Marketing and Patient Growth

Keeping Insurance Directory Listings Accurate

What the No Surprises Act requires of plans and practices for provider directories, how often directories are wrong, and a routine to keep yours right.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing6 min read

On this page
  1. Why plan directories matter to your schedule
  2. What the law requires of plans
  3. What the law requires of practices
  4. How often directories are wrong
  5. Build a routine that keeps you accurate
  6. Get the accepting new patients field right
  7. Languages, accessibility and digital contact
  8. Who should own directory accuracy
  9. Common mistakes
  10. Example: cleaning up after a provider departure
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Marketing and Patient Growth: Keeping Insurance Directory Listings AccurateArticle coverMARKETING AND PATIENT GROWTHKeeping InsuranceDirectory ListingsAccurateAva Medical IntakeInsightsMarketing and Patient Growth: Keeping Insurance Directory Listings AccurateArticle coverMARKETING AND PATIENT GROWTHKeeping InsuranceDirectory ListingsAccurateAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Plans must verify directory data at least every 90 days and update it within 2 business days of receiving changes[1].
  • Providers must send directory information when a network agreement starts or ends, when details change materially, and on request[2].
  • Directories are often wrong: CMS found inaccuracies at 48.74% of listed Medicare Advantage locations in one review round[3].
  • Keep a master roster, answer every verification request, and secret-shop your own listings each quarter.

Why plan directories matter to your schedule

When an insured patient looks for a new doctor, a plan's provider directory is often the first or second place they check. It tells them whether you are in network, whether you are taking new patients, where you are and how to call. If any of that is wrong, the patient either chooses someone else or calls you on a wrong assumption, and both outcomes cost you. Nearly every patient relies on some plan's directory: in 2025, employment-based insurance covered 53.5% of the US population, Medicare 20.1% and Medicaid 17.1%[4].

Directory errors also have financial consequences. Under the No Surprises Act, if a plan wrongly tells an enrollee that a provider is in network and the enrollee relies on it, the plan may not charge more than in-network cost-sharing, and must apply the in-network deductible and out-of-pocket maximum[1]. That protects patients, but it also means plans have strong reasons to chase accurate data from practices, and practices that respond slowly create friction with every payer they work with.

What the law requires of plans

The federal provider directory rules require group health plans and issuers to verify their directory information not less frequently than once every 90 days, to update the directory within 2 business days of receiving information from a provider, and to respond to an enrollee's phone inquiry about a provider's network status as soon as practicable and no later than 1 business day after the call, in writing[1]. Those deadlines drive the verification requests that arrive at your office by email, fax, portal and phone.

What the law requires of practices

Providers have their own obligations. The law requires providers and facilities to submit provider directory information to plans when they begin a network agreement, when they terminate one, when there are material changes to their directory information, and at any other time determined appropriate, including on the plan's request[2]. Directory information means the names, addresses, specialty, telephone numbers and digital contact information of the individual providers, and similar details for contracted groups and facilities[2]. Providers were required to have business processes in place for this by January 1, 2022[2].

A practice-side update calendar based on the federal directory requirements. Payer contracts may set stricter timelines.
EventWhat to sendTarget timing
New network agreementFull roster: each provider, location, specialty, phone, digital contactWith the signed agreement
Agreement endsTermination notice listing affected providers and locationsBefore the end date
Provider joinsProvider details, locations and start dateAs soon as credentialing completes
Provider leavesDeparture date and locations to removeBefore the last day
Address, suite or phone changeUpdated details for each affected locationBefore the change takes effect
New-patient status changesAccepting or not accepting new patientsWhen the decision is made
Plan verification requestConfirm or correct the listingWithin the plan's stated deadline

How often directories are wrong

The best public evidence comes from CMS's secret shopper reviews of Medicare Advantage online directories. In the third round, conducted from November 2017 to July 2018, reviewers checked 5,602 providers at 10,504 locations across 52 organizations and found that 48.74% of listed locations had at least one inaccuracy[3]. The errors included providers not at the listed location, incorrect phone numbers and providers listed as accepting new patients when they were not[3]. Inaccuracy rates ranged from 4.63% to 93.02% across organizations, with an average of 44.97%[3].

Directory inaccuracy rates across Medicare Advantage organizations, CMS Round 3
Directory inaccuracy rates across Medicare Advantage organizations, CMS Round 3Bar chart. Lowest organization: 4.63%; Average organization: 44.97%; All listed locations: 48.74%; Highest organization: 93.02%.Lowest organizationLowest organization: 4.63%4.63%Average organizationAverage organization: 44.97%44.97%All listed locationsAll listed locations: 48.74%48.74%Highest organizationHighest organization: 93.02%93.02%Directory inaccuracy rates across Medicare Advantage organizations, CMS Round 3Bar chart. Lowest organization: 4.63%; Average organization: 44.97%; All listed locations: 48.74%; Highest organization: 93.02%.Lowest organizationLowest organization: 4.63%4.63%Average organizationAverage organization: 44.97%44.97%All listed locationsAll listed locations: 48.74%48.74%Highest organizationHighest organization: 93.02%93.02%

Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, 2018[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Lowest organization4.63%
Average organization44.97%
All listed locations48.74%
Highest organization93.02%

Inaccurate listings are one ingredient of what critics call ghost networks: directories full of providers who cannot actually be reached or booked. Access gaps are already wide for some patients. A meta-analysis of secret shopper studies found that Medicaid coverage was associated with a 1.6-fold lower likelihood of successfully scheduling a primary care appointment and a 3.3-fold lower likelihood for specialty care, compared with private insurance[5]. Directory errors make those gaps worse.

Build a routine that keeps you accurate

  1. Keep one master roster

    A single spreadsheet or credentialing system record listing each provider, the locations and days they practice, specialty, phone, languages, new-patient status and each plan they are contracted with.

  2. Route every verification request to one owner

    Requests arrive by email, fax, portal and letter. Send them all to a named credentialing or directory owner with a backup.

  3. Answer from the roster, not from memory

    Confirm or correct each listing against the master roster and log the date and confirmation.

  4. Trigger updates on change

    Any hire, departure, schedule change, move or phone change updates the roster first, then every plan.

  5. Re-attest on schedule

    Many plans rely on credentialing databases or portals that require regular re-attestation. Set calendar reminders for each.

  6. Secret-shop your own listings

    Each quarter, look yourself up in each major plan's directory as a patient would and fix every discrepancy you find.

Get the accepting new patients field right

The new-patient status is the field patients act on and the one practices forget to update. If a provider's panel closes, tell every plan at once; otherwise the front desk spends weeks fielding calls from patients the directory sent you. When the panel reopens, update it again, because a closed listing hides available capacity. Treat the decision to open or close a panel as a directory event, not just a scheduling note.

Front desk prompt: when a caller says they found you in their plan's directory, ask which plan and which provider, and note any detail that was wrong. Those notes are your fastest early warning that a listing has drifted.

Languages, accessibility and digital contact

Directories increasingly show languages spoken, accessibility features and websites. These help the right patients find you, and they go stale like everything else. Confirm each provider's languages with the provider rather than assuming, list physical accessibility accurately, and give plans a stable website address for each location rather than a campaign landing page. Patients who need a Spanish-speaking clinician often search by language; see reaching Spanish-speaking patients.

Who should own directory accuracy

In many practices, directory data falls between credentialing, the front desk and the practice manager, so nobody owns it. Give it a named owner, usually the credentialing coordinator, with the practice manager as backup. The owner keeps the master roster, answers verification requests, sends change notices and runs the quarterly self-check. Everyone else has one job: tell the owner about any change before it happens.

  • Providers tell the owner about schedule changes, new locations and planned departures.
  • Schedulers tell the owner when a panel opens or closes.
  • The front desk logs any caller who reports a wrong directory detail.
  • The practice manager adds directory updates to the checklist for moves, hires and phone changes.

Report directory status at the monthly management meeting: requests received and answered, changes sent, and discrepancies found in the self-check. A five-minute agenda item keeps the work visible and funded.

Common mistakes

  • Listing every provider at every location, including places they rarely or never practice.
  • Leaving departed providers listed because the termination notice never went to every plan.
  • Ignoring verification requests because they look like junk mail or arrive by fax.
  • Updating one plan and assuming others share the data.
  • Using a call center or tracking number instead of the location's direct number.
  • Correcting the plan directory but not the practice's own website and Google profile, so data conflicts across sources.

Example: cleaning up after a provider departure

Example (fictional): Crestview Cardiology's front desk notices callers asking for a cardiologist who left six months earlier. The directory owner checks the master roster, finds that termination notices went to three of the practice's eight contracted plans, and sends the rest the same day. She also finds two plans still listing the practice's old suite and one listing a fax number as the main phone. Each correction is logged with the confirmation date. At the next quarterly self-check, all eight directories show the right providers, address and phone, and the front desk stops receiving calls for the departed physician.

Plan directories sit alongside public listings; keep them consistent with the routine in directory listings and NAP consistency. Accurate data everywhere also helps AI-generated search answers describe you correctly, as covered in showing up in AI search answers.

Frequently asked questions

How often must health plans verify provider directories?

At least once every 90 days, and they must update the directory within 2 business days of receiving changes from a provider[1].

What must practices tell plans about their directory listings?

Directory information such as names, addresses, specialty, phone numbers and digital contact details, at the start and end of a network agreement, after material changes and on request[2].

What happens if a patient relies on a wrong directory listing?

If a plan wrongly listed an out-of-network provider as in network and the patient relied on it, the plan may not charge more than in-network cost-sharing[1].

How can we check our own listings?

Each quarter, search each major plan's directory as a patient would, compare the results with your master roster and correct every difference.

References

  1. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 42 U.S. Code § 300gg-115 - Protecting patients and improving the accuracy of provider directory information (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 42 U.S. Code § 300gg-139 - Provider requirements to protect patients and improve the accuracy of provider directory information (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (2018). Online Provider Directory Review Report (Medicare Advantage, Round 3) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. U.S. Census Bureau (2025). Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2025 (Current Population Reports P60-291) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Inquiry: The Journal of Health Care Organization, Provision, and Financing (via PubMed Central) (2019). Medicaid Patients Have Greater Difficulty Scheduling Health Care Appointments Compared With Private Insurance Patients: A Meta-Analysis (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo