Key takeaways
- Most workers with employer coverage have a deductible, so January visits often cost patients the full allowed amount.
- Check deductible status before the visit, not at the window, and tell the patient the likely amount in advance.
- Give staff short, tested scripts for the three moments that matter: the reminder call, check-in and the patient who objects.
- Watch for cost-driven cancellations. Offer an estimate conversation before a patient drops a visit they need.
Why January feels different at the desk
Every January, a patient who paid a small copay in November is suddenly asked for the full visit amount. Nothing changed at the practice; the plan year did. 88% of workers with single employer coverage have a general annual deductible that must be met before most services are paid[1], and the average for single coverage was $1,955 in 2026[2]. Workers at smaller firms face higher deductibles than those at larger ones[3], which matters if your patients skew toward small employers or self-employed families.
Source: KFF, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Smaller firms | $2,624 |
| Larger firms | $1,772 |
Out-of-pocket health spending reached $556.6 billion in 2024, up 5.9% in a year[4]. Patients feel that most sharply in the first quarter, and the front desk is where they feel it first. A practice that plans for the reset collects more at the time of service and fields fewer angry calls in February.
Who is most likely to be surprised
- Patients who changed jobs or plans in the fall and have not told you.
- People newly covered through the Marketplace, where enrolling by December 15 gives coverage starting January 1[5].
- Families on a plan with both individual and family deductibles, who may not know which one applies to a child's visit.
- Patients who met last year's deductible in the fall and got used to paying only copays.
- Patients on high-deductible plans with a health savings account, who may want to pay from a different card.
Flag these groups in your schedule for the first six weeks of the year so the person making reminder calls knows who needs the longer conversation.
Before the first visit of the year
Run eligibility early
For January and February visits, check eligibility two to three business days before each appointment and capture the remaining deductible, coinsurance and copay. Eligibility and prior authorization are already the most time-consuming phone tasks for staff[6], so batch these checks rather than doing them at check-in.
Ask for the new card
In every reminder, ask patients to bring or upload a new insurance card if anything changed on January 1.
Make the estimate
Use your fee schedule or payer allowed amounts to estimate what the patient will owe for the booked visit type.
Tell the patient
Share the estimate on the reminder call or by portal message, with the payment options you offer.
Note it in the account
Record the estimate and what the patient was told, so check-in staff do not start the conversation from zero.
Working out what the patient owes
The arithmetic is simple, but staff need to be confident with it. Until the deductible is met, the patient generally pays the plan's allowed amount for covered services, not your full charge. After it is met, coinsurance or copays apply. Preventive visits may be covered without cost sharing on many plans, so check how the plan treats the visit type you booked.
| Situation | What the patient likely pays | How to say it |
|---|---|---|
| Deductible not met, sick visit | The allowed amount for the visit | Your plan's deductible started over in January, so this visit applies to it. |
| Deductible partly met | Allowed amount up to what remains | You have a small amount left on your deductible; this visit should cover most of it. |
| Deductible met, coinsurance plan | A percentage of the allowed amount | Your deductible is met; your plan now pays most of the cost and you pay your share. |
| Preventive visit on a plan that covers it in full | Often nothing for the preventive part | The checkup itself is usually covered; anything extra we treat today may apply to your deductible. |
| Uninsured or self-pay | Your self-pay rate | Here is your good faith estimate for today's visit. |
Example: a patient with $1,200 left on her deductible books a follow-up visit with an allowed amount of $142. She owes $142 today and has $1,058 left on her deductible. A lab drawn at the same visit adds its own allowed amount, so quote the visit and say that tests may be billed separately.
Self-pay patients need a good faith estimate
January brings more patients between plans. When an uninsured or self-pay patient schedules a service at least three business days ahead, the provider must give a good faith estimate no later than one business day after scheduling, or within three business days if the visit is booked ten or more business days out[7]. Build that into the scheduling script, not the check-in script, so the timing is met.
Scripts for the three key moments
Reminder call: 'Hi, this is Lakeside Internal Medicine calling to confirm your visit on Thursday at 10. Since plans reset in January, we checked your coverage, and your deductible applies to this visit. We expect your share to be about the amount in your portal message. We take cards, HSA cards and payment plans. Do you have any questions before you come in?'
At check-in: 'Your estimate for today is in your account. Would you like to pay it now with a card or your HSA card? If anything else is done during the visit, we'll let you know before it is billed.'
When a patient objects: 'I understand, January is hard on a lot of our patients. The amount is set by your plan, not by us, and it counts toward your deductible for the rest of the year. If paying it today is a problem, we can set up a payment plan so you don't have to put off care.'
Lakeside Internal Medicine is a fictional name. Have your billing lead approve each script and check that the payment options you mention are ones you really offer.
Payment options and staff authority
- Decide in December which payment options you offer and post them at the desk and in reminder messages.
- Write down who can approve a payment plan and on what terms, so the front desk does not have to find a manager for every request.
- Collect card-on-file consent in writing if you charge cards after claims settle.
- Never hold a visit hostage. If a patient cannot pay, follow your written policy and involve the manager, especially for urgent care needs.
Questions patients ask, with short answers
- 'Why didn't I pay this last month?' Your deductible was met last year, so your plan paid more. It started over on January 1.
- 'Can I pay with my HSA card?' Yes, if your account allows it for this visit. Use it like a debit card at check-in.
- 'Is my son's visit on my deductible or his?' Family plans often have both. We checked your plan, and this visit applies to the amount shown in your estimate.
- 'Why is the bill different from the estimate?' Estimates cover the booked visit. Tests or procedures added during the visit are billed separately once the claim settles.
- 'Can you bill my plan and send me the rest?' We can for anything we cannot estimate today. For the visit itself, we collect the estimated amount now so you don't get a surprise bill later.
Print these on one page at each check-in station. Consistent answers matter more than perfect ones; patients get upset when two staff members tell them two different things.
Train the team before January 2
Hold a short session in the second half of December. Walk through three fictional patients, from eligibility check to check-in, and let each staff member practice the objection script out loud. Confirm that everyone can find the remaining deductible in your eligibility tool and knows where estimates are stored in the patient account. New and temporary staff hired for the winter rush need this most, and they are often the ones who start on the busiest days of the year.
Do not let cost turn into a no-show
In 2026, 32% of medical groups said no-show rates were higher than the year before[8]. Cost is one reason patients skip visits quietly instead of calling. When a patient cancels in January, have staff ask whether cost is part of the reason and offer to go through the estimate. A short call that ends with a payment plan keeps the visit, the revenue and the patient's care on track.
Checklist for the first six weeks
- Payment options and plan-approval rules agreed in December.
- Eligibility checks scheduled two to three business days ahead for every January visit.
- Reminder scripts updated to ask for new cards and mention the deductible.
- Good faith estimate step built into self-pay scheduling.
- Daily review of estimate accuracy against paid claims, starting in mid-January.
- Time-of-service collection rate tracked weekly against the fall.
The deductible reset is one of several January shifts. Pair this playbook with new year insurance re-verification and plan the year-end side in filling December schedules.
Frequently asked questions
Why do patients owe more at January visits?
Most employer plans have an annual deductible that resets at the start of the plan year, usually January 1. Until it is met, the patient generally pays the plan's allowed amount for covered visits.
Should we collect the deductible at check-in?
Collect what you can estimate reliably, such as the allowed amount for the booked visit, and tell the patient in advance. Bill anything uncertain, such as added tests, after the claim settles.
Do preventive visits count toward the deductible?
Many plans cover preventive care without cost sharing, but anything treated during the visit may apply to the deductible. Check the plan and explain the difference to the patient before the visit.
What if a patient cannot pay their January balance?
Offer the payment options in your written policy, such as a payment plan, and involve a manager for exceptions. Do not let cost delay urgent care.
References
KFF (2026). 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey (opens in a new tab) โ
KFF (2026). 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey (opens in a new tab) โ
KFF (2026). 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey (opens in a new tab) โ
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ
HealthCare.gov (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) (2026-2027). Dates and deadlines for 2027 health insurance (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Phones are still a bottleneck costing medical practices time they can't afford (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR ยง 149.610 - Requirements for provision of good faith estimates of expected charges for uninsured (or self-pay) individuals (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). About 1 in 3 medical groups see higher no-shows in 2026 as patients face higher costs (opens in a new tab) โ