Key takeaways
- HHS has said practices may send patients unencrypted email when the patient has been told of the risk and still prefers it; the patient then has a right to receive information that way.
- The warning can be short: there is some risk a third party could read an unencrypted email. Record that it was given and what the patient chose.
- Patients asking for their records by email are using their right of access: provide an electronic copy in the form requested if it is readily producible, within 30 days.
- The biggest everyday risk is the wrong address. Verify addresses, turn off auto-complete for patient email and treat misdirected emails as possible breaches.
What HHS has said about unencrypted email
The clearest statement comes from HHS's 2013 rulemaking on patient access. Responding to practices that asked whether they could email patients without encryption, HHS clarified that covered entities are permitted to send individuals unencrypted emails if they have advised the individual of the risk and the individual still prefers unencrypted email[1]. It also rejected the idea that this duty to warn is unduly burdensome, calling it a necessary step to protect the information[1].
HHS set a low bar for the warning itself. Practices are not expected to educate patients about encryption technology; they need only notify the patient that there may be some level of risk that the information in the email could be read by a third party[1]. If the patient is notified and still prefers unencrypted email, the patient has the right to receive the information that way, the practice is not responsible for unauthorized access while the message is in transmission because of the patient's request, and it is not responsible for safeguarding the information once delivered[1].
This is a right the patient can exercise, not a requirement that practices use unencrypted email. A practice can offer secure email or the portal as its default, and switch to ordinary email when a warned patient asks for it.
Records requests by email
When a patient asks for a copy of their records by email, they are using their right of access. If the information is kept electronically and the patient asks for an electronic copy, the practice must provide it in the electronic form and format requested if it is readily producible in that form[2]. The practice must act on the request no later than 30 days after receiving it, with one extension of no more than 30 days[2].
- Log the date the request arrived, including requests sent by email to a general inbox.
- Confirm the requester's identity with your normal verification standard before sending anything.
- Ask how they want the copy delivered: portal download, secure email, or ordinary email after the risk warning.
- If they choose ordinary email, give the warning, record the choice, and send to the address on file or one they have confirmed in writing.
- Do not insist on a different format because it is easier for the practice, if the requested one is readily producible.
Giving the warning and recording the choice
Offer the secure option first
“We can send this through your patient portal or by secure email, which you open with a code.”
If the patient asks for regular email, warn
“Regular email isn't encrypted, so there's some risk someone other than you could read it. Would you still like us to use regular email?”
Confirm the address
Ask the patient to spell it, or send a short test message with no health information and ask them to reply.
Record it
Note the date, the warning given, the patient's choice, the address and what types of information it covers, such as records copies or visit summaries.
Apply it consistently
Make the preference visible to everyone who sends email to patients, and review it if the patient changes address or asks to stop.
Patients also have the broader right to request communications by alternative means or at alternative locations, and providers must accommodate reasonable requests without asking for an explanation[3]. A request to use only a personal email address, never a work address, falls under that right.
Email the practice starts
| Email type | Suggested approach |
|---|---|
| Appointment reminders and logistics | Ordinary email is usually fine with neutral wording and no reason for the visit |
| Portal notifications | Ordinary email saying a new message is waiting; details stay in the portal |
| Visit summaries, results, records | Portal or secure email by default; ordinary email only for warned patients who chose it |
| Billing statements | Portal or secure email; avoid service descriptions in subject lines |
| Newsletters and health tips | Separate from patient-specific email; check marketing rules before using patient lists |
| Replies to patient emails with clinical questions | Route to the clinical team; reply through the portal or by phone |
Whichever service the practice uses to send patient email, if the vendor handles protected health information on the practice's behalf it is a business associate and needs a business associate agreement[4].
Managing the patient email inbox
Many practices publish a general email address and then find it full of appointment requests, records requests, insurance questions and the occasional urgent symptom. An unmanaged inbox is both a privacy risk and a patient safety risk.
- Set an auto-reply that says what the inbox is for, how fast it is answered, and that urgent medical concerns must go to 911 or the phone line, not email.
- Name an owner for each business day and a backup, and set a response target, such as one business day for non-clinical requests.
- Sort incoming email into queues: scheduling, records requests (with the received date logged), billing and clinical. Clinical messages go to the clinical team the same day.
- Move conversations that need health details into the portal: reply with a short note inviting the patient to continue there.
- Do not forward patient emails to personal accounts or discuss them in staff group chats.
- Keep a record of email exchanges that affect care, by adding them to the chart or the portal thread.
Review the inbox volume monthly. If most messages are scheduling requests, a better online booking link or phone coverage may serve patients more than more email staff.
The wrong-address problem
Most email incidents in medical offices are not hacking. They are a staff member picking the wrong address from auto-complete, a typo in a domain, or a reply-all to a group. A misdirected email with health information can be a breach, and if it is a breach of unsecured information, affected patients must be notified without unreasonable delay and no later than 60 calendar days after discovery[5].
- Turn off address auto-complete for patient email, or use a system that sends patient email from the record rather than a general mail client.
- Keep health information out of subject lines.
- Use blind copy, or better, individual messages, for any group email to patients.
- Send attachments through secure links that expire, rather than as open files.
- If an email goes to the wrong person, tell the privacy officer at once, ask the recipient to delete it, and document what happened.
Why the portal is still the best default
Portals have become the normal channel. The share of individuals who were offered and accessed their online medical record or patient portal rose from 25% in 2014 to 65% in 2024[6]. A portal message avoids the wrong-address problem, keeps the conversation with the record and needs no encryption decisions. Email works best as the doorbell: a short note that something is waiting in the portal.
Source: Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS, 2024[6]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2014 | 25% |
| 2024 | 65% |
Help patients get there. Offer to set up portal access at check-in, show them where messages appear, and include a portal link in every appointment email. Patients who are encouraged by their provider to use the portal tend to use it more, so a brief personal invitation from the front desk is worth the minute it takes[6].
Example: a patient who wants everything by email
Example (fictional). A patient emails the practice's general inbox asking for her last three visit summaries and lab reports to be sent to her personal email. The front desk logs the request with the date it arrived and forwards it to the records coordinator. The coordinator calls the patient, verifies her identity, and offers a portal download or secure email. The patient says the portal is hard for her to use and she wants ordinary email.
The coordinator explains that ordinary email is not encrypted and there is some risk a third party could read it. The patient confirms she still wants it. The coordinator records the warning and the choice, sends a test email with no health information, receives the patient's reply, and then sends the documents four days after the request. The preference is noted in the chart for future records requests. Related guidance: texting patients, the minimum necessary rule, front desk layout for privacy and business associate agreements.
Frequently asked questions
Can a doctor's office email a patient without encryption?
Yes, when the patient has been told there is some risk a third party could read it and still prefers unencrypted email. HHS has said patients have the right to receive information that way after being warned.
Do we have to email records if a patient asks?
If the records are electronic and the patient asks for an electronic copy, you must provide it in the form and format requested if it is readily producible. Many practices offer the portal or secure email first, then ordinary email after a risk warning.
Is a misdirected email a HIPAA breach?
It can be. Report it to the privacy officer immediately. If it is a breach of unsecured information, affected patients must be notified no later than 60 calendar days after discovery.
References
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2013). Modifications to the HIPAA Privacy, Security, Enforcement, and Breach Notification Rules; Final Rule (78 FR 5566, January 25, 2013), at 78 FR 5634 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.524 - Access of individuals to protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.522 - Rights to request privacy protection for protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.404 - Notification to individuals (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS (2024). Individuals' Access and Use of Patient Portals and Smartphone Health Apps, 2024 (Data Brief No. 77) (opens in a new tab) ↑