Key takeaways
- Illinois eavesdropping turns on secrecy: recording a private conversation surreptitiously needs every other party's consent[2].
- An eavesdropping device includes one that transcribes, and a practice that benefits from a vendor's secret recording can be liable as a principal[3].
- BIPA covers voiceprints, at $1,000 or $5,000 per violation[1]; information collected for treatment, payment or operations is carved out[1].
- Staff voices and a vendor's own product uses sit at the edge of the carve-out; get written releases and written vendor answers.
Two Illinois laws reach every recorded call
Illinois regulates a recorded patient call twice. The eavesdropping article of the Criminal Code decides whether the call may be recorded at all. The Biometric Information Privacy Act decides what a voice tool may extract from the recording, and it carries statutory damages large enough to matter to any practice.
The eavesdropping rule turns on one word. A person commits eavesdropping by using a device in a surreptitious manner to record or transmit a private conversation they are part of, unless every other party consents[2]. Surreptitious means obtained or made by stealth or deception, or executed through secrecy or concealment[3]. A recording that callers are told about at the start is not secret, which is why the notice carries so much weight in this state. A first offense is a Class 4 felony[4], and the people recorded can sue for actual and punitive damages and ask a court for an injunction[5].
A private conversation is one where at least one party intended it to be private under circumstances that reasonably justify that expectation[3]. Patients calling about appointments, bills, prescriptions or symptoms meet that test without effort, and so do most calls staff make back to them. Our overview of one-party and all-party states shows where Illinois sits nationally.
What the eavesdropping article covers
The definitions read as if they were written with modern phone tools in mind. An eavesdropping device is any device capable of hearing or recording oral conversation, or of intercepting or transcribing electronic communications, with an exception for hearing aids[3]. Transcription is named outright, so a tool that keeps a transcript and discards the audio is still within reach.
The article also reaches people who never touch the device. A principal includes anyone who knowingly benefits from another person's illegal eavesdropping, or directs someone to eavesdrop on their behalf[3]. If a vendor records patients' calls in secret for you, the practice is not a bystander. That makes the recording notice a practice decision, not a vendor setting left at its default.
Health care gets one narrow exemption. Illinois exempts recording emergency communications made in the normal course of operations by institutions dealing in emergency services, and the list names hospitals and clinics[6]. It covers emergency communications. A scheduling line, a billing queue or a general main number does not become an emergency line because some callers have emergencies, so do not build a recording program on this exemption.
The same article covers private conversations in person, not only phone calls[3]. A security camera that records sound at the check-in counter, where patients spell out insurance details and reasons for the visit, raises the same consent question as a recorded phone line. Video-only cameras in the waiting room are a different matter; for counter design that keeps conversations private in the first place, see front desk layout for privacy.
When a voice becomes biometric data
BIPA lists a voiceprint as a biometric identifier[1]. Before a private entity collects one, it must tell the person in writing that it is being collected, the specific purpose and how long it will be kept, and it must receive a written release[1]. It must also publish a retention policy and destroy the data when the purpose is met or within three years of the person's last interaction, whichever comes first[1].
A call recording is not automatically a voiceprint. The statute is concerned with identification: biometric information means information based on a biometric identifier and used to identify a person[1]. The features worth asking about are the ones that model a particular voice: caller verification by voice, speaker recognition that labels who is talking in a transcript, and voice cloning, such as building a synthetic copy of the office manager's voice for the phone greeting.
Example: a fictional three-clinic group outside Chicago is offered a branded-voice option that would build a synthetic version of its practice manager's voice for the greeting and hold messages. Before saying yes, the group asks the vendor in writing whether a voice model or template is created and kept, gets the manager's signed release naming the purpose and how long the model will be kept, and adds the model to its published retention schedule. If the manager leaves, the model is deleted on the schedule, not whenever someone remembers.
Source: Illinois General Assembly, 2024[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Negligent violation | $1,000 |
| Intentional or reckless violation | $5,000 |
Public Act 103-769, effective August 2, 2024, changed the arithmetic. Repeated collection of the same identifier from the same person by the same method now counts as a single violation, with at most one recovery, and an electronic signature counts as a written release[1]. The exposure is per person rather than per scan, which still adds up across a whole staff or a patient list.
The health care carve-out and its edges
BIPA's definitions exclude information captured from a patient in a health care setting, and information collected, used or stored for health care treatment, payment or operations under HIPAA[1]. Recordings of patients calling to schedule, reschedule or ask about a bill fit the second clause well. The edges are where practices should slow down.
| Voice data | Whose voice | Starting point for counsel |
|---|---|---|
| Recordings and transcripts of patient calls | Patients | Collected for treatment, payment or operations, which the carve-out is written for[1] |
| Caller verification by voice | Patients | Likely within the carve-out when used for patient access; confirm templates are used only for that |
| Synthetic voice of a staff member for greetings | Staff | Not information from a patient; get a written release before any voice is modelled |
| Call audio used to improve a vendor's product | Staff and patients | The vendor's product work is not the practice's treatment, payment or operations; get terms in writing |
| Calls from non-patients | Vendors, job applicants, sales reps | Not patient information; treat any voice modelling as outside the carve-out |
Staff are the group most often forgotten. The first clause speaks only of patients. Whether the second clause covers an employee's voice depends on what the voice data is used for, and a greeting voice built from a receptionist's recordings is a question to settle before the vendor builds it, with a signed release either way.
Questions to put to any voice vendor in writing
Patients already worry about this. In a 2026 KFF poll, 77% of the public said they were concerned about the privacy of personal medical information provided to AI tools[7]. Ask the vendor these questions and keep the answers with the contract.
- Does any feature create a voiceprint, speaker profile or voice template of a caller or a staff member? Which features, and can they be switched off?
- Is any audio or transcript from our calls used to train or improve models used for other customers?
- Where are audio, transcripts and summaries stored, for how long, and how is deletion confirmed?
- Will you sign a business associate agreement? A covered practice may let a vendor handle patient information only with that written assurance[8].
- Can recording stop on a single call when a caller declines, and does the notice play before any audio is captured?
- Who at the vendor can listen to our calls, and is that access logged?
Our guide to what vendors do with recordings and the checklist in AI phone agents and HIPAA go further into contract terms.
Notice and consent on an Illinois line
Because the offense depends on secrecy, the notice should be impossible to miss and should name what actually happens to the call. If a tool transcribes, say so. If a manager can listen live, say monitored.
- Caller
- System
- Your team
01Caller
Caller reaches the practice
Main number, a forwarded overflow line or the after-hours line.
02System
Notice before anything else
βThis call is recorded, transcribed and may be monitored.β
03Caller
Caller decides
Continues, or says they would rather not be recorded.
04Your team
Decline handled on the spot
Recording off, or a prompt callback on an unrecorded line.
05System
Voice templates off
Features that identify speakers stay off unless written releases are on file.
06Your team
Retention schedule applies
Audio and transcripts deleted on schedule; access limited to named staff.
Example sequence for a practice that records calls. Adapt the wording with counsel.
Example greeting: βThanks for calling Prairie Street Pediatrics. This call is recorded, transcribed and may be monitored for quality. If you'd rather not be recorded, tell us when we answer.β The practice name is fictional.
Automated answering follows the same rule. When an SI Employee answers a practice's forwarded calls, the practice approves the greeting, which can include an automated-assistant disclosure and the recording notice, and each call reaches the practice's account with a recording, transcript and summary. A manager can also listen in while a call is in progress, so keep monitored in the notice (what it does). The orthopedic after-hours example shows how such a line hands urgent post-operative calls to the on-call physician.
Staff are parties too
Every recorded call has at least two voices, and one of them belongs to your employee. The consent requirement runs to all other parties to the conversation[2], so staff need the same clear notice as callers. In practice that means a written recording policy, acknowledged at onboarding, that names which lines record, who can listen and how long recordings are kept.
BIPA has its own employment rule. In the context of employment, a written release can be one an employee executes as a condition of employment[1]. That route only helps if the release actually describes the biometric use, its purpose and its retention period, as the statute's notice requirements expect[1]. A generic consent-to-recording clause in the handbook does not describe a voice model.
A short policy for Illinois practices
Inventory recording points
Phone queues, outbound calls, the answering service, transcription tools and any camera with a microphone.
Use one notice everywhere
Recorded, transcribed and monitored, before the first word, repeated whenever someone joins the call.
Get the vendor answers
The six questions above, in writing, before go-live and again at renewal.
Handle biometrics separately
If any voice is modelled, publish a retention policy and collect written releases first; electronic signatures count[1].
Train for the decline
Everyone who answers should be able to stop recording or offer a callback without putting the caller on hold for long.
For greeting wording you can adapt, see call recording disclosure scripts; for where recordings live inside the phone system, see what makes a phone system HIPAA compliant.
Frequently asked questions
Is Illinois a two-party consent state?
For recording a private conversation in secret, yes: a party who records surreptitiously needs the consent of all other parties[2]. A recording that everyone is told about at the start is not surreptitious[3].
Does BIPA apply to ordinary call recordings?
BIPA targets biometric identifiers such as voiceprints, and information based on them that is used to identify a person[1]. Its carve-out is written for information collected for treatment, payment or operations under HIPAA[1]; features that model a specific voice are the ones to examine.
Can we rely on the hospital and clinic exemption?
Only for emergency communications made in the normal course of operations[6]. A general practice line needs a notice.
What changed in BIPA in 2024?
Repeated collection of the same identifier from the same person by the same method is now one violation with at most one recovery, and an electronic signature counts as a written release[1].
Is a transcript without audio covered?
Illinois defines an eavesdropping device to include devices that transcribe electronic communications[3], so treat transcription the same as recording.
References
Illinois General Assembly (2024). Biometric Information Privacy Act (740 ILCS 14) (opens in a new tab) β
Illinois General Assembly (2016). 720 ILCS 5/14-2 - Elements of the offense (eavesdropping) (opens in a new tab) β
Illinois General Assembly (2014). 720 ILCS 5/14-1 - Definitions (eavesdropping) (opens in a new tab) β
Illinois General Assembly (2014). 720 ILCS 5/14-4 - Sentence (eavesdropping) (opens in a new tab) β
Illinois General Assembly (2014). 720 ILCS 5/14-6 - Civil remedies to injured parties (opens in a new tab) β
Illinois General Assembly (2026). 720 ILCS 5/14-3 - Exemptions (eavesdropping) (opens in a new tab) β
KFF (2026). KFF Tracking Poll on Health Information and Trust: Use of AI For Health Information and Advice (opens in a new tab) β
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2013). 45 CFR Β§ 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) β