Key takeaways
- Per-minute pricing rewards short calls, per-call pricing rewards long ones, and packages reward steady volume; none is cheapest for every practice.
- The definition of a billable minute matters as much as the rate. One state bid counted time spent trying to reach the responder and connecting the caller[2].
- Rounding is a hidden rate. Billing to the second, as one university contract did[3], and rounding each call up to a whole minute can differ by half on short calls.
- Price a full year of your own call profile under each model, quiet months and busy ones, before choosing.
Four ways services bill, and what each one rewards
Answering services sell the same thing, a trained person on your line, in four different units. The unit decides which of your calls are expensive. A per-minute plan punishes the long, anxious 11 p.m. call; a per-call plan punishes the wrong numbers and hang-ups; a package punishes the quiet month. Before comparing any rates, know which unit you are being quoted and what it quietly rewards.
| Model | You pay for | Rewards | Where it bites |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per minute | Billable minutes, sometimes with a first-minute premium | Short, routine calls | Anxious callers, interpreter calls, slow pages |
| Per call | Each call, sometimes priced by call type | Long calls of a predictable kind | Hang-ups, wrong numbers and repeat callers, if they count |
| Package | A monthly fee for an allowance of minutes or calls, then overage | Steady volume close to the allowance | Quiet months, when unused time is still paid for |
| Per agent hour | Agent time, whether or not calls arrive | High, steady volume with dedicated agents | Long nights with few calls |
Mixed contracts are common in public procurement, where the price sheets are published. A university health service's after-hours contract priced nurse calls per call and non-clinical calls per minute, with a monthly minimum on top[3]. A 2024 state tender sheet offered per-minute pricing with a dearer first minute or, as an alternative, a bundled rate of $29.50 per operator hour[4]. If a vendor quotes you one model, ask what the others would cost; most can price more than one way.
What counts as a billable minute
Two services quoting the same per-minute rate can send very different invoices, because they count different minutes. A New Jersey state answering-service bid defined its billable “minutes of service” to include the incoming call, time spent trying to reach a department responder, the call relaying the information and the time spent connecting the caller to the responder[2]. Under a definition like that, a night call that needs three paging attempts can bill for several times as long as the caller was on the line.
- Caller
- Your team
- System
01Caller
Caller connected
Greeting, name, callback number and reason: about two minutes of talk.
02Your team
Message completed
Some services bill the agent's time finishing the message after hang-up.
03System
On-call clinician paged
Each attempt to reach the physician can count as billable time.
04Your team
Caller patched through
Connecting the caller may add minutes or a per-call patch fee.
05System
Message delivered
Secure delivery is usually included, but confirm it in writing.
Example. Which steps are billable depends entirely on how the contract defines a minute.
Ask for the definition in writing, then check it against a sample invoice with call-level detail: start time, talk time, paging time and billed time for each call. If a vendor cannot show call-level detail, you cannot audit the bill, and that alone is a reason to look elsewhere.
Rounding: the rate behind the rate
Billing increments change the effective price of short calls more than most rate differences do. Billing to the second, as the university contract did for non-clinical calls[3], charges for the time used. Rounding each call up to the next whole minute charges for time nobody used, and the shorter the call, the bigger the share.
| Actual call length | Billed to the second | Rounded up per call | Extra billed time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0:45 | 0.75 min | 1 min | 33% |
| 1:20 | 1.33 min | 2 min | 50% |
| 2:10 | 2.17 min | 3 min | 38% |
| 3:40 | 3.67 min | 4 min | 9% |
| 6:05 | 6.08 min | 7 min | 15% |
Example: a practice with 400 after-hours calls a month averaging 1 minute 20 seconds would be billed about 533 minutes to the second, or 800 minutes rounded up per call. At a dollar a minute, that is about $267 a month for time nobody spent on the phone. Rounding per segment, where the call and each page are rounded separately, can add more. A slightly higher rate billed to the second can be the cheaper quote.
Packages: allowances, overage and the quiet month
Packages are easy to budget and easy to overpay. A county health department's 2013 overflow call-center contract set $895 a month for up to 1,200 minutes, $0.78 for each additional minute and a patching charge of $0.06 per call[1]. The chart shows what that structure costs per minute actually used at different monthly volumes.
Source: Ingham County Board of Commissioners, 2013[1]
Show the data
| Minutes used per month | Cost per minute used |
|---|---|
| 400 | $2.24 |
| 800 | $1.12 |
| 1,200 | $0.75 |
| 1,600 | $0.75 |
| 2,000 | $0.76 |
| 2,400 | $0.76 |
Below the allowance, the package costs the same whether you use 400 minutes or 1,200, so the effective rate in a quiet month is three times the rate in a full one. Above it, overage in this contract was priced close to the package's own average[1], which made surges cheap and lulls expensive. Size an allowance to your quiet months rather than your average, and ask whether unused minutes roll over.
Seasonal allowances exist too. The New Jersey bid asked for flat fees covering 400 minutes a month from April to October and 200 from November to March, with per-minute overage above each[2]. A practice whose volume climbs every winter can ask for the same shape in reverse: a larger allowance from December to February and a smaller one the rest of the year.
Example: one practice, two months, two winners
Example: a two-physician practice compares three fictional quotes. Quote A is $1.10 a minute, rounded up per call. Quote B is $3.25 a call. Quote C is $650 a month for 600 minutes, then $0.95 a minute. The rates are invented for illustration; the call profiles are the kind your own log will show.
| Example | Quiet month: 300 calls, 1:20 average | Flu-season month: 450 calls, 3:30 average |
|---|---|---|
| Billed minutes, rounded up per call | 600 (2 per call) | 1,800 (4 per call) |
| Quote A: per minute | $660 | $1,980 |
| Quote B: per call | $975 | $1,462.50 |
| Quote C: package | $650 | $1,790 |
| Cheapest that month | Quote C | Quote B |
In this example, a year with nine quiet months and three busy ones totals $11,220 under Quote C, $11,880 under Quote A and $13,162.50 under Quote B, so the package wins the year while losing badly every winter. Each quiet month gives Quote C a lead of about $325 over Quote B, and each busy month hands roughly the same amount back. The answer turns on how many busy months you really have, which is why a year of call data beats any single month.
Per agent hour is a different scale altogether. Example: covering 5 p.m. to 8 a.m. every night at the $29.50 per operator hour figure from the state tender sheet[4] comes to 450 hours, or $13,275 a month, whether ten calls arrive or two hundred. That can suit a large group or a health system with steady overnight volume. At a small practice's night volume, it rarely does.
Fees that sit outside every model
Whatever the unit, the headline rate is rarely the whole price. The county package above charged $0.06 per call for patching on top of its minutes[1]; the university contract added a $370 monthly minimum, a language surcharge of $1.26 a minute and an hourly charge for programming[3]. Line items like these can decide which model is cheapest for a small practice, because they do not shrink when volume does.
- Patch or transfer fees, charged per connection to the on-call clinician.
- Monthly minimums, which turn a per-minute or per-call plan into a package in quiet months.
- Holiday surcharges, and the list of days they apply to.
- Interpreter or language surcharges, added on top of the standard rate.
- Setup, programming and script-change charges, one-time or hourly.
Add every one of them to each model's monthly figure before comparing. A per-call quote with no patch fee can beat a cheaper per-minute quote that charges for every connection, and a package that includes holidays can beat both on a long weekend.
What the calls are worth sets the ceiling
Pricing models only compare costs. Before signing, put a value on the calls, because the cheapest model that sends callers to voicemail once its allowance runs out can cost more than it saves. New patients accounted for 16.8% of US physician office visits in 2019[5], and some of the people who call after hours are looking for a practice, not calling their own.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| After-hours calls per week | 70 |
| Share from prospective new patients | 10% |
| Share who go on to book a first visit | 50% |
| Average revenue from a first visit | $150 |
| After-hours calls a month | 303 |
| From new customers | 30 |
| Bookings if answered | 15 |
| Monthly after-hours value | $2,273 |
How it is worked out: After-hours calls a week × 4.33 weeks × new-customer share × booking rate × average value.
Assumptions
- New patients were 16.8% of US physician office visits in 2019; this example uses a more cautious 10% of after-hours callers.[5]
- Most emergency department visits in 2022 (56.3%) arrived outside weekday business hours, a sign of how much care-seeking happens after the office closes.[6]
- Seventy calls a week, a 50% booking rate and $150 of first-visit revenue are invented placeholders; use figures from your own billing data.
Example only: a modelled value, not a measured result. It sets a ceiling for what after-hours coverage is worth, before any pricing model is compared.
If the model you are leaning towards has an allowance, ask what happens when it runs out: overage billing, or calls rolling to a voicemail box. A package that is cheap because it caps calls is not cheap. Medical answering service cost builds the full monthly estimate, including one-time fees, and what missed calls cost a practice covers the daytime side of the same question.
Matching the model to your call profile
- Mostly short, routine calls at steady volume: per minute billed to the second, or a package sized to your quiet months.
- Fewer, longer calls, many with pages or patches: per call, with a written definition of what counts as a call.
- A strong seasonal swing: a seasonal package or per-minute pricing, never a fixed allowance sized for winter.
- High volume over long hours: per agent hour can make sense, especially with dedicated agents who learn your practice.
- A large share of office questions: shrink the paid profile first, because an office question answered in full costs nothing to return in the morning.
On the last point, some practices route routine office questions to an SI Employee, which answers them from information the practice approves and transfers patient-specific calls to the answering service or staff line the practice chooses. The answering service is then priced on the calls that genuinely need it. See how an SI Employee handles calls before you re-run the numbers.
Whichever model wins, lock its definitions into the agreement: medical answering service contracts lists the clauses to check, and cost per patient call gives the in-house figure to set beside any quote. The physical therapy scheduling example shows how large the office-question share of a clinic's calls can be.
Frequently asked questions
What is a typical per-minute rate for an answering service?
Rates vary with service level, hours and region, and few are published. Public documents give reference points: one 2024 state tender sheet listed $1.25 for the first minute and $1.15 for each additional minute[4], and a 2020 university contract priced non-clinical calls at $1.22 a minute[3]. Get quotes against your own call log.
Is per-call pricing better for medical practices?
It suits practices whose after-hours calls are long and predictable, especially calls that need a page or a patch. It suits practices with many short calls, hang-ups or wrong numbers less well, unless those are excluded from billable calls in writing.
Do unused package minutes roll over?
Only if the contract says so. Many packages reset every month, which is why the allowance should match your quiet months rather than your average.
How do we compare quotes quoted in different units?
Turn each one into a monthly bill for the same call profile: calls, minutes per call, pages, interpreter minutes and the vendor's rounding rule. Do it for an average month and for your busiest month, then for a full year.
Can we change pricing model during the contract?
Ask before you sign. Some vendors allow a plan change at renewal or once a year; others fix the model for the whole term.
References
Ingham County Board of Commissioners (2013). Resolution #13-190: Resolution to authorize an agreement for call center services at the Health Department (opens in a new tab) ↑
New Jersey Department of Community Affairs (2017). DCS052017 Telephone Answering Service: Pricing Structure (opens in a new tab) ↑
University of Wisconsin–Madison Purchasing Services (2020). Telephone Nurse Triage Services, contract 20-5393 (last updated February 14, 2020; archived copy) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Arkansas Department of Human Services (2024). Revised Official Bid Price Sheet: 710-24-058 Telephone Answering Service (opens in a new tab) ↑
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2019). National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2019 National Summary Tables (opens in a new tab) ↑
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2022). National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2022 Emergency Department Summary Tables (Table 3) (opens in a new tab) ↑