic Associates a real practice?
No. It is a fictional practice used to show the method, and every figure is modelled from the sources listed or invented for the example.
Does the SI Employee triage post-op symptoms?
No. In this example it asks no questions about symptoms, gives no advice and never decides that a call can wait. It gives the approved 911 line for emergency language and offers the on-call physician on any call about how a patient is doing; anyone unsure is put through. The clinical judgement stays with the surgeons, as in on-call escalation rules.
Why not let it take the overnight messages instead of the old service?
Because the setup is built to keep health details out of the call. A vendor that creates, receives, maintains or transmits protected health information for a practice needs a business associate agreement, and AssistCall does not sign one today. Patient messages go to the practice's own voicemail line or portal instead. Callers can still volunteer details, so at setup the practice agrees with AssistCall what the account keeps, and decides which staff can open recordings and transcripts.
What happens if the on-call physician does not answer the transfer?
The caller comes back to the phone agent, hears the physicians' fallback line and leaves a name and callback number only. That message is emailed to the shared on-call inbox, and the nurses call it first the next morning if the surgeon has not already.
Do callers know they are not talking to a person?
Yes. In this example the greeting names the practice, says the caller is speaking with an automated assistant and gives a recording notice before anything else. See AI phone agents and HIPAA for the other questions to settle before go-live.
References
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (2026). Total Knee Replacement (OrthoInfo) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Medical Association (2026). AMA: Physician burnout rates are falling, specialty gaps remain (press release) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS (2025). Individuals' Access and Use of Patient Portals and Smartphone Health Apps, 2024 (Data Brief No. 77) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Registered Nurses (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4: private industry workers by occupational and industry group, June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑