Key takeaways
- A new patient meets your office eight or more times before the first cleaning; each touchpoint needs an owner and a deadline.
- Most patients read reviews first: 57% of surveyed patients said they read online reviews of their physician[1].
- Send forms and portal access early; patients encouraged by their provider use portals at higher rates[2].
- Close the first visit with a booked next step and a follow-up call within a week.
Why map the whole journey
Offices tend to polish the visit itself and leave the rest to chance. Yet a new patient forms an opinion long before the chair: on the review site, on the phone, in the confirmation text and at the front door. Adults are also visiting the dentist a little less than they used to; the share of adults aged 18 to 64 with a dental visit in the past year fell from 65.5% in 2019 to 62.7% in 2020[3]. Every new patient who books is worth a smooth path.
The map below covers nine touchpoints. For each, decide who owns it, when it happens and what "done" looks like. Then walk it yourself as a mystery patient once a quarter.
The nine touchpoints
| Touchpoint | Owner | Timing | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Finding you online | Office manager | Ongoing | Hours, plans accepted and new-patient info are current |
| 2. First call or web request | Scheduler | Same business hour | Visit booked or callback set |
| 3. Confirmation | Scheduler | Within 5 minutes | Text or email with date, address, parking |
| 4. Forms and portal | Scheduler | Same day | Secure link sent; reminder at 72 hours if incomplete |
| 5. Insurance check | Insurance coordinator | 3 business days before | Breakdown on file; patient told of anything unusual |
| 6. Reminder | Scheduler | 2 days and 2 hours before | Confirmed or rescheduled |
| 7. Arrival | Front desk | Visit day | Greeted by name, seated within 10 minutes |
| 8. In the chair | Dentist and hygienist | Visit | Findings explained, questions answered |
| 9. Checkout and follow-up | Front desk or coordinator | Visit day and within 7 days | Next visit booked; follow-up call made |
Before the call: what patients check
In a survey of 284 patients in Kansas, 57% said they read online reviews of their physician[1], and among millennials the share was 67.2%[1]. The study covered physicians, but dental patients search the same way. Before you change anything else, search for your practice as a new patient would and fix what you find: wrong hours, an old phone number, a photo of a building you left, no mention of which plans you accept.
Source: Kansas Journal of Medicine (via PubMed Central), 2022[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| All surveyed patients | 57% |
| Millennials (18-38) | 67.2% |
Ask happy patients for reviews, but keep it honest. The FTC rule on consumer reviews, in effect since October 21, 2024, prohibits buying or selling fake reviews and certain review suppression practices[4]. Ask every patient the same way, never only the ones you expect to be positive, and never offer a reward tied to a positive rating.
Between booking and arrival
This is the stretch where new patients drop off. The visit may be two or three weeks away, and nothing has happened since the call. Fill the gap with useful steps rather than marketing. A confirmation within minutes, a forms link the same day, an insurance check a few days ahead and two reminders keep the visit real.
Digital forms help, but only if patients use them. In 2024, 65% of individuals were offered and accessed their online medical records or patient portal, up from 25% in 2014[2], and people encouraged by their provider to use the portal accessed it at higher rates[2]. Mention the forms on the call, send the link right away, and offer help on the phone for anyone who gets stuck.
- Confirmation text: date, time, address, parking or transit tips, and a line on what to bring.
- Forms link: health history, consent, HIPAA notice acknowledgement and insurance card photos.
- Insurance check: run eligibility and a benefit breakdown; call the patient if anything affects the visit, such as a frequency limit already used.
- Two-day reminder: confirm or reschedule, with a reply option.
- Two-hour reminder: short, friendly, with a phone number for running late.
The visit itself
At arrival, greet the patient by name before they reach the counter. If forms are complete, there should be nothing to do but confirm the ID and insurance card and take a seat. If the patient is anxious, the front desk is the first to notice; a short note to the clinical team ("first visit in eight years, nervous about the cleaning") changes how the appointment goes.
In the chair, the experience patients remember is understanding. Show the images, explain findings in plain words, and separate what is urgent from what can wait. If treatment is recommended, hand off to whoever presents treatment plans so the conversation about sequencing and cost happens at a table, not a counter.
Checkout and the first week
Book the next step
Hygiene recall, the first treatment visit, or a consult. If the patient will not book, note why.
Give a written estimate
For recommended treatment, print or send the estimate with insurance assumptions spelled out.
Collect today's portion
Explain what was charged today and what the plan is expected to pay.
Call within a week
Ask how they are, answer questions and offer to book anything still pending.
The follow-up call is the most skipped step and one of the most valued. It takes three minutes. Script: "Hi Sam, this is Jordan from Maple Dental. I wanted to check how you are feeling after your first visit and whether any questions came up about the plan Dr. Lee went over." Log the outcome either way.
Special cases worth planning for
Anxious patients. Ask on the first call, gently: "Is there anything that would make your first visit more comfortable?" Patients who have avoided the dentist for years will often say so if invited. Note it on the appointment, give them the first slot of the morning so they do not sit and wait, and let the hygienist know before they walk in. A short tour or a chance to meet the dentist before any treatment costs a few minutes and can save the relationship.
Children and families. Send one forms link per child, not one for the family, and name the child in each reminder so parents do not confuse visits. Book siblings back to back. If the parent who books will not be the one who attends, confirm in writing who is bringing the child and whether they can sign consent.
Caregivers and older adults. Some patients rely on a family member to manage appointments. Record who the patient has authorized you to speak with, and send reminders to the contact the patient chooses. Ask whether the patient needs step-free access, a longer appointment or help with forms on paper rather than online, and write the answer where every touchpoint owner can see it.
Patients with urgent problems. A new patient who calls in pain should not enter the standard path at all. Route them to the emergency protocol, see them as soon as clinically appropriate, and then invite them into the full new-patient experience once the problem is under control.
Example: finding the leak
Example: a fictional practice books 40 new patients in a month but sees only 30. The team checks the map and finds that patients booked more than two weeks out miss the visit far more often than those booked within a week, and that forms links were sent only at the two-day reminder. The fix: send forms the same day, add a one-week check-in text, and hold two new-patient slots each week for the following seven days. The office tracks the show rate for new patients separately from the overall rate to see whether it works.
Measure the experience
- Share of new-patient calls that end in a booking.
- Days from first call to first visit.
- New-patient show rate.
- Share of new patients with forms complete before arrival.
- Share who book a next visit before leaving.
- Share who return for their first recall.
Review these monthly. Each one points to a touchpoint on the map, so a drop tells you exactly where to look.
Once a quarter, walk the journey as a patient would. Ask a friend or family member to call as a new patient, fill in the forms on a phone, and arrive for a real visit. Afterwards, ask them three questions: what was confusing, where did they wait without knowing why, and what would have made them choose another office. Compare their answers with the touchpoint table and change one thing at a time, so you can see which change moved the numbers.
Frequently asked questions
What happens at a first dental visit?
Usually a health history review, a comprehensive exam, any X-rays the dentist needs, and a discussion of findings. Many offices also do a cleaning if time and the patient's needs allow.
How far ahead should a new dental patient be booked?
As soon as you can. Long gaps between the call and the visit increase drop-off, so many offices hold a few new-patient slots in the coming week.
When should new patients get their forms?
The same day they book, through a secure link, with a reminder a few days before if the forms are not complete.
Can we ask new patients for reviews?
Yes, as long as you ask consistently and honestly. The FTC rule bans fake reviews and certain review suppression practices, so do not filter who you ask or reward positive ratings.
References
Kansas Journal of Medicine (via PubMed Central) (2022). Millennials Seeking Healthcare: Examining the Degree to Which Patients Utilize Online Resources (Kansas Journal of Medicine, 2022) (opens in a new tab) โ
Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS (2024). Individuals' Access and Use of Patient Portals and Smartphone Health Apps, 2024 (Data Brief No. 77) (opens in a new tab) โ
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2022). Dental Care Utilization Among Adults Aged 18-64: United States, 2019 and 2020 (NCHS Data Brief No. 435) (opens in a new tab) โ
Federal Trade Commission (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2024). Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (Final rule, 89 FR 68034) (opens in a new tab) โ