Seasonal Operations

Annual Payer Contract and Fee Schedule Review

Compare payer rates against volume and Medicare, flag underpayments, check contract terms and plan renegotiations with a yearly review method.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why a yearly review pays off
  2. What to gather
  3. Build a fair comparison
  4. Worked example: what a rate gap is worth
  5. Medicare Advantage and managed Medicaid contracts
  6. Find the underpayments
  7. Terms beyond the rates
  8. Decide: keep, renegotiate or end
  9. How to renegotiate
  10. Small practices have more leverage than they think
  11. Bring the front desk along
  12. A yearly review calendar
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References
Seasonal Operations: Annual Payer Contract and Fee Schedule ReviewArticle coverSEASONAL OPERATIONSAnnual Payer Contractand Fee Schedule ReviewAva Medical IntakeInsightsSeasonal Operations: Annual Payer Contract and Fee Schedule ReviewArticle coverSEASONAL OPERATIONSAnnual Payer Contractand Fee ScheduleReviewAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Review every major payer contract once a year, on a set calendar, before renewal and notice dates pass.
  • Compare rates for your highest-volume codes, weighted by volume and expressed as a share of Medicare, so payers can be compared fairly.
  • Check what you were actually paid against what the contract says. Underpayments hide in remittances.
  • Rates are only part of a contract. Timely filing, escalators, authorization rules and termination terms matter as much.

Why a yearly review pays off

Payer contracts tend to renew quietly. A rate agreed years ago keeps rolling over while practice costs climb: 84% of medical groups reported higher year-to-date operating costs in 2026 than at the same point in 2025[1]. On the Medicare side, physician payments declined 33% from 2001 to 2026 after adjusting for inflation in practice costs[2]. Commercial payers are where most of the money sits. Private health insurance spending grew 8.8% to $1,644.6 billion in 2024[3], against $931.7 billion for Medicaid[4] and $556.6 billion paid out of pocket[5].

US health spending by selected payer, 2024
US health spending by selected payer, 2024Bar chart. Private health insurance: 1,645 billion dollars; Medicaid: 931.7 billion dollars; Out of pocket: 556.6 billion dollars.Private health insurancePrivate health insurance: 1,645 billion dollars1,645 billion dollarsMedicaidMedicaid: 931.7 billion dollars931.7 billion dollarsOut of pocketOut of pocket: 556.6 billion dollars556.6 billion dollarsUS health spending by selected payer, 2024Bar chart. Private health insurance: 1,645 billion dollars; Medicaid: 931.7 billion dollars; Out of pocket: 556.6 billion dollars.Private health insurancePrivate health insurance: 1,645 billion dollars1,645 billion dollarsMedicaidMedicaid: 931.7 billion dollars931.7 billion dollarsOut of pocketOut of pocket: 556.6 billion dollars556.6 billion dollars

Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), 2024[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Private health insurance1,645 billion dollars
Medicaid931.7 billion dollars
Out of pocket556.6 billion dollars

A review once a year, done the same way each time, tells you which contracts pull their weight, which are underpaying, and where you have a case to ask for more.

What to gather

  • Every current payer contract, with amendments, fee schedules and renewal and notice dates.
  • Twelve months of claims data: billed codes, units, allowed amounts and paid amounts by payer.
  • The current Medicare Physician Fee Schedule rates for your locality.
  • Denial and appeal data by payer and reason.
  • Days in accounts receivable by payer.
  • Notes on payer behavior: authorization hassles, credentialing delays, recoupments.

Build a fair comparison

  1. Pick the codes

    List the 20 to 30 codes that make up most of your revenue. For most practices these are office visit codes plus a handful of procedures or tests.

  2. Get each payer's rate

    Pull the contracted allowed amount for each code from each payer's fee schedule, not from a sample of paid claims.

  3. Convert to a share of Medicare

    Divide each rate by the Medicare rate for the same code and locality. This puts every payer on one scale.

  4. Weight by volume

    Multiply by how often you bill each code to that payer. A high rate on a code you rarely bill matters little.

  5. Rank the payers

    Compare each payer's volume-weighted average against the others and against your cost per visit.

Example: a fictional practice's payer comparison
PayerVolume-weighted rate (share of Medicare)Share of visitsDenial rateNotes
Commercial payer A128%24%6%Renews in March; escalator ended last year
Commercial payer B112%18%11%Heavy authorization rules for imaging
Medicare Advantage plan C98%15%9%Paid below traditional Medicare on visit codes
Managed Medicaid plan D74%12%8%Slow credentialing for new providers

Worked example: what a rate gap is worth

Example: in the fictional comparison above, payer B pays a volume-weighted 112% of Medicare and payer A pays 128%. Suppose payer B accounts for 6,000 visits a year with an average Medicare-equivalent allowed amount of $110. Moving payer B from 112% to 120% of Medicare adds about $8.80 per visit, or roughly $52,800 a year. That number, set against the staff time a renegotiation takes, tells the practice whether the effort is worth it, and it gives the request letter a concrete figure.

Run the same sum for every payer on your renegotiation list and rank them by value. The biggest gains often come from a mid-sized payer with an old fee schedule rather than the largest payer.

Medicare Advantage and managed Medicaid contracts

Contracts with Medicare Advantage and managed Medicaid plans need the same review, with a few extra checks. Confirm whether rates are tied to the current Medicare fee schedule or frozen at an older year, which matters every January when the schedule changes. Look closely at authorization rules, which are often stricter than in traditional Medicare, and at how quickly the plan credentials new providers. For managed Medicaid, check the state's own fee schedule and any rules on how plans must pay.

Find the underpayments

The contract says one thing; the remittance may say another. Load each payer's contracted rates into your billing system if it supports it, and run a report of claims paid below the contracted amount. If not, sample at least 50 paid claims per major payer and compare by hand. Common causes include a fee schedule never updated after an amendment, the wrong locality, bundling the contract does not allow, and quiet recoupments.

Look at denials in the same pass. Physicians report that 32% of prior authorization requests are often or always denied[6], and a payer whose rates look good may cost more in rework than one with lower rates and fewer denials. Put a rough staff cost on denials and appeals for each payer before deciding which contracts are worth keeping.

Terms beyond the rates

  • Escalators: does the contract raise rates each year, by a set amount or tied to an index?
  • Fee schedule basis: is the rate a share of a named year's Medicare schedule, and does it update?
  • Timely filing and appeal deadlines, and whether they are realistic for your billing cycle.
  • Authorization and referral rules, including which services are carved out to other vendors.
  • Recoupment rules: how far back the payer can recover payments, and with what notice.
  • Credentialing timelines for new providers.
  • Term, renewal and termination: notice periods, and what happens to patients in treatment.

Termination notice periods are the ones that catch practices out. Some contracts require notice many months before the end of the term. Put every notice date on the calendar the day you finish the review.

Decide: keep, renegotiate or end

  • Keep when the payer's weighted rate covers your cost per visit, denials are manageable and the patient base matters to you.
  • Renegotiate when rates are below your cost or well below peers, an escalator has expired, or administrative burden has grown.
  • Consider ending when rates are below cost with no movement after renegotiation, and the patients have other in-network options nearby.
  • In every case, count the patients affected and the effect on your access goals before deciding.

How to renegotiate

Start early: most payers take months to respond. Prepare a short data pack showing your volume, rates as a share of Medicare against your other payers, quality and access measures, and any services you offer that the payer's network lacks, such as extended hours or same-day access. Send a written request to your provider relations contact with a specific ask, then follow up on a schedule. Keep the termination notice date in view in case talks stall.

Practices must negotiate their own rates. Sharing rate information or agreeing on rates with competing practices can raise antitrust problems. Groups that negotiate together usually do so through a properly structured network with legal advice.

Small practices have more leverage than they think

47.4% of physicians worked in practices with 10 or fewer physicians in 2024[7], so small practices are a large part of every payer's network. Payers need enough primary care and specialty access to meet network requirements, especially in rural and fast-growing areas. Strong data on access, patient satisfaction and quality, plus evidence of how many of the payer's members you see, is often enough to open a conversation.

Bring the front desk along

Contract changes reach patients through the front desk. When a contract changes or ends, update the accepted-plans list on the same day it takes effect, tell schedulers and the phone team, and change any website or phone wording that lists plans. If you end a contract, give affected patients clear written notice with the date and their options, following any notice rules in the contract and your state.

A yearly review calendar

  1. Summer: pull claims data and contracts; build the comparison.
  2. Early fall: run the underpayment review and fix systemic issues.
  3. Fall: decide which contracts to keep, renegotiate or end; send letters before notice dates.
  4. November to December: load new Medicare rates and any renegotiated commercial rates for January.
  5. First quarter: check that new rates are being paid correctly on the first remittances.

The review sits inside your wider Q4 planning and depends on the January update covered in Medicare fee schedule changes each January. Use the results to brief staff in the annual front desk training refresh.

Frequently asked questions

How often should a practice review payer contracts?

Once a year on a fixed calendar, plus whenever a payer sends an amendment. Start in the summer so decisions are made before fall notice deadlines.

How do we compare rates across payers?

Take your highest-volume codes, express each payer's rate as a share of the Medicare rate for your locality, and weight by how often you bill each code to that payer.

How do we find underpayments?

Compare paid amounts with contracted rates, either through your billing system or by sampling paid claims for each major payer, and look for patterns such as outdated fee schedules or wrong localities.

Can small practices renegotiate payer rates?

Yes. Bring data on volume, rates against other payers, access and quality, and start months before the renewal date. Negotiate on your own rather than coordinating with competitors.

References

  1. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Operating costs keep climbing for medical practices in 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. American Medical Association (2001-2026). June 18, 2026: National Advocacy Update (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  6. American Medical Association (2026). AMA survey: Prior authorization reform pledge falls short with physicians (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  7. American Medical Association (2024). Physician Practice Characteristics in 2024: Private Practices Account for Less Than Half of Physicians in Most Specialties (Policy Research Perspectives) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo