Key takeaways
- Your competitors include urgent care and retail clinics: 27.6% of people in the US visited an urgent care center and 19.0% a retail clinic in 2024[1].
- Score each competitor on access, hours, phone experience, insurance, services, providers, reviews and online presence.
- Look at review themes rather than star averages; they show what patients value and what frustrates them.
- Turn findings into two or three decisions, such as evening hours or faster callbacks, and repeat the analysis twice a year.
Why competitor analysis is worth an afternoon
Patients compare. Someone new to town or unhappy with their current office will look at a handful of options on a map, read reviews, check who takes their insurance and call one or two. Your practice is judged against whoever else appears in that search. Knowing how you compare on the things patients notice, such as how quickly they can be seen, whether the phone is answered and what reviews say, lets you fix the gaps that cost you patients and promote the strengths that win them.
This is not about copying other practices or undercutting them. It is a structured look at your local market from a patient's point of view, done once or twice a year, that ends in a short list of decisions.
Who your competitors really are
The obvious competitors are practices in your specialty within a reasonable drive. The less obvious ones are the places patients go instead of booking with any practice. In 2024, 27.6% of people in the US had at least one urgent care center visit in the past 12 months and 19.0% had at least one retail health clinic visit[1]. For younger adults these settings can replace a practice altogether: 12.2% of adults aged 18 to 34 use an urgent care center or retail clinic as their usual source of care, compared with 3.8% of adults 65 and older[2].
Source: CDC National Center for Health Statistics, 2024[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Urgent care center | 27.6% |
| Retail health clinic | 19% |
Add telehealth services your patients mention, hospital-owned groups nearby and, for dental and aesthetic practices, chains and dental service organizations. Then trim the list to the five to ten that appear most often when you search as a patient.
Set up the analysis
Define your area
Use the drive time most of your patients travel, often 15 to 20 minutes for primary care and longer for specialty care. Your patient ZIP code report shows the real catchment.
Search like a patient
On a phone, search your specialty plus near me and your town name, check the map results and note which practices and clinics appear, in what order.
Pick the comparison set
Choose five to ten competitors, including at least one urgent care or retail clinic if you offer primary care.
Gather public information
Websites, Google profiles, health directories, plan directories and review sites. Record what you find in a shared scorecard.
Make a few honest calls
Call as a prospective patient to ask about new-patient availability, hours and insurance. Do not book appointments you will not keep.
The scorecard
| Dimension | What to check | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| New-patient access | Earliest new-patient appointment offered | A short call asking about availability |
| Hours | Evenings, weekends, lunch coverage | Website and Google profile |
| Phone experience | Answered by a person, hold time, menu length | The same call |
| Online booking | Whether new patients can request or book online | Website |
| Insurance | Plans accepted, self-pay information | Website and plan directories |
| Services | Same-day visits, procedures, vaccines, telehealth | Website and service pages |
| Providers | Number, specialties, languages, accepting new patients | Provider pages and directories |
| Reviews | Volume, recency, rating and common themes | Google profile and major review sites |
| Online presence | Mobile-friendly site, complete profile, photos, videos | Website and Google profile |
| Location | Parking, transit, accessibility | Website, map and a drive past |
Access is usually the deciding factor
Of everything on the scorecard, access tends to matter most to new patients, and it is where practices differ most. Among medical groups polled in 2026, 28% said new-patient wait times were longer than a year earlier, while 22% said they were shorter[3]. Practice leaders' top access priorities for 2026 were split between no-shows, online scheduling, phone access and wait times[4]. If your new-patient wait is a week and the practice across town offers three weeks, that is your headline. If it is the other way round, it is your first problem to fix.
Read reviews for themes, not stars
Patients read reviews; in one published survey, 57% said they read online reviews of their physician[5]. For competitor analysis, star averages are less useful than what reviewers repeat. Read the 20 most recent reviews for each competitor and tally the themes.
- Praise themes: the doctor listens, staff are friendly, easy to get an appointment, on time, clear billing.
- Complaint themes: phones not answered, long waits in the office, rude front desk, surprise bills, hard to get a callback.
- Recency: a practice with many reviews from years ago and few lately may have changed.
- Replies: whether the practice responds, and whether replies are calm and privacy-safe.
Do the same for your own reviews. Where competitors' complaints match your strengths, say so in your marketing in general terms. Where their praise matches your complaints, you have found your priority.
Check online presence against the rules
Compare Google profiles for completeness: hours, photos, services, booking links and accurate categories. You may notice competitors with keywords stuffed into their business names. Google's guidelines say a name should reflect the real-world name used on signage and branding, without extras such as taglines or location details[6]. Keep your own listing clean; a stuffed name can bring short-lived gains and a suspended profile. If you see clear violations, you can suggest an edit through Google's normal process, but spend most of your energy on your own listings.
Use what patients and staff already know
Some of the best competitive information is already inside your practice. New patients who switched from another office can tell you why, if you ask a simple question at intake: what made you look for a new practice? Staff who used to work elsewhere know how other front desks run. Referring physicians hear which specialists their patients complain about. Collect these answers in the same scorecard, without names, and look for patterns.
- Add an optional question to new-patient intake about why they changed practices.
- Ask providers and staff to note any competitor change they hear about, such as new hours or a closed location.
- Review departing patients' records requests for patterns in where they go.
Turn findings into decisions
- Differentiate on access: if you can offer faster new-patient visits, same-day sick visits or evening hours, make them visible everywhere.
- Close gaps that cost patients: if every competitor answers the phone faster, fix lunch coverage and callback times before spending on ads.
- Fill service gaps: a service no nearby practice offers, such as Saturday hours or a Spanish-speaking clinician, can be a strong reason to choose you.
- Improve listings and pages where competitors look more complete, using directory listings and NAP consistency as the checklist.
- Avoid comparative claims you cannot prove, and never disparage other practices.
Limit the output to two or three decisions with owners and dates. A long report with no decisions is the most common outcome of competitor analysis, and the least useful.
Example: a primary care scorecard
Example (fictional): Elmwood Family Practice compares itself with three nearby practices, a hospital-owned group and an urgent care center. Its scorecard shows that Elmwood offers the fastest new-patient appointments and the only Spanish-speaking physician in the area, but it is the only office with no evening hours and its phone menu is the longest. Competitors' reviews often praise evening availability; Elmwood's reviews often mention waiting on hold. The practice makes three decisions: add two evening sessions a week, shorten its phone menu to three options, and feature its new-patient availability and Spanish-speaking physician on its Google profile and website. Six months later it repeats the scorecard and finds its phone complaints have fallen.
Repeat on a schedule
Markets change: a practice opens, a group is acquired, an urgent care adds a location. Repeat the analysis once or twice a year, using the same scorecard so results are comparable, and refresh it after any major local change. Share the summary with your providers and front desk; they often know things about competitors that never appear online. The same lens applies to elective services, covered in handling cosmetic consult leads, and to choosing outside help, covered in hiring a healthcare marketing agency. If competitors answer inquiries faster, start with speed to lead.
Frequently asked questions
Who are a medical practice's competitors?
Practices in your specialty nearby, plus urgent care centers, retail clinics, telehealth services and hospital-owned groups. Urgent care and retail clinics reach large shares of the population[1].
What should a competitor scorecard include?
New-patient access, hours, phone experience, online booking, insurance, services, providers and languages, reviews, online presence and location.
Is it OK to secret shop competitors?
Calling as a prospective patient to ask about availability and insurance is common. Do not book appointments you will not keep, and do not misrepresent yourself beyond that.
How often should we analyze local competitors?
Once or twice a year, and after major local changes such as a new practice opening or an acquisition.
References
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2024). Urgent Care Center and Retail Health Clinic Use: United States, 2024 (NCHS Data Brief No. 562) (opens in a new tab) โ
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2024). Source of Usual Health Care for Adults Age 18 and Older: United States, 2024 (NCHS Data Brief No. 558) (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). New-patient wait times largely hold flat in 2026 as some groups add providers in bid to meet demand (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2025). Patient access priorities for 2026: Tackling wait times, phones, no-shows and more (opens in a new tab) โ
Kansas Journal of Medicine (via PubMed Central) (2022). Millennials Seeking Healthcare: Examining the Degree to Which Patients Utilize Online Resources (Kansas Journal of Medicine, 2022) (opens in a new tab) โ
Google Business Profile Help (2026). Guidelines for representing your business on Google (opens in a new tab) โ