Scheduling and Access

Telehealth or In-Person? A Front Desk Decision Guide

A front desk decision guide for telehealth vs in-person visits: three deciding questions, a provider-approved list of visit reasons and red flags.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the desk needs a written guide
  2. Three questions that decide the format
  3. Example provider-approved list
  4. Red flags that override the list
  5. Patient factors that change the answer
  6. When a phone visit is the better choice
  7. What patients choose
  8. If you cannot offer the right visit, patients go elsewhere
  9. At the desk: the decision in five steps
  10. Example: three calls on a Monday
  11. Keep the list current
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References
Scheduling and Access: Telehealth or In-Person? A Front Desk Decision GuideArticle coverSCHEDULING AND ACCESSTelehealth orIn-Person? A Front DeskDecision GuideAva Medical IntakeInsightsScheduling and Access: Telehealth or In-Person? A Front Desk Decision GuideArticle coverSCHEDULING AND ACCESSTelehealth orIn-Person? A FrontDesk Decision GuideAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Front desk staff should not make clinical calls; give them a provider-approved list of reasons suited to video, phone or office visits.
  • Three questions decide most cases: does the visit need hands-on care or a test, can the patient join by video, and is there any red flag?
  • Red flag symptoms always go to the nurse or emergency instructions, never to a booked video slot.
  • Patients who cannot get a suitable visit with you will often go to urgent care or a retail clinic instead.

Why the desk needs a written guide

When a patient calls and asks whether they can be seen by video, the scheduler is being asked a clinical question. Without a guide, answers vary by who picks up. One scheduler books a video visit for a rash, another refuses a video visit for a medication check that the provider would happily do from a desk. Patients notice the inconsistency, and providers end up converting visits on the day.

The fix is a short list, written and approved by your clinicians, that sorts common visit reasons into video, phone or office, with clear red flags that override everything. Schedulers apply the list; anything not on it goes to the nurse. The guide below is an example to adapt with your own providers, specialty and payer rules.

Three questions that decide the format

  1. Does the visit need hands-on care, an exam that cannot be done on camera or a test done in the office, such as a swab, a urine sample, an injection or an ECG? If yes, book in person.
  2. Can the patient join a video visit? They need a working device with a camera, a private place, a connection that will hold and a location where the provider can legally see them. If not, offer phone if the reason allows it, or the office.
  3. Is there any red flag in what the patient described? If yes, stop and follow the red flag rule, whatever format the patient asked for.

If the three answers point to video, check the list to confirm the reason is approved. If the reason is not on the list, send a message to the nurse rather than guessing.

Example provider-approved list

Example visit reasons sorted by format; your clinicians set the final list
Visit reasonVideoPhoneOfficeNotes
Stable chronic condition follow-upYesSometimesYesOffice if labs or vitals are due and not available from home
Medication check or dose reviewYesYesYesVideo preferred if side effects need to be seen
Results reviewYesYesYesOffice if results need an exam or procedure next
Behavioral health follow-upYesSometimesYesConfirm the patient has privacy
Rash or skin concernSometimesNoYesVideo only if the provider allows photos or good lighting
Cold symptoms without red flagsSometimesSometimesYesOffice if a test is needed
Urinary symptomsPer provider protocolPer provider protocolYesSome practices require a urine test
Injury, joint or back painInitial triage onlyNoYesExam usually needed
Annual physical or wellness examPartlyNoYesSome wellness elements can be done by video; payer rules vary
New patient visitPer providerNoYesMany practices require the first visit in person

Red flags that override the list

Agree red flags with your clinical team and print them next to the list. When a caller mentions one, the scheduler does not book a video or office slot. They follow the escalation rule: emergency instructions to call 911 for life-threatening symptoms, or a warm transfer to the nurse for urgent ones.

  • Chest pain or pressure, trouble breathing, signs of stroke, fainting or severe bleeding.
  • High fever in a young infant, a child who is hard to wake or not drinking.
  • Severe abdominal pain, pregnancy with bleeding or pain, or a sudden severe headache.
  • Thoughts of self-harm; give the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline and transfer to clinical staff.
  • Any symptom the patient describes as the worst they have ever had.

A video slot is not a triage tool. If a patient's description makes the scheduler uneasy, the right answer is a nurse callback today, not a video visit next week.

Patient factors that change the answer

  • No private space: a patient calling from an open-plan office or a shared home may prefer phone or office for sensitive topics.
  • Hearing or vision loss: video may help lip reading, or phone may be easier; ask.
  • Interpreter needed: check that the platform supports an interpreter joining before booking video.
  • Caregiver involvement: a family member may need to join from another place.
  • Location at the time of the visit: patients traveling out of state may not be eligible for a video visit with your provider.
  • Preference: some patients simply want to be seen in person. Where the reason allows both, let them choose.

When a phone visit is the better choice

Audio-only visits are often treated as a fallback for failed video, but for some patients and reasons they are the right first choice. The decision is still clinical, so the list should say where phone is allowed, but schedulers should know the situations where it fits best.

  • The patient has no camera-enabled device, limited data or a weak connection where they live.
  • The visit is mostly conversation: reviewing normal results, adjusting a medication the patient tolerates well or checking how a plan is going.
  • The patient has a cognitive or physical condition that makes video hard, and a caregiver can help by phone.
  • The patient is at work and can step away for a call but not for a video session.
  • An interpreter can join by phone more easily than by video on your platform.

Coverage and billing for audio-only care differ by payer and have changed several times in recent years. Before offering phone as an option, make sure your billing team has confirmed which payers and services allow it, and keep that in the same guide the schedulers use. A phone visit the practice cannot bill for is a cost, and a patient told afterwards that it was not covered will be unhappy with the practice, not the payer.

What patients choose

Telehealth is a mainstream choice, not a niche one. In national survey data, 37.0% of US adults used telemedicine in the past 12 months in 2021, and women were more likely to use it than men, at 42.0% versus 31.7%[1][2]. Use was highest among adults 65 and older, at 43.3%[3].

US adults who used telemedicine in the past 12 months, 2021
US adults who used telemedicine in the past 12 months, 2021Bar chart. All adults: 37%; Women: 42%; Men: 31.7%; Ages 65 and older: 43.3%.All adultsAll adults: 37%37%WomenWomen: 42%42%MenMen: 31.7%31.7%Ages 65 and olderAges 65 and older: 43.3%43.3%US adults who used telemedicine in the past 12 months, 2021Bar chart. All adults: 37%; Women: 42%; Men: 31.7%; Ages 65 and older: 43.3%.All adultsAll adults: 37%37%WomenWomen: 42%42%MenMen: 31.7%31.7%Ages 65 and olderAges 65 and older: 43.3%43.3%

Source: CDC National Center for Health Statistics, 2021[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
All adults37%
Women42%
Men31.7%
Ages 65 and older43.3%

Those numbers argue for offering video wherever your clinicians are comfortable, because many patients will take it, but they do not mean video suits every request. The guide's job is to let patients use it for the visits where it works and steer them to the office where it does not.

If you cannot offer the right visit, patients go elsewhere

When the desk says 'you need to come in' and the first office slot is days away, many patients find another option. In 2024, 27.6% of people in the US had at least one urgent care center visit in the past year[4], and 19.0% had at least one retail health clinic visit[5]. A same-day video or phone option for suitable reasons keeps those patients with the practice that knows their history.

At the desk: the decision in five steps

  1. Listen for red flags

    Ask what is going on in the patient's own words. If anything on the red flag list comes up, follow the escalation rule immediately.

  2. Find the reason on the list

    Match the request to a visit reason. If none fits, send to the nurse.

  3. Check the patient factors

    Ask about device, privacy, interpreter needs and where they will be at the visit time.

  4. Offer the options the list allows

    Say the formats that are available and the earliest time for each, and let the patient choose.

  5. Book and prepare

    Book the right visit type and trigger the matching preparation: tech check and link for video, call-back number for phone, forms and arrival time for the office.

Example: three calls on a Monday

Example (fictional): the first caller wants to discuss side effects from a new blood pressure medicine. The list allows video, the patient has a home cuff and a phone with a camera, so the scheduler books a video slot that afternoon. The second caller has a sore knee after a fall; the list says exam needed, so she is booked into the office the next morning. The third caller asks for a video visit for chest tightness when climbing stairs. That is a red flag, so the scheduler transfers him to the nurse instead of offering any slot.

Keep the list current

Review the list with providers every six months and whenever payer or state rules change. Track how often video visits are converted to office visits on the day, and why. A reason that is often converted should move off the video column; a reason that is never converted might move onto it. Keep one version of the list, dated, at every scheduling station.

Frequently asked questions

How does the front desk decide between telehealth and an office visit?

By following a provider-approved list of visit reasons, plus three questions: does the visit need hands-on care or a test, can the patient join by video, and is there any red flag? Anything not on the list goes to the nurse.

Which visits work well by telehealth?

Commonly stable chronic condition follow-ups, medication checks, results reviews and many behavioral health follow-ups. Your clinicians should approve the final list.

When should a patient always be seen in person?

When the visit needs an exam, a test or a procedure that cannot be done on camera, and when the clinician's protocol requires it. Red flag symptoms need the nurse or emergency instructions, not a booked visit.

Can a new patient have a first visit by video?

Some practices allow it for certain specialties; many require the first visit in person. Follow your providers' rules and check payer and state requirements.

References

  1. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2021). Telemedicine Use Among Adults: United States, 2021 (NCHS Data Brief No. 445) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2021). Telemedicine Use Among Adults: United States, 2021 (NCHS Data Brief No. 445) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2021). Telemedicine Use Among Adults: United States, 2021 (NCHS Data Brief No. 445) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2024). Urgent Care Center and Retail Health Clinic Use: United States, 2024 (NCHS Data Brief No. 562) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  5. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2024). Urgent Care Center and Retail Health Clinic Use: United States, 2024 (NCHS Data Brief No. 562) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo