Key takeaways
- Ask agencies to report booked and completed new-patient visits, not clicks and impressions.
- Every account, domain, number and creative file should be owned by the practice, with the agency as a user.
- An agency that touches protected health information needs a business associate agreement first[1].
- Ask how the agency uses AI tools; 56% of medical groups have no formal AI-use policy of their own[2].
Why the choice matters more in healthcare
Hiring a marketing agency is a bigger decision for a medical or dental practice than for most small businesses. An agency will touch your website code, your phone numbers, your review profiles and sometimes your patient communications. Mistakes are not just wasted budget. A tracking tag on the wrong page or a careless email list can become a privacy incident, and an agency that owns your accounts can leave you starting from scratch when the contract ends.
The questions below are designed to separate agencies that understand healthcare from those that apply a retail playbook. Use them in the first meeting, ask for answers in writing, and compare agencies on the same list.
Before the first meeting
- Define the goal in your own terms: booked new-patient visits per month, by location and service, at a cost per patient you can afford.
- Know your capacity. Marketing that brings more calls than the front desk can answer, or more new patients than providers can see, makes things worse.
- List what you already have: website platform, Google profiles, ad accounts, analytics, call tracking, review tools, and who controls each.
- Decide your budget range for fees and for media separately.
Questions about results and reporting
- What will you report each month, and can it end in booked and completed new-patient visits by channel?
- How do you connect calls and form requests to visits in our scheduling system?
- Which numbers will you show us that we can check independently, such as ad platform invoices and call logs?
- What results have you seen for practices like ours, and can we speak to two current healthcare clients?
- What will you do in the first 90 days, and how will we know by day 90 whether it is working?
- Who exactly will work on our account, and how much of their time does it get?
A good answer names specific measures and admits what cannot be measured. Be wary of reports built around impressions, rankings for chosen keywords or vague engagement scores without any link to patients booked.
Questions about who owns what
Ask the agency to confirm, in the contract, that the practice owns every account and asset, with the agency granted access as a user or manager. That includes the domain name, website and hosting, Google Business Profiles, ad accounts and their conversion history, analytics properties, call tracking numbers, social accounts, review platform accounts, email lists, and all creative files, photos and videos produced for you. If an agency says it must own the ad account or the tracking numbers to do its job, treat that as a warning sign. Phone numbers in particular spread to directories and print; losing them at the end of a contract damages listings for years.
Questions about HIPAA and privacy
HIPAA allows a covered entity to let a vendor handle protected health information only with satisfactory assurances, in a business associate agreement, that the vendor will safeguard it[1]. Agencies that manage call recordings, patient email lists, review requests sent to patients, or website forms will often handle such information. Ask which of their services involve it and whether they will sign a business associate agreement before starting.
- Which tracking pixels and tags will you place on our site, on which pages, and what data does each send?
- Will you keep advertising tags off the patient portal, intake and appointment forms and bill pay?
- Will you upload any patient data to ad platforms? (The right answer is no.)
- Do your call tracking and recording tools sit under a business associate agreement?
- Who at the agency can see patient-related data, and how is access removed when staff leave?
Regulators take advertising data seriously. The FTC's first action under its Health Breach Notification Rule required GoodRx to pay a $1.5 million civil penalty over sharing health information with Facebook, Google and other companies[3]. Under HIPAA, civil penalties reach a calendar-year cap of $2,190,294 per identical provision in the highest tier[4]. The site-level detail is in tracking pixels and HIPAA.
Questions about reviews, testimonials and outreach
Some agencies offer reputation packages that cross legal lines. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, effective October 21, 2024, prohibits buying or selling fake reviews and certain review suppression practices[5]. Ask exactly how the agency generates reviews: it should invite every patient the same way and never write, buy or filter reviews. For outbound calls and texts, ask how consent is collected and recorded. Under FCC rules, telemarketers must obtain prior express written consent before robocalling consumers[6].
Questions about AI tools
Most agencies now use AI tools for drafting content, ads and reports. That can be fine, but healthcare content needs care, and many practices have not set rules of their own. Only 20% of medical groups reported having AI governance or a formal AI-use policy in early 2026, with 22% developing one and 56% having none[2].
- Have a formal AI-use policy 20%
- Developing one 22%
- None 56%
Source: Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Have a formal AI-use policy | 20% |
| Developing one | 22% |
| None | 56% |
- Which AI tools do you use, and for what?
- Will any practice or patient data be entered into those tools? Under what agreements?
- Who reviews AI-drafted health content for accuracy before it is published, and is that a clinician?
- How do you avoid publishing thin, repetitive pages that could weaken our site?
- Will translated content be reviewed by a qualified human translator?
Contract terms to check
| Term | What to look for | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Length and exit | Monthly or a short initial term with a 30-day exit | Long lock-in with large termination fees |
| Ownership | Practice owns all accounts, numbers, content and data | Agency owns ad accounts, numbers or the website |
| Hand-over | Full access and files returned within days of exit | Assets held until fees are paid in full or no hand-over clause |
| Fees and media | Agency fee separate from ad spend; invoices from platforms visible | Blended pricing that hides how much reaches the ad platform |
| Privacy | Business associate agreement where required; tag approval rules | Refusal to sign or vague privacy language |
| Reporting | Monthly report tied to booked visits; access to raw data | Reports only in the agency's own dashboard |
| Subcontractors | Named, bound by the same privacy terms | Unnamed offshore subcontractors with access to accounts |
Run a fair selection
Shortlist three agencies
Prefer agencies with current healthcare clients in your specialty and a clear answer on business associate agreements.
Send the same questions
Use the lists above and ask for written answers before a second meeting.
Check references
Speak to two current clients, and ask what happened when something went wrong.
Score on four areas
Reporting, ownership, privacy and contract terms, each scored from one to five. Fees are compared only between agencies that pass the other four.
Start with a defined pilot
Agree a 90-day scope with targets and a review date, and keep the right to exit if targets are missed.
Warning signs during the sales process
- Guaranteed rankings or guaranteed numbers of new patients before the agency has seen your data.
- Case studies with no named clients and no way to speak to one.
- Proposals that never mention HIPAA, business associate agreements or tracking tags.
- A reluctance to put ownership of accounts and numbers in writing.
- Pressure to sign a long contract quickly to secure a discount.
- Review or reputation tactics that involve filtering which patients are invited, or writing responses that discuss care.
- Reports that you can only view in the agency's own dashboard, with no export.
One warning sign is not always fatal; several together usually are. Write down which ones you saw for each agency and discuss them at the reference calls, where current clients can tell you whether the concern was justified.
Example: comparing two proposals
Example (fictional): Meadowbrook Dental receives two proposals. Agency A promises top rankings, reports impressions and clicks, would create the ad account in its own name and offers a review package that only sends invitations to patients rated happy by staff. Agency B proposes a 90-day pilot, reports booked new-patient visits by channel using call tracking and the practice's scheduling data, sets up all accounts in the practice's name and signs a business associate agreement for call recordings. Agency B's fee is higher, but it scores well on ownership, privacy and reporting, and Meadowbrook can check every number it reports. The practice chooses B and reviews results at day 90.
The same questions apply to vendors offering AI search visibility, short video or competitor analysis.
Frequently asked questions
Does a marketing agency need a business associate agreement?
If it will create, receive or handle protected health information, such as call recordings, patient email lists or form submissions, yes. HIPAA permits that only under a business associate agreement[1].
Who should own our Google Ads and Google Business Profile accounts?
The practice. The agency should be added as a user or manager, so you keep the accounts, history and numbers if you change vendors.
What should a healthcare agency report?
Booked and completed new-patient visits by channel and cost per new patient, with access to the underlying data, not just clicks and rankings.
Can an agency buy or filter reviews for us?
No. The FTC's review rule bans buying or selling fake reviews and certain review suppression practices[5].
References
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). AI governance in medical group practices: Rules for the humans in the loop (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2023). FTC Enforcement Action to Bar GoodRx from Sharing Consumers' Sensitive Health Info for Advertising (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 102.3 - Penalty adjustment and table (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2024). Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (Final rule, 89 FR 68034) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (news release) (opens in a new tab) ↑