Key takeaways
- HIPAA does not ban voicemails to patients; it requires reasonable safeguards and limiting the message to what is needed.
- A safe default message is the patient's first name, the practice name and a callback number, with no diagnosis, results or reason for the visit.
- Patients can ask to be contacted only by a certain method or at a certain number, and providers must accommodate reasonable requests without asking why.
- Automated reminder calls also fall under telemarketing law; the FCC's health care exemption comes with strict limits on content and frequency.
The short answer
Yes, a practice can leave voicemails for patients. HIPAA permits uses and disclosures that are incidental to an otherwise permitted one, as long as the practice has applied reasonable safeguards and the minimum necessary standard[1]. A message that reaches a shared voicemail box, or is heard by someone else in the house, can be an incidental disclosure; the practice's job is to keep the content small enough that little is revealed if that happens.
The harder questions are about what the message says, which number to use and what the patient has asked for. Those are the parts a practice should decide once, write down and train on.
Why voicemail is still part of the job
Despite portals and texting, most patient contact still runs through the phone. In an MGMA poll, only 11% of medical group leaders said a majority of their patients self-schedule, and 73% said a quarter or fewer of their patients use digital scheduling tools[2]. Callbacks for scheduling, referrals, forms and billing are a daily task, and many go to voicemail.
What to leave and what to keep out
| Usually fine | Keep out of a voicemail |
|---|---|
| Patient's first name, or first and last name if the patient has agreed | Diagnosis, condition, symptoms or test results |
| The practice name, or a neutral name if the patient has asked for that | The specialty, when it reveals the condition (for example oncology, fertility or behavioral health), unless the patient agreed |
| A callback number and the hours to call | Medication names, procedure names or reasons for the visit |
| The appointment date and time, for reminders | Balances, debt amounts or collections language |
| A request to call back about “a message from your care team” | Anything the patient has asked you not to leave |
When in doubt, leave less. A patient who calls back gets the full answer from a verified conversation; a detailed voicemail heard by the wrong person cannot be taken back.
Honor the patient's communication requests
Patients have a specific right here. A covered health care provider must permit patients to request, and must accommodate reasonable requests, to receive communications by alternative means or at alternative locations[3]. The practice may require the request in writing, but a provider may not require an explanation of why the patient wants it[3].
- Ask at registration and record the answers in a field every staff member sees: which number to call, whether messages may be left, how much detail, and whether texts or portal messages are preferred.
- Common requests include calling only a mobile number, never the home or work line, never leaving messages, or using a neutral practice name.
- Re-ask at least once a year and whenever a patient updates their phone number.
- Flag charts where a patient's safety may depend on discretion, for example where the patient has disclosed a concern about someone in the household, and make the flag hard to miss.
- If a patient's request cannot be met by your phone system, say so and agree an alternative, such as portal-only contact.
When someone else answers
A spouse, parent or roommate often picks up. HIPAA allows sharing with a family member or other person involved in the patient's care the information directly relevant to that involvement, when the patient agrees or does not object, or when staff judge it is in the patient's interest if the patient is not available[4]. For a routine callback, that rarely needs more than: “This is Lakeside Family Medicine for Maria. Could you ask her to call us back at this number?” If the patient's preferences say the person answering may hear more, follow them; if they say nothing, keep it to the callback request.
Situations that call for extra care
- Work numbers. A message on a work line or a shared office voicemail may be heard by colleagues. Use a work number only if the patient listed it for that purpose, and keep the message to a callback request.
- Teenagers. When a minor has consented to their own care, a message on the family's home line can disclose that care to a parent. Use the number and method the teen provided for those services.
- Sensitive specialties. For behavioral health, reproductive health, substance use treatment and similar services, avoid naming the clinic or service unless the patient has said it is fine.
- Shared or full mailboxes. If the greeting gives a different name or the mailbox is full, do not leave details; try the patient's other listed method or send a portal message.
- Wrong numbers. If the greeting suggests you have reached the wrong person, hang up without leaving the patient's name, and flag the number for correction.
- Language needs. If the patient prefers another language, use a template recorded or written in that language, or ask the patient to call back for an interpreter-assisted conversation.
Write these cases into the policy as short rules, so staff are not left to improvise when they meet one for the first time.
Automated reminder calls and the TCPA
Voicemails left by an automated or prerecorded system raise a second set of rules under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. In 2015 the FCC exempted certain health care calls and texts to mobile numbers from the consent requirement, subject to conditions[5]. The conditions include sending only to the number the patient provided, stating the provider's name and contact information, keeping voice calls generally to one minute or less, and initiating no more than one message per day and three per week[5]. The messages must not include telemarketing or billing and debt collection content, and must comply with HIPAA privacy rules[5].
The opt-out conditions matter for voicemail specifically: calls that could be answered by an answering machine or voice mail service must include a toll-free number the person can call to opt out of future calls[5]. And since February 2024 the FCC has treated calls made with AI-generated voices as artificial under the TCPA[6], so an AI voice counts as an artificial voice for these rules. Have your reminder vendor show you how its messages meet each condition.
Message templates
Callback request
“Hi, this is Jordan from Lakeside Family Medicine calling for Sam. Please call us back at 555-0142 between 8 and 5. Thank you.”
Appointment reminder
“This is Lakeside Family Medicine with a reminder for Sam about an appointment on Tuesday at 10:30. To confirm or change it, call 555-0142.”
Results or clinical follow-up
“This is Lakeside Family Medicine calling for Sam with a message from the care team. Please call us at 555-0142, or check your patient portal.” Never say the results are normal or abnormal.
Forms or paperwork ready
“This is Lakeside Family Medicine for Sam. The paperwork you asked for is ready. You can pick it up at the front desk or we can send it to your portal.”
Billing
“This is the billing office at Lakeside Family Medicine for Sam. Please call us at 555-0150 about your account.” No amounts and no collections language.
The names and numbers in these templates are fictional examples; replace them with your own. Keep templates on the script sheet so every caller uses the same wording.
Example: one patient, two numbers
Example (fictional). A patient registers with a home landline and a mobile number. On the intake form, she asks the practice to call only her mobile, to leave callback messages only, and to use the portal for results. The registration clerk records all three preferences in the communication field.
A month later, a new medical assistant needs to reach her about a referral. The chart shows the preferences at the top of the phone screen. The assistant calls the mobile number, gets voicemail, and leaves the callback template with no mention of the referral or specialty. She also sends a portal message with the details. The patient calls back the same afternoon. Without the recorded preference, the assistant might have called the landline and left the specialist's name on a shared machine.
Set the policy once
- Write a default message standard: what may be left, what never is, and how to use templates.
- Add communication preferences to registration and make them visible on every phone screen.
- Decide which messages go to the portal instead of voicemail, such as results and anything clinical.
- Review your reminder vendor's scripts against the TCPA conditions above and your HIPAA standard.
- Train new staff on the templates in their first week, and spot-check a sample of messages each quarter.
Related reading: verifying a caller's identity, talking to family members, HIPAA for front desk staff and sign-in sheets.
Frequently asked questions
Is leaving a voicemail a HIPAA violation?
Not by itself. HIPAA permits incidental disclosures when the practice uses reasonable safeguards and limits the information. Keep messages to a name, the practice and a callback number unless the patient has agreed to more.
Can we leave test results on voicemail?
It is safest not to. Results are better given in a verified call or through the patient portal. If a patient has asked in writing for results by voicemail at a specific number, follow your policy for honoring that request.
Do automated appointment reminders need patient consent?
The FCC exempted certain health care calls to mobile numbers from the consent requirement, but only under strict conditions on content, frequency and opt-out. Many practices also collect consent at registration to be safe.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2024). Putting the power of scheduling into patients' hands (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.522 - Rights to request privacy protection for protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.510 - Uses and disclosures requiring an opportunity for the individual to agree or to object (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Communications Commission (2015). Rules and Regulations Implementing the Telephone Consumer Protection Act of 1991, Declaratory Ruling and Order (FCC 15-72) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (news release) (opens in a new tab) ↑