HIPAA and Compliance

Patients Asking to Be Called at a Different Number

How to honor HIPAA confidential communications requests: what the rule requires, how to flag a new number in every system, and where billing slips.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. A request that usually arrives in one sentence
  2. What the rule requires and what it leaves to you
  3. Billing mail is where most requests break
  4. Flag it once, in fields every system reads
  5. Phone scripts for the moments that go wrong
  6. Calls the desk never takes
  7. A quarterly check that catches the misses
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
HIPAA and Compliance: Patients Asking to Be Called at a Different Number43.5M: US women who have experienced sexual violence, physical violence or stalking by an intimate partnerHIPAA AND COMPLIANCEPatients Asking to Be Calledat a Different Number43.5MUS women who have experienced sexual violence,physical violence or stalking by an intimate partnerAva Medical IntakeInsightsHIPAA and Compliance: Patients Asking to Be Called at a Different Number43.5M: US women who have experienced sexual violence, physical violence or stalking by an intimate partnerHIPAA AND COMPLIANCEPatients Asking to BeCalled at a DifferentNumber43.5MUS women who have experienced sexualviolence, physical violence orstalking by an intimate partnerAva Medical Intake
Figure source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2024[1]

Key takeaways

  • A provider must accommodate reasonable requests to be contacted by other means or at other locations, and may not ask why[2].
  • You may require the request in writing and ask for the alternative contact details and how payment will be handled[2].
  • Most misses happen in billing: guarantor statements, collection files and outside labs keep the old address.
  • Put the request in structured fields every system reads, block the old number, and audit a sample every quarter.

A request that usually arrives in one sentence

“Please don't call the house. Use my cell, and don't leave a message.” Front desks hear some version of that most weeks, usually mid-check-in with two people waiting behind the patient. It sounds like a preference. Under HIPAA it is a right: a covered health care provider must let patients ask to receive communications by alternative means or at alternative locations, and must accommodate the reasonable requests[2]. The practice may ask for the request in writing and for the new number or address, but it may not require the patient to explain why[2].

That last point is the one staff find hardest. The reason is often ordinary: a shared landline, a roommate who picks up, a work phone the employer monitors. Sometimes it is not. CDC estimates that nearly 43.5 million women and 20.7 million men in the US have experienced contact sexual violence, physical violence or stalking by an intimate partner during their lifetime[1]. A patient in that situation may live with the person who answers the home phone and opens the mail. Nobody at the desk will be told which kind of request this is, so every request gets handled as if it were the serious kind.

Lifetime violence or stalking by an intimate partner, US adultsShare of adults reporting each form by an intimate partner during their lifetime.
Lifetime violence or stalking by an intimate partner, US adultsBar chart. Physical violence: Women 22.5%, Men 13.7%; Contact sexual violence: Women 19.7%, Men 4.4%; Stalking: Women 12.2%, Men 4.2%.Physical violencePhysical violence · Women: 22.5%22.5%Physical violence · Men: 13.7%13.7%Contact sexual violenceContact sexual violence · Women: 19.7%19.7%Contact sexual violence · Men: 4.4%4.4%StalkingStalking · Women: 12.2%12.2%Stalking · Men: 4.2%4.2%Lifetime violence or stalking by an intimate partner, US adultsBar chart. Physical violence: Women 22.5%, Men 13.7%; Contact sexual violence: Women 19.7%, Men 4.4%; Stalking: Women 12.2%, Men 4.2%.Physical violencePhysical violence · Women: 22.5%22.5%Physical violence · Men: 13.7%13.7%Contact sexual violenceContact sexual violence · Women: 19.7%19.7%Contact sexual violence · Men: 4.4%4.4%StalkingStalking · Women: 12.2%12.2%Stalking · Men: 4.2%4.2%
  • Women
  • Men

Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2024[1]

Show the data
FormWomenMen
Physical violence22.5%13.7%
Contact sexual violence19.7%4.4%
Stalking12.2%4.2%

The rule itself is short. Living up to it is operational work: the new number has to reach every system and every outside company that might contact the patient, and the old one has to stop being used. The failures tend to surface weeks later, in a department that never heard about the request.

What the rule requires and what it leaves to you

Summary of 45 CFR 164.522(b) and 164.520. State law can add rules, especially for minors.
ElementWhat the regulation saysWhat it means at the desk
Who must accommodateCovered health care providers, for reasonable requests[2]Every team that contacts patients: scheduling, clinical callbacks, billing, recall
Health plansOnly when the patient clearly states that disclosure could endanger them[2]Insurer mail is the plan's job; the patient asks the plan separately
WritingThe provider may require it[2]Use a one-page form, but act on the spoken request the same day
ReasonA provider may not require an explanation[2]Never ask why, and never write a guessed reason in the chart
ConditionsAn alternative address or contact method, and how payment will be handled when appropriate[2]Get the new number or address and where statements should go
NoticeThe Notice of Privacy Practices must describe the right[3]Staff should be able to point a patient to that paragraph

“Reasonable” is about whether you can do it, not about the motive. Calling only a mobile number, mailing to a PO box, sending statements to a work address, leaving no voicemail, using the portal instead of the phone, or leaving callback messages without the practice name are all requests most offices can meet. A request you genuinely cannot meet, such as calling only between noon and 12:15, deserves an honest answer and an alternative the patient accepts, recorded the same way.

Keep this right separate from its neighbor in the same regulation. A patient who pays for a service in full out of pocket can require you not to disclose information about it to their health plan for payment or operations[2]. That is a restriction on disclosure, not a change of phone number, and it lands on the billing team rather than the scheduling screen. Patients often ask for both in one breath, so train staff to hear two requests.

Billing mail is where most requests break

Scheduling usually gets the new number right. Billing is where the old address comes back. Statements are often printed by an outside vendor from a nightly file, aged balances move to a collection agency with whatever address was on file the day they moved, and labs, imaging centers and anesthesia groups that bill separately took their own copy of the demographics when the order went out.

  • Statement vendor: confirm the vendor's file reads the address field you changed, not a guarantor field that still holds the old address.
  • Guarantor records: when a spouse or parent is the guarantor, statements go to the guarantor by default. Settling where statements go is the “how payment will be handled” condition the rule lets you raise[2].
  • Collections: accounts already placed with an agency keep the old details until someone sends the update. Send it in writing and keep the confirmation.
  • Outside billers: labs and imaging centers on open orders need the change too. A demographic sheet faxed three weeks ago is what they are working from.
  • The health plan: explanation-of-benefits mail comes from the insurer, not from you. The patient has to contact the plan, which may ask them to state that disclosure could endanger them[2].

Example: a 24-year-old covered on a parent's employer plan asks for statements by email and calls only to her mobile. The practice updates both fields, flags the account and sends the new contact details to the outside lab that ran last month's tests. The explanation of benefits for the same visit still goes to the parent as policyholder, because that mail belongs to the plan. The desk says so plainly at the time, so she can call the plan that afternoon.

Flag it once, in fields every system reads

A request written in a free-text note protects nobody. The reminder platform does not read notes, the statement vendor never sees them, and a temp covering the phones will not scroll down to find one. Put the request in structured fields: the approved number, whether messages may be left, the approved mailing address and a confidential-communications flag that shows as a banner whenever anyone opens the chart or the account. Our guide to capturing patient contact preferences covers the registration side; what follows is about a request that arrives partway through the relationship.

Example: an alternate-number request, from first sentence to every system
  • Caller
  • Your team
  • System
  1. 01Caller

    Patient makes the request

    “Cell only, no voicemail.” No reason is asked for or written down.

  2. 02Your team

    Desk confirms details

    New number read back; request form signed, or sent for signature.

  3. 03Your team

    Structured fields updated

    Approved number, message rule and address in the PM and EHR; banner on.

  4. 04System

    Downstream tools refresh

    Reminder, texting, portal and statement systems pick up the change.

  5. 05Your team

    Outside parties told

    Statement vendor, collection agency and labs with open orders get the update.

  6. 06Your team

    Next-visit check

    Confirm the number, and that nothing has gone to the old one since.

Example sequence. Steps four and five are where most practices lose a request.

Automated messages need particular care. Under the FCC's health care exemption, automated reminder calls and texts to mobile phones may go only to the wireless number the patient provided[4], so the reminder tool must hold the approved number, not whatever the phone system captured from caller ID last spring. Delete the old number or mark it do-not-contact. Left in place as a second contact, it invites a well-meaning staff member to try it when the first number goes unanswered.

Watch record merges as well. When two charts for the same person are combined, the surviving record can inherit the old phone number from the duplicate; preventing duplicate records covers the merge checks.

Phone scripts for the moments that go wrong

Most broken requests are broken out loud. Someone calls, someone answers, and a staff member trying to be helpful says one sentence too many. These scripts keep the sentence short.

  • Taking the request: “Of course. What number should we use, and is it all right to leave a message there? I'll send a short form to sign, but we'll use the new number starting today.”
  • Someone asks why they can't reach the patient: “I'm not able to discuss anyone's account or say whether they're a patient here. I'm happy to take a message.”
  • A different person answers the approved number: “Hi, I'm trying to reach Sam. I'll try again later.” No practice name if the patient asked for none, and no reason for the call.
  • The patient wants the request removed: confirm it is the patient using your caller identity checks, update the fields and note the date. Never reverse a request because a relative says it is no longer needed.

When messages are allowed on the new number, keep them to what HIPAA permits in a patient voicemail.

Two situations belong with the privacy officer, not the desk. The first is when the person the patient wants kept out is legally their personal representative, such as a spouse holding a health care power of attorney. HIPAA lets a practice decline to treat someone as a personal representative when it reasonably believes the patient has been or may be subjected to domestic violence, abuse or neglect by that person, or could be endangered, and decides in professional judgment that doing so is not in the patient's best interest[5]. The second is any request from a minor, where state consent law decides who controls the information; see intake for minors.

Calls the desk never takes

Requests also arrive on calls nobody at the desk answers: after hours, over lunch, or in the 8 a.m. overflow. Whoever answers those calls needs the same instructions. An answering service operator should take the request as a message for privacy-trained staff, never confirm or read back the number on file, and call back only on the number the caller gives. Check that the service does not default to the caller ID from an earlier call.

The same goes for an SI Employee answering forwarded calls. Set up for a medical office, it answers questions about hours, location and accepted insurance from your approved information and hands anything patient-specific to the staff line you choose; it does not look up or change records. When nobody can pick up, the request and the callback number the caller gave reach staff in the call summary, and staff complete the change through the steps above. The family practice example shows how overflow calls are split between the SI Employee and staff, and what it does lists the rest.

A quarterly check that catches the misses

  1. Pull the flagged list

    Run a report of every patient with a confidential-communications flag. If you cannot run that report, the flag is not structured enough.

  2. Sample ten records

    For each, check reminders, texts, statements and recall calls sent since the request date. Anything that went to an old number or address is a miss.

  3. Check the outside files

    Ask the statement vendor and the collection agency to confirm the current address on the sampled accounts.

  4. Look at portal proxies

    A proxy granted before the request may belong to the very person the patient is avoiding. Confirm with the patient privately.

  5. Fix the cause, not the record

    A miss usually traces back to one sync, one export or one habit. Correct that, then retrain the team in five minutes at the next huddle.

Keep the written requests and the procedure. HIPAA requires required policies, procedures and documentation to be kept for six years from creation or the date last in effect[6]. Penalties are set per violation and scale with culpability, from a minimum of $145 for a violation the entity did not know about up to a calendar-year cap of $2,190,294 per identical provision[7]. A request that was taken and then ignored is hard to describe as one the practice did not know about.

Frequently asked questions

Can we ask a patient why they want calls at a different number?

No. A covered health care provider may not require an explanation as a condition of honoring the request[2]. You may ask for the alternative number or address and, where it matters, how payment will be handled.

Do we have to get the request in writing?

You may require it[2], and a signed form is useful evidence later. Don't let the form hold up the change: use the new number from the moment the patient asks, and collect the signature after.

Does “don't leave a voicemail” count as a confidential communications request?

Treat it as one. It asks you to communicate by different means, so the same flag, fields and audit apply.

Can we stop insurance mail going to the policyholder?

No. Explanation-of-benefits mail comes from the health plan. The patient has to ask the plan, which must accommodate the request if the patient clearly states that disclosure could endanger them[2].

Where is this right explained to patients?

In your Notice of Privacy Practices, which must state the right to receive confidential communications[3]. Use the same wording on your request form.

References

  1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2024). About Intimate Partner Violence (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2013). 45 CFR § 164.522 - Rights to request privacy protection for protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2013). 45 CFR § 164.520 - Notice of privacy practices for protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR) (2026). 47 CFR 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2013). 45 CFR § 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2013). 45 CFR § 164.530 - Administrative requirements (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 45 CFR § 102.3 - Penalty adjustment and table (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo