HIPAA and Compliance

New York SHIELD Act: What Medical Offices Must Do

How New York's SHIELD Act overlaps HIPAA for medical and dental offices, the extra breach notices New York requires, and a front office response plan.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Two laws inside one name
  2. Where HIPAA already does the work
  3. Where New York adds steps after a breach
  4. The inadvertent exposure exception
  5. A breach response plan for a New York office
  6. Teach the front desk to spot a breach
  7. Example: a misdirected spreadsheet
  8. What it costs to get this wrong
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
HIPAA and Compliance: New York SHIELD Act: What Medical Offices Must DoArticle coverHIPAA AND COMPLIANCENew York SHIELD Act:What Medical OfficesMust DoAva Medical IntakeInsightsHIPAA and Compliance: New York SHIELD Act: What Medical Offices Must DoArticle coverHIPAA AND COMPLIANCENew York SHIELD Act:What Medical OfficesMust DoAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • A practice that complies with HIPAA is deemed compliant with SHIELD's data security section, but the breach notice rules still add New York steps.
  • New York requires notice to affected residents within 30 days of discovering a breach, and HIPAA-covered practices that notify HHS must also notify the Attorney General within five business days.
  • Even when HIPAA notices go to patients, the Attorney General, Department of State and State Police must still be told.
  • Employee and payment records are private information too, so staff files and card data need the same protection as charts.

Two laws inside one name

The SHIELD Act changed two parts of New York's General Business Law. Section 899-aa sets out who must be told after a breach of private information and how fast. Section 899-bb requires businesses that hold New York residents' private information to keep reasonable administrative, technical and physical safeguards[1][2]. Both reach any practice that owns or licenses computerized private information of New York residents, which includes out-of-state practices that see New York patients or employ New York residents[1].

Private information is broader than a lot of office managers expect. It includes medical information, meaning information about a person's medical history or mental or physical condition, and health insurance information such as a policy or subscriber number[1]. It also includes the classic identity data that sits in every HR folder and billing system. For a medical office, that means charts, insurance cards, staff files and card payments are all in scope.

Where HIPAA already does the work

The data security section gives HIPAA-covered practices real relief. A business that is subject to and in compliance with the HIPAA and HITECH regulations is treated as a compliant regulated entity and deemed to meet SHIELD's safeguards requirement[2]. The key words are 'in compliance'. A practice that has never done a security risk analysis, has no written policies or has not trained staff cannot lean on the deeming rule, and it is then judged against SHIELD's own list of safeguards.

SHIELD Act safeguard areas compared with a typical HIPAA security program. Source: GBL 899-bb.
SHIELD safeguard areaWhat it asks forWhere a HIPAA program usually covers it
AdministrativeA named coordinator, risk assessment, staff training, vendor selection and contracts, regular updatesSecurity official, risk analysis, workforce training, business associate agreements
TechnicalRisk assessment of networks and software, detecting and responding to attacks, testing key controlsSecurity Rule technical safeguards, audit controls, incident procedures
PhysicalSecure storage and disposal, intrusion response, protection in transport, erasing old mediaFacility access, device and media controls, disposal policy

Small businesses get a scaled standard: safeguards appropriate to their size and complexity. A small business is one with fewer than 50 employees, or under $3 million in gross annual revenue in each of the last three fiscal years, or under $5 million in year-end total assets[2]. Most independent practices qualify, but scaled safeguards are still safeguards.

Where New York adds steps after a breach

Breach notice is where New York differs most. Affected New York residents must be notified in the most expedient time possible and without unreasonable delay, and no later than 30 days after the breach is discovered[1]. HIPAA's outer limit for notifying individuals is 60 calendar days after discovery[3].

Outer limit to notify affected people after discovering a breachNew York: GBL 899-aa. HIPAA: 45 CFR 164.404.
Outer limit to notify affected people after discovering a breachComparison. New York residents (SHIELD): 30 days; HIPAA individual notice: 60 days.30 daysNew York residents (SHIELD)New York residents (SHIELD): 30 days60 daysHIPAA individual noticeHIPAA individual notice: 60 daysOuter limit to notify affected people after discovering a breachComparison. New York residents (SHIELD): 30 days; HIPAA individual notice: 60 days.30 daysNew York residents (SHIELD)New York residents (SHIELD): 30 days60 daysHIPAA individual noticeHIPAA individual notice: 60 days

Source: New York State Senate, 2024[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
New York residents (SHIELD)30 days
HIPAA individual notice60 days

There is an important overlap rule. If you notify affected people under HIPAA, the statute says no additional notice to those people is required, but you must still notify the New York Attorney General, the Department of State and the Division of State Police[1]. A covered entity that reports a breach to the HHS Secretary must also send that notice to the Attorney General within five business days[1]. If more than 5,000 New York residents are notified at one time, consumer reporting agencies must be told as well[1].

Do not forget HIPAA's small-breach log. Breaches affecting fewer than 500 people are reported to HHS within 60 days after the end of the calendar year[4]. If New York's five-business-day rule is triggered by HHS notice, that annual filing date is the day the clock starts, so diarize it.

Breaches of staff files or card data are not PHI breaches, so HIPAA's notices do not apply and New York's 30-day clock to affected residents runs on its own.

The inadvertent exposure exception

Notice to affected residents is not required when information was exposed inadvertently by people authorized to access it and the practice reasonably concludes that misuse or financial or emotional harm is unlikely[1]. That determination must be written down and kept for at least five years, and if it covers more than 500 New York residents, it must be sent to the Attorney General within ten days[1]. Front desk examples include an email with an appointment list sent to the wrong colleague inside the practice, which is very different from a list sent to a stranger.

A breach response plan for a New York office

  1. Hour one: contain and record

    Stop the exposure: recall the email, disable the account, retrieve the paper. Write down what happened, when it was discovered and who discovered it. The discovery date starts both the HIPAA and New York clocks.

  2. Day one: classify the data

    Decide whether the data is PHI, other private information (staff files, card numbers) or both, and how many New York residents are involved. Classification decides which notices and which clocks apply.

  3. Days two to five: risk assessment

    For PHI, run the HIPAA four-factor risk assessment. For other private information, test the inadvertent-exposure exception and document the reasoning either way.

  4. By day 30: notify people

    Send individual notices so that New York residents are told within 30 days of discovery unless law enforcement has asked for a delay. This also meets HIPAA's 60-day outer limit.

  5. Same window: notify the state

    File with the Attorney General, Department of State and State Police. If you notify HHS, send the Attorney General a copy within five business days. Add consumer reporting agencies if more than 5,000 New Yorkers are notified[1].

  6. Afterwards: fix and file

    Update the risk analysis, retrain the staff involved and keep the file, including any written no-notice determination, for at least five years.

Teach the front desk to spot a breach

Most small-practice breaches are found by front office staff, not by IT. The clock starts at discovery, so the people who answer phones and handle mail need to know what to report and to whom. Give them a short list and a single person to tell, the same day.

  • A patient calls to say they received someone else's statement, results or appointment letter.
  • An email, text or fax with patient details went to the wrong recipient, inside or outside the practice.
  • A laptop, phone, tablet or paper schedule left the office and has not come back.
  • A login was shared, a password was written on a monitor, or a former employee can still sign in.
  • A vendor tells you it had an incident, even if it says no data was affected.

Ask staff to write down the time they noticed, what they saw and what they did, and not to try to investigate on their own. A clear first note makes every later step faster.

Example: a misdirected spreadsheet

Example: a fictional four-provider family practice in Albany discovers on a Monday that a front desk lead emailed a spreadsheet of 340 upcoming appointments, with names, dates of birth and insurance member numbers, to a personal address belonging to a former employee. This is a PHI disclosure to someone no longer authorized, so the inadvertent exception does not fit. The practice manager logs the discovery date, asks the former employee in writing to delete the file and confirm, runs the HIPAA risk assessment, and decides notice is required. Letters go out on day 12. Because fewer than 500 people are affected, the HHS report goes in the annual log, and the Attorney General, Department of State and State Police are notified in the same week as the letters. The practice then turns on outbound email rules that block spreadsheets with member numbers from leaving the domain.

What it costs to get this wrong

For knowing or reckless failures to notify, a court can impose a civil penalty of the greater of $5,000 or up to $20 per failed notification, with the per-notification amount capped at $250,000[1]. SHIELD's security section does not create a private right of action[2], but HIPAA civil money penalties sit on top for PHI, starting at $145 per violation in the lowest tier and capped at $2,190,294 per calendar year for identical provisions[5]. Teams that already keep tidy HIPAA files usually find SHIELD adds paperwork rather than new controls. For other states your patients come from, see our notes on Washington's health data law and record retention by state.

Frequently asked questions

Does HIPAA compliance satisfy the SHIELD Act?

For the data security section, yes: a business in compliance with HIPAA and HITECH is deemed compliant. For breach notification, New York still requires notice to the Attorney General, Department of State and State Police, and has its own 30-day clock for notifying residents.

Do we have to send patients two breach letters?

No. If you notify affected people under HIPAA, the statute does not require additional notice to them, but the state agencies must still be notified.

Does SHIELD apply to a practice outside New York?

It applies to any person or business that owns or licenses computerized private information of New York residents, so practices near the state line or with New York employees should plan for it.

Can patients sue under the SHIELD Act's security section?

The data security section says it does not create a private right of action. The Attorney General enforces it.

References

  1. New York State Senate (2024). New York General Business Law section 899-AA: Notification; person without valid authorization (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. New York State Senate (2019). New York General Business Law section 899-BB: Data security protections (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR § 164.404 - Notification to individuals (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR § 164.408 - Notification to the Secretary (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR § 102.3 - Penalty adjustment and table (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo