Key takeaways
- Patients can ask for an accounting of certain disclosures from the past six years, and the practice must act within 60 days[1].
- Treatment, payment, operations and anything sent under the patient's authorization are excluded; subpoenas, public health reports, police requests and misdirected faxes are not[1][2].
- The first accounting in any 12 months is free; later ones may carry a cost-based fee the patient hears about first[1].
- Requests are rare, so the work is in the log you keep all year, not in the response[2].
The question behind the request
It rarely arrives as "I would like an accounting of disclosures under 45 CFR 164.528." It arrives as "Who did you give my records to?", usually after a surprise: a letter from an insurer's lawyer, a call from a state agency, a worry that an ex-partner found something out. Under HIPAA the formal answer is an accounting of disclosures: a written list of certain disclosures of the patient's information made in the six years before the request, which the practice must provide within 60 days[1].
Most practices see very few of these. When HHS asked covered entities about it, almost 30 respondents had never received a request and more than 90 had received fewer than 20 since the Privacy Rule took effect in 2003[2]. That rarity is the trap. Nobody remembers how to answer one, the information was never collected in one place, and the 60 days start running the day the letter is opened.
What goes in and what stays out
The rule works by exclusion. Every disclosure goes in the accounting unless it falls in an excluded category: treatment, payment and health care operations; disclosures to the patient; disclosures incident to an otherwise permitted use; disclosures under the patient's authorization; the facility directory and people involved in the patient's care; national security; correctional institutions or law enforcement custody; a limited data set; and anything before the compliance date[1]. Disclosures made by your business associates count too[1].
| Disclosure | In the accounting? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Referral letter and notes to a specialist | No | Treatment |
| Claim and records sent to the patient's insurer | No | Payment |
| Records sent to a lawyer with the patient's signed authorization | No | Authorization |
| Talking to the patient's spouse with the patient's agreement | No | Persons involved in care |
| Reportable disease report to the health department | Yes | Public health disclosure |
| Proof of immunization sent to a school with the parent's agreement | Yes | Public health disclosure, not an authorization |
| Records produced for a subpoena or court order | Yes | Judicial proceedings |
| Information given to police at their request | Yes, unless suspended | Law enforcement |
| A fax that went to the wrong number | Yes | Impermissible disclosure[2] |
| A disclosure your billing company made in one of these categories | Yes | Business associate disclosures count[1] |
The "yes" rows are almost all disclosures the Privacy Rule allows without the patient's authorization, the ones listed in 164.512: public health, abuse reporting, health oversight, judicial proceedings, law enforcement and the like[3]. Requests from attorneys, agencies and courts are sorted in records requests from attorneys and third parties. School immunization proofs are easy to forget; calls from school nurses explains why that one is logged and a treatment call to the same nurse is not.
Mistakes count. In its 2011 proposal HHS said covered entities would continue to be required to account for disclosures that are impermissible under the Privacy Rule, including ones that did not rise to the level of a breach[2]. A misdirected fax that you assessed and decided was not a notifiable breach still goes in the log. If it was a breach, the breach notification steps apply as well, and the log entry is one piece of that file.
What each entry must say
Date
When the disclosure was made
Recipient
Name of the person or organization, and the address if known
What
A brief description of the information disclosed
Why
A brief statement of the purpose, or a copy of the written request
The required content of each accountable disclosure under 45 CFR 164.528(b).
Those four items are required for each disclosure[1]. When the practice made several disclosures to the same recipient for a single purpose, for example monthly reports to a state registry, the accounting can give the full details of the first one, the frequency or number, and the date of the last[1]. That shortcut only works if the log was kept that way from the start.
Example log entry: "2026-03-12 | County Department of Health, 400 Main St | Lab-confirmed diagnosis, date of onset, contact phone | Reportable disease report required by state law | Sent by: lead nurse." One line, written the day it happened, saves an afternoon of chart archaeology later.
The clock and the fee
The practice must act within 60 days of receiving the request. If it cannot, it may take one extension of no more than 30 days by giving the patient a written statement of the reasons and the date it will deliver, within the first 60 days[1]. That is the same outer limit as an amendment request and longer than the 30 days for a records copy[4].
- Standard limit
- With the one extension
Source: Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), 2026[4]
Show the data
| Request | Standard limit | With the one extension |
|---|---|---|
| Copy of records (access) | 30 days | 60 days |
| Amendment | 60 days | 90 days |
| Accounting of disclosures | 60 days | 90 days |
The first accounting a patient requests in any 12-month period is free. For later requests in the same 12 months the practice may charge a reasonable, cost-based fee, but only if it tells the patient about the fee in advance and gives them the chance to withdraw or narrow the request[1]. Patients can also ask for a shorter period than six years[1], which is worth offering when the worry is about one recent event.
One exception can pause the whole thing. If a health oversight agency or law enforcement official gives the practice a written statement that an accounting would be reasonably likely to impede its activities, the practice must suspend the patient's right to an accounting of those disclosures for the time specified. If the statement is oral, document it and the official's identity, and the suspension lasts no more than 30 days unless a written statement follows[1]. How to handle the police request itself is covered in when police call.
Handling a request, step by step
- Caller
- Your team
- System
01Caller
Patient asks
"Who did you send my records to?" by phone, portal or at the window.
02Your team
Desk verifies and logs
Confirms identity, takes the request, records the date received.
03Your team
Privacy officer checks log
Searches the disclosure log and asks business associates for theirs.
04Your team
Excluded items removed
Treatment, payment, operations and authorized disclosures are left out.
05Your team
Letter sent by day 60
Each entry with date, recipient, description and purpose.
06System
Copy filed
The letter and the request are kept with the privacy records.
Example workflow for a small practice where the privacy officer is also the practice manager.
Front desk script: "You can ask us for a list of certain places we've shared your information over the past six years. Some routine sharing, like with your other doctors and your insurance, isn't on that list by law. I'll send you the request form now. Your first list in any twelve months is free, and you'll have it in writing within 60 days. We aim to send it well before that."
Check who is asking before anything else; a request from someone claiming to act for the patient needs the same checks as any records request, described in verifying a caller's identity. If an SI Employee answers your main line, it can give the address, fax number or portal directions for written privacy requests from the information you approve and route the caller to the privacy contact's line. It takes no health details, so the request itself is handled by staff. What it does sets out where that handoff happens, and the family practice example shows the same routing rule on a busy morning.
A worked example
Example: on March 3 a patient writes asking who received her information over the past two years. She is worried that her former employer saw something. The privacy officer searches the log for her name and finds three entries: a reportable-disease report to the county health department, records produced in response to a subpoena in a car-accident case, and a lab result faxed to a wrong number at a pharmacy, assessed at the time as a low-risk impermissible disclosure.
She also finds a dozen disclosures that do not belong in the accounting: referral notes to a cardiologist, claims to two insurers and records sent to the patient's own lawyer under her signed authorization[1]. The billing company confirms in writing that it made no accountable disclosures for her. The letter goes out on March 20 listing the three entries, each with date, recipient, description and purpose. It also tells her, in plain words, that routine sharing for treatment and payment is not included, which is the honest answer to her real question about the employer.
Letter outline: (1) the period covered and the date of the request; (2) a numbered list of disclosures, oldest first, each with date, recipient and address, what was shared and why; (3) a plain sentence that disclosures for treatment, payment, operations and those the patient authorized are not included by law; (4) whether this was the free accounting for the 12-month period; (5) the privacy contact's title and phone number for questions.
Keep the tone factual. A patient who reads "subpoena, county court, March 2025" next to their name will have questions, and the letter should give them somewhere to take them rather than leave them to guess.
Build the log before anyone asks
Keep one log
One shared log for the whole practice, with the four required fields and a column for who made the disclosure. A spreadsheet in a secured folder works if everyone uses it.
Make it part of the release step
Whoever sends records in response to a subpoena, agency or police request adds the line before the envelope or fax leaves.
Log mistakes too
Every misdirected fax, email or mailing gets a line when it is discovered, whatever the breach assessment concludes[2].
Ask business associates
Billing companies, record-release vendors and anyone else disclosing on your behalf should report accountable disclosures to you, or produce them on request[1].
Keep it six years
Keep the log, each accounting you send and the titles of the people who handle requests for six years[1][5]. Disclosures under reporting duties, such as mandated reports, go in the same log.
What about who looked at the chart?
Patients sometimes mean something narrower: which staff member opened my record? That is not what today's accounting covers. The HITECH Act directs HHS to require accountings to include treatment, payment and operations disclosures made through an electronic health record in the three years before a request, but the rule was never finalized, and in 2018 HHS said it intended to withdraw its 2011 proposal for an "access report"[6]. Until a new rule arrives, 164.528 as written is the standard.
Treat "who looked at my chart" as a privacy concern rather than an accounting request. The privacy officer can review the EHR's access history, explain what was found and, if someone looked without a reason, follow the sanctions policy. If the patient also wants to correct what they found in the record, that is a separate request with its own 60-day clock, covered in requests to amend a record.
Frequently asked questions
Do we have to list every time we sent records to another doctor?
No. Disclosures for treatment, payment and health care operations are excluded from the accounting, as are disclosures made under the patient's authorization[1].
Can we charge for an accounting of disclosures?
Not for the first one in any 12-month period. Later requests in the same period may carry a reasonable, cost-based fee if you tell the patient in advance and let them withdraw or narrow the request[1].
Does a misdirected fax belong in the accounting?
Yes. Impermissible disclosures are accounted for even when they did not amount to a reportable breach[2].
The police asked us not to tell the patient. What do we do?
If they give you a written statement that an accounting would impede their activities, suspend the patient's right to an accounting of that disclosure for the time stated. An oral request must be documented and lasts no more than 30 days without a written statement[1].
A patient wants to know which employees viewed their record. Is that an accounting?
Not under the current rule. The HITECH requirement to account for electronic record disclosures for treatment, payment and operations was never finalized[6]. Handle it as a privacy concern and review the access history.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 45 CFR 164.528 - Accounting of disclosures of protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2011). HIPAA Privacy Rule Accounting of Disclosures Under the HITECH Act (proposed rule, 76 FR 31426, May 31, 2011) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 45 CFR 164.512 - Uses and disclosures for which an authorization or opportunity to agree or object is not required (opens in a new tab) ↑
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR) (2026). 45 CFR Part 164, Subpart E - Privacy of Individually Identifiable Health Information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 45 CFR 164.530 - Administrative requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2018). Request for Information on Modifying HIPAA Rules To Improve Coordinated Care (83 FR 64302, December 14, 2018) (opens in a new tab) ↑