Key takeaways
- A waitlist is a promise. Only run one if you will actually offer places from it, in a predictable order.
- Give callers an honest estimate, an alternative and a clear explanation of how the list works.
- Write down the order rules and the few exceptions, and apply them the same way to every caller.
- Confirm every entry on a fixed cycle and remove people who no longer need a place, so the list stays real.
When a waitlist makes sense
A waitlist is the right tool when your practice is closed or limited to new patients but expects to open places in the coming months, because a clinician is joining, a schedule is being restructured or established access is recovering. It is the wrong tool when there is no realistic plan to take anyone from it. A list that never moves is worse than an honest no, because patients stop looking elsewhere while they wait for a call that never comes.
Decide before you start how many places you expect to open per month, and from when. That number drives what you tell callers and how long the list can sensibly get.
Waits are moving in both directions
Access is uneven across practices. In a 2026 poll, 28% of medical groups said new-patient wait times were longer than a year earlier, 46% said about the same and 22% said shorter[1]. The year before, the split was 31% longer, 40% the same and 26% shorter[2]. A waitlist strategy should assume that capacity can improve as well as worsen, and be ready to move people quickly when it does.
- 2025
- 2026
Source: Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | 2025 | 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Longer | 31% | 28% |
| About the same | 40% | 46% |
| Shorter | 26% | 22% |
Patient access is a leading concern for practice leaders: asked about their top access focus for 2026, they split between no-shows at 27%, online scheduling at 24%, phone access at 22% and wait times at 21%[3]. A well-run waitlist touches all four.
What to tell callers
The call is the waitlist's front door. Keep the script honest and specific.
- Status: “Dr. Ruiz's panel is full right now, so we are not booking new patients directly.”
- Offer: “I can add you to our new patient waitlist. We expect to start offering places in the spring, and we contact people in the order they joined.”
- Estimate: “Right now I would expect a wait of a few months, but I cannot promise a date.”
- Alternative: “If you need care sooner, here are two nearby practices that are accepting new patients, and urgent care is open evenings and weekends.”
- Next step: “We will text you every couple of months to check you still want a place. Reply to keep your spot.”
Never imply a caller is on a list if they are not. If you are not keeping a list, say so and give alternatives.
What to record for each entry
| Field | Why |
|---|---|
| Date and time joined | Sets the order on the list |
| Name, date of birth and mobile number | Identifies the person and how to reach them |
| Preferred clinician or location, if any | Matches offers to openings |
| Insurance plan | Confirms you can accept the plan when a place opens |
| Reason category (routine, transfer of care, referral) | Applies your written exceptions |
| Household members also waiting | Lets you offer places together |
| Last confirmed date | Shows whether the entry is current |
| Outcome | Offered, accepted, declined, removed, with date |
Keep clinical detail out of the list. Callers with urgent symptoms should be directed to urgent care or emergency services, not placed on a list.
Keeping the list fair
Fairness is mostly about writing the order down and sticking to it. First come, first served works for most practices, with a short list of written exceptions approved by the practice owner or medical director.
- Typical exceptions: family members of current patients, transfers from a clinician leaving the practice, and referrals from your own specialists or hospital program.
- Apply exceptions by category, never by who the caller knows.
- Do not reorder by insurance type. Secret shopper research has found Medicaid coverage associated with a markedly lower likelihood of successfully scheduling appointments[4]; a list that quietly favors other plans compounds that.
- Record every exception used, with the category and who approved it.
- Review the list's order once a quarter for anything that looks out of line.
Keeping the list current
Confirm on a cycle
Every 60 to 90 days, text each person: “You are on the new patient waitlist at Lakeside Family Medicine. Reply YES to keep your place or NO to be removed.”
Follow up once
If there is no reply after a week, send one reminder.
Remove after no response
After two unanswered confirmations, mark the entry as removed for no response, with the date. Explain this rule when people join.
Remove people who found care
Ask in the confirmation whether they have found another practice, and thank those who have.
Report the real length
Count only confirmed entries when estimating waits for new callers.
One list or several?
Multi-clinician and multi-site practices face a design choice: one practice-wide list, or a list per clinician or location. A single list is simpler and fairer, because everyone moves in one order. Separate lists suit practices where patients strongly prefer a particular clinician, language or site, but they drift out of balance quickly, with one list stuck for months while another clears in weeks.
A workable middle path is one list with a preference field. When a place opens with any clinician, offer it to the next person in order whose preferences fit, and record a declined offer without moving them to the back. Patients who said any clinician is fine will usually move fastest, so say that when they join: “If you are happy to see any of our doctors or our nurse practitioner, you will likely be offered a place sooner.”
Whichever design you choose, report the length and movement of every list at the same monthly meeting, so nobody discovers a forgotten list a year later.
Offering places
When places open, move quickly and predictably. Offer to the next confirmed people in order, give a clear response window and move on if they do not respond.
- Offer text: “Good news: a new patient place with Dr. Ruiz is available. Reply within two days or call us to book your first visit.”
- If no response in the window, offer the place to the next person and keep the first person's entry with a note.
- Book households together when you can, so a family is not split across waits.
- Send the welcome packet the same day the patient books, so the first visit is prepared.
People will not wait forever
Waiting has consequences. Among US adults who use AI tools for health information, 18% said a major reason was not having a regular provider or not being able to get an appointment, rising to 38% among users aged 18 to 29[5]. People on a waitlist are often getting by on urgent care, online advice or nothing at all. Include those alternatives in your messages so patients know where to go safely while they wait.
The not-accepting-new-patients message
Callers hear the status long before they talk to anyone. Make the recorded greeting, the website and online booking say the same thing in the same words.
- Phone greeting: “Thank you for calling Lakeside Family Medicine. We are not accepting new patients at this time, but you can join our waitlist. Press 2 for new patients.”
- Website: “New patients: our panel is currently full. Join our waitlist by calling us or using the form below. Last updated 1 November.”
- Online booking: hide new patient visit types and show the waitlist form instead.
- Referrers: send a short notice with the date you expect to reopen and which referrals you still accept.
Measures to watch
- Confirmed entries on the list, and how that number changes each month.
- Median days from joining to an offer.
- Share of offers accepted within the response window.
- Entries removed for no response, and for finding care elsewhere.
- Exceptions used, by category.
Example: a fictional pediatric practice had a paper waitlist with several hundred names, many from a year earlier. It texted everyone a confirmation and found that most no longer needed a place. The confirmed list was short enough to clear within two months once a new nurse practitioner started, and the practice now confirms entries every 60 days. See should you keep accepting new patients, self-pay intake and the new patient arrival flow.
Frequently asked questions
Should we keep a waitlist if our panel is closed?
Only if you expect to open places and will offer them from the list in a predictable order. Otherwise, tell callers you are not keeping a list and give them alternatives.
How often should we update the waitlist?
Confirm each entry every 60 to 90 days by text or call, and remove entries after two unanswered confirmations, as explained when people join.
Can we prioritize some patients on the waitlist?
Yes, with a short list of written exceptions such as family members of current patients or referrals from your specialists. Apply them by category and record each use.
What should we say on our voicemail when we are not accepting new patients?
State that the panel is full, how to join the waitlist and where to go for urgent care, and keep the wording the same as on your website.
References
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). New-patient wait times largely hold flat in 2026 as some groups add providers in bid to meet demand (opens in a new tab) ↑
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2025). Opportunities to improve new-patient appointment wait times in your medical practice (opens in a new tab) ↑
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2025). Patient access priorities for 2026: Tackling wait times, phones, no-shows and more (opens in a new tab) ↑
Inquiry: The Journal of Health Care Organization, Provision, and Financing (via PubMed Central) (2019). Medicaid Patients Have Greater Difficulty Scheduling Health Care Appointments Compared With Private Insurance Patients: A Meta-Analysis (Inquiry, 2019) (opens in a new tab) ↑
KFF (2026). KFF Tracking Poll on Health Information and Trust: Use of AI For Health Information and Advice (fielded Feb 24 - Mar 2, 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑