No-Shows and Reminders

Text vs Call vs Email Reminders: What Works

Text, phone call or email reminders? The evidence by channel, cost and patient age, and a simple rule for when to combine channels.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Text vs phone call: what the trials show
  3. Email and portal messages
  4. Channels compared
  5. Cost per kept appointment, worked through
  6. Age and channel
  7. How to ask patients which channel they prefer
  8. When to combine channels
  9. Privacy differences between channels
  10. Example: choosing channels for one clinic
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
No-Shows and Reminders: Text vs Call vs Email Reminders: What WorksArticle coverNO-SHOWS AND REMINDERSText vs Call vs EmailReminders: What WorksAva Medical IntakeInsightsNo-Shows and Reminders: Text vs Call vs Email Reminders: What WorksArticle coverNO-SHOWS AND REMINDERSText vs Call vs EmailReminders: What WorksAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Texts and phone calls improve attendance by similar amounts; a Cochrane review found no meaningful difference between them[1].
  • Texts cost far less per attendance than calls in the studies that measured it[1], so lead with text and save calls for higher-risk visits.
  • Email and portal messages suit forms, links and prep instructions better than time-critical reminders.
  • Do not assume older patients avoid digital channels; telemedicine use was highest among adults 65 and over in 2021[2].

The short answer

For most practices the best default is a text reminder for patients with a mobile number, an automated or live call for patients without one or who prefer it, and email or the patient portal for anything longer, such as forms and preparation. Combine channels for visits where a miss is costly. The evidence behind that rule is clearer for text and calls than for email, so it is worth knowing what has and has not been tested.

Text vs phone call: what the trials show

The Cochrane review of mobile phone messaging reminders pooled randomized trials and found moderate-quality evidence from three studies, with 2,509 participants, that text reminders had a similar impact on attendance to phone call reminders, with a risk ratio of 0.99[1]. Across the included studies, attendance was 78.6% with text reminders and 80.3% with phone call reminders, against 67.8% with none[1].

The difference that does show up is cost. Two studies in the review found that the cost per text message per attendance was 55% and 65% lower than the cost per phone call reminder[1]. For a practice sending thousands of reminders a month, that gap pays for live calls where they add more value, such as to new patients or patients who have missed before.

Reach is no longer a strong argument against text. About 91% of US adults own a smartphone and 98% own a cellphone of some kind[3]. The practical barriers are wrong or outdated numbers, shared phones and patients who simply prefer a call, all of which you can record and work around.

Email and portal messages

Email and portal reminders have been studied less than texts and calls, so there is no comparable pooled estimate of their effect on attendance. What we do know is how widely patients now use online records. Access to online medical records through apps rose from 38% of individuals in 2020 to 57% in 2024[4], and 65% of individuals were offered and accessed their online records or patient portal in 2024[4].

Individuals accessing online medical records through an app
Individuals accessing online medical records through an appComparison. 2020: 38%; 2024: 57%.38%20202020: 38%57%20242024: 57%Individuals accessing online medical records through an appComparison. 2020: 38%; 2024: 57%.38%20202020: 38%57%20242024: 57%

Source: Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS, 2024[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
202038%
202457%

That makes the portal a good home for content that does not fit in a text: new-patient forms, insurance uploads, detailed preparation instructions, maps and links for video visits. It is a weaker choice for the main reminder, because many patients check email and portals less often than texts, and a reminder read after the visit is no reminder at all.

Channels compared

Summary of the evidence cited in this article and practical trade-offs.
ChannelEffect on attendanceCost per reminderTwo-wayBest use
Text messageImproves attendance vs none; similar to calls[1]LowestYes, with reply codesMain and day-before reminders
Automated callImproves attendance; one trial found it less effective than staff callsLowLimited (press 1 to confirm)Patients without text, landlines
Live staff callLowest no-show rate in one trialHighestFullyNew patients, prior no-shows, long visits
EmailLess studiedVery lowLimitedForms, prep and links
Patient portalLess studiedVery lowYes, via messagesForms, uploads and self-scheduling

Cost per kept appointment, worked through

The cheapest reminder is not always the best value. What matters is cost per appointment kept that would otherwise have been missed. A simple way to compare channels is to estimate, for each, the cost per reminder and the number of misses it prevents per hundred reminders, then divide.

Example. Suppose a fictional practice pays a few cents per text and estimates that a staff call costs about two dollars once staff time is counted. If texts prevent four misses per hundred reminders and staff calls prevent six, the text program costs far less per prevented miss, even though calls prevent more. The calculation flips for a small group of high-risk patients: if calls to new patients with long lead times prevent fifteen misses per hundred calls, the cost per prevented miss falls sharply and the extra effort is worth it.

Use your own costs and your own before-and-after no-show rates; the figures above are illustrative. The pattern holds across most practices: text for volume, calls for risk.

Age and channel

It is common to assume older patients want calls and younger ones want texts. The data is more mixed. In 2021, telemedicine use rose with age, from 29.4% of adults aged 18 to 29 to 43.3% of adults 65 and over[2]. Older adults with chronic conditions are often heavy users of digital health tools, while some younger patients rarely answer a call from an unknown number.

So ask rather than guess. Record each patient's preferred channel at registration and at annual updates, and use it. Where you have no preference recorded, text is the sensible default for any mobile number, with a call for landlines.

How to ask patients which channel they prefer

Make the question part of registration and annual updates, and keep it simple: "How would you like us to remind you about appointments: text, a phone call or email? And is this the best number?" Record the answer in the field your reminder system reads, not in a free-text note.

Ask about caregivers at the same time: whether someone else should also get reminders, and whether there is any channel the patient does not want used, such as texts to a shared phone. Patients are entitled to ask for communications by alternative means, and asking up front avoids complaints later.

Specialties may need a different mix. Procedure-heavy practices rely more on portal or email for preparation instructions, behavioral health practices may prefer minimal text content, and pediatric practices need reminders to reach the right parent. Write the channel rules for each visit type into your reminder setup.

When to combine channels

  1. Default: one channel, two touches

    A text a few days ahead and a short text the day before covers most routine visits.

  2. Add email or portal for content

    New patients, procedures and telehealth visits get an email or portal message with the details a text cannot hold.

  3. Add a live call for risk

    New patients, patients with a prior no-show and visits booked far ahead get a live call if they have not confirmed.

  4. Switch channel on failure

    If a text bounces or goes unanswered twice, try a call. If a call goes to a full voicemail, try text.

  5. Stay within limits

    Count every automated message toward the healthcare exemption limits of one per day and three per week per patient.

Privacy differences between channels

Each channel exposes information differently. Texts appear on lock screens and shared phones. Voicemails can be heard by anyone in the household. Emails may go to a work account. Portal messages are the most private, because the patient has to log in, which is also why they are less likely to be seen in time.

Keep reminder content minimal on every channel: who, when and where, and how to change it. Put anything more sensitive, such as preparation for a specific procedure, in the portal or a call, unless the patient has told you otherwise.

Example: choosing channels for one clinic

Example. A fictional internal medicine clinic sends automated calls to everyone and sees about 10% no-shows. It switches to texts for the 85% of patients with a mobile number, keeps calls for the rest, and moves preparation instructions to the portal with a text alert. It adds a live call list for new patients.

In this Example, after two months no-shows fall to about 8%, the reminder vendor bill falls because texts cost less than calls, and the front desk spends the time it saved on live calls to the 30 highest-risk patients each day. The clinic tracks no-shows by channel and visit type monthly to check the gains hold.

For setting up replies, see two-way text confirmations. For the rules on automated calls and texts, see TCPA rules for appointment reminders. For wording, see the reminder call script and text templates.

Frequently asked questions

Are text reminders better than phone calls?

They work about as well. A Cochrane review found a risk ratio of 0.99 for texts against calls, with lower cost per attendance for texts[1].

Do email reminders work?

They are less studied than texts and calls. Use email and the portal for forms, links and preparation, and text or call for the main reminder.

Should older patients get phone calls instead of texts?

Ask each patient. Telemedicine use was highest among adults 65 and over in 2021[2], so age alone is a poor guide.

Is it worth combining channels?

For new patients, procedures and patients with prior no-shows, yes. For routine follow-ups, two texts are usually enough.

References

  1. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (via PubMed) (2013). Mobile phone messaging reminders for attendance at healthcare appointments (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  2. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2021). Telemedicine Use Among Adults: United States, 2021 (NCHS Data Brief No. 445) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  3. Pew Research Center (2026). Americans' Use of Mobile Devices in 2026 (Mobile Fact Sheet) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

  4. Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS (2024). Individuals' Access and Use of Patient Portals and Smartphone Health Apps, 2024 (Data Brief No. 77) (opens in a new tab) โ†‘

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. Weโ€™ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo