Metrics and Benchmarks

Using MGMA Benchmarks in a Small Practice

How a small practice can use MGMA benchmarks and polls well: pick comparable peers, read medians and percentiles, check definitions and sample size.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. Why small practices need care with benchmarks
  2. Two kinds of MGMA data, used differently
  3. A comparability checklist
  4. Read the range, not the number
  5. How to use a benchmark in five steps
  6. Small practices are different in ways benchmarks miss
  7. Common benchmark traps
  8. Front office measures worth benchmarking
  9. Example: one benchmark, one decision
  10. Your own trend is the best benchmark
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References
Metrics and Benchmarks: Using MGMA Benchmarks in a Small PracticeArticle coverMETRICS AND BENCHMARKSUsing MGMA Benchmarksin a Small PracticeAva Medical IntakeInsightsMetrics and Benchmarks: Using MGMA Benchmarks in a Small PracticeArticle coverMETRICS AND BENCHMARKSUsing MGMA Benchmarksin a Small PracticeAva Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • A benchmark is only useful if the comparison group looks like you: same specialty, similar size, ownership and region.
  • Use medians and percentile ranges, not averages, and look at where you sit in the range rather than whether you beat a single number.
  • Check the definition and the sample. A poll of a few hundred respondents shows direction, not a standard to hit.
  • Your own trend is the most reliable benchmark. Use external data to ask better questions, not to set targets by itself.

Why small practices need care with benchmarks

Benchmarks are tempting because they answer the question every owner asks: are we doing well? For a small practice, the answer is harder than it looks. Most published benchmarks are built from many practices of different sizes, specialties, ownership models and regions. A two-physician independent practice compared with a figure dominated by large hospital-owned groups can draw exactly the wrong conclusion.

The landscape has shifted. In 2024, 47.4% of US physicians worked in practices with 10 or fewer physicians, down from 61.4% in 2012[1]. Over the same period the share in hospital-owned practices rose from 23.4% to 34.5%[1], and the share working in private practices fell from 60.1% to 42.2%[2]. As larger and hospital-owned groups make up more of the field, they also make up more of many benchmark samples.

Where US physicians work: small and hospital-owned practices, 2012 vs 2024
Where US physicians work: small and hospital-owned practices, 2012 vs 2024Column chart. Practices with 10 or fewer physicians: 2012 61.4%, 2024 47.4%; Hospital-owned practices: 2012 23.4%, 2024 34.5%.0%20%40%60%80%Practices with 10 or fewer physicians · 2012: 61.4%61.4%Practices with 10 or fewer physicians · 2024: 47.4%47.4%Practices with 10 or fewer physiciansHospital-owned practices · 2012: 23.4%23.4%Hospital-owned practices · 2024: 34.5%34.5%Hospital-owned practicesWhere US physicians work: small and hospital-owned practices, 2012 vs 2024Column chart. Practices with 10 or fewer physicians: 2012 61.4%, 2024 47.4%; Hospital-owned practices: 2012 23.4%, 2024 34.5%.Practices with 10 or fewer physiciansPractices with 10 or fewer physicians · 2012: 61.4%61.4%Practices with 10 or fewer physicians · 2024: 47.4%47.4%Hospital-owned practicesHospital-owned practices · 2012: 23.4%23.4%Hospital-owned practices · 2024: 34.5%34.5%
  • 2012
  • 2024

Source: American Medical Association, 2024[1]

Show the data
Item20122024
Practices with 10 or fewer physicians61.4%47.4%
Hospital-owned practices23.4%34.5%

Two kinds of MGMA data, used differently

Practice leaders mostly meet MGMA data in two forms. The first is survey-based benchmark data on costs, staffing, revenue and compensation, usually broken down by specialty, size and ownership. The second is the MGMA Stat poll: a quick question put to practice leaders, with results published alongside the number of responses.

Stat polls are good at showing direction across the field. For example, in an August 2026 poll with 190 responses, 32% of medical groups reported higher no-show rates year to date than in 2025[3]. In a May 2026 poll, 29% reported higher staff turnover than the year before[4]. Those results tell you whether a problem you are seeing is widespread. They do not tell you what your no-show rate or turnover should be, because the question asks about change, not level, and the respondents are not a sample built to match your practice.

Survey benchmarks are the right tool for level comparisons, such as staff per physician or cost per visit, but only once you have checked that the comparison group and the definitions match yours.

A comparability checklist

Example checklist before comparing your practice with a benchmark
DimensionWhy it mattersWhat to check
SpecialtyStaffing, visit length and revenue differ widely by specialtyUse your specialty, or the closest one; avoid multispecialty figures for a single-specialty practice
SizeFixed costs and staffing ratios change with the number of providersPick the size band closest to your provider count
OwnershipHospital-owned, private equity-backed and independent practices account for costs differentlyMatch ownership type where the data allows
Region and settingWages, rents and payer mix vary by areaUse regional or urban/rural cuts where available
DefinitionsFTE, visit, staff role and cost category definitions varyRead the definitions and recalculate your own figure the same way
Sample sizeSmall cells produce unstable mediansNote the number of respondents behind the figure you use
YearCosts and wages move each yearCompare like years, and adjust for known changes

Read the range, not the number

Benchmark reports usually show a median and a range of percentiles. Use them. The median is the middle practice; half of the respondents are above and half below. Being slightly above or below the median means little. Being outside the middle half of the range, below the 25th or above the 75th percentile, is worth a closer look.

Averages are less useful because a few very large or unusual practices pull them away from the typical case. The same is true inside your own data, which is why median wait times and median handle times are often more honest than averages.

Then ask why. A small practice may be above the range on front office staff per physician for a good reason, such as doing its own billing in-house, or for a fixable one, such as manual work the practice management system could do. The benchmark starts the conversation; it does not end it.

How to use a benchmark in five steps

  1. Start with a question

    Pick one decision you need to make, such as whether to hire another front desk staff member. Choose the benchmark that informs it, such as support staff per physician.

  2. Match the peer group

    Use the checklist above to choose the closest specialty, size, ownership and region. Record the sample size behind the figure.

  3. Recalculate your number

    Calculate your own figure using the benchmark’s definitions, such as how part-time staff count toward FTEs and which roles count as front office.

  4. Place yourself in the range

    Note your percentile position, not just above or below the median.

  5. Explain the gap

    List the reasons your practice differs. Separate the ones you choose, such as in-house billing, from the ones you would fix if you could. Act only on the second list.

Small practices are different in ways benchmarks miss

Small practices often run on different systems from large ones. In 2024, only 32% of physicians in solo practice used an EHR from one of the five market-leading developers, compared with 90% in practices with more than 50 physicians[5]. Differences in systems change how much manual work the front office does, and so how many staff it needs and what each visit costs. A benchmark drawn mainly from large groups with integrated systems will make a small practice look overstaffed even when the team is working efficiently with the tools it has.

Small practices also have less room for averages to settle. One staff vacancy or one provider’s leave can move a monthly figure more than any process change. That is another reason to compare quarters or years rather than months.

Common benchmark traps

  • Comparing a change with a level. A poll that says a third of groups saw no-shows rise says nothing about whether your no-show rate is high.
  • Ignoring who answered. Survey respondents choose to take part. Practices that track their numbers closely may be more likely to respond, which can make the field look better organized than it is.
  • Mixing FTE definitions. If the benchmark counts a full-time employee as a set number of hours and you count heads, your ratio will be off.
  • Using a figure from a different year without adjustment. Wages and costs have moved; a benchmark from several years ago can make current costs look high.
  • Cherry-picking. Choosing the benchmark that makes the practice look best, or worst, to support a decision already made.
  • Treating the median as the goal. Half of all practices are below the median by definition; the right position depends on your strategy.

When a benchmark result surprises you, assume first that the comparison is wrong, check the definitions and the peer group again, and only then assume the practice is.

Front office measures worth benchmarking

Not every front office measure has a useful external comparison. Staffing ratios, such as front office staff per physician FTE, and front office cost per visit are the most commonly benchmarked, and they suit annual decisions about hiring and systems. Access measures such as appointment lag, and accuracy measures such as denial rates, are better tracked against your own history, because definitions vary so much between practices that external figures rarely line up. Phone measures such as abandonment and speed of answer have few reliable published comparisons for small practices; build your own baseline and watch the trend.

Example: one benchmark, one decision

Example: a fictional three-physician independent family practice wants to know if it needs another front desk staff member. The office manager finds a benchmark for front office support staff per physician FTE for family medicine practices of a similar size. The practice’s own figure, calculated with the same definitions, sits above the 75th percentile.

Example, continued: before deciding, the manager lists the reasons. The practice does its own insurance verification and prior authorizations at the desk, where many peers use a central team or a billing service. It also uses a practice management system with no automated eligibility checks. Adjusting for those, the practice looks close to the middle of the range. The decision changes from whether to hire to whether automating eligibility would free enough time to avoid hiring. The benchmark did its job: it raised the right question.

Your own trend is the best benchmark

  • Keep a fixed set of internal measures, calculated the same way every month: access, accuracy, collections and cost.
  • Compare each quarter with the same quarter last year to remove seasonality.
  • Use external benchmarks once or twice a year, for specific decisions.
  • Use polls to check whether a change you are seeing is shared across the field, which helps decide whether the cause is local or external.

For the internal measures that pair well with benchmarks, see revenue per visit, cost per patient call, front office staff cost per visit and patient retention rate.

Frequently asked questions

Can a small practice use MGMA benchmarks?

Yes, if it chooses a comparable peer group by specialty, size, ownership and region, uses the same definitions and reads the percentile range rather than a single number.

What is the difference between MGMA Stat polls and benchmark surveys?

Stat polls ask practice leaders a quick question and publish the results with the number of responses; they show direction across the field. Benchmark surveys provide levels, such as staffing or cost figures, by peer group.

Should we set targets from benchmarks?

Use them to ask questions and inform specific decisions. Set targets mainly from your own baseline and trend.

Why might a small practice look overstaffed against benchmarks?

Small practices often do tasks in-house that larger groups centralize, and many use different systems; in 2024 only 32% of solo physicians used an EHR from a market-leading developer[5].

References

  1. American Medical Association (2024). Physician Practice Characteristics in 2024: Private Practices Account for Less Than Half of Physicians in Most Specialties (Policy Research Perspectives) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. American Medical Association (2024). Physician Practice Benchmark Survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). About 1 in 3 medical groups see higher no-shows in 2026 as patients face higher costs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Stabilized but not solved: Staff turnover in medical practices looking no better, no worse in 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS (2024). Office-based Physician Electronic Health Record Adoption, 2008-2024 (ONC Data Brief) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo