Key takeaways
- Providers must work out whether Medicare is primary or secondary before submitting claims, by asking patients about other coverage.
- Employer size decides a lot: 20 or more employees for patients 65 and older with current employment coverage, 100 or more for those under 65 with a disability.
- Workers' compensation and no-fault or liability insurance pay first for related services.
- Ask at the first visit and reconfirm on a schedule, especially after open enrollment and any job change.
What the MSP questions decide
Medicare is not always the first payer for a Medicare patient. When a patient also has coverage through current employment, a spouse's employer, workers' compensation or an accident claim, that other coverage may have to pay first. The Medicare secondary payer questions, often run as a questionnaire at registration, work out which payer is primary for the visit.
Getting it wrong has a cost. A claim sent to Medicare when another payer should pay first can be denied, or paid and later recovered, sometimes long after the visit. A claim sent to the employer plan when Medicare should be primary is denied by that plan. Either way, the patient gets confused statements and the practice waits for money it has already earned.
What CMS expects from providers
CMS guidance is direct. Medicare provisions require providers to determine the primary or secondary payer for patient items or services before submitting claims[1]. For physicians and other Part B providers, CMS says to gather accurate MSP data by asking patients or their representatives about other coverage, and to bill the primary payer before billing Medicare[1].
CMS also sets a limit on what providers may do with the answer: you cannot deny Medicare-covered services to a patient because you find another coverage record[1]. The MSP questions decide who pays, not whether the patient is seen.
How many patients this touches
Medicare covered 20.1% of the US population in 2025[2], and for many primary care and specialty practices the share of visits is much higher. A growing number of people keep working past 65 or are covered through a working spouse, which makes the employer coverage questions more common, not less.
Employer size is the hinge for two of the most common situations. For patients 65 and older with group health plan coverage through their own or a spouse's current employment, the plan generally pays first when the employer has 20 or more employees; for patients under 65 with a disability, the threshold is 100 or more employees[3].
Source: Medicare.gov (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services), current[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Age 65 or older, current employment coverage | 20 employees |
| Under 65 with a disability, current employment coverage | 100 employees |
When to ask
At the first visit
Run the full set of questions for every new Medicare patient, before the visit is billed.
At each visit, a quick check
Ask whether anything about the patient's coverage or employment has changed since the last visit. CMS asks institutional providers to have patients update insurance information at each visit; a short check works well for practices too.
After open enrollment
The Medicare open enrollment period runs from October 15 to December 7, with changes effective January 1[4]. Re-run the questions at each patient's first visit of the year.
After any life event
Retirement, a new job, a spouse's retirement, an accident or a work injury all change the answers.
When eligibility shows other coverage
If the eligibility response flags another primary payer, ask the questions again before the visit.
The questions in plain language
The official model questionnaire is long and full of terms patients do not use. Ask the same questions in everyday words, and record the answers in the structured MSP fields of your practice management system.
- “Is today's visit because of an injury at work, a car accident or another accident?”
- “Are you working right now, with health insurance through your job?”
- “Is your husband, wife or partner working, with health insurance that covers you?”
- “About how many people work for that employer? Fewer than 20, 20 to 99, or 100 or more?”
- “Do you have Medicare because of age, a disability or kidney failure?”
- “If kidney failure, when did your Medicare start, and do you have an employer or union plan as well?”
- “Do you have any other insurance, such as a retiree plan, military coverage or a Medicare supplement?”
If the patient does not know the employer's size, record that, check with the employer plan or the patient's benefits office, and mark the payer order as unconfirmed until you know.
How the answers set billing order
| Situation | Pays first | Pays second |
|---|---|---|
| 65 or older, coverage from own or spouse's current job, employer has 20 or more employees | Group health plan | Medicare |
| 65 or older, coverage from own or spouse's current job, employer has fewer than 20 employees | Medicare | Group health plan |
| Under 65 with a disability, coverage from own or family member's current job, employer has 100 or more employees | Large group health plan | Medicare |
| Under 65 with a disability, employer has fewer than 100 employees | Medicare | Group health plan |
| Services related to a work injury | Workers' compensation | Medicare only in limited cases |
| Services related to an accident with no-fault or liability coverage | No-fault or liability insurance | Medicare |
| Retiree coverage only | Medicare | Retiree plan |
These rows summarize Medicare's published guidance[3]. Multi-employer plans have an extra wrinkle: if the patient's small employer belongs to a multi-employer group where at least one employer has 20 or more staff, the group plan generally pays first[1].
Kidney failure and the coordination period
Patients with end-stage renal disease follow a different rule. When they have group health plan coverage, the plan pays first during a 30-month coordination period, after which Medicare becomes primary[1]. If Medicare was already primary because of age or disability and the patient has no group plan coverage, Medicare stays primary during and after the coordination period[1]. Record the date Medicare entitlement based on kidney failure began, because the coordination period runs from it.
Accidents and work injuries
Workers' compensation pays first for items or services related to a work claim, and no-fault or liability insurance pays first for services related to an accident or injury[3]. If the no-fault or liability insurer does not pay promptly, Medicare may make a conditional payment and recover it later[3]. Create a separate injury case for these visits and bill unrelated care to Medicare as usual. The full intake for these patients is in workers' comp and auto injury intake.
Common mistakes
- Assuming that a patient over 65 is Medicare primary without asking about current employment.
- Asking about the patient's job but not the spouse's.
- Treating a retiree plan as if it were current employment coverage.
- Recording a Medicare Advantage plan as Original Medicare, or the reverse.
- Leaving the questionnaire answers in a scanned form instead of the structured fields billing uses.
- Never re-asking after the first visit, so a retirement two years later goes unnoticed.
When patients push back on the questions
Long-time Medicare patients often find the questions repetitive or intrusive, especially questions about a spouse's job. A short explanation usually ends the resistance.
- “Medicare asks every office to check this before we send a bill, so the right insurance pays first. It saves you confusing letters later.”
- “I know we asked last year. Plans and jobs change, so we check again each January. It takes under a minute.”
- “If you are not sure how many people work at your wife's company, that is fine. I will note it, and our billing team can check with the plan.”
- “None of this affects whether the doctor sees you today. It only decides where we send the bill.”
For patients who complete forms online, put the MSP questions on their own short page with a one-line explanation at the top, and pre-fill answers from the last visit with a clear prompt to confirm or change them. Staff should still read the answers before the visit and call the patient if anything looks inconsistent with eligibility results.
Documenting the answers
Keep the answers with the date asked and who asked them. When billing questions the payer order months later, the record should show what the patient said and when. Many practice management systems have an MSP screen that stores the answers and sets the payer order automatically; check that it is turned on and that staff complete it rather than skipping past it.
Example: a fictional cardiology practice with a large Medicare panel found that a run of denials came from patients whose spouses had employer coverage. Its registration asked only about the patient's own job. It added the spouse question, asked about employer size, and re-ran the questions at each patient's first visit of the year. The denials from employer plans and Medicare recoveries both fell. Related reading: self-pay intake, updating patient demographics and cutting double entry.
Frequently asked questions
Do physician practices have to use the MSP questionnaire?
CMS expects Part B providers to gather MSP information by asking patients about other coverage and to bill the primary payer first. The model questionnaire is one way; plain-language questions recorded in structured fields work too.
How often should we ask MSP questions?
Ask in full at the first visit, do a quick change check at each visit and re-run the full set at the first visit of each year and after any job change or accident.
Is Medicare primary if the patient works for a small company?
For patients 65 and older with coverage through current employment, Medicare generally pays first when the employer has fewer than 20 employees, unless the employer is part of a multi-employer plan with a larger employer.
Can we refuse to see a Medicare patient until other coverage is sorted out?
No. CMS says providers cannot deny Medicare-covered services because another coverage record exists. Sort out the payer order for billing, but see the patient.
References
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2025). Medicare Secondary Payer (MLN Booklet MLN006903) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Census Bureau (2025). Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2025 (Current Population Reports P60-291) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Medicare.gov (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) (current). Who pays first? (opens in a new tab) ↑
Medicare.gov (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) (current). Joining a plan (opens in a new tab) ↑