Insurance and Front-Desk Billing

When to Send a Patient Balance to Collections

The checks to finish before referring a patient balance, the federal rules agencies follow, how to choose an agency, and alternatives to try first.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the referral decision deserves a policy
  2. Six checks before any referral
  3. The rules that apply
  4. Choosing a collection agency
  5. Tell patients the rules before there is a balance
  6. Example: a referral policy in practice
  7. Alternatives to try first
  8. The final-notice call
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Insurance and Front-Desk Billing: When to Send a Patient Balance to CollectionsArticle coverINSURANCE AND FRONT-DESK BILLINGWhen to Send a PatientBalance to CollectionsAva Medical IntakeInsightsInsurance and Front-Desk Billing: When to Send a Patient Balance to CollectionsArticle coverINSURANCE AND FRONT-DESK BILLINGWhen to Send aPatient Balance toCollectionsAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Referral should follow a written policy applied to every account, not a judgement made when someone is frustrated.
  • Medical debt is the most common debt in collections on US credit records, so referrals affect patients' finances and the practice's reputation.
  • Before referring, confirm the balance is right, send clear statements, offer a payment plan and screen for discounts or assistance.
  • Agencies must follow federal debt collection rules, and a practice that collects under a different name can be treated as a debt collector itself.

Why the referral decision deserves a policy

Sending a balance to collections is a big step for a patient relationship. It is also common. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau estimated $88 billion in medical debt on consumer credit records as of June 2021, and found that 58% of all third-party debt collection tradelines were for medical debt, far ahead of the next most common type, telecommunications, at 15%[1]. Most medical collection tradelines were under $500[1].

Share of third-party collection tradelines on credit records, by type of debt, 2021
Share of third-party collection tradelines on credit records, by type of debt, 2021Comparison. Medical debt: 58%; Telecommunications: 15%.58%Medical debtMedical debt: 58%15%TelecommunicationsTelecommunications: 15%Share of third-party collection tradelines on credit records, by type of debt, 2021Comparison. Medical debt: 58%; Telecommunications: 15%.58%Medical debtMedical debt: 58%15%TelecommunicationsTelecommunications: 15%

Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 2022[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Medical debt58%
Telecommunications15%

Patients are carrying more of their costs. The average deductible for covered workers reached $2,624 at smaller firms in 2026, against $1,772 at larger firms[2], and out-of-pocket spending grew to $556.6 billion in 2024[3]. A practice that sends balances to collections without a consistent process will refer some accounts that should never have gone, such as balances still waiting on insurance or patients who would have paid with a plan.

58%

of third-party debt collection tradelines on credit records were for medical debt in 2021[1]

Six checks before any referral

  1. Confirm the balance is correct

    Check that every payer has processed the claim, denials have been worked or appealed, coordination of benefits is settled and no credit or misposted payment is sitting on the account. A large share of patient complaints about collections start with a balance that was wrong.

  2. Confirm the patient was told

    The account should show a series of clear statements over time, with the amount, what it is for, how to pay and who to call. Check that the address and phone number are current; returned mail is not notice.

  3. Offer a payment plan

    Make at least one documented offer of a payment plan under your financial policy. Many balances that look uncollectible are paid in small monthly amounts.

  4. Screen for discounts or assistance

    If the practice has a self-pay discount, hardship policy or financial assistance program, check whether the patient was told about it and whether they qualify. Practices owned by a hospital may be bound by the hospital's assistance policy.

  5. Send a final notice

    Send a final letter that names a specific date after which the account will be referred, and the ways to avoid referral. Call as well, using the script below.

  6. Get approval and document

    A manager approves each referral against the checklist, and the account notes record the date and reason. Accounts on an active payment plan, in dispute or awaiting insurance are never referred.

The rules that apply

The federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act and the CFPB's Regulation F govern debt collectors, which mainly means third-party agencies. The statute's definition excludes officers and employees of a creditor collecting debts in the creditor's own name, but it includes a creditor that, in collecting its own debts, uses a different name that suggests a third party is collecting[4]. A practice that sends letters under a made-up collections department name can therefore bring itself under the law.

Regulation F sets specific limits on agencies. For example, a debt collector is presumed to comply with the call-frequency rule if it calls a person about a particular debt no more than seven times within seven consecutive days, and does not call within seven days after having a telephone conversation with that person about the debt[5]. Your agency contract should require compliance with these rules and with state collection laws, which in many states add licensing, notice and medical debt protections.

Privacy rules come along too. HIPAA lets a covered entity share protected health information with a business associate, such as a collection agency, only with a business associate agreement that gives satisfactory assurance the agency will safeguard it[6]. Send only what the agency needs to collect: name, contact details, dates of service, amounts and payments, not clinical notes.

Credit reporting of medical debt has its own rules and voluntary limits by the credit bureaus, and several states restrict it. See medical debt and credit reports before letting an agency report anything.

Choosing a collection agency

Questions to ask before signing with a medical collection agency
Question to askWhy it matters
Do you specialize in medical accounts?Medical balances involve insurance questions and privacy rules that general agencies handle poorly
Will you sign our business associate agreement?Required before you share protected health information
Are you licensed in the states where our patients live?Many states require collector licenses
Do you report to credit bureaus, and when?Determines the impact on patients and your exposure to state rules
Can we approve settlements and see call notes?Lets you protect patient relationships and audit conduct
How do you handle disputes and insurance questions?Disputed or insurance-pending accounts should come back to you quickly
What are your fees and how are recoveries remitted?Affects net recovery and reconciliation

Ask for references from practices of similar size and specialty, and read the agency's sample letters and call scripts. The agency speaks for your practice to patients at their most stressed, so its tone matters as much as its recovery rate.

Tell patients the rules before there is a balance

The fairest collections process starts at registration. When patients sign the financial policy, they should be able to see in plain words when payment is due, how statements arrive, that payment plans are available, and at what point an unpaid balance may be referred. A patient who knew the rules in advance is far less likely to feel ambushed by a final notice.

  • Keep the financial policy to one page and use the same wording on the website, the intake packet and the statement back.
  • Ask for a mobile number and email address for billing messages, and confirm them at every visit; outdated contact details are the most common reason a patient never saw a statement.
  • Make the statement easy to read: the date of service, what insurance paid, what the patient owes and why, and a phone number answered by someone who can explain it.
  • Give staff a short answer for the question β€œWhat happens if I can't pay?” that points to the payment plan rather than the agency.

Measure the policy as well as the agency. Track how many accounts reach final notice, how many of those are found to be wrong, how many convert to payment plans, and how many are referred. A rising share of wrong balances at final notice points back to billing, not to the patients.

Example: a referral policy in practice

Example (fictional). A pediatric practice writes a one-page policy. Statements go out monthly. After the second unpaid statement, the front desk calls and offers a payment plan. After the third, a final notice gives 30 days. Balances under $50 are written off rather than referred, because the cost of collecting them is higher than the amount. Before referral, the billing lead checks the account against the six-step checklist, and the practice manager signs off.

In the first quarter under the policy, 41 accounts reach the final-notice stage. The calls turn up four balances that were wrong (two coordination of benefits errors, one misposted payment, one denial that should have been appealed). Fourteen patients set up payment plans, nine pay in full, and fourteen are referred. The practice manager reviews the agency's reports monthly and pulls back two accounts when the patients call to say they had new insurance information.

Alternatives to try first

  • A longer in-house payment plan with a smaller monthly amount, set up on a card or bank draft.
  • A one-time settlement offer for older balances, approved under a written rule.
  • A small-balance write-off threshold, below which accounts are adjusted rather than referred.
  • Moving to text and email statements with a payment link; some patients ignore paper but respond to a message.
  • A pre-collection letter from the practice itself, in its own name, before the account leaves your hands.

Many practices also decide whether a patient can continue to be seen while a balance is unpaid. If you dismiss patients for non-payment, follow your state's rules on patient dismissal and continuity of care, give written notice, and make sure the decision is consistent and documented.

The final-notice call

Script: β€œHi, this is Sam from the billing office at Lakeside Pediatrics. I'm calling about the balance on your account for your son's visits in June. Our records show a balance of $180 after your insurance paid. I want to make sure you know about it before the 15th, because after that date the account would go to our collection agency. We can set up a monthly plan today, or if you think the balance is wrong, I can look into it right now.” Every detail in this example script is illustrative; use the patient's real figures.

Listen for anything that should stop the referral: new insurance, a hardship, a dispute or a promise to pay. Record what was said and the next step. Most of the time this call, not the agency, is what resolves the balance. For related processes, see handling overpayments and refunds and front desk cash handling.

Frequently asked questions

How long should a practice wait before sending a balance to collections?

There is no single federal waiting period for practices. Most set one in a written policy, typically after several statements, a payment plan offer and a final notice with a specific date. State laws and any hospital affiliation may add requirements.

Does the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act apply to our billing staff?

Generally not when your own staff collect in the practice's name. It can apply if the practice collects using a different name that suggests a third party is collecting.

What information can we give a collection agency?

Only what it needs to collect, such as name, contact details, dates of service, amounts and payments, and only after a business associate agreement is in place.

References

  1. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2022). Medical Debt Burden in the United States (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. KFF (2026). 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 15 U.S. Code Β§ 1692a - Definitions (Fair Debt Collection Practices Act) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 12 CFR Β§ 1006.14 - Harassing, oppressive, or abusive conduct (Regulation F) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR Β§ 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo