Marketing and Patient Growth

Removing Fake or Policy-Violating Reviews

What Google removes, how a practice reports and appeals fake or policy-violating reviews, how to handle review attacks and what to do when one stays.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. What Google will and will not remove
  2. Before you report: gather evidence
  3. How to report a review
  4. Statuses and appeals
  5. Review attacks and extortion
  6. When a review stays up
  7. Do not create the problem yourself
  8. Reviews on other platforms
  9. Preventing the next attack
  10. Example: a former employee's review
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Marketing and Patient Growth: Removing Fake or Policy-Violating ReviewsArticle coverMARKETING AND PATIENT GROWTHRemoving Fake orPolicy-ViolatingReviewsAva Medical IntakeInsightsMarketing and Patient Growth: Removing Fake or Policy-Violating ReviewsArticle coverMARKETING AND PATIENT GROWTHRemoving Fake orPolicy-ViolatingReviewsAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Google removes reviews that break its content policies, such as fake engagement, conflicts of interest, off-topic content and harassment. It does not remove reviews because a business disagrees with them.
  • Report through your Business Profile or Google's Reviews Management Tool, check the status there, and use the one-time appeal for reviews found not to violate policy.
  • Never pay anyone who offers to remove reviews or demands money to stop posting them; report it.
  • When a review stays, reply calmly without patient details and let a steady flow of genuine reviews put it in context.

What Google will and will not remove

Google judges reported reviews against its content policies, not against the business's account of what happened. Its help page advises against reporting a review just because you disagree with it or dislike it, and says Google does not get involved in conflicts between businesses and customers[1]. Knowing which reviews are likely to qualify saves time and frustration.

Review types and the likely outcome of a report
Review typeLikely policy issueWhat to do
Posted by a competitor, former employee or someone with a grudge connected to the businessConflict of interestReport as conflict of interest; note the relationship if known
Clearly about a different businessOff-topicReport; reply politely inviting the person to call
One of a sudden burst of reviews from accounts with no historyFake engagementReport each; document the pattern
Contains threats, slurs or harassmentHarassment or hate speechReport; follow your safety procedures if there is a threat
Includes someone's personal information, such as a staff member's home addressPersonal informationReport promptly
Offered in exchange for a reward from a competitor or a third partyPaid or incentivized contentReport
Harsh but genuine complaint about a real visitUsually noneDo not report; reply and fix the issue if there is one

The policy list is broad. Google's prohibited content includes reviews or ratings that have been paid for, directly or in kind, and content based on a conflict of interest, which may include current or former employment or a contractual relationship[2]. A former employee's review of the practice therefore usually qualifies for a report, while a patient's angry but honest account usually does not.

Before you report: gather evidence

  • Screenshot the review with its date, star rating and reviewer name.
  • Note anything that links the reviewer to a conflict, such as a former employee's name or a competitor's staff, but do not search patient records to identify a reviewer.
  • For a burst of reviews, list them all with times and note that the accounts have no other reviews or share patterns.
  • Write a one-paragraph summary of why each review breaks a specific policy. You may need it for the appeal.
  • Keep a log of every report, the date and the outcome.

Never check the practice's records to work out whether a reviewer was a patient for use in a reply or a report. Looking up patients for that purpose raises privacy problems of its own.

How to report a review

  1. From the Business Profile

    Go to your Business Profile, select Read reviews, choose Report next to the review, pick a reason and send the report[1].

  2. Or from the Reviews Management Tool

    Open the tool, confirm your account, select the business, choose the option to report a new review, then select Report next to the review and submit the reason[1].

  3. Choose the closest reason

    Match the reason to the policy issue in your evidence notes, such as conflict of interest or off-topic.

  4. Wait for the evaluation

    Google says evaluation typically takes several days[1]. Avoid reporting the same review repeatedly in the meantime.

  5. Check the status

    Return to the Reviews Management Tool to see whether a decision is pending or the report was reviewed.

Statuses and appeals

The Reviews Management Tool shows where each report stands. "Decision pending" means the review is flagged but not yet evaluated. "Report reviewed - no policy violation" means Google found no violation, and you can then submit a one-time appeal. "Escalated - check your email for updates" means an appeal was escalated and the final decision will come by email[1].

Appeals are made from the same tool by choosing to check the status of previously reported reviews and appeal eligible ones; up to 10 reviews can be selected at a time[1]. Use your evidence summary in the appeal form and be specific about which policy the review breaks. If the appeal also finds no violation, the review stays live.

Review attacks and extortion

Some practices face sudden waves of fake one-star reviews, sometimes followed by a message demanding payment to remove them. Google says its systems now flag scam patterns, including demands for payment to remove fake one-star reviews, and that when spam reviews suddenly spike it removes the fake content, may temporarily pause new reviews on the profile, alerts the owner and shows a notification banner[3]. Google reports that it blocked or removed over 292 million policy-violating reviews in 2025, while more than 1 billion helpful reviews were published[3].

Google Maps reviews in 2025Google-reported figures: more than 1 billion helpful reviews published and over 292 million blocked or removed
Google Maps reviews in 2025Comparison. Helpful reviews published: 1,000 million; Policy-violating reviews blocked or removed: 292 million.1,000 millionHelpful reviews publishedHelpful reviews published: 1,000 million292 millionPolicy-violating reviews blocked or removedPolicy-violating reviews blocked or removed: 292 millionGoogle Maps reviews in 2025Comparison. Helpful reviews published: 1,000 million; Policy-violating reviews blocked or removed: 292 million.1,000 millionHelpful reviews publishedHelpful reviews published: 1,000 million292 millionPolicy-violating reviews blocked orremovedPolicy-violating reviews blocked or removed: 292 million

Source: Google (The Keyword blog), 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Helpful reviews published1,000 million
Policy-violating reviews blocked or removed292 million
  1. Do not pay, and do not reply to the extortion message beyond what is needed to preserve it.
  2. Report the reviews and keep screenshots of both the reviews and the demand.
  3. Brief the front desk so staff can answer callers calmly.
  4. Consider reporting the demand to law enforcement, and talk to counsel.
  5. Avoid any "reputation repair" vendor that promises to remove reviews for a fee. Removal decisions belong to the platform.

When a review stays up

Many unwelcome reviews will stay, because they are genuine opinions. What you can control is how the profile looks overall and how you respond.

  • Reply once, calmly and without patient details: apologize for the experience in general terms and invite the reviewer to call the practice manager.
  • Fix the underlying issue if there is one, and mention the general fix in the reply if appropriate.
  • Keep asking every patient for a review in the same way, so one bad review sits among many representative ones.
  • Do not threaten legal action over an honest review. The FTC rule on consumer reviews prohibits certain review suppression practices[4], and aggressive threats tend to draw more attention to the review.

Readers weigh replies as much as reviews. In one survey, 57% of patients said they read online reviews of their physician[5]. A calm, professional reply to a harsh review often reassures them more than a perfect rating would.

Do not create the problem yourself

Practices sometimes end up on the wrong side of the same policies they report others for. A burst of five-star reviews from staff, relatives or a marketing vendor can be flagged as fake engagement and removed, and it can expose the practice under federal rules. The FTC rule bans selling or purchasing fake consumer reviews, buying positive or negative reviews and undisclosed insider reviews[6].

  • Do not ask staff, their families or vendors to review the practice.
  • Do not hire services that post reviews or promise a rating.
  • Do not post reviews of competitors, positive or negative.
  • Do not move reviews between profiles or ask patients to repost reviews from another site in bulk.

Reviews on other platforms

Health directories and social platforms have their own rules and reporting tools. The principles are the same: report content that breaks the platform's policies, such as reviews about the wrong clinician, fake accounts or abusive language, and accept that genuine opinions stay. Directory reviews about a different doctor with a similar name are common; report those with the correct clinician details, and make sure the profile itself is accurate. See claiming Healthgrades, Vitals and WebMD profiles for the profile side.

Preventing the next attack

A few habits make attacks less damaging. Keep the Business Profile owned by practice-controlled accounts with at least two managers, so someone can act quickly. Keep alert emails going to a shared inbox that is read daily. Maintain a steady flow of genuine reviews, which makes a sudden burst of fake ones easier for the platform to spot and less damaging to your rating. And log every report, so you have a record if a pattern develops.

Example: a former employee's review

Example (fictional): Two weeks after a front desk employee left Cedar Point Family Practice on bad terms, a one-star review appeared under a name the office manager recognized, describing staff and internal procedures rather than a visit. The manager screenshotted the review, reported it from the Business Profile as a conflict of interest and noted the reason in the practice's log.

In this example, the first report came back as no policy violation, so the manager used the one-time appeal with a short explanation of the employment connection, without mentioning any patients. The appeal was escalated and the review was later removed. The practice kept its reply on the review until then: a brief note inviting the reviewer to contact the practice manager. For the wider routine, see online reputation management for practices, and for the federal rules, see FTC rules on reviews and testimonials.

Frequently asked questions

Can a medical practice get a bad Google review removed?

Only if it breaks Google's content policies, for example a fake review, a conflict of interest, off-topic content or harassment. Genuine negative opinions usually stay up.

How long does Google take to review a reported review?

Google says evaluation typically takes several days. Check the status in the Reviews Management Tool.

What if Google says the review does not violate its policy?

You can submit a one-time appeal from the Reviews Management Tool with a clear explanation of which policy the review breaks.

Someone is demanding money to stop posting fake reviews. What should we do?

Do not pay. Preserve the messages and reviews, report the reviews to Google, brief your staff and consider contacting law enforcement and counsel.

References

  1. Google Business Profile Help (2026). Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. Google (2026). Prohibited & restricted content (Maps user-generated content policy) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Google (The Keyword blog) (2026). New ways we're protecting businesses on Maps (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Federal Trade Commission (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2024). Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (Final rule, 89 FR 68034) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. Kansas Journal of Medicine (via PubMed Central) (2022). Millennials Seeking Healthcare: Examining the Degree to Which Patients Utilize Online Resources (Kansas Journal of Medicine, 2022) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  6. Federal Trade Commission (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2024). Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (Final rule, 89 FR 68034) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo