Patient Experience

Patient Experience Metrics Worth Tracking

Eight patient experience measures a practice can track without a survey vendor: access, phones, callbacks, portal replies, no-shows and reviews.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why a short list works better than a long survey
  2. The short list
  3. How to calculate the access and phone measures
  4. Setting thresholds from your own baseline
  5. The in-office part of the experience
  6. Turning comments into themes
  7. Example: a monthly one-page review
  8. Who owns what
  9. Common mistakes
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Patient Experience: Patient Experience Metrics Worth TrackingArticle coverPATIENT EXPERIENCEPatient ExperienceMetrics Worth TrackingAva Medical IntakeInsightsPatient Experience: Patient Experience Metrics Worth TrackingArticle coverPATIENT EXPERIENCEPatient ExperienceMetrics WorthTrackingAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Track a short list of measures you can pull from your phone system, schedule and portal, and review them on a fixed rhythm.
  • Access and responsiveness measures move first and are the easiest to act on: days to the third next available visit, answered calls, callbacks kept and portal reply time.
  • Pair each number with a named owner and a threshold that triggers action, or the dashboard becomes decoration.
  • Read survey comments and reviews for themes; a handful of specific complaints is more useful than a single satisfaction score.

Why a short list works better than a long survey

Most practices already hold the raw data for patient experience. The phone system logs calls, the schedule shows how far out the next opening is, the portal timestamps every message and the review sites show what patients say in public. The problem is rarely a lack of data. It is too many numbers with no owner.

Practice leaders are also split on where to focus. Asked to name their top patient access priority for 2026, US practice leaders spread their answers across no-shows (27%), online scheduling (24%), phone access (22%) and wait times (21%)[1]. No single measure covers all four, which is why a small balanced set works better than one headline score.

Top patient access focus for 2026, US practice leaders
Top patient access focus for 2026, US practice leadersBar chart. No-shows: 27%; Online scheduling: 24%; Phone access: 22%; Wait times: 21%.No-showsNo-shows: 27%27%Online schedulingOnline scheduling: 24%24%Phone accessPhone access: 22%22%Wait timesWait times: 21%21%Top patient access focus for 2026, US practice leadersBar chart. No-shows: 27%; Online scheduling: 24%; Phone access: 22%; Wait times: 21%.No-showsNo-shows: 27%27%Online schedulingOnline scheduling: 24%24%Phone accessPhone access: 22%22%Wait timesWait times: 21%21%

Source: Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
No-shows27%
Online scheduling24%
Phone access22%
Wait times21%

The short list

The table below gives eight measures, where the data usually lives and how often to look. Start with the ones your systems can already produce and add the rest over time.

Eight patient experience measures for a medical practice
MeasureWhere the data livesReviewAct when
Third next available appointment (new and established)Scheduling systemWeeklyIt rises two weeks in a row
Answered-call rate during open hoursPhone system reportsWeeklyIt falls below your target
Average hold timePhone system reportsWeeklyPeak-hour holds exceed your target
Callbacks completed within the promised windowCallback log or task listDailyAny open promise at close of day
Portal message reply timePatient portal or EHR inboxWeeklyMessages wait more than two business days
No-show rate by visit typeScheduling systemMonthlyOne visit type moves well above the rest
Check-in to rooming timeEHR timestampsMonthlyPatients wait longer at the busiest sessions
Review rating and themesGoogle, health directories, comment cardsMonthlyThe same complaint appears three times

Thresholds should be your own. A practice with one front desk person will set a different answered-call target than a multi-site group with a call center. What matters is that the threshold exists before the number moves, so nobody debates whether a bad week is bad.

How to calculate the access and phone measures

  1. Third next available

    Count the calendar days from today to the third open slot for a given visit type. The third slot ignores one-off cancellations that make access look better than it is.

  2. Answered-call rate

    Divide calls answered by a person or an approved automated option by all calls offered during open hours. Count abandoned calls in the denominator.

  3. Hold time

    Use the phone system's average and also look at the worst hour of the week, because patients remember the worst wait.

  4. Callback completion

    Divide callbacks completed inside the promised window by all callbacks promised that day.

  5. Portal reply time

    Measure from the patient's message to the first response that answers or routes it, in business hours.

Access is under pressure in many practices. In July 2026, 28% of US medical groups said new-patient wait times were longer than a year earlier, against 22% who said shorter[2]. Tracking third next available by visit type shows whether your own practice is part of that trend.

70%

of US medical groups reported rising patient portal message volume in 2024[3]

Portal measures matter more each year. Seven in 10 medical groups reported an increase in portal message volume in 2024 and only 1% a decrease[3]. If reply time is not measured, the inbox quietly becomes the slowest channel in the practice.

Setting thresholds from your own baseline

Benchmarks from other practices are a poor starting point because phone systems, visit mixes and staffing differ so much. A better method is to pull eight to twelve weeks of your own data, find the typical range and set the first threshold just outside it. That way the alert fires when something has genuinely changed, not every Monday.

  1. Pull the baseline

    Export the last two to three months of each measure, by week. Note holiday weeks and provider absences so you can exclude them.

  2. Find the normal range

    Look at the middle of the distribution rather than the best week. If answered-call rates usually sit between the high 80s and low 90s, that band is your normal.

  3. Set the action line

    Put the threshold just below the bottom of the normal band for good-direction measures, or just above the top for waits and delays.

  4. Write the first response

    Decide in advance what happens when the line is crossed, such as moving a person to phones at 8 a.m. or opening an extra new-patient block.

  5. Tighten later

    After a quarter of stable results, move the threshold a step and repeat.

This approach also keeps the measures honest. When a target is set from a wish rather than a baseline, staff learn to explain away misses, and the dashboard loses credibility within a few months.

The in-office part of the experience

Phones and portals get most of the attention, but the visit itself still shapes how patients describe the practice. Two measures are worth adding once the access basics are in place. The first is check-in to rooming time, taken from EHR timestamps, which shows whether delays start at the desk or in the back. The second is whether patients were told about a delay. A simple rule, such as telling every patient who has waited past a set time how long the remaining wait is likely to be, can be tracked with a tick on the schedule.

Look at these by session rather than by day. A practice can look fine on average while the Monday afternoon session runs late every week because it absorbs the morning's overflow. Splitting the data by session makes that pattern visible and points to a scheduling fix rather than a staff performance conversation.

Turning comments into themes

Numbers show where to look; comments show what to fix. Once a month, read the free-text comments from surveys, comment cards and online reviews and tag each with one theme: phones, scheduling, wait in office, billing, staff courtesy or clinician communication. More than half of surveyed patients in one study said they read online reviews of their physician[4], so public comments are part of the experience other patients see.

  • Count themes, not stars. Three comments about hold music at lunch is a staffing pattern.
  • Quote the patient's words in the team meeting, without names, so staff hear the experience directly.
  • Close the loop: when a theme leads to a change, say so at the front desk or in the next newsletter.

Example: a monthly one-page review

Example (fictional): Riverbend Internal Medicine reviews its eight measures on the first Tuesday of each month. Last month the third next available new-patient visit rose from 9 to 16 days, the answered-call rate dipped on Monday mornings, and two reviews mentioned waiting on hold to reschedule.

The practice manager traced both problems to the same cause: a provider on leave had left reschedules piling up on Mondays. The fix was a temporary Monday morning reschedule block for one staff member and a recorded message offering the portal for non-urgent reschedules. The next month the Monday dip closed and the new-patient wait fell back to 11 days.

Note what made this work in the example. Each measure had an owner, the thresholds were already written down and the review looked at two measures together rather than in isolation.

Who owns what

Patient experience measures are only useful if someone is responsible for each one. A simple split many practices use:

  • Front desk lead: answered-call rate, hold time and callback completion.
  • Clinical lead or nurse manager: portal reply time and check-in to rooming time.
  • Scheduler or practice manager: third next available and no-show rate.
  • Office manager or owner: reviews, survey comments and the monthly summary.

Turnover can distort these numbers. In 2026, 29% of medical group leaders reported higher staff turnover than in 2025[5]. When a new hire joins the front desk, expect phone measures to slip for a few weeks and plan cover rather than reading it as a failure.

If overflow or after-hours calls go to an answering service or an SI Employee such as Ava, include those calls in your answered-call rate and read a sample of call transcripts in the monthly review, so the measure reflects what patients actually experience.

Common mistakes

  • Measuring only satisfaction scores. A high average can hide a phone line nobody can get through.
  • Reviewing everything weekly. Some measures, like no-show rate by visit type, need a month of data to mean anything.
  • Ignoring the denominator. A low abandoned-call count on a quiet day says little.
  • Setting targets nobody can meet. Start from your current baseline and improve in steps.
  • Changing several things at once. Change one thing, watch two measures, then decide.

For ways to improve the measures once you are tracking them, see personal touches small practices can afford and handling after-visit questions without clogging phones.

Frequently asked questions

What is the single most useful patient experience metric?

There is no single one. If you can only track one, third next available appointment shows access problems early, but pair it with answered-call rate so you also see the phone experience.

How often should a practice review patient experience metrics?

Callbacks daily, phone and access measures weekly, and no-shows, rooming time and review themes monthly. A quarterly look at trends helps with staffing decisions.

Do we need a survey vendor to measure patient experience?

Not to start. Phone reports, the schedule, portal timestamps and online reviews cover most of what matters. A formal survey adds value once those basics are tracked.

Should online reviews count as a patient experience measure?

Yes, as a source of themes rather than a score. Read them monthly, tag the theme and look for repeats.

References

  1. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2025). Patient access priorities for 2026: Tackling wait times, phones, no-shows and more (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). New-patient wait times largely hold flat in 2026 as some groups add providers in bid to meet demand (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2024). Ensuring accurate coding and billing for patient portal messages as e-visits (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Kansas Journal of Medicine (via PubMed Central) (2022). Millennials Seeking Healthcare: Examining the Degree to Which Patients Utilize Online Resources (Kansas Journal of Medicine, 2022) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Stabilized but not solved: Staff turnover in medical practices looking no better, no worse in 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo