Key takeaways
- The average DPC panel reached 504 patients in 2025, up from 402 a year earlier, and 69% of DPC practices run a single physician panel[1]: one phone is carrying more members.
- Split member access from everything else. The physician's phone should ring for members' health concerns and calls from other clinicians, and little more.
- Since January 2026, DPC fees up to $150 a month for one person no longer block HSA contributions[2]; give callers one approved answer, not an improvised one.
- In the worked example, unanswered prospect calls put about $1,960 a month of first-year membership fees at risk, before family plans and renewals.
The access promise lands on one phone
In most membership practices the access promise rides on one device: the physician's mobile. Members were told at enrollment that they could reach the doctor, the number sits in their contacts, and the physician answers at dinner, at a school concert and on the first morning of a vacation. That holds at 150 members. It strains at 500, which is roughly where the average practice now sits. In the AAFP's 2026 survey of physicians engaged with direct primary care, the average panel across respondents was 504 patients in 2025, up from 402 a year earlier, and 69% of DPC practices ran a single physician panel[1].
The same survey shows where the hours go. E-visit encounters averaged 13 a week, up from 11 in 2024 and 7 in 2022, and physicians' workweeks averaged 42.3 hours, up from 39.8[1]. Among respondents practicing in DPC, the top challenges were panel growth (40%), the burden of care outside visits (33%) and revenue stability (29%)[1]. Two of those three are phone problems: bringing new members in, and keeping existing members from absorbing the physician between visits.
Source: American Academy of Family Physicians, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Year | E-visits per week |
|---|---|
| 2022 | 7 |
| 2024 | 11 |
| 2025 | 13 |
Members' expectations are set by more than the practice. In a 2026 KFF poll, 65% of adults who use AI tools for health information said wanting quick, immediate advice was a major reason[3]. A member who can get an instant answer from a chatbot judges a two-hour wait for a callback against that. This guide covers the phone layer: who answers, what reaches the physician and when. The reply standards themselves are in front desk standards for concierge and DPC practices.
Separate member access from everything else
Membership practices get the same mix of calls as any primary care office, plus some of their own. Prospective members ask what is included, what it costs and whether they still need insurance. Employers and brokers ask about group contracts. Members call about labs, refills, forms and how they feel. Pharmacies, specialists and hospitals call for the physician. Only some of those need the physician, and only a few need the physician tonight.
| Caller | What they need | Who should answer | How fast |
|---|---|---|---|
| Member with a new symptom or worry | A clinician's judgment | Physician or covering clinician | Tonight, by live transfer |
| Member with a routine request | Refill, lab question, form, appointment | Care team during hours | Next business day, as the agreement says |
| Prospective member | What is included, the fee, how to join | Approved answers, then the membership coordinator | Same day; prospects compare practices |
| Employer or broker | Group contract terms | Owner or practice manager | Within two business days |
| Hospital, specialist or pharmacy | The physician, about a patient | Physician | Straight through at any hour |
| Anyone describing an emergency | Emergency care | 911 first | Immediately |
Laid out like that, the design choice is plain. The physician's phone should ring for the first and fifth rows and almost nothing else. A coverage layer exists to absorb the rest without making members feel pushed back into the phone tree of the traditional office many of them left.
Five ways membership practices cover the phone
- The physician carries the phone. Members reach their doctor directly, which is the product as sold. It breaks on volume, vacations and sleep, and the AAFP tells physicians weighing DPC that they will need a plan for urgent requests while on vacation or away from the office[4].
- Shared call with a nearby practice. Two or three independent physicians cover each other's nights and weekends. Members reach a physician, though not their own, so agree on record access and a morning handoff in writing.
- A medical answering service. A live agent takes messages and pages the physician by your rules. Members hear a stranger reading a script, which can feel like the traditional office they joined you to escape.
- A nurse triage service or in-house nurse. Clinical questions get a clinical answer at night, which suits larger panels with many families. The nurse still escalates to your physician by your rules.
- An SI Employee in front of the physician's line. It answers membership and office questions from approved wording at any hour and transfers member concerns to the physician or covering clinician. It takes no health details and does not triage.
Most practices end up with two layers: something that answers every call in the practice's name, and a short, dependable path to a clinician for the calls that need one. Doctors answering after-hours calls themselves shows how to log two weeks of calls to see which layer you need, nurse triage service vs answering service compares the clinical options, and 24/7 vs after-hours-only coverage covers the hours.
Keeping the promise at 9:40 pm
- Caller
- SI Employee
- Your team
- System
01Caller
Member calls at 9:40 pm
The practice line forwards after 6 pm; she hears the practice name.
02SI Employee
Greeting and 911 line
Automated-assistant and recording notice, then the approved emergency wording.
03SI Employee
Hears it is about her health
Asks nothing about symptoms; offers the physician now or a morning callback.
04SI Employee
Transfers to the physician
A plain transfer to the on-call number the practice approved.
05Your team
Physician takes the call
Decides between advice tonight, a visit tomorrow or the emergency department.
06System
Summary waits by email
Recording, transcript and summary; the care team reads it at 8 am.
Example flow. If the physician does not pick up, the call comes back, the member is told plainly and an urgent message is saved.
The flow keeps what members pay for: when it matters, they talk to their doctor. What it removes is the 9:40 pm call asking whether the office opens at 8 or 8:30, the prospect asking whether the membership covers labs, and the employer's office manager who wants a contract callback. The physician's phone rings less often, and each call that does get through is one the physician would want.
That matters for the physician as much as the member. Burnout has eased but remains common: 41.9% of US physicians reported at least one symptom in 2025[5]. Even in conventional primary care, physicians already spent 1.4 hours a day in the EHR after clinic hours in one time-and-motion study[6]. A membership model that adds unfiltered evening calls on top of that undoes part of the reason many physicians chose it.
Example vacation rule: βFrom Friday 6 pm to Monday 8 am, member health calls transfer to Dr. Lee's covering partner. The greeting says so before the transfer, and the covering physician's notes go into the morning email.β
Write the covering rotation down the same way for every holiday and conference, and change the transfer number before the physician leaves, not from the airport. On-call escalation rules has a template for who gets which call.
Membership questions now include HSAs
Prospective members ask about money more than medicine, and in 2026 one answer changed. Under the 2025 budget law, for months beginning after December 31, 2025, a direct primary care service arrangement no longer stops a member from contributing to a health savings account, provided it consists only of primary care paid for by a fixed periodic fee and the fees stay at or below $150 a month for one person, or $300 for an arrangement covering more than one[2]. Those fees can also be paid from the HSA. Fees above the limit can still be reimbursed from it, but the member cannot make HSA contributions while enrolled[2].
The rule has edges callers will not know about. A qualifying arrangement cannot include procedures that need general anesthesia, prescription drugs other than vaccines, or lab services not typically done in an ambulatory primary care setting[2]. A concierge practice that also bills insurance for covered services, as the AAFP notes concierge practices may[4], is a different arrangement from fee-only DPC. Most DPC fees already sit well inside the limit: 61% of DPC respondents charged adults $51 to $100 a month[1].
None of that belongs in an improvised phone answer. Write one approved paragraph with your accountant or counsel, saying whether your arrangement is designed to fit the rule and that members should confirm with their HSA administrator, and have every person and system that answers the phone read it, nothing more. Anything beyond it goes to the membership coordinator. Accepting HSA and FSA cards at the front desk covers the payment side.
What a missed prospect call is worth
Membership practices tend to see coverage as a retention tool, and it is one, but the base is already sticky: 53% of DPC respondents reported annual member termination rates of 1% to 5%[1]. The quicker payoff is usually growth, because 40% of DPC physicians called panel growth a major challenge[1], and prospects call while they are comparing options, often at lunch or after work.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Calls per week | 90 |
| Calls unanswered (%) | 15% |
| Calls from prospective members (%) | 10% |
| Prospects who enroll (%) | 35% |
| First-year membership fees | $960 |
| Unanswered calls a month | 58 |
| From new customers | 5.8 |
| Bookings that would have followed | 2 |
| Monthly value at risk | $1,964 |
How it is worked out: Calls a week Γ 4.33 weeks Γ unanswered share Γ new-customer share Γ booking rate Γ average value.
Assumptions
- A first-year value of $960 is an adult membership at $80 a month; 61% of DPC respondents charged adults between $51 and $100 a month.[1]
- Example: 15% of calls go unanswered, mostly at lunch, after 5 pm and while the physician is with members. Read yours from the phone report.
- Example: one call in ten comes from a prospective member, and 35% of those enroll after a good first conversation.
Example only. It leaves out family memberships, enrollment fees and the years a member stays.
In this example about $1,960 a month of first-year membership fees passes through calls nobody answers. Family plans, enrollment fees and renewals would raise it. Compare that figure, and the physician hours each option takes off the phone, against the quotes you collect.
Setting it up without changing what members value
Log two weeks of calls
Every call to the practice line and the physician's mobile: who, what, when, and whether it needed the physician.
Write the access tiers
Which calls reach the physician tonight, which wait for the morning and which go to the membership coordinator. Put the tiers in the membership agreement.
Approve the answer sheet
Hours, location, what the membership includes, how to enroll, the approved HSA paragraph and the emergency wording, in the physician's own words.
Set the transfer numbers
The physician's direct number, a covering clinician as backup and the coordinator's line. Test each from an outside phone.
Tell members first
A short note: the practice line now answers at all hours, health concerns still reach the doctor, and here is what happens when you call.
Review every call for a month
The physician or nurse listens to a sample each week and adjusts the tiers and the answer sheet.
An SI Employee can sit in front of the physician's line without changing the promise. The practice forwards its number on the schedule it picks, and it answers membership and office questions from approved information, takes no health details and gives the 911 wording to anyone describing an emergency. A member who wants the doctor is transferred to the number you approve, which must be a direct line, since a forwarded call cannot go back to the line it came from. Each call arrives with a recording, transcript and emailed summary, and the physician can listen to a call live and take it over. The family practice morning-rush example shows the same handoffs in a busy primary care office, and you can try a demo call.
Frequently asked questions
What response time should our after-hours line promise members?
Promise what you can keep every night, vacations included: for example, a live answer every time and a call with the physician or covering clinician for anything about a member's health. Routine requests can wait for the next business day if the membership agreement says so.
Will members feel they have lost direct access?
Not if the physician still takes the calls that need a physician. Tell members before the change, keep the practice name in the greeting and offer a transfer to the doctor whenever the call is about their health.
Can members pay DPC fees from an HSA?
For months beginning after December 31, 2025, fees for a qualifying direct primary care arrangement can be paid from an HSA, and fees up to $150 a month ($300 for more than one person) do not affect HSA eligibility[2]. Have counsel confirm your arrangement fits before staff say so.
Is a concierge practice that bills insurance treated like DPC under these rules?
No. The HSA rule covers arrangements paid solely by a fixed periodic fee for primary care[2], while concierge practices may also bill insurance[4]. Give callers one approved answer that fits your model.
How many calls should still reach the physician?
Log two weeks and look. The aim is that every call reaching the physician is one they would want, such as members' health concerns and calls from hospitals and specialists, and none are about hours, forms or enrollment.
References
American Academy of Family Physicians (2026). 2026 Direct Primary Care Data Brief (opens in a new tab) β
Internal Revenue Service (2026). Notice 2026-5: Expanded Availability of Health Savings Accounts under the One, Big, Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) (opens in a new tab) β
KFF (2026). KFF Tracking Poll on Health Information and Trust: Use of AI For Health Information and Advice (opens in a new tab) β
American Academy of Family Physicians (2026). Direct Primary Care Model For Family Physicians (opens in a new tab) β
American Medical Association (2025). AMA: Physician burnout rates are falling, specialty gaps remain (opens in a new tab) β
Annals of Family Medicine (2017). Tethered to the EHR: Primary Care Physician Workload Assessment Using EHR Event Log Data and Time-Motion Observations (Annals of Family Medicine, 2017) (opens in a new tab) β