Key takeaways
- Sort every outside request into one of three lanes: the patient's own written direction, a HIPAA authorization, or legal process such as a subpoena or court order.
- A valid authorization has required elements, including an expiration date and a signature; a form missing any of them is defective.
- A subpoena without a court order needs satisfactory assurance that the patient was notified or that a protective order was sought.
- Disclose only what the document allows, log every release, and send anything unusual to the privacy officer.
First question: on whose authority?
A letter from a law firm, a fax from an insurer or a call from a case manager can look urgent and official. None of that matters until you know what legal authority sits behind the request. For a medical or dental practice, nearly every outside request falls into one of three lanes, and each lane has different paperwork, deadlines and fee rules.
| Lane | What it looks like | What you need before releasing | Deadline and fees |
|---|---|---|---|
| Patient's written direction | Patient asks you to send their records to their lawyer, a new doctor or an app | A signed, written request that names the recipient and where to send it | Patient access rules: act within 30 days; cost-based fee only |
| HIPAA authorization | Attorney, insurer or employer sends a release form the patient signed | An authorization with every required element, not expired or revoked | No federal deadline; state law often sets fees |
| Legal process | Subpoena, discovery request or court order | Court order: release only what it covers. Subpoena alone: satisfactory assurance of notice or a protective order | Follow the order or the subpoena's terms; involve the privacy officer |
Getting the lane right matters because staff often treat all three alike. A patient's own direction to send records to their attorney is a right of access request with a firm clock[1], and it is easy to let it drift because a lawyer is involved. A subpoena, on the other hand, is not a reason to send the whole chart the same afternoon.
Lane one: the patient tells you where to send it
When the patient asks you, in writing and with their signature, to send a copy of their records to a person they clearly identify, you must send it, and the request must say where the copy should go[1]. This is still the patient's access right. The same timeline applies: act within 30 days, with one 30-day extension only if you tell the patient in writing why and when you will finish[1].
Attorneys sometimes prefer this route for their clients because it carries the patient access fee limits. You do not need to second-guess that choice. Check the signature and the recipient details, log the request with its receipt date, and process it as you would any other access request, as described in our guide to the 30-day right of access.
Lane two: checking an authorization
Most attorney and insurer requests arrive with a release form the patient signed for the requester. Before you release anything, check it against the core elements HIPAA requires[2]. Keep a laminated copy of this checklist at the records desk.
- A specific and meaningful description of the information to be disclosed, such as office notes from a date range, not simply all records forever.
- The name or identification of who may make the disclosure, which should be your practice.
- The name or identification of who may receive the information.
- A description of each purpose, or the words at the request of the individual when the patient started it and gave no purpose.
- An expiration date or an expiration event.
- The patient's signature and date, or a personal representative's signature with a description of their authority.
- Statements about the right to revoke in writing, whether treatment can be conditioned on signing, and that the information may be redisclosed by the recipient.
The authorization must also be written in plain language[2]. Treat it as defective if the expiration date has passed, if it is not filled out completely, if you know it has been revoked, or if you know material information in it is false[2]. When a form fails, do not fix it yourself or call the patient for verbal permission. Send it back to the requester with a short note that names the missing element.
Minimum necessary does not apply to disclosures made under a valid authorization[3], but the authorization itself limits what you send. If it describes office notes from one year, do not add imaging reports or billing statements because they were in the same folder.
Lane three: subpoenas and court orders
A court order signed by a judge or an administrative tribunal lets you disclose the information the order expressly authorizes, and nothing beyond it[4]. Read the order closely, release exactly what it lists, and record the order's details in your disclosure log.
A subpoena or discovery request signed only by an attorney is different. You may respond only after receiving satisfactory assurance that the requesting party made reasonable efforts to give the patient notice, or made reasonable efforts to secure a qualified protective order[4]. For the notice route, the written statement and documents must show a good faith attempt to give the patient written notice, enough information about the case for the patient to object, and that the time to object has passed with no objections, or with objections resolved[4].
Stamp and log the subpoena
Record the date received, the court, the case name, the requesting attorney and the response date in the subpoena.
Check for a court order
If a judge signed an order, release only what it expressly covers. If not, go to the next step.
Look for the assurance
Check for a written statement showing patient notice and an expired objection period, or a qualified protective order.
Ask if it is missing
Send a written reply to the attorney explaining that you need the assurance before you can respond. Note the date in the log.
Escalate when unsure
Send anything unusual to the privacy officer or practice counsel, especially requests involving minors, mental health or substance use treatment, where other rules may apply.
Family members and caregivers are a separate case
Not every third party arrives with a law firm letterhead. Caregivers increasingly manage patients' health information directly: proxy or caregiver access to patient portals more than doubled between 2020 and 2024[5].
Source: Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS, 2024[5]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2020 | 24% |
| 2024 | 51% |
A caregiver who is the patient's personal representative, such as a parent of a minor or a court-appointed guardian, generally stands in the patient's shoes[3]. A relative without that status needs the patient's written direction or an authorization before you send copies of records. Keep these requests in the same log so you can see who has received what.
Scripts for the front desk
Attorney's office calls for records: We can help once we have the right document. Please send either your client's signed request directing us to send records to your office, or a HIPAA authorization that includes an expiration date and describes the records you need. I will log it when it arrives and let you know if anything is missing.
Caller says a subpoena is on the way: Thank you. When it arrives we will log it and review it with our privacy officer. If it is not accompanied by a court order, we will also need the written assurance about patient notice before we can respond.
Do not confirm over the phone whether someone is a patient. A caller from a law office has no more right to that fact than any other stranger, and the confirmation itself is a disclosure.
Log every disclosure
A single disclosure log protects the practice in every lane. For each request, record who asked, the lane, the document received, what was released and when, and who approved it. Keep the log and the supporting documents for at least six years, the HIPAA retention period for required documentation[6]. If a release goes wrong, a clear log turns a messy investigation into a short one. Penalties for impermissible disclosures start at a per-violation minimum even when the practice did not know it was violating the rule[7].
$1,461
Minimum civil money penalty per violation in the reasonable cause tier, after inflation adjustment[7]
Example: one week of outside requests
Example (fictional): In one week, an orthopedic practice receives three outside requests. The first is a patient's signed letter asking that her records go to her attorney; staff log it as an access request with a 30-day due date. The second is an insurer's authorization with no expiration date; staff return it with a note naming the missing element. The third is a subpoena from a law firm with no court order and no statement about patient notice.
For the subpoena, the records lead sends a written reply asking for the required assurance, and the privacy officer diaries the response date. Two weeks later the firm sends a statement showing notice to the patient and an expired objection period. The practice releases only the records the subpoena describes and logs the release. All three requests are handled without anyone guessing.
Frequently asked questions
Can we charge an attorney more than a patient for copies?
If the attorney requests records under an authorization or subpoena, state law usually governs the fee. If the patient directs you in writing to send records to the attorney, treat it as a patient access request with cost-based fees.
Is a photocopy or faxed authorization acceptable?
The HIPAA rule lists a signature and date among the required elements but does not say the signature must be an original. Check that every element is present, that you have no reason to doubt the form, and follow your written policy and any state rule.
What if a subpoena demands records within days?
Log it and contact the issuing attorney in writing. Without a court order you need the required assurance before releasing records, whatever date the subpoena lists.
Do we tell the patient we received a subpoena?
Many practices do, as a courtesy, after checking with counsel. The rule places the duty to give notice on the requesting party, so document what you received either way.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.524 - Access of individuals to protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.508 - Uses and disclosures for which an authorization is required (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.512 - Uses and disclosures for which an authorization or opportunity to agree or object is not required (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS (2024). Individuals' Access and Use of Patient Portals and Smartphone Health Apps, 2024 (Data Brief No. 77) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.530 - Administrative requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 102.3 - Penalty adjustment and table (opens in a new tab) ↑