Key takeaways
- Tell patients early, in writing and by phone, before their next visit rather than at the check-in desk.
- Lead with what stays the same: their dentist, their hygienist, their records and their right to use their benefits.
- Segment patients by plan and visit history so the most affected households get a personal call.
- Offer at least one practical way to keep costs predictable, such as claim filing on their behalf or an in-house plan, and measure retention for a year.
Why the communication plan matters more than the decision
Leaving a PPO network is a business decision, but patients experience it as a change to their wallet and their routine. Practices that handle the change well usually keep many of the affected patients. Practices that let patients find out at the front desk, holding a bill they did not expect, lose them and their families.
The patients you are writing to are mostly people with job-based coverage. Employment-based insurance covered 53.5% of the US population in 2025, ahead of Medicare at 20.1% and Medicaid at 17.1%[1]. Many employer plans renew on January 1, and Marketplace open enrollment runs from November 1 to January 15[2], so late fall is when many households compare coverage. Avoid announcing a change in the middle of that window without a clear explanation.
The share of dentists who own their practice has fallen from 84.7% in 2005 to 72.5% in 2023[3], and about one in six dentists was affiliated with a dental support organization in 2025[3]. Patients who leave over a network change have plenty of in-network alternatives, which is why the message has to be clear and early.
Segment before you write
Not every patient is affected the same way. Pull a report of active patients by insurance plan and sort them into groups before drafting any letter.
| Group | Who is in it | Contact method |
|---|---|---|
| Most affected | Active patients on the plan you are leaving, with treatment planned or recall due in the next 90 days | Personal phone call from someone they know, then the letter |
| Affected, routine | Active patients on the plan with no planned treatment | Letter and email, follow-up call if no response |
| Family members | Other people in the same household, even if on a different plan | Include in the household letter |
| Not affected | Patients on plans you keep, self-pay and other coverage | Short note in the next newsletter, if any |
| Lapsed | Patients on the plan with no visit in 18 months | Letter only; treat any return as a new conversation |
Count each group. The size of the 'most affected' group tells you how many calls the team must make and how much front desk time to protect for them.
The timeline
Before the notice goes to the plan
Read your network contract for the termination notice period and the date you stop being in network. Confirm whether you must keep in-network fees for treatment already in progress.
Train the team first
Hold a meeting where everyone hears the reason, the date and the answers to the hardest questions. Run role plays with the scripts below until everyone can say them calmly.
Personal calls to the most affected
Call these households before any letter lands, so they hear it from a person. Offer to schedule planned treatment before the change date where that helps them.
Send the letter and email
Mail and email the letter to every affected household on the same day. Post a short page on your website with the same facts and a phone number.
Update every script and screen
Change the phone greeting, the new patient insurance answer, the online booking form and the website insurance list on the change date.
Follow up
Two to three weeks after the letter, call affected patients who have not responded or booked. Keep a log of objections.
Review at 3, 6 and 12 months
Measure recall kept, treatment accepted and households lost, compared with the same months last year.
Patient letter template
Keep the letter to one page, in plain words, signed by the dentist. Lead with what stays the same.
Dear [first name], I am writing to let you know about a change at [practice]. From [date], we will no longer be a contracted provider with [plan name]. What stays the same: your dentist, your hygiene team, your records and the care you receive. You can still use your [plan name] benefits with us; most plans pay for out-of-network care, though your share may change. To make this simple, we will [file your claims for you / explain your options at your next visit / offer our in-house plan]. If you have treatment planned, we can schedule it before [date]. Please call [name] at [number] with any questions. Thank you for trusting us with your care. [Dentist name]
Check every claim in the letter against your actual policies. If you will not file claims for patients, do not imply it. If out-of-network benefits vary a lot by plan, say so and offer to check theirs.
Phone scripts for the hard questions
Most objections fall into four types. Give the team a short, honest answer for each, then a next step.
- 'Why are you doing this?' Answer: 'The plan's fees no longer cover the time and materials our care needs. We chose to keep the care the same rather than shorten visits.' Keep it brief and true; do not criticize the insurer.
- 'How much more will I pay?' Answer: 'It depends on your plan's out-of-network benefit. Can I check your plan now and call you back today with an estimate for your next cleaning?'
- 'Can I keep coming at the old price?' Answer only with your real policy. If you honor in-network fees for treatment already in progress, say so and give the end date.
- 'I need to find an in-network dentist.' Answer: 'I understand. We will send your records wherever you choose, and you are always welcome back.' Make the records transfer easy; it protects your reputation.
Coaching note: the team member's tone matters as much as the words. A calm, warm answer to an angry caller keeps more patients than a perfect script read defensively.
Update every place patients look
Patients check more than the letter. On the change date, every public listing should say the same thing, or the front desk will spend weeks correcting confused callers. Assign one person to own this list and tick it off.
- Website insurance page: remove the plan from the accepted list and add a short line explaining out-of-network benefits.
- Online booking form: change the insurance dropdown so the plan is not shown as in network.
- Phone greeting and on-hold message: remove any line that lists the plan.
- Search and map listings: update the insurance field in your business profiles and any directory you control.
- Plan provider directory: confirm the insurer has removed you, and check again a month later, because outdated directories send callers who expect in-network fees.
- Answering service or after-hours scripts: update the insurance answer so callers outside office hours hear the same thing.
- New patient forms: add a plain acknowledgement that the practice is out of network with the plan, so new patients sign it before treatment.
Keep a dated copy of the old and new wording. If a patient later says they were told you were still in network, the record shows what each channel said and when.
Prepare the team for the first month
The first four weeks after the letter bring the most calls. Plan front desk coverage for them as you would for a busy season: protect phone time, avoid scheduling staff training in that window and agree who handles escalations.
Hold a ten-minute huddle each Friday to share the questions patients asked that week and how they were answered. Add the good answers to the script sheet. When the same objection comes up three times, the dentist should decide on a policy answer, so the team never has to invent one at the desk.
Payment options that keep costs predictable
Cost is already on patients' minds: US out-of-pocket health spending grew 5.9% to $556.6 billion in 2024[4]. Patients stay when the cost is predictable, not only when it is low. Offer one or two of these, set up before the letter goes out.
| Option | How it helps the patient | What the practice must set up |
|---|---|---|
| Claim filing on the patient's behalf | Same paperwork experience as before | Claim workflow, a clear policy on when the patient pays |
| Benefit check before each visit | Patient knows their share in advance | Eligibility routine and a script for sharing the estimate |
| In-house membership plan | Fixed yearly fee for preventive care, discount on treatment | Written plan terms, enrollment process, legal review in your state |
| Third-party financing | Spreads larger treatment over time | Lender relationship, plain-language disclosure |
Put the chosen options into your written financial policy before the change date, so the front desk is quoting policy, not improvising.
What to measure afterwards
Decide the numbers before the change, so you can judge it fairly later. A useful set:
- Households on the old plan that completed at least one visit in the 12 months after the change.
- Recall appointments kept versus the same period a year earlier.
- Treatment acceptance for affected patients, compared with the rest of the practice.
- Records transfer requests, as a direct count of patients leaving.
- New patient calls that ask about the plan you left, and how many book anyway.
Example: a fictional practice leaves one PPO that covers 400 active households. After 12 months, 290 households have completed a visit, 60 requested records and 50 have no activity. The practice calls the 50 inactive households once more, then adjusts its new patient target to replace the 60 it lost.
Price-sensitive new callers will ask about the plan you left for some time. Prepare an answer that explains out-of-network benefits in one breath, as described in our guide to price-shopper calls.
Frequently asked questions
Can patients still use their insurance if we go out of network?
Many plans pay something towards out-of-network care, but the amount varies by plan. Offer to check each patient's benefits rather than giving a general promise.
How far ahead should we tell patients?
As soon as the change date is fixed and the team is trained, and before any affected patient's next visit. Check your contract for the formal notice period.
Should we explain the business reasons?
Briefly and honestly. One sentence about keeping care quality is enough. Avoid criticizing the insurer.
What if a patient on the plan has treatment in progress?
Follow your contract and your written policy. If you will complete it at the old fee, say so clearly and give the end date.
References
U.S. Census Bureau (2025). Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2025 (Current Population Reports P60-291) (opens in a new tab) โ
HealthCare.gov (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) (2026-2027). Dates and deadlines for 2027 health insurance (opens in a new tab) โ
American Dental Association Health Policy Institute (2023). Dental Practice Research (FAQs) (opens in a new tab) โ
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ