Call Coverage and Answering Services

Switching Answering Services Without Losing Calls

A cut-over plan for changing medical answering services: contract dates, protocols, parallel test calls, the forwarding change and a first-week audit.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. Where calls get lost in a switch
  2. Four weeks out: the old contract
  3. Three weeks out: move the protocols
  4. Two weeks out: parallel test calls
  5. Cut-over day: change the forwarding
  6. Tell everyone who calls you
  7. The first-week audit
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
Call Coverage and Answering Services: Switching Answering Services Without Losing Calls1 business day: interval carriers must meet for a simple port of a phone number unless a longer one is requestedCALL COVERAGE AND ANSWERING SERVICESSwitching Answering ServicesWithout Losing Calls1 business dayinterval carriers must meetfor a simple port of a phonenumber unless a longer one i…Ava Medical IntakeInsightsCall Coverage and Answering Services: Switching Answering Services Without Losing Calls1 business day: interval carriers must meet for a simple port of a phone number unless a longer one is requestedCALL COVERAGE AND ANSWERING SERVICESSwitching AnsweringServices WithoutLosing Calls1 business dayinterval carriers must meet for asimple port of a phone number unless alonger one is requestedAva Medical Intake
Figure source: Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, current[1]

Key takeaways

  • Start with the old contract: renewal date, notice deadline, record export and who controls any number patients or hospitals call.
  • Move your protocols as a document the practice owns, then test the new service with fictional calls on a test line before any real call is forwarded.
  • Cut over on a weekday during office hours, keep the old service running for an overlap, and tell hospitals, labs and pharmacies about any new number.
  • Audit the first week call by call: compare counts, read every message and keep placing test calls until the numbers match.

Where calls get lost in a switch

Practices rarely lose calls because the new answering service is worse than the old one. They lose them in the gap between the two: a forwarding rule changed at 5 p.m. on a Friday and never tested, a hospital switchboard still dialling the old service's number, an on-call schedule sent to one vendor and not the other, a weekend of messages stranded in the old vendor's portal after the account closed. Each of those is a planning failure, and each has a fix.

There is no quiet window to hide a mistake in. More than half of US emergency department visits in 2022, 56.3%, arrived outside weekday business hours[2], and some of those patients rang a practice first. A switch only has quieter windows, and the plan below uses them.

It runs over about four weeks: two of preparation, one of parallel testing, then the cut-over and a week of audit. Compress it if you must, but keep the test calls and the overlap. Those two steps are where lost calls are caught.

Give the switch three named owners before anything else happens:

  • A project owner, usually the practice manager, who holds the dates, the contracts and the checklist.
  • A clinical lead, usually the medical director, who signs the paging rules and reviews every test call that should have led to a page.
  • A phone-system owner, in-house or your phone vendor, who changes the forwarding and can reverse it within minutes if the first night goes wrong.

The last role is the one practices skip. Write down how to point the line back at the old service, and keep that note by the phone system until the audit is finished.

Four weeks out: the old contract

  1. Find the renewal date, the notice deadline and the form notice must take. Missing the deadline can mean paying two services for months.
  2. Check who controls each number. If the old service issued the number patients, hospitals or labs call, find out whether you can port it; carriers must complete a simple port within one business day unless a longer period is requested[1].
  3. Ask for an export of messages, call logs and recordings now, and again after the last night of service.
  4. Ask in writing what the vendor will do with your records afterwards. Under the business associate agreement it must return or destroy them if feasible and keep no copies[3].
  5. Ask for a short month-to-month extension so the two services can overlap.

Give notice only once the new contract is signed and its test line works. The contract terms guide covers what to fix in the new agreement so the next switch is easier, from export rights to number control. And sign the new vendor's business associate agreement before anyone shares real patient details with it: HIPAA allows a covered entity to let a business associate handle protected health information only with satisfactory written assurances[4].

Three weeks out: move the protocols

Do not ask the new service to copy the old one's account. Vendors format instructions differently, and a straight copy carries over every rule that went out of date years ago. Export what the old service holds, compare it with your own master document, and send the new vendor a clean version with a new version number and date. If you have no master document, write one now; writing answering service instructions sets out the parts.

  • Greeting, disclosures and the word-for-word emergency and crisis lines.
  • Every call type with its single action: answer, message, transfer or page.
  • The paging rules your physicians signed, and the on-call schedule for the first month with change-over times.
  • Contact methods and backups for each clinician, in the order to try them.
  • The message format, where each message type is delivered, and by when.
  • Who may change the instructions, and how the vendor confirms each change.

Have the physicians who take call sign the paging section again, even if nothing in it changed. A signature on the new vendor's file is what its agents will be held to, and the on-call escalation rules deserve a fresh read anyway. Keep the old version alongside the new one: HIPAA requires required policy documentation to be kept for six years from the date it was last in effect[5].

Two weeks out: parallel test calls

Ask the new service for a test number that runs on your new instructions, and call it the way patients will. Use fictional names and details in every test call; real patient information has no place in a test.

Example scenarios with fictional details. Score each call the same way and repeat any that fail.
ScenarioExpected actionWhat to check next morning
Caller describes chest painApproved 911 line, at onceExact words used; call logged
Post-op patient with a feverPage the on-call surgeonPage time, re-page if no callback, message fields
Hospital asking for the physicianPage immediatelyMinutes from call to page
Refill request at 10 p.m.Routine messageDelivered on time, to the right inbox
Spanish-speaking parentSpanish-speaking agent or interpreterDelay before the caller was understood
Caller asking for office hoursAnswered in full, no messageNot turned into a message for staff
Caller who hangs up mid-callLogged, callback rule appliedShows in the log

Make the calls at different hours, including after midnight and on a weekend morning, and have more than one person call; agents handle a calm manager differently from a breathless parent. Score each call against the written rule, not against your impression of the agent. A failure is either the vendor's training or your wording, so fix the wording first and call again. Test delivery as well: messages should arrive where your instructions say, in the format they describe, at the time agreed.

Run one page test with each physician who takes call, on the phone they will actually carry that night. A page that reaches the right person in the test but lands on a muted work phone at 3 a.m. is still a missed page, and the first week of a new service is the wrong time to discover it.

If you are splitting the line at the same time, so that routine office questions go to an SI Employee and patient calls transfer to the new service, test that path in the same script. A call cannot be transferred back to the line that forwarded it, so the service's own number is the transfer destination, not your main line. You can try a demo call to hear how office questions are answered from approved information before deciding.

Cut-over day: change the forwarding

Example: a Tuesday cut-over
  • Your team
  • System
  • Caller
  1. 01Your team

    Morning final check

    Test line passed every scenario; both vendors confirm the on-call schedule.

  2. 02System

    Midday forwarding change

    After-hours and overflow rules now point to the new service.

  3. 03Caller

    Outside test calls

    Call the main line from a mobile on each path: closed, busy, no answer.

  4. 04System

    First night

    New service answers; the old one stays live for anyone dialling it directly.

  5. 05Your team

    Next-morning check

    Phone system's forwarded-call count compared with the new service's log.

Example. Pick a weekday, never the start of a weekend or a holiday.

Change forwarding during office hours, when staff are in the building to notice a mistake, and test every path that sends calls to the service: the after-hours schedule, busy overflow and no-answer overflow. Call from a mobile, not an internal extension, because internal calls often follow different rules. How each path is set up on common phone systems is covered in forwarding office phones to an answering service.

If a number is being ported, submit the request early in the day. Under FCC rules, a complete simple port request received between 8 a.m. and 1 p.m. local time is eligible for activation at midnight the same day[1]. Keep the old service live for at least a week after the switch: hospitals, nursing facilities and pharmacies often keep an answering service's direct number on file, and patients save numbers from old voicemail greetings. Ask the old vendor to log anything that still arrives and pass it on.

Tell everyone who calls you

List everyone who might call the answering service directly rather than your main line, and give each of them the new number and the date: hospitals where your physicians have privileges, nearby emergency departments, labs and imaging centers, the pharmacies you deal with most, nursing and home health agencies, and practices that share call with you. Update the voicemail greeting, website, patient portal and printed after-hours instructions on the same day, using the same words as your after-hours voicemail greeting.

Watch caller ID as well. If the new service, or the on-call physician working through it, calls patients back from a number they do not recognize, many will let it ring: in a 2020 Pew survey, 80% of US adults said they generally do not answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers[6]. Ask the service which number its callbacks display, and tell patients in the greeting which number to expect.

US adults who generally don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbersPew Research Center survey, July 2020. 19% said they generally do answer.
US adults who generally don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbersDonut chart. Generally don't answer unknown numbers: 80%.Generally don't answer unknown numbers: 80%80%
  • Generally don't answer unknown numbers 80%

Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Generally don't answer unknown numbers80%

The first-week audit

  1. Count every night

    Compare the phone system's count of forwarded calls with the new service's log. A gap of more than one or two calls needs an explanation the same day.

  2. Read every message

    For the first week, one named person reads every message against the format and the rule it should have followed.

  3. Check the pages

    Ask each on-call physician whether every page made sense and arrived when the log says it did.

  4. Keep test-calling

    Place two fictional test calls a night at different hours, at least one of which should lead to a page.

  5. Check the old line

    Ask the old vendor how many calls still reached it and from whom, then contact those callers again with the new details.

  6. Close the old account

    After a full week with matching counts and nothing reaching the old service, give final notice, take the last export and get written confirmation of destruction.

After the first week, move to a weekly sample for a month, then monthly. The answering service problems practices report most give you a list of what to sample for, and the family practice morning-rush example shows overflow and after-hours forwarding set up as separate paths, which makes each easier to test on its own. If the switch is part of a wider rethink, how to choose a medical answering service covers the selection side.

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take to switch medical answering services?

Plan on about four weeks: two to prepare the protocols and contracts, one for parallel test calls, then the cut-over and a week of audit with the old service still live. Most of the time goes on testing, not setup.

Can we keep the same phone number when we switch?

Your main office number does not change; only where it forwards. If patients or hospitals call a number the old service issued, you may be able to port it, and carriers must complete a simple port within one business day unless a longer period is requested[1]. Check the old contract first.

Should we tell patients we changed answering services?

Tell them what changes for them: a new number to call, a different number for callbacks, or new instructions in the greeting. Most patients only notice the greeting and whether someone calls back when promised.

What happens to messages stored with the old service?

Export them before the account closes. Under the business associate agreement, the old vendor must then return or destroy what it holds if feasible and keep no copies[3].

When is the safest time to cut over?

A weekday during office hours, with staff in the building to spot a problem and the old service still running as a backstop. Avoid Fridays, the day before a holiday and the peak of flu season.

References

  1. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 47 CFR § 52.35 - Porting Intervals (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2022). National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2022 Emergency Department Summary Tables (Table 3) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.504 - Uses and disclosures: Organizational requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.530 - Administrative requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo