Key takeaways
- When patients request their own records, HIPAA allows only a reasonable, cost-based fee built from four costs: copying labor, supplies, postage and an agreed summary.
- Search, retrieval and general admin charges are not on that list, so leave them out of patient access fees.
- State law can be stricter: California caps paper copies at 25 cents a page and requires a free copy for public benefit appeals.
- OCR has penalized practices for unreasonable fees and for holding records until a fee was paid.
The rule in one sentence
When a patient asks for a copy of their own records, you may charge a reasonable, cost-based fee that includes only four things: labor for copying, supplies for paper copies or portable media the patient asked for, postage when the patient wants the copy mailed, and preparing a summary or explanation if the patient agreed to one[1]. Everything else is outside the fee.
That short list catches many practices out, because the costs they think of first, such as finding the chart, checking the request or maintaining the records system, are not on it. A fee that bundles those costs in is not cost-based in the HIPAA sense, even if it feels fair.
What you can and cannot include
| Cost | Allowed in a patient access fee? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Staff time to copy, scan or export the records | Yes | Labor for copying, paper or electronic |
| Paper, toner, a USB drive or disc the patient asked for | Yes | Supplies only for the format requested |
| Postage | Yes, if the patient asked for mailing | Not for portal or email delivery |
| Writing a summary or explanation | Yes, only if the patient agreed in advance | Agree the fee before you prepare it |
| Searching for and retrieving records | No | Not one of the four permitted costs |
| Verifying identity or processing the request | No | Part of running the practice |
| EHR licensing, storage or maintenance | No | Fixed costs of your systems |
| Rush or convenience surcharge | No | Not a permitted cost category |
Notice what the list does to electronic copies. If a patient asks for a PDF sent through the portal, there is no postage and usually no supplies, so the only possible charge is the staff time spent producing the copy. For a record your system can export in a few clicks, that time is small, and many practices decide it is simpler to charge nothing at all.
Two other points come up often. First, the summary fee only applies when the patient agreed to receive a summary instead of, or in addition to, the full record, and agreed to the fee in advance. Second, the fee rule is written for copies. None of its four costs arises when a patient simply looks at their records, so do not put an inspection charge on the schedule. When in doubt, ask whether the cost would exist if the patient had not asked for a copy. If it would, it does not belong in the fee.
State caps can be lower
HIPAA sets the ceiling on what you may include. State law can set lower caps or add free-copy rights, and when it does, you follow the more protective rule. California is a useful example of how specific a state can be.
- Fees are limited to the same categories HIPAA allows: labor, supplies for portable media, postage and an agreed summary[2].
- Paper copies are capped at 25 cents per page, or 50 cents per page for copies made from microfilm[2].
- A patient who needs records to support a claim or appeal for public benefits can get one free copy of the relevant records on written request, due within 30 days[2].
Check your own state's statute and any medical board rule before you publish a fee schedule. Write the state citation on the schedule itself, so the next person who updates it knows which limits apply.
Patient requests versus third-party requests
The cost-based limit belongs to the patient's right of access. When a patient signs a written direction asking you to send their records to someone else, such as a new doctor or their own attorney, that request still flows from the patient's access right and has the same timeline[1].
Requests that a lawyer, insurer or employer makes under an authorization the patient signed for them, or under a subpoena, are a different process. State law usually governs the fees for those. Keep the two categories separate in your log and your fee schedule, and see our guide to records requests from attorneys and third parties for the details.
What overcharging has cost practices
OCR has treated unreasonable fees as part of its right of access enforcement, which reached its 55th action in 2026[3]. In a 2022 case, a Georgia dental group agreed to pay $80,000 and adopt a corrective action plan; the patient had reportedly been told she would get her records only after paying a $170 copying fee, and OCR found the practice's fees were not reasonable and cost-based[4].
Penalties are set by culpability tier. Even the lowest tier carries a per-violation minimum, and the floor rises sharply once a violation is due to willful neglect[5].
The lesson from these cases is less about the exact fee and more about the sequence. Quote the fee up front, deliver on time, and never make access depend on payment of an old balance. A modest, well-documented fee rarely draws a complaint. Records held hostage almost always does.
Five fee mistakes and their fixes
Most fee problems are not deliberate. They come from an old price list nobody has revisited since the practice moved to an electronic record, or from a records vendor whose charges were set for attorneys and insurers and then applied to patients by default. These are the patterns to look for when you review your own process.
- One price for everyone. A single per-page rate applied to patients, lawyers and insurers alike usually overcharges patients. Keep a separate patient access schedule.
- Paper pricing for electronic copies. Charging per page for a PDF export assumes labor and supplies that do not exist. Price electronic copies on the actual time it takes to produce them.
- A retrieval or processing fee on every request. Those costs are not among the four the rule allows for patient access, so remove them from the patient schedule.
- Fees quoted after the work is done. Patients who learn the price only when the records are ready feel ambushed. Quote at intake and note the quote in the log.
- Outsourced copy services left on autopilot. If a release-of-information vendor handles requests for you, check that its patient pricing follows your schedule and that it has signed a business associate agreement.
Review the schedule once a year, and any time you change records systems or vendors. A short annual note saying the fees were checked against current costs and state law is cheap insurance.
Build a fee schedule you can defend
Time the work
For a week, record how long it takes to produce typical requests: a recent-visit PDF, a full electronic record, a paper copy of a long chart.
Price the labor
Multiply the minutes by the hourly cost of the staff member who does the copying. Use that person's actual pay rate, not a manager's.
Add only permitted supplies and postage
Paper, a drive if the patient asked for one, and postage when mailing was requested.
Apply your state cap
If your state sets a lower per-page or flat limit, use the lower figure.
Write it down
Publish the schedule internally, note how each number was calculated, and keep the working. HIPAA documentation must be kept for six years[6].
Train the front desk to quote it
Staff should tell the patient the expected fee when the request is logged, not when the records are ready.
Example: pricing an electronic copy
Example (fictional): A family practice in a state with no lower cap times its requests and finds that exporting a full electronic record and uploading it to the portal takes a receptionist about 12 minutes. The national median wage for receptionists was $18.27 an hour in 2025[7]; at a similar rate, 12 minutes of labor costs under four dollars. There are no supplies and no postage.
The practice decides not to charge for portal delivery of electronic copies, because the fee would be smaller than the cost of collecting it. For paper copies it sets a per-page price within the state limit and notes the calculation on the schedule. The front desk script now includes one line: there is no charge for an electronic copy through the portal, and paper copies are priced per page.
Script for quoting a fee
Script: I have logged your request today. An electronic copy through the portal has no charge. If you would like paper copies mailed, the cost is based on the number of pages plus postage, and I can tell you the total before we send it. Either way, you will receive your records by the date I give you.
Keep the quote in the request log with the date. If a patient disputes the fee, you will have the schedule, the calculation and the record of what was quoted, which is exactly what an investigator would ask for.
Frequently asked questions
Can we charge a flat fee?
A flat fee can work for simple electronic copies if it is reasonable and no higher than your cost-based calculation. Document how you arrived at it and stay within any state cap.
Can we charge a search and retrieval fee?
Not for a patient's own access request. Search and retrieval is not one of the four costs HIPAA allows in that fee.
Can we refuse to release records until the patient pays?
Do not hold records over an unpaid balance for other services. Quote any copy fee up front and keep access on schedule.
Do these limits apply to attorneys requesting records?
Not when the attorney requests records under a patient authorization or subpoena; state law usually governs those fees. If the patient directs you in writing to send their records to their attorney, treat it as a patient access request.
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.524 - Access of individuals to protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), California Code (2026). California Health and Safety Code § 123110 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Hall Render (2026). OCR Reaches 55th HIPAA Right of Access Settlement (opens in a new tab) ↑
TechTarget HealthTech Security (2022). OCR Settles Three HIPAA Right of Access Cases With Dental Practices (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 102.3 - Penalty adjustment and table (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.530 - Administrative requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Outlook Handbook: Receptionists (opens in a new tab) ↑