HIPAA and Compliance

California Rules for Recording Patient Calls

California's all-party consent rule for recording patient calls, the penalties under Penal Code 632 and 637.2, and notice wording a practice can use today.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. The rule in California
  2. What a violation can cost
  3. Notice language for a California practice
  4. Callers from outside California, and California callers to you
  5. Recordings are medical information too
  6. Automated assistants and AI voices
  7. Beyond the phone: cameras, exam rooms and staff
  8. Checklist for California practices
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
HIPAA and Compliance: California Rules for Recording Patient CallsArticle coverHIPAA AND COMPLIANCECalifornia Rules forRecording Patient CallsAva Medical IntakeInsightsHIPAA and Compliance: California Rules for Recording Patient CallsArticle coverHIPAA AND COMPLIANCECalifornia Rules forRecording PatientCallsAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • California makes it an offense to record a confidential communication without the consent of all parties.
  • Criminal fines reach $2,500 per violation, or $10,000 for repeat violations, and anyone injured can sue for $5,000 per violation without proving actual damages.
  • Patient calls are almost always confidential in the legal sense, so announce recording before the conversation starts and honor opt-outs.
  • Recorded calls also contain medical information protected by HIPAA and California's medical privacy law.

The rule in California

California Penal Code section 632 is the heart of the state's recording law. It applies to anyone who, intentionally and without the consent of all parties to a confidential communication, uses an electronic device to eavesdrop on or record it, whether the conversation happens in person or by telephone[1]. That is why California is usually described as a two-party, or all-party, consent state.

The key phrase is confidential communication. The statute defines it as a communication made in circumstances that reasonably indicate that any party wants it confined to the parties, and it excludes situations where the parties may reasonably expect the communication to be overheard or recorded[1]. A patient calling a medical or dental office to discuss symptoms, medications, test results or a bill is about as clear an example of a confidential communication as exists.

The exclusion is also what makes a good notice work. When a caller hears, before speaking, that the call is recorded and chooses to continue, they can no longer reasonably expect the call to stay unrecorded, and their continuing on the line is generally treated as consent. Without a notice, assume every patient call is confidential.

What a violation can cost

The penalties are set per violation, which in a call center context can mean per call. A first violation of section 632 carries a fine of up to $2,500 per violation, along with possible jail time; a repeat violation carries a fine of up to $10,000 per violation[1].

Maximum criminal fine per violation under California Penal Code 632Fines may be combined with jail time; civil damages are separate
Maximum criminal fine per violation under California Penal Code 632Comparison. First violation: $2,500; Repeat violation: $10,000.$2,500First violationFirst violation: $2,500$10,000Repeat violationRepeat violation: $10,000Maximum criminal fine per violation under California Penal Code 632Comparison. First violation: $2,500; Repeat violation: $10,000.$2,500First violationFirst violation: $2,500$10,000Repeat violationRepeat violation: $10,000

Source: FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), California Code, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
First violation$2,500
Repeat violation$10,000

Civil exposure is often the bigger risk. Under Penal Code section 637.2, a person injured by a violation can sue for the greater of $5,000 per violation or three times their actual damages, and actual damages are not a prerequisite to bringing the action[2]. A practice that records thousands of patient calls without a valid notice is multiplying a statutory amount, not waiting for someone to prove harm.

$5,000

Civil damages per violation available under California Penal Code 637.2, without proof of actual damages[2]

Notice language for a California practice

The goal is a notice that every caller hears before the conversation begins, in plain words, with a real way to decline. These versions are written for a medical or dental office; adapt the wording with your counsel.

Main line greeting: Thank you for calling. To help us serve you, calls are recorded. If you would prefer that your call is not recorded, just let us know when we answer and we will turn recording off.

Spanish version for the same greeting: Gracias por llamar. Para ayudarle mejor, las llamadas se graban. Si prefiere que su llamada no se grabe, díganoslo al contestar y desactivaremos la grabación.

Outbound calls by staff: Hi, this is Jordan calling from the clinic. Just so you know, this call is recorded. Is that okay? I can turn it off if you prefer.

  • Play the greeting on every line that records: main number, scheduling, billing, after-hours and any direct lines.
  • Repeat the notice when a third person joins, such as an interpreter or family member.
  • Use the same notice for calls answered by an automated assistant.
  • Keep a dated copy of the greeting audio and script, so you can show what callers heard on a given day.

Callers from outside California, and California callers to you

Patients do not stay put. A practice in Nevada or Arizona near the state line takes calls from California residents every day, and a California practice calls patients who are traveling. Rather than trying to work out which state's law governs each call, use the California standard everywhere: announce recording up front and offer an opt-out. It is the simplest way to stay on the right side of the strictest rule your patients are likely to be under.

For a broader view of how other states compare, see our guide to one-party and all-party recording laws.

Recordings are medical information too

Once a call is recorded lawfully, the recording itself is protected. Under HIPAA, a recording in which a patient discusses their care is protected health information, subject to the same limits on use and disclosure as the chart[3]. California adds its own layer: the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act says a provider may not disclose medical information about a patient without first obtaining an authorization, except in the situations the statute allows, such as disclosures to other providers for treatment and to payers for payment[4].

  • Do not share recordings outside the practice, for example with a marketing agency or a consultant, without checking both HIPAA and CMIA first.
  • Limit who can listen: supervisors and the privacy officer, not everyone with a phone system login.
  • Set a short retention period that matches your purpose, and delete on schedule.
  • Make sure the phone vendor has signed a business associate agreement that covers recordings and transcripts.

Automated assistants and AI voices

Many practices now let an automated assistant answer overflow or after-hours calls. The same recording rules apply when software listens and transcribes: tell callers up front that the call is recorded and, ideally, that they are speaking with an automated assistant. For outbound calls, remember that the FCC ruled in 2024 that calls made with AI-generated voices are artificial under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act[5], which brings federal calling consent rules into play on top of California's recording law.

Patients care about how their information is handled by these tools. In a 2026 national poll, 77% of the public said they were concerned about the privacy of personal medical information provided to AI tools[6]. A clear, honest notice at the start of the call is the first step in earning their trust.

Beyond the phone: cameras, exam rooms and staff

Section 632 is not limited to telephone calls. It also covers recording confidential conversations in person[1]. That catches practices that add security cameras with microphones to the front desk or waiting room, or that record staff meetings and training sessions without telling everyone.

  • Security cameras: video-only cameras in public areas raise fewer issues than cameras that also capture audio. If a camera records sound near the counter, where patients discuss insurance and symptoms, get legal advice before switching audio on.
  • Exam and consultation rooms: do not record audio without explicit, documented consent from everyone present, and treat any such recording as part of the medical record.
  • Ambient documentation tools: if clinicians use software that listens to visits to draft notes, get the patient's consent at the start of each visit and record that consent in the chart.
  • Staff calls and meetings: tell staff in writing which lines and rooms are recorded. A coaching program that records calls without employees' knowledge creates its own consent problem.

The common thread is simple: if a microphone is on and people expect privacy, everyone in the conversation needs to know before it starts.

Checklist for California practices

  1. List every recorded line

    Include after-hours, billing, scheduling, mobile apps and any automated assistant numbers.

  2. Confirm the notice plays first

    Call each line yourself and check the notice plays before anyone, human or automated, starts talking.

  3. Test the opt-out

    Ask a colleague to request no recording and confirm staff can turn it off quickly.

  4. Cover outbound calls

    Give staff the outbound script and check that automated outbound calls include a notice.

  5. Lock down storage

    Check vendor agreements, access roles, audit logs and deletion settings.

  6. Document it

    Keep the scripts, greeting audio and settings screenshots with your privacy records.

Example (fictional): A Los Angeles pediatric practice switches phone vendors and assumes the new system copied its recording greeting. A test call shows the greeting is missing on the scheduling queue, which records by default. The manager pauses recording on that queue until the greeting is uploaded, then re-tests every line and files the results.

Frequently asked questions

Is California a two-party consent state?

Yes. Penal Code 632 requires the consent of all parties to record a confidential communication, which includes almost every patient call to a medical or dental office.

Does a recorded greeting count as consent?

A clear notice before the conversation, followed by the caller choosing to continue, is the standard approach. It works best when callers are also offered a way to decline.

Can a patient sue even if they were not harmed?

Under Penal Code 637.2, actual damages are not required. A person injured by a violation can seek $5,000 per violation or three times actual damages, whichever is greater.

Do we need a separate notice in Spanish?

Many California practices offer the greeting in English and Spanish, and in other languages their patients commonly speak. It helps ensure every caller understands the notice before they talk.

References

  1. FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), California Code (2026). California Penal Code § 632 - Eavesdropping on or recording confidential communications (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), California Code (2026). California Penal Code § 637.2 - Civil action for damages (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), California Code (2026). California Civil Code § 56.10 - Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, disclosure (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (news release) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. KFF (2026). KFF Tracking Poll on Health Information and Trust: Use of AI For Health Information and Advice (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo