Key takeaways
- Triage first: list every front desk task, then keep, shift, defer or stop each one so the reduced team works on what patients notice most.
- Protect phone access and check-in before anything else; deferred back-office work can wait, unanswered patients cannot.
- Hiring is slow: 56% of practices say hiring medical assistants got harder in the past year[1], and front-desk roles are among the most common churn points[2].
- Watch the people who are left. Short-term overtime is fine; a month of it drives the next resignation.
A shortage is an operations problem, not just a hiring problem
When two people leave the front desk in the same month, the instinct is to post jobs and ask everyone else to work harder until the new hires arrive. That can work for a week. Beyond that, the remaining staff fall behind, mistakes rise, patients notice and someone else starts looking for a new job. A shortage needs an operating plan for the gap, not just a recruiting plan.
The labor market explains why the gap often lasts longer than expected. The job openings rate in health care and social assistance was 5.8% in September 2026[3]. In a May 2026 MGMA poll, 29% of medical group leaders reported higher staff turnover than in 2025[4]. For medical assistants, often the first people pulled to cover the desk, 56% of practices said hiring had become more difficult in the past year and only 7% said easier[1].
- More difficult 56%
- About the same 37%
- Easier 7%
Source: Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| More difficult | 56% |
| About the same | 37% |
| Easier | 7% |
Week one: triage the workload
List every task
Write down everything the front desk does in a normal week, from answering the main line to scanning old records. Ask staff to add what you miss; they always find more.
Sort into four groups
Keep: patient-facing work that cannot slip. Shift: tasks someone else can do, such as a billing team member taking insurance follow-up. Defer: work that can wait four to six weeks. Stop: work nobody will miss.
Set minimum staffing by hour
Decide the minimum number of people needed at check-in and on the phones for each hour of the day, using call and arrival patterns. Staff to the minimum first, then add extra where you can.
Write it on one page
Share the plan with the team, including what you are deliberately not doing. People cope better when they know the backlog is a decision, not a failure.
Review weekly
Each week, check what slipped, what the backlog looks like and whether any deferred task has become urgent.
Protect phones and check-in first
Patients judge a practice most quickly on whether they can get through and whether check-in runs smoothly. Those two areas should be the last to lose staff. Practical steps include:
- Separate phone and window roles for the busiest hours, so one person is not trying to do both.
- Update the phone greeting and on-hold message with the most common answers, such as hours, directions and new-patient information, to shorten calls.
- Set up a callback queue for non-urgent requests with a promised return time, rather than letting calls ring out.
- Move routine requests, such as forms and records requests, to the patient portal or a web form where possible.
- Route overflow and lunch-hour calls to a backup instead of voicemail.
For the backup, options include a medical answering service, staff at another location or an SI Employee such as Ava, which answers routine office and new-patient questions and passes appointment and patient-specific requests to the staff line you choose. Whichever you use, check that urgent calls are recognized and escalated, and that any vendor handling patient information has the right agreements in place.
What to defer, shift or stop
| Task | Typical decision | Risk to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Scanning and indexing old paper records | Defer | Make sure current visit documents are still scanned the same day |
| Manual appointment confirmation calls | Shift to automated reminders | Keep calls for high-risk visits such as procedures |
| Insurance follow-up on old claims | Shift to billing | Agree a handoff list so nothing is lost |
| Recall lists for annual visits | Defer up to a month | Do not defer recalls for patients with chronic conditions |
| Supply ordering | Shift to clinical lead | Use par levels to keep it simple |
| Reports nobody uses | Stop | Confirm with the physicians before stopping |
| Prior authorization requests | Keep | Delays affect patient care; protect this work |
Some work can never be deferred: urgent clinical messages, prior authorizations for scheduled care, insurance verification for upcoming visits and anything with a legal deadline, such as patient records access requests. Mark these clearly so a well-meaning team member does not push them into the backlog.
Track a few numbers every day
During a shortage, decisions need fresh information. Track four numbers daily on a whiteboard or shared sheet: calls abandoned on the main line, open callbacks older than one business day, check-in delays of more than ten minutes and overtime hours by person. Look at them in the morning huddle. If abandoned calls climb, move a person from back-office work to the phones. If callbacks age, add a protected callback hour in the afternoon. If one person's overtime keeps rising, rebalance before they burn out. The numbers also tell you when the shortage is over in practice, not just on the staffing chart.
Stabilize the people who are still there
The biggest risk during a shortage is losing another person. Front-desk and entry-level administrative roles are already among the most common churn points in medical practices[2], and a team that feels overrun will look elsewhere.
- Cap overtime per person per week and share it fairly. Offer it; do not assume it.
- Say thank you specifically and often, and tell the team what the practice is doing to fix the gap.
- Protect breaks and lunch. Skipped breaks feel heroic in week one and lead to mistakes by week three.
- Consider a temporary pay premium or bonus for the shortage period, written down with an end date.
- Hold a short weekly check-in with each remaining staff member to hear what is not working.
- Take the most stressful tasks, such as escalated complaints, onto the manager's desk for the duration.
Hire and cover faster
- Ask current staff for referrals and pay a referral bonus after the new hire completes probation.
- Call former employees who left on good terms and floats who have worked for you before.
- Shorten the hiring process: one phone screen, one in-person interview with a short practical exercise and a decision within a week.
- Use a temp agency for gaps longer than two weeks, with a temp-to-hire option.
- Consider internal moves, such as a medical assistant who wants administrative work, and backfill the clinical role in parallel.
- Widen the pool: bilingual candidates, career changers from retail or hospitality and students in health administration programs.
Our guides to using temp agencies and building a float pool cover the fastest stopgaps in more detail.
Use the shortage to fix the process
A shortage forces decisions that are hard to make in normal times, and some of the changes should stay. Practice leaders already lean this way: automation (36%) and process fixes (23%) were their top planned cost-cutting moves for 2026, ahead of hiring freezes or cuts (18%)[5]. Yet 68% say they have not redesigned a role or adjusted staffing with the help of AI in the past year[6]. Before you refill every seat exactly as it was, ask which deferred tasks nobody missed, which shifted tasks now sit in a better place and which automated steps worked. A front desk workload assessment gives you the numbers to decide.
Example: down two receptionists
Example (fictional): a five-provider internal medicine practice loses two of its six receptionists in three weeks. The manager lists 38 recurring tasks, keeps 21, shifts 8 to billing and the clinical lead, defers 6 and stops 3. She sets minimum staffing of two on the phones from 8 to 11 a.m. and one on each window all day, routes lunch and overflow calls to a backup, and moves records requests to a portal form. A former employee returns for three days a week, and a temp covers the rest. The remaining staff get a written temporary premium and capped overtime. Six weeks later both roles are filled, the deferred backlog is cleared in two Saturdays of paid overtime, and the practice keeps the portal form and automated confirmations permanently.
Tell patients what to expect
Patients are more forgiving when they know what is happening. A short note on the website and phone message that response times are longer than usual, with the best way to reach the practice for each type of request, reduces repeat calls. At the desk, staff can say: We're short-staffed this month, so callbacks may take until tomorrow afternoon. If it's urgent, tell me now and I'll flag it. Keep the message honest and specific, and update it when the shortage ends. If your patient population includes people who prefer another language, record the message in that language too; see hiring bilingual front desk staff.
Frequently asked questions
What do you do when the front desk is short-staffed?
Triage the workload into keep, shift, defer and stop; staff phones and check-in first; route overflow calls to a backup; protect the remaining team from burnout; and speed up hiring with referrals, former staff, floats and temps.
Which front desk tasks can be deferred during a staffing shortage?
Usually back-office work such as scanning old records, some recall lists and non-urgent reports. Never defer urgent clinical messages, prior authorizations for scheduled care, insurance verification for upcoming visits or tasks with legal deadlines.
How do I keep remaining staff from quitting during a shortage?
Cap and share overtime, protect breaks, thank people specifically, consider a written temporary premium and take the most stressful tasks onto the manager's desk.
How long does it take to fill a front desk vacancy?
It varies by market, but plan for several weeks. Health care job openings remain high relative to quits, so have temporary cover in place rather than waiting for a fast hire.
References
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Medical assistants: Tackling practices' worst hiring problem before it gets worse (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Stabilized but not solved: Staff turnover in medical practices looking no better, no worse in 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). JOLTS series JTS620000000000000JOR: Health care and social assistance, job openings rate (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Stabilized but not solved: Staff turnover in medical practices looking no better, no worse in 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Automation, process fixes top list of cost-cutting moves for medical practices in 2026 (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). AI is slowly redesigning work in medical practices rather than replacing workers (opens in a new tab) โ