Practice Technology

Choosing Practice Management Software: Checklist

A checklist for choosing practice management software: features to test, data ownership, security, support terms, contract traps and a scoring sheet.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Start with your own list, not the vendor's
  2. Plan the decision timeline
  3. Checklist 1: front desk features
  4. Checklist 2: billing and reporting
  5. Checklist 3: data, security and compliance
  6. Checklist 4: AI and automation features
  7. Run the demo on your scenarios
  8. Score consistently
  9. Support terms and contract traps
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Practice Technology: Choosing Practice Management Software: ChecklistArticle coverPRACTICE TECHNOLOGYChoosing PracticeManagement Software:ChecklistAva Medical IntakeInsightsPractice Technology: Choosing Practice Management Software: ChecklistArticle coverPRACTICE TECHNOLOGYChoosing PracticeManagement Software:ChecklistAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Write your requirements from your own team's frustrations before you watch a single demo.
  • Make vendors run your scenarios in the demo, not their script, and score each one the same way.
  • Treat data ownership, export, the business associate agreement and support terms as must-haves, not small print.
  • Read the contract for term length, renewal, price increases and exit help before you negotiate the price.

Start with your own list, not the vendor's

Vendor demos are designed to show strengths. If you arrive without your own list, you will judge each product on what it chose to show you. Spend a week gathering requirements first: ask the front desk, billers, the office manager and one or two clinicians to write down their five biggest daily frustrations with the current system and five things they would never give up.

Small practices have the most to gain from this discipline. In 2024, only 32% of US physicians in solo practice used an EHR from one of the five market-leading developers, against 90% in practices with more than 50 physicians[1]. Smaller practices choose from a wider and more varied market, where quality differs a lot from product to product, so a structured comparison protects them from expensive mistakes.

If you are still deciding whether to buy a PM system alone or a combined suite, read EHR vs practice management system first.

Plan the decision timeline

A rushed choice usually happens because the current contract is about to renew. Work backwards from your renewal or notice date and leave enough time for each stage, including the go-live itself.

  1. Gather requirements from staff and write the must-have list.
  2. Shortlist from a longer list using the must-haves, and send scenarios to the top three.
  3. Run scripted demos and score them the same day.
  4. Call references and review contracts, including the business associate agreement.
  5. Negotiate, sign and agree an implementation plan with dates.
  6. Train, convert data, test and go live, avoiding your busiest season.

Give the shortlist and demo stages to a small team: the office manager, one scheduler and one biller. A decision made by the people who will use the system every day is more likely to stick, and they will be the ones explaining it to everyone else at go-live.

Checklist 1: front desk features

  • Scheduling: appointment types with rules, templates that hold time for new patients and urgent visits, fast next-available search, waitlist and recurring appointments.
  • Registration: required fields, format checks, duplicate patient detection and guarantor handling.
  • Eligibility: real-time and batch checks, results saved with the visit, clear flags on the schedule.
  • Authorizations and referrals: tracking by visit with due dates and status.
  • Check-in and checkout: the patient's balance and expected copay on one screen, card payments and receipts.
  • Communication: reminders and confirmations, or a clean connection to the tool you use for them.
  • Online booking: shares the same rules as the internal schedule, with real-time write-back.

Checklist 2: billing and reporting

  • Charge capture from the EHR with a missing-charges report.
  • Claim scrubbing before submission, with errors explained in plain words.
  • Work queues for rejections and denials, grouped by payer and reason.
  • Electronic remittance posting and secondary claim creation.
  • Patient statements, payment plans and card-on-file with consent records.
  • Reports the manager can run without exporting: schedule fill, no-shows, new patients by source, aging by payer, denials by reason.
  • Multi-location reporting, if you have or plan more than one site.

Checklist 3: data, security and compliance

These items decide whether you can trust the system with your patients' information and whether you can leave it one day. Treat each as a must-have.

  • Business associate agreement: a HIPAA covered entity may let a vendor handle protected health information only with satisfactory assurance, in a business associate agreement, that it will be safeguarded[2]. Get it signed before any real data is loaded.
  • Data ownership: the contract should state that the practice owns its data.
  • Export: a documented export of all data in standard formats, available during the contract and at its end, with a sample provided during evaluation.
  • Patient access: the system should make it easy to produce records, because a covered entity must act on an access request within 30 days, with one extension of up to 30 days[3].
  • Security: individual logins, role-based permissions, multi-factor sign-in for remote access and searchable audit logs.
  • Accessibility of patient-facing pages: recipients of HHS federal financial assistance with 15 or more employees must make web content and mobile apps meet WCAG 2.1 Level AA from May 11, 2027[4]. Ask vendors for an accessibility statement for any portal, booking or payment pages they provide.
  • Documentation: keep the vendor's security and compliance documents with your own HIPAA records, which must be retained for six years from creation or last effective date[5].

Checklist 4: AI and automation features

Many PM vendors now advertise AI features for scheduling, eligibility, coding or messages. Ask exactly what each feature does today, what data it uses, whether a person reviews its output and whether it is covered by the same agreement as the rest of the product. Ask for a live demonstration on realistic fictional data, not a slide.

US medical groups with AI governance or a formal AI-use policy, January 2026MGMA Stat poll; remaining responses not shown
US medical groups with AI governance or a formal AI-use policy, January 2026Stacked bar chart. Have a policy: 20%; Developing one: 22%; None: 56%.Have a policy: 20% (20%)Developing one: 22% (22%)None: 56% (57%)US medical groups with AI governance or a formal AI-use policy, January 2026Stacked bar chart. Have a policy: 20%; Developing one: 22%; None: 56%.Have a policy: 20% (20%)Developing one: 22% (22%)None: 56% (57%)
  • Have a policy 20%
  • Developing one 22%
  • None 56%

Source: Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), 2026[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Have a policy20%
Developing one22%
None56%

Few practices are ready to judge these features yet. In January 2026, only 20% of US medical groups had AI governance or a formal AI-use policy, 22% were developing one and 56% had none[6]. If you do not have a policy, write a short one before switching on AI features: what they may be used for, who reviews outputs and how errors are reported.

Run the demo on your scenarios

Send each shortlisted vendor the same five to eight scenarios a week before the demo, and ask them to run them live on a test system. Have the people who do the work score each scenario on the spot.

  1. New patient call

    Register a new patient with insurance and a guarantor, find the next new patient slot with a specific provider and book it, in under three minutes.

  2. Insurance change at check-in

    Update the plan, run eligibility, see the result and the expected copay.

  3. Same-day cancellation

    Cancel a visit and fill the slot from the waitlist.

  4. End of day

    Show the missing-charges report, post payments and reconcile the card total.

  5. Denied claim

    Find a denied claim, see the reason, correct it and resubmit.

  6. Manager questions

    Show no-shows by visit type for last month and new patients by referral source, without exporting.

  7. Leaving the vendor

    Show what a full data export looks like.

Score consistently

Use one scoring sheet for all vendors. Weight the categories by what matters most to your practice, and decide the weights before the first demo so the most charming sales presentation does not set them.

Example only: a weighted scoring sheet for comparing two fictional practice management vendors.
Category (Example weights)WeightVendor A score (1-5)Vendor B score (1-5)
Front desk scenarios30%43
Billing and reporting25%34
Data, security and export20%44
Support and training15%24
Contract terms10%34
Weighted total100%3.43.7

In this Example, Vendor A wins the front desk scenarios but loses on support and contract terms, and Vendor B comes out ahead overall. The sheet makes that trade-off visible, so the practice can decide whether better support is worth slower booking screens, or negotiate with Vendor A on support.

Support terms and contract traps

  • Term and renewal: how long is the initial term, does it renew automatically, and how much notice is needed to cancel?
  • Price increases: are annual increases capped, and are they tied to anything specific?
  • Per-provider or per-location fees: what happens when you add a provider or open a site?
  • Implementation: what is included, who does the data conversion and who checks it?
  • Support: hours, response times for urgent problems during clinic hours and how to escalate.
  • Exit help: will the vendor provide a full export and read-only access after the contract ends, and at what cost?
  • Modules: which features in the demo are extra-cost modules?

Call at least two reference practices of a similar size and specialty that went live in the last two years. Ask what surprised them during go-live, how support has been since and what they would negotiate differently. Then plan the change carefully; see switching EHRs: protecting the front desk for a go-live plan that also fits a PM change.

Frequently asked questions

How many PM vendors should we compare?

Three is usually enough for a full demo comparison. Shortlist from a longer list using your must-have checklist, then run scripted demos with the top three.

Who should attend the demos?

The people who do the work: at least one scheduler, one biller and the office manager, plus a clinician if the PM system is part of a suite.

What is the most overlooked part of a PM contract?

Exit terms. Practices often discover too late that a full data export or read-only access after leaving costs extra or is not offered.

Do we need a business associate agreement with a PM vendor?

Yes, if the vendor will handle protected health information, which a PM system does. Sign it before loading any real patient data.

References

  1. Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS (2024). Office-based Physician Electronic Health Record Adoption, 2008-2024 (ONC Data Brief) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR § 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR § 164.524 - Access of individuals to protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (2026). 45 CFR § 84.84 - Requirements for web and mobile accessibility (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR § 164.530 - Administrative requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). AI governance in medical group practices: Rules for the humans in the loop (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo