HIPAA and Compliance

TCPA and Marketing Texts: Where Practices Get Sued

Where practice texts cross from healthcare messages into TCPA marketing, the conditions of the healthcare exemption, and the consent records to keep.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why texts are where the lawsuits are
  2. Two rulebooks that use the same words differently
  3. The healthcare exemption and its conditions
  4. Where practices cross the line
  5. The consent records you need
  6. Set up your tools to keep messages apart
  7. Automated voices count too
  8. Example: auditing a texting program
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
HIPAA and Compliance: TCPA and Marketing Texts: Where Practices Get SuedArticle coverHIPAA AND COMPLIANCETCPA and MarketingTexts: Where PracticesGet SuedAva Medical IntakeInsightsHIPAA and Compliance: TCPA and Marketing Texts: Where Practices Get SuedArticle coverHIPAA AND COMPLIANCETCPA and MarketingTexts: WherePractices Get SuedAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • The TCPA lets people sue for $500 per violation, and courts can triple that for willful or knowing violations, so a single text campaign can create large exposure.
  • Appointment reminders, lab result notices and similar healthcare texts can fit an FCC exemption, but only if strict conditions on content, length, frequency and opt-out are met.
  • Promotions, discounts and new-service announcements are marketing; automated marketing texts need prior express written consent.
  • Keep consent records for every number: what the patient agreed to, when, how and the exact wording they saw.

Why texts are where the lawsuits are

The Telephone Consumer Protection Act gives individuals a private right to sue. A person can recover their actual loss or $500 for each violation, whichever is greater, and if a court finds the violation was willful or knowing, it may increase the award to up to three times that amount[1]. Each text can be a separate violation.

TCPA statutory damages per violationPer call or text; actual loss can be claimed instead if greater
TCPA statutory damages per violationComparison. Statutory damages: $500; Maximum if willful or knowing (up to three times): $1,500.$500Statutory damagesStatutory damages: $500$1,500Maximum if willful or knowing (up to threetimes)Maximum if willful or knowing (up to three times): $1,500TCPA statutory damages per violationComparison. Statutory damages: $500; Maximum if willful or knowing (up to three times): $1,500.$500Statutory damagesStatutory damages: $500$1,500Maximum if willful or knowing (up tothree times)Maximum if willful or knowing (up to three times): $1,500

Source: Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, current[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Statutory damages$500
Maximum if willful or knowing (up to three times)$1,500

That arithmetic is what makes texting risky for a busy practice. A promotional text sent to 2,000 patients without the right consent is not one mistake; it is potentially 2,000 claims. With about nine in ten US adults owning a smartphone[2], almost every patient list is a mobile list, and almost every campaign reaches enough people to interest a plaintiff's lawyer.

Two rulebooks that use the same words differently

Practices have to satisfy two separate sets of rules, and the word marketing does not mean the same thing in each.

How HIPAA and the TCPA treat practice communications. A message can be fine under one and a problem under the other.
QuestionHIPAATCPA and FCC rules
What is regulatedUse and disclosure of patient information for marketingCalls and texts, especially automated or prerecorded ones and telemarketing
What counts as marketingA communication about a product or service that encourages purchase or use, with exceptions for treatment and operations unless the practice is paid by a third partyTelemarketing and advertising: messages that encourage buying goods or services
Consent neededAn authorization for marketing that falls outside the exceptionsPrior express written consent for automated telemarketing calls and texts to mobile numbers
Who enforcesHHS Office for Civil RightsThe FCC, state attorneys general and private plaintiffs

Under HIPAA, marketing means a communication about a product or service that encourages recipients to buy or use it, but communications about treatment and the practice's own health-related services are excluded unless the practice receives financial remuneration from a third party for sending them[3]. So a text about your new sleep clinic is not HIPAA marketing, while a text promoting a device because the manufacturer pays you is.

The TCPA asks a different question: is this a telemarketing or advertising message sent with regulated technology? The FCC's rules require prior express written consent for telemarketing or advertising calls and texts that use an autodialer or an artificial or prerecorded voice to mobile numbers[4]. The same new sleep clinic text that passes HIPAA can still be TCPA telemarketing.

The healthcare exemption and its conditions

The FCC created an exemption for certain calls and texts from healthcare providers to mobile numbers, but it is narrow, and every condition must be met[4]. Use it as a checklist for your reminder and notification program.

  • Free to the patient: the message must not be charged to the recipient or count against their plan limits.
  • To the patient's own number: send only to the wireless number the patient provided.
  • Identify yourself: state the provider's name and contact information.
  • Healthcare purposes only: appointment and exam confirmations and reminders, wellness checkups, hospital pre-registration and pre-operative instructions, lab results, post-discharge follow-up, prescription notifications and home healthcare instructions.
  • No telemarketing, solicitation or advertising, and no accounting, billing, debt-collection or other financial content.
  • Short: generally one minute or less for voice calls and 160 characters or less for texts.
  • Infrequent: no more than one message per day per patient, and no more than three combined calls or texts per week.
  • Easy opt-out: every message offers one; for texts, replying STOP must work, and opt-outs must be honored immediately.

Notice what is outside the exemption: billing reminders, payment links, balance notices and anything promotional. Those messages need their own consent analysis, and payment texts may also raise debt collection rules.

Where practices cross the line

  • A reminder that ends with a discount: Your cleaning is Tuesday at 2 pm. Book whitening this month and save. The add-on turns a reminder into advertising.
  • Seasonal promotions: cosmetic specials, holiday gift cards or membership plan offers sent to the whole patient list.
  • New-service launches: texts announcing a new aesthetics line or weight-loss program to everyone on file.
  • Recall texts that go too far: a recall reminder is healthcare, but a recall reminder with a bundle offer is marketing.
  • Sponsored content: messages about a product a manufacturer pays you to promote, which can be marketing under HIPAA as well.
  • Frequency creep: a reminder, a confirmation, a pre-visit form link and a survey in the same 24 hours can break the one-per-day limit for exempt messages.

Review request texts sit in a gray area. They do not sell a product, but they are not healthcare either. Keep them clearly separate from reminders, send them only with consent you can document, and follow the FTC rules on reviews covered in our guide to responding to online reviews.

In a TCPA dispute, the practice usually has to prove consent. Keep a record for every number that receives anything other than exempt healthcare messages.

  1. Separate the consents

    Ask for healthcare messaging consent at registration, and ask separately, with its own checkbox or signature, for marketing texts. Never bundle marketing consent into intake paperwork as a condition of care.

  2. Use clear wording

    The marketing consent should say the patient agrees to receive marketing texts from the practice at the number given, that messages may be sent using automated technology, that consent is not a condition of treatment and that they can reply STOP at any time.

  3. Capture the evidence

    Store the number, the exact wording shown, the date and time, the channel (paper, portal, web form) and the patient's signature or click.

  4. Log opt-outs

    Record every STOP and every verbal request to stop, apply it across all your sending tools immediately, and keep the log.

  5. Refresh when numbers change

    A new number needs new consent. Reassigned numbers are a common source of claims, because the new owner never agreed to anything.

Set up your tools to keep messages apart

Most TCPA problems at practices are configuration problems. The reminder platform, the marketing tool, the review request service and the patient portal all send texts, often from different vendors, and none of them knows what the others sent today. A few setup choices prevent most mistakes.

  • Use separate campaigns, and ideally separate sending numbers, for healthcare messages and marketing, so a patient's STOP to one is easy to trace.
  • Make marketing lists opt-in only, built from the separate marketing consent, never from the full patient database.
  • Sync opt-outs across every tool at least daily, and immediately where the tools allow it.
  • Limit who can create a new campaign to one or two trained people, with a second person approving any message that goes to more than a handful of patients.
  • Keep templates for reminders short and free of offers, and lock them so staff cannot add promotional lines on the fly.
  • Ask each texting vendor for a business associate agreement and for its consent and opt-out logs in exportable form.

Automated voices count too

Everything above applies to calls as well as texts. The FCC ruled on February 8, 2024 that calls made with AI-generated voices are artificial under the TCPA, effective immediately[5], and telemarketers must have prior express written consent before robocalling consumers[6]. If your practice uses an AI or prerecorded voice to call patients, treat promotional calls exactly like promotional texts, and keep healthcare calls inside the exemption's conditions.

Do-not-call rules add another layer. A person who receives more than one telemarketing call within 12 months from the same entity in violation of the do-not-call rules can also sue, for up to $500 per violation, trebled if willful or knowing[1]. Some states have their own telemarketing and texting laws as well, so ask counsel to review any campaign that goes beyond healthcare messages.

Example: auditing a texting program

Example (fictional): A dermatology practice with a cosmetic service line reviews its texting. It finds that reminders are well within the exemption, but the same platform sends a monthly specials text to every patient with a mobile number, using consent collected only in the general intake form.

The practice pauses the specials campaign, adds a separate, optional marketing consent to its portal and front desk forms with clear wording, and restarts the campaign only for patients who opt in. It removes the whitening-style upsell lines from reminders, merges its pre-visit form link into the reminder to stay within the daily limit, and checks that STOP replies sync across both its reminder and marketing tools. The patient list for marketing shrinks, and so does the risk.

Frequently asked questions

Do appointment reminder texts need written consent?

Reminders that meet every condition of the FCC healthcare exemption do not need marketing consent. Keep them short, informational, free to the patient, within the frequency limits and with a working STOP option.

Is a recall reminder marketing?

A plain reminder that a patient is due for a checkup is a healthcare message. Adding offers, discounts or promotions for other services turns it into advertising.

Can we text patients about a new service we offer?

Under HIPAA it may not be marketing if no third party pays you. Under the TCPA, a promotional text sent with automated technology generally needs prior express written consent.

How long should we keep consent records?

Keep them for as long as you text the number and for several years after, so you can answer a claim. Ask counsel what period fits your state.

References

  1. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 47 U.S. Code § 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Pew Research Center (2026). Americans' Use of Mobile Devices in 2026 (Mobile Fact Sheet) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.501 - Definitions (marketing) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (news release) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (news release) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo