Key takeaways
- A caller who asks 'how much is a cleaning?' is usually asking 'can I afford to come in?', so answer the money question honestly and then the access question.
- Give a real fee or a narrow range for common first-visit services, and explain in one sentence what can change it.
- Uninsured and self-pay patients who schedule ahead are owed a good faith estimate on a set timeline; build it into the booking workflow.
- Score price-shopper calls monthly: share answered live, share booked, and the reason for every call that did not book.
Who is really calling
Price-shopper calls are not a nuisance to get off the line. Most come from people who are trying to work out whether they can afford care before they commit. Out-of-pocket spending in US health care grew 5.9% to $556.6 billion in 2024[1], and patients feel it directly. For workers with single employer coverage, the average general deductible was $1,955 in 2026[2], and 26.7 million people were uninsured for the whole of 2025[3].
Dental benefits often work differently from medical plans, but the caller's experience is similar: they have been surprised by bills before, and they want a number before they walk in. A front desk that treats the question with respect wins a large share of these callers. One that dodges it loses them to the next office on the search results page.
Source: KFF, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Smaller firms | $2,624 |
| Larger firms | $1,772 |
Callers who work for small employers face higher deductibles on average: $2,624 against $1,772 at larger firms in 2026[2]. Many of the self-employed and small business staff calling your office at lunchtime are in that first group.
Five types of cost question and what each needs
| What the caller says | What they usually mean | Best response |
|---|---|---|
| How much is a cleaning? | Can I afford a first visit? | Give the new patient visit fee or range, say what is included, offer a time |
| Do you take my insurance? | Will I be surprised by a bill? | Confirm network status, explain you will check benefits before the visit |
| How much is a crown or implant? | I was quoted elsewhere and want to compare | Give a range, explain the exam and X-rays decide the plan, offer a consult |
| Do you have a cash price? | I have no coverage | Give self-pay fees, mention payment options, start the good faith estimate |
| Is the first visit free? | I am testing whether you are honest | Answer plainly, never bait-and-switch |
Write these five responses down and keep them next to the phone. New team members should be able to read them in the first week and use them word for word until they find their own voice.
Rules for honest answers
- Give a number. 'It depends' with no number sounds like hiding. A fee for the new patient exam and X-rays is almost always knowable.
- Use ranges only for treatment that genuinely depends on the exam, and keep them narrow enough to be useful.
- Say in one sentence what moves the price: the number of X-rays needed, whether gum treatment is required, and what the insurance plan pays.
- Never promise what insurance will pay before benefits are checked. Say you will verify and call back.
- Do not quote a teaser price that applies to almost nobody. Callers remember, and online reviews repeat it.
- Keep the fee list in one shared place, dated, so everyone quotes the same number.
House rule worth adopting: if a caller asks about cost three times, the person answering must give a number or a range before the call ends.
A call script that works
The script below assumes a general practice and a caller asking about a cleaning. Adapt the fees to your own schedule; the structure is what matters.
Thank and ask one question
'Thanks for calling. Happy to help with cost. Is this for a first visit with us, or are you already a patient?'
Answer the money question first
'For new patients, the first visit is an exam, X-rays and a cleaning. Our fee for that is [your fee]. If you have insurance, we check your benefits before you come so you know your share.'
Explain the one thing that can change it
'If the dentist finds you need a deeper gum cleaning, that is a different appointment and we would go over the cost with you before doing anything.'
Remove the next worry
'We take most major plans and also have payment options. Can I ask which plan you have, or are you paying yourself?'
Offer two times
'I have Tuesday at 8 a.m. or Thursday at 4:30. Which works better?'
Confirm what happens next
'Great. You will get a text confirmation and a link to the forms. If you are paying yourself, we will also send a written estimate.'
Notice what the script does not do. It does not interrogate the caller before giving information, it does not push a special offer, and it does not end with 'call us back when you are ready'. Every step either answers a concern or moves towards a booked time.
Good faith estimates for self-pay callers
If the caller is uninsured or chooses not to use insurance, federal No Surprises Act rules apply once they schedule. When the service is scheduled at least 3 business days ahead, the provider must give a good faith estimate no later than 1 business day after scheduling, and within 3 business days when it is scheduled at least 10 business days ahead[4].
- Add a 'self-pay' flag in the booking screen so the estimate task is created automatically.
- Keep a template estimate for the standard new patient visit, so most estimates take minutes, not a phone call back.
- Store a copy of every estimate with the patient record.
- When the exam leads to a treatment plan, issue a new estimate for the planned treatment, not just the first visit.
Ask your compliance adviser how the rules apply to your fee schedule and payment plans. The point for the front desk is simple: a self-pay booking is not finished until the estimate task exists.
Specialty and high-value treatment questions
Callers asking about implants, aligners, veneers or full-mouth work often have a quote from another office in hand. They are comparing value, not just price. Give an honest range, then explain what a consult includes: the exam, imaging and a written plan with options. A specific date for that consult is worth more than any discount. For a full approach to those calls, see implant consult calls.
Example: a fictional caller says another office quoted a single implant and asks whether you are cheaper. A strong reply is: 'Our fees for a single implant and crown usually fall in [your range]. The final number depends on whether you need a bone graft or extraction first, which the consult shows. The consult is [fee or free], and you leave with a written plan. Would next Wednesday morning work?'
Measure and coach
Track price-shopper calls as their own category for at least a month. If your phone system records calls, pull five a week for coaching, with consent rules followed. If not, ask the team to log each cost question on a shared sheet.
- Answered live: calls that go to voicemail rarely become bookings, so look at lunch hours and the last hour of the day first.
- Booked on the call: the share of cost-question callers who leave with an appointment.
- Reason not booked: price too high, insurance not accepted, timing, wanted to think, or call ended before a number was given.
- Kept rate: whether price-shopper bookings show up as often as other new patients.
If many calls end because no number was given, the fix is training and a clearer fee list. If many end because the price was too high, review your new patient fee against your local market. If calls go unanswered at lunch, cover that hour: stagger breaks, or forward the line to an answering option, such as Ava, that answers approved new patient questions like which plans you accept and passes the caller to staff for anything else. Insurance and eligibility questions are a heavy load for every practice: eligibility and prior authorization were named the most time-consuming phone task by 45% of practice leaders in one 2026 poll[5].
Mistakes that lose price-sensitive callers
- Transferring the caller to billing, who is at lunch, and promising a call back.
- Asking for full insurance details and date of birth before saying anything about cost.
- Quoting a fee from last year's list.
- Sounding irritated by the question. Tone carries further than words on the phone.
- Offering a special that does not include X-rays, then charging for them at the visit.
Each of these turns a reasonable question into a reason to call someone else. Fix the most common one first, then review the call log again next month. If price shoppers are a large part of your new patient flow, they deserve a slot in your new patient target planning too.
Frequently asked questions
Should we give prices over the phone?
Yes, for common services such as the new patient visit and a standard cleaning. Give ranges for treatment that depends on the exam, and explain what changes the cost.
What if the caller only wants the cheapest office?
Answer honestly and offer a time. Some callers will choose on price alone, but many book with the office that answered clearly and kindly.
Do we need a written estimate for patients paying cash?
Under the No Surprises Act, uninsured and self-pay patients who schedule ahead are owed a good faith estimate on a set timeline. Ask your compliance adviser how it applies to your services.
Who should handle cost questions?
Whoever answers the phone should handle the common ones from a shared fee list. Hand complex treatment questions to the financial coordinator with a scheduled call back, not an open promise.
References
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ
KFF (2026). 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2025). Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2025 (Current Population Reports P60-291) (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR ยง 149.610 - Requirements for provision of good faith estimates of expected charges for uninsured (or self-pay) individuals (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Phones are still a bottleneck costing medical practices time they can't afford (opens in a new tab) โ