Key takeaways
- Front-desk and entry-level administrative roles are among the most common churn points in medical practices[1], so every departure is a chance to learn something fixable.
- Have someone other than the direct manager run the exit interview, and ask about specific moments rather than general satisfaction.
- Stay interviews with current staff catch the same problems before people resign.
- Code answers into a small set of themes and review them quarterly; leaders rate higher pay and engagement as the top retention tactics for front-desk staff[2].
Why ask, and why most exit interviews fail
Front desk turnover is common and expensive in time. In a May 2026 MGMA poll, 29% of medical group leaders reported higher staff turnover than in 2025, while 39% said it was about the same and 30% lower[3]. Across health care and social assistance, the monthly quits rate was 2.0% in September 2026[4]. Each departure means recruiting, training and a period when the remaining team covers the gap.
Exit interviews are meant to explain why people leave. Many produce little because they are run as a formality: a form on the last afternoon, filled in for the manager the person is leaving. People say better opportunity and move on. A useful exit interview is a short, structured conversation with someone neutral, focused on specific moments in the job, and its answers are reviewed alongside everyone else's rather than filed away.
Who, when and how
- Who: someone other than the direct manager, such as the practice manager, an HR adviser or a manager from another site. People are more candid with someone who did not supervise them.
- When: during the notice period, ideally in the last week, or by phone two to four weeks after the person leaves, when they may speak more freely. Offer both.
- How: a 20 to 30 minute conversation using the same core questions every time, with notes written up the same day.
- Confidentiality: explain that comments will be grouped with others and not attributed by name, except where the law or practice policy requires action, such as allegations of harassment or a safety issue.
- Tone: thank the person, listen, do not argue with their view and do not try to persuade them to stay unless you genuinely intend to make an offer.
Exit interview questions
- What made you start looking for another job? Was there a specific moment?
- What would have had to change for you to stay?
- How did the job compare with what you expected when you were hired?
- Which part of the work took the most energy: phones, the window, insurance, scheduling, difficult patients?
- Did you have the training and system access you needed? What was missing?
- How was the workload on a typical day? On the hardest days?
- How fair did schedules, time off and overtime feel?
- How well did your manager support you when things went wrong?
- Did you feel your work was recognized? How?
- Did you see a way to grow here? What would that have looked like?
- How did your pay compare with what you were offered elsewhere?
- Is there anything you think we should know that we have not asked?
Follow each answer with one probe: can you give me an example? Specific examples, such as covering the phones alone every lunch hour or being told off in front of patients, are what turn an exit interview into a fix. If the person raises harassment, discrimination, safety or a privacy breach, tell them how it will be handled and pass it to the right person the same day.
Stay interviews: ask before they leave
A stay interview asks current staff the same kind of questions while there is still time to act. Hold one with each front desk employee once a year, separate from the performance review, and with new hires at about 90 days.
- What do you look forward to when you come to work?
- What frustrates you most about the job right now?
- If you could change one thing about how the front desk runs, what would it be?
- What might tempt you to leave?
- Do you feel you are learning and growing here? What would you like to learn next?
- How can I make your job easier?
- Are your schedule and hours working for you?
- Who on the team helps you most, and how?
Write down one action from each stay interview and report back within a month, even if the answer is no. A stay interview that leads to nothing does more harm than not asking.
Turn answers into themes
Individual answers are anecdotes. Patterns are management information. Code every exit and stay interview comment into a short list of themes and count them each quarter.
| Theme | Example comment | Usual owner of the fix |
|---|---|---|
| Pay | I was offered more at the hospital for the same work | Practice manager and owners |
| Workload and staffing | I covered two seats most mornings | Office manager |
| Schedule and flexibility | I couldn't get school pickup days off | Office manager |
| Manager support | Nobody backed me up with the angry patient | Practice manager |
| Training and tools | I never really learned the insurance part | Front desk lead |
| Growth | I didn't see anywhere to go | Practice manager |
| Patient behavior | The abusive calls wore me down | Office manager |
| Team and culture | The two shifts didn't talk to each other | Office manager and lead |
Look at the counts alongside your own data: turnover by seat, tenure at departure, overtime, and how many leavers left within the first six months. Early departures often point to hiring or onboarding problems; departures after two or three years more often point to pay, growth or burnout.
Keep notes that are useful and safe
Write exit and stay interview notes the same day, in neutral language, recording what the person said rather than your interpretation of it. Quote key phrases where they help, such as I covered two seats most mornings. Keep notes separate from the personnel file where your HR adviser recommends it, restrict access to the people who review themes, and never include patient information. If an interview raises a possible legal issue, such as unpaid hours or a harassment complaint, record the facts, pass them to the person responsible for investigating and follow your policy for that type of complaint. The aim is a record that helps the practice improve and that you would be comfortable for the former employee to read.
Match themes to the levers that work
When MGMA asked practice leaders which tactics were most effective for retaining front-desk staff, higher pay and engagement tied at 33%, followed by flexible schedules at 19%[2]. Your exit data tells you which of those levers matters most for your team.
Source: Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), 2025[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Higher pay | 33% |
| Engagement | 33% |
| Flexible schedules | 19% |
If pay dominates, compare your rates with local job postings and set pay ranges by level. If workload dominates, run a workload assessment before replacing like for like. If manager support or growth comes up repeatedly, look at reviews, recognition and a visible career path. Replacement need is high regardless: the BLS projects about 105,100 receptionist openings a year over 2025-35, mostly to replace people who leave[5].
A quarterly review routine
Collect
Gather the quarter's exit and stay interview notes, coded by theme, plus turnover and tenure numbers.
Count and compare
Count themes and compare with the previous quarter. Note any theme that appears for the first time.
Pick one or two fixes
Choose the fixes with the most impact that you can act on within the next quarter.
Tell the team
Share what you heard, without names, and what you are changing. Staff are more open in future interviews when they see results.
Check the effect
Next quarter, see whether the theme count fell and whether turnover in the affected seat changed.
Example: a pattern behind three resignations
Example (fictional): an orthopedic practice loses three front desk staff in six months. Each exit form says better opportunity. The practice manager phones each person a few weeks after they leave and hears the same story: the lunch-hour phone shift is always covered by the newest person, alone, and the busiest callback block falls in that hour. Stay interviews with current staff confirm it. The practice rotates the lunch shift, adds a second person from 12 to 1 and moves the callback block to 2 p.m. The next two stay interview rounds do not mention lunch coverage, and no front desk employee resigns in the following two quarters.
Close the loop with policy
Some themes point to policies. Complaints about unpaid lunch interruptions or off-the-clock callbacks should be checked against overtime and wage-hour rules straight away, because they may involve pay owed. Complaints about inconsistent rules on time off or discipline point to the employee handbook. And feedback about reviews or recognition belongs in your performance review process. Exit interviews are most valuable when someone is clearly responsible for acting on them.
Frequently asked questions
What questions should I ask in an exit interview?
Ask what made them start looking, what would have had to change for them to stay, which parts of the work were hardest, whether they had the training and support they needed, how fair schedules felt and whether they saw a way to grow. Follow each answer with a request for an example.
Who should conduct exit interviews in a medical practice?
Someone other than the direct manager, such as the practice manager, an HR adviser or a manager from another site, so the employee can speak more freely.
What is a stay interview?
A short conversation with a current employee about what keeps them, what frustrates them and what might make them leave, held while there is still time to act.
What do you do with exit interview results?
Code comments into themes, count them each quarter, pick one or two fixes, tell the team what changed and check whether turnover in the affected area improves.
References
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Stabilized but not solved: Staff turnover in medical practices looking no better, no worse in 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2025). 5 proven tactics to retain front-desk staff - and how to do them right (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Stabilized but not solved: Staff turnover in medical practices looking no better, no worse in 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). JOLTS series JTS620000000000000QUR: Health care and social assistance, quits rate (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025-2035). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Receptionists (opens in a new tab) โ