HIPAA and Compliance

California CMIA: Privacy Rules Beyond HIPAA

How California's Confidentiality of Medical Information Act differs from HIPAA in front office work: disclosures, damages, records timing and scripts.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Two laws at the same front desk
  2. What you may share without an authorization
  3. Why the damages change the risk
  4. Everyday front office situations
  5. Where the differences bite in practice
  6. Records access runs on a faster clock
  7. When something goes wrong
  8. A California front desk checklist
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
HIPAA and Compliance: California CMIA: Privacy Rules Beyond HIPAAArticle coverHIPAA AND COMPLIANCECalifornia CMIA:Privacy Rules BeyondHIPAAAva Medical IntakeInsightsHIPAA and Compliance: California CMIA: Privacy Rules Beyond HIPAAArticle coverHIPAA AND COMPLIANCECalifornia CMIA:Privacy Rules BeyondHIPAAAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Under the CMIA, a California provider may not disclose medical information without an authorization unless the statute specifically allows it.
  • Unlike HIPAA, the CMIA lets patients sue: nominal damages of $1,000 are available without proof of harm, plus actual damages.
  • Penalties climb steeply with intent, up to $250,000 per violation for knowing and willful disclosure for financial gain.
  • California's records rules are faster than HIPAA's: inspection within five working days and copies within 15 days.

Two laws at the same front desk

California practices live under two privacy regimes at once. HIPAA sets the federal floor. The Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, in the California Civil Code, adds a state layer with its own definitions, its own list of permitted disclosures and, most importantly for risk, its own private right of action. When the two differ, the practical rule for staff is to follow whichever is more protective of the patient.

The CMIA's starting point is short. A provider of health care, a health care service plan or a contractor shall not disclose medical information about a patient without first obtaining an authorization, except as the statute provides[1]. The rest of the law is largely a list of those exceptions and the consequences of getting them wrong.

New tools make the question sharper. Practices are adding online intake, texting platforms, call transcription and AI assistants, and each one is a new place medical information can travel. Patients are wary: in a 2026 national poll, 77% of the public said they were concerned about the privacy of personal medical information provided to AI tools[2]. Before a California practice switches on any new tool that touches patient details, it should know which CMIA exception, if any, covers sharing that information with the vendor, and whether the vendor's contract matches.

What you may share without an authorization

The permitted disclosures will look familiar to anyone who knows HIPAA, but the CMIA spells them out as a list rather than as broad categories. Among others, the statute allows disclosure without an authorization[1]:

  • To other providers and health professionals for the diagnosis or treatment of the patient.
  • To insurers, health plans, employers or government agencies responsible for paying for the care, as needed to determine and make payment.
  • To billing, claims management and data processing services working for the provider.
  • To medical staff committees, licensing and accrediting bodies and others reviewing the competence or quality of care.
  • To researchers for bona fide research, without revealing patient identities.
  • To public health departments for disease prevention and control.
  • Basic information to disaster relief organizations responding to welfare inquiries.

If a request does not fit one of the listed exceptions, treat it as needing a written authorization. That habit covers most of the gaps between the two laws, because the CMIA list is narrower in places than the HIPAA categories a practice might rely on elsewhere.

Why the damages change the risk

HIPAA is enforced by regulators; patients cannot sue under it directly. The CMIA is different. A patient whose medical information was negligently released can recover nominal damages of $1,000 without showing that they suffered or were threatened with actual damages, along with any actual damages they can prove[3]. In a breach that affects many patients, that per-person amount is what drives class actions.

Administrative fines and civil penalties sit on top of private claims and scale with intent. A negligent disclosure can bring a penalty of up to $2,500 per violation; a knowing and willful one, up to $25,000 per violation for entities other than licensed professionals; and a knowing and willful disclosure for financial gain, up to $250,000 per violation plus disgorgement of any proceeds[3]. Licensed health care professionals face their own tiered amounts that rise with repeat violations[3].

Maximum CMIA amounts per violation, by type of disclosureCalifornia Civil Code 56.36; penalty amounts shown for entities other than licensed professionals
Maximum CMIA amounts per violation, by type of disclosureBar chart. Nominal damages to the patient: $1,000; Negligent disclosure penalty: $2,500; Knowing and willful penalty: $25,000; Knowing and willful for financial gain: $250,000.Nominal damages to the patientNominal damages to the patient: $1,000$1,000Negligent disclosure penaltyNegligent disclosure penalty: $2,500$2,500Knowing and willful penaltyKnowing and willful penalty: $25,000$25,000Knowing and willful for financial gainKnowing and willful for financial gain: $250,000$250,000Maximum CMIA amounts per violation, by type of disclosureBar chart. Nominal damages to the patient: $1,000; Negligent disclosure penalty: $2,500; Knowing and willful penalty: $25,000; Knowing and willful for financial gain: $250,000.Nominal damages to the patientNominal damages to the patient: $1,000$1,000Negligent disclosure penaltyNegligent disclosure penalty: $2,500$2,500Knowing and willful penaltyKnowing and willful penalty: $25,000$25,000Knowing and willful for financial gainKnowing and willful for financial gain: $250,000$250,000

Source: FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), California Code, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Nominal damages to the patient$1,000
Negligent disclosure penalty$2,500
Knowing and willful penalty$25,000
Knowing and willful for financial gain$250,000

For comparison, HIPAA civil money penalties also rise with culpability, from a did-not-know tier up to willful neglect left uncorrected, with a calendar-year cap of $2,190,294 for violations of an identical provision[4]. The difference is who brings the case: under the CMIA, patients themselves can.

Everyday front office situations

Common requests and the safer approach under California's medical privacy law. Ask counsel about anything unusual.
SituationSafer approach in a California practice
Employer calls to confirm an employee's appointment and diagnosisDo not confirm anything without the patient's written authorization
Spouse asks for test results by phoneCheck the chart for the patient's documented permission or representative status before sharing
Marketing agency wants patient testimonials and visit detailsWritten authorization from each patient first, describing exactly what will be used
New specialist's office requests records for an upcoming visitPermitted for treatment; send what the referral needs and log it
Insurer requests notes to process a claimPermitted for payment, limited to what is needed to determine and make payment
Staff member wants to look up a friend's visitNever; access only for work, and audit logs are reviewed

The employer row deserves emphasis. California employers frequently call to verify absences, and a friendly confirmation that a patient was seen, and why, is exactly the kind of disclosure the CMIA targets. Give the front desk a script and make it the default.

Script for an employer call: I am not able to confirm whether anyone is a patient here or share any health information without the patient's written permission. If your employee needs a note, they can request one from us directly.

Where the differences bite in practice

Most of the day-to-day rules line up: share for treatment, share for payment, verify callers, limit what you send. The differences that change how a California office should run are fewer, but they matter.

  • Patients can sue directly. A slip that HIPAA would treat as a matter for the practice and OCR can, under the CMIA, become a claim by the patient, so documentation of how you handled it matters even more.
  • No harm needs to be proven for nominal damages. A practice cannot assume a low-risk disclosure is safe from claims simply because nothing bad happened to the patient.
  • The exceptions are a list. Staff used to thinking in broad HIPAA categories should check that a disclosure fits a listed CMIA exception, or get an authorization.
  • Intent drives penalties sharply upward. Snooping and selling information are treated far more severely than an honest mistake, which is another reason to monitor access logs.
  • Records deadlines are shorter. The state's inspection and copy timelines are much tighter than HIPAA's, as covered below.

Records access runs on a faster clock

California's patient access rules sit in the Health and Safety Code rather than the CMIA, but they apply to the same front office. A patient must be allowed to inspect their records during business hours within five working days of a request, and must receive paper or electronic copies within 15 days[5]. HIPAA allows up to 30 days, with one 30-day extension[6].

  • Set your internal deadline to the California timeline for every request, so staff never have to choose between rules.
  • Copy fees are limited to the same cost categories HIPAA allows, with a cap of 25 cents per page for paper copies[5].
  • A patient who needs records for a public benefits claim or appeal is entitled to one free copy of the relevant records on written request[5].

When something goes wrong

  1. Contain it the same day

    Retrieve the document, recall the message or end the access, and record exactly what happened.

  2. Run both assessments

    Assess the incident under the HIPAA Breach Notification Rule and, with counsel, consider the CMIA consequences and any California reporting rules that apply to your type of facility.

  3. Mitigate and explain

    Where appropriate, contact the patient promptly, explain what happened and what you have done. A clear, early explanation often matters as much as the formal notice.

  4. Document the decision

    Keep the assessment, the notices and the remediation steps together. If a claim follows, this file is the practice's account of what happened.

  5. Fix the cause

    Change the process that failed, retrain the people involved and apply the sanctions policy consistently.

A California front desk checklist

  1. Default to authorization

    If a request does not clearly fit a listed exception, ask for a written authorization before sharing.

  2. Verify every caller

    Confirm identity and check documented permissions before discussing anything, including with family.

  3. Log disclosures

    Record who received what, when and under which exception or authorization.

  4. Run records on the state clock

    Five working days for inspection and 15 days for copies, tracked in a shared log.

  5. Lock down access

    Unique logins, role-based permissions and regular audit log reviews to catch snooping.

  6. Train on the differences

    Cover the CMIA alongside HIPAA in onboarding, with the employer and family scripts.

Example (fictional): A San Diego clinic's receptionist receives a call from a construction company asking whether an employee really had a procedure last Tuesday. She uses the employer script, logs the call and lets the patient know at their next contact that their employer called. A week later the employee brings a signed authorization for a work note, and the clinic provides exactly what it covers, nothing more.

Frequently asked questions

Does HIPAA override the CMIA?

No. HIPAA sets a federal minimum and generally gives way to state laws that are more protective of patient privacy. California practices must comply with both.

Can a patient sue us under the CMIA even if they were not harmed?

Yes. Nominal damages of $1,000 are available for a negligent release without proof of actual damages, and actual damages can be added if proven.

Can we tell a patient's spouse about their appointment?

Only if the patient has given permission or the spouse has legal authority to act for them. Check the chart and default to not sharing.

Do our vendors have to follow the CMIA?

The CMIA applies to contractors of providers, and billing or data processing services receive information under its exceptions. Keep business associate agreements in place and ask counsel how California rules apply to each vendor.

References

  1. FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), California Code (2026). California Civil Code § 56.10 - Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, disclosure (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. KFF (2026). KFF Tracking Poll on Health Information and Trust: Use of AI For Health Information and Advice (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), California Code (2026). California Civil Code § 56.36 - Remedies and penalties (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 102.3 - Penalty adjustment and table (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. FindLaw (Thomson Reuters), California Code (2026). California Health and Safety Code § 123110 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.524 - Access of individuals to protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo