Key takeaways
- An emergency visit is a first impression made under stress; fast access and kindness do most of the selling.
- Book the comprehensive exam or next treatment visit before the patient leaves, while the relief is fresh.
- Call the next day to check on the patient; it is the single most remembered follow-up.
- Track emergency visits through to a second, non-emergency visit, by source, so you know what is working.
Emergency patients are new patients in disguise
Many people only find a dentist when something hurts. They call several offices, take the first one that can see them today and arrive anxious. If the visit goes well, a share of them stay for years. If the office treats the visit as a one-off, almost none do.
The size of the problem is clear from hospital data. Tooth disorders accounted for an annual average of about 1.94 million US emergency department visits in 2020 to 2022, about 1.4% of all ED visits, and Medicaid was the expected primary payer for 55.4% of them[1]. Many of those patients had no dental home. Every one seen in a dental office instead is a chance to start regular care.
Untreated disease is common, so emergencies will keep coming. CDC reports that 1 in 5 adults aged 20 to 64 (21%) has at least one untreated cavity[2]. One in three US adults had no dental exam or cleaning in the past year[3], which makes the emergency visit the moment when many of them re-enter care.
Know which emergency patient you have
| Patient type | What they need from you | Retention approach |
|---|---|---|
| No regular dentist | Relief today and a reason to come back | Book a comprehensive exam before they leave; explain why it matters |
| Has a dentist who could not see them | Relief and a report for their dentist | Treat, send a report to their dentist, leave the door open |
| Lapsed for years, anxious | Gentle care and no lecture | Book a short, easy next visit; assign a consistent team member |
| Cost-worried, uninsured or self-pay | A clear fee and options | Give the estimate, offer a plan for next steps in stages |
| Public coverage | Confirmation of what is covered | Check eligibility; book covered follow-up care |
| Traveling or temporary | Relief and records | Treat and give records; ask for a review if they were pleased |
Ask on the first call: 'Do you have a regular dentist?' The answer changes the goal. A patient with a loyal dentist elsewhere should be treated well and sent home with a report; poaching them damages referral relationships. A patient with no dentist is the one to invite back.
Step by step: from the call to the second visit
On the call: book today
Offer the earliest time, even if it means a short wait in the office. Tell the patient what to bring and what the visit will cost, or the range.
At arrival: make it easy
Short forms on a phone or tablet, a warm welcome and a clear sense of how long they will wait.
In the chair: relief and a plan
The dentist treats the urgent problem, then explains in plain words what else they saw and what should happen next.
At checkout: book the next visit
Book the comprehensive exam and cleaning, or the definitive treatment, before the patient leaves. Give a written summary and the estimate.
Next day: a check-in call
Call to ask how they are feeling. Answer questions, confirm the next appointment and offer to move it if needed.
Before the next visit: reminders
Two reminders by the patient's preferred channel. For anxious patients, add a short note about what the visit involves.
After the second visit: welcome
Once they complete a non-emergency visit, put them on routine recall and treat them as an established patient.
Scripts that help
At checkout: 'I'm glad you're feeling better. Dr [name] would like to see you for a full check-up and cleaning so we can look after the rest of your teeth and avoid another painful surprise. I have Tuesday the [date] at 8 or Thursday at 3. Which is better?'
Next-day call: 'Hi [name], it's [team member] from [practice]. I'm just calling to see how you're feeling after yesterday. Any questions about the aftercare? And I see you're booked with us on [date]; does that still work for you?'
If the patient says they will think about it, do not push. Offer to hold a time for 48 hours and ask permission to call back. Record the answer and the reason in the record.
Why emergency patients do not come back
- Nobody asked them to book a next visit, or they were told to 'call when ready'.
- The emergency fee surprised them, so they distrust the next estimate.
- They were made to feel judged for not having been to a dentist in years.
- They never received a reminder, or it went to an old number.
- The next available exam was weeks away and the pain had gone.
- They had a dentist already and were treated as if they did not.
Each of these is fixable. Most are front office habits: clear fees before treatment, a booked next step, the next-day call and a reminder system that works.
Make access the marketing
Emergency patients choose the office that can see them first. Protect one or two emergency slots in each dentist's day, released to the cancellation list by early afternoon if unused. Make sure the phone is answered at lunch and late afternoon, when many people decide they cannot wait. Many urgent problems start out of hours: across all causes, 56.3% of US emergency department visits in 2022 arrived outside weekday business hours[4].
- Answer the phone live during the day; an emergency caller who reaches voicemail calls the next office.
- After hours, give a clear message with your emergency instructions and the time the office opens.
- Put same-day emergency availability on your website and in your online listings, if you offer it.
- Offer a virtual triage option where it suits; see teledentistry for triage and consults.
For after-hours and lunchtime calls, an answering option such as Ava can cover the line, give your approved emergency message and leave a call summary for the team, so callers who need an appointment can be phoned back first thing rather than left at voicemail.
Making the second visit easy for anxious patients
Many emergency patients stayed away from the dentist because of fear, cost or a bad past experience. The emergency visit shows them it can be different; the second visit has to confirm it. Small choices at the desk make a big difference.
- Book the second visit with the same dentist or hygienist the patient met, where possible.
- Choose a time of day the patient says suits them, not just the next free slot.
- Tell them exactly what will happen: how long it takes, whether X-rays are needed and that nothing will be done without their agreement.
- Note anxiety in a visible alert, so the team greets them with extra time and patience.
- Split a large treatment plan into stages the patient can manage, and start with the most urgent item.
A patient who leaves the second visit feeling in control is far more likely to keep the third.
Reviews and referrals, done properly
Relieved emergency patients are often happy to say so. Ask satisfied patients, after the follow-up call, whether they would be willing to leave an honest review, and give them a simple link. Ask every patient the same way rather than only those you expect to be positive.
Never offer anything in return for a review and never write or buy reviews. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, in effect since October 21, 2024, prohibits buying or selling fake reviews and certain review suppression practices[5]. Honest reviews from real emergency patients are among the most persuasive things the next anxious searcher will read.
Track the conversion
Measure what matters: not emergency visits, but emergency patients who complete a second, non-emergency visit. Track monthly:
- Emergency visits by new patients, and by source: search, referral, insurer directory, walk-in.
- Share who booked a next visit before leaving.
- Share who completed a comprehensive exam within 90 days.
- Share still active after 12 months.
Example: a fictional practice sees 30 new emergency patients in a quarter. 18 book a next visit before leaving, and 14 complete a comprehensive exam within 90 days. After the office adds the next-day call and a written summary at checkout, the next quarter's numbers rise to 22 booked and 19 completed out of 31. The extra retained patients feed directly into the new patient target.
Who owns the follow-up matters. In practices with split front office roles, the scheduling coordinator usually owns the next-day call and the booking; see scheduling coordinator vs financial coordinator.
Frequently asked questions
Should we charge more for emergency visits?
Charge your normal fees for the services provided, and tell the patient the fee or range before treatment. Surprise charges are a leading reason emergency patients do not return.
What if the emergency patient already has a dentist?
Treat them well, send a report to their dentist and leave the door open. Trying to poach them can harm your referral relationships.
When should we call after an emergency visit?
The next day. A short check-in call is the follow-up patients remember most, and it is a natural moment to confirm their next appointment.
How do we know if our emergency patients are staying?
Track the share who complete a non-emergency visit within 90 days and who are still active after a year, by source.
References
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2020-2022). Emergency Department Visits for Tooth Disorders: United States, 2020-2022 (NCHS Data Brief No. 531) (opens in a new tab) โ
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2017-2020). Oral Health Facts (opens in a new tab) โ
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2025). FastStats - Oral and Dental Health (opens in a new tab) โ
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2022). National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2022 Emergency Department Summary Tables (Table 3) (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2024). Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (Final rule, 89 FR 68034) (opens in a new tab) โ