Key takeaways
- Confirm network status for the patient's exact product and clinician before saying you are out of network, and say it before the visit is booked.
- Federal balance-billing protections for non-emergency care apply at hospitals, hospital outpatient departments, critical access hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers, not to most office visits; check your state's rules too.
- Give a cost range built from the patient's out-of-network benefits, or a self-pay estimate, rather than a single guess.
- Offer real options and record exactly what the patient was told and what they chose.
Say it before you book
The worst time for a patient to learn you are out of network is when the bill arrives. Many insured adults already find their coverage hard to follow: in a KFF survey, 36% said it was at least somewhat difficult to understand what their insurance covers, and 30% found it difficult to understand what they would owe out of pocket[1]. A clear sentence at booking prevents a complaint, a dispute and often a lost patient.
The stakes for patients are real. Out-of-pocket health spending in the US grew 5.9% to $556.6 billion in 2024[2]. People are paying more of their own money for care, and they expect to be told the cost in advance.
First, be sure you are out of network
Saying "we are out of network" when you are not loses patients for no reason. Saying "we take your insurance" when you do not creates bills nobody expected. Check these points first.
- Product, not payer: you may be in network with an insurer's PPO and out of network with its exclusive provider or HMO product.
- Clinician, not practice: a newly hired clinician may not be credentialed yet even though the practice is contracted.
- Location: some contracts cover only certain addresses.
- Pending credentialing: if a clinician's application is pending, say so plainly and do not promise an in-network bill.
- Medicaid and Medicare Advantage plans: check the specific plan, since contracts differ even within one insurer.
If you cannot confirm network status during the call, say so and book a call back rather than guessing. "Let me confirm with your plan and call you back this afternoon" is better than a wrong answer.
Keep a current list of every plan and product you participate in, with effective dates, and give schedulers read access to it. The list should match what your website says, so callers hear the same answer wherever they look.
What federal protections do and do not cover
Patients often assume the No Surprises Act protects them from all out-of-network bills. Its protections for non-emergency care given by out-of-network providers apply at health care facilities as the rule defines them: hospitals, hospital outpatient departments, critical access hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers[3]. A visit to an out-of-network physician in an ordinary office is generally outside those protections, so the patient may owe what the plan does not pay. Some states add their own rules, so check yours with your compliance lead.
Another part of the law does reach every office. Patients who are uninsured, or who have coverage but choose not to have a claim sent to their plan, are treated as self-pay, and must receive a good faith estimate. For a service scheduled at least 3 business days ahead, the estimate is due no later than 1 business day after scheduling[4]. If an out-of-network patient chooses to pay without using their insurance, start the estimate.
The out-of-network script
State the network status plainly
"I checked, and Dr. Rivera is not in network with your plan. I want to tell you now so there are no surprises."
Explain what that usually means
"Your plan may pay part of the visit as an out-of-network benefit, or it may pay nothing. Anything the plan does not pay would be your responsibility."
Give what you know about cost
"Based on your plan's out-of-network benefits, you would likely pay between this amount and this amount," or, if there is no benefit, "our self-pay rate for this visit is this amount, and we will send you a written estimate."
Offer the options
"You can still book with us, we can help you find an in-network clinician, or you can check with your plan first and call us back. Which would you like?"
Confirm and record
Repeat what the patient chose, tell them what happens next, and note the conversation in the appointment record.
Keep the tone neutral. The aim is an informed choice, not talking the patient into or out of the visit. If the patient sounds anxious about cost, slow down and offer to send the details in writing.
Likely costs: give a range, not a guess
What the patient pays depends on the plan type. HMO and exclusive provider products usually pay nothing out of network except emergencies. PPO and point-of-service products often pay out-of-network claims after a separate, higher deductible, then at a higher coinsurance, based on an allowed amount that may be far below your charge.
In-network deductibles alone are substantial. The average single-coverage deductible for workers in a plan with a general deductible was $1,955 in 2026, and $2,624 at smaller firms against $1,772 at larger ones[5]. Out-of-network deductibles are often higher, so for many patients early in the year the realistic expectation is that they will pay most or all of the visit.
Source: KFF, 2026[5]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| All covered workers with a general deductible | $1,955 |
| Smaller firms | $2,624 |
| Larger firms | $1,772 |
- Ask the payer for the out-of-network deductible, amount met and coinsurance.
- Ask how the plan sets its allowed amount for out-of-network claims, if it will say.
- Give the low end of the range as the plan's share applied after the deductible is met; give the high end as your full charge.
- If the plan has no out-of-network benefit, quote your self-pay rate and issue a written estimate.
Options to offer
- Book as out of network, with the patient's informed agreement and a written note of the expected range.
- Book as self-pay, with a good faith estimate and your prompt-pay terms.
- Help the patient find an in-network clinician, and offer to send records if they have been seen before.
- Ask the plan about a network gap exception or single-case agreement when no in-network clinician offers the service nearby or the patient is mid-treatment.
- Let the patient check with their plan first, and hold the slot until a set time.
Present the options in the same order every time, starting with the one that keeps the patient's cost lowest. Patients notice when the practice is steering them, and a consistent order shows it is not.
Worked Example: a new patient on an exclusive provider plan
Example: A fictional caller, Ms. Patel, asks for a dermatology visit. Her card shows an insurer the practice contracts with, but the product is an exclusive provider plan the practice is not part of. The scheduler checks the portal, confirms the plan has no out-of-network benefit, and uses the script.
Example: Ms. Patel asks what a self-pay visit costs. The scheduler quotes the practice's self-pay rate for a new-patient visit, explains that any biopsy would cost extra, and offers to send a written estimate within one business day. Ms. Patel books as self-pay. The estimate goes out the next morning, and the appointment note records what she was told and when.
When the patient is already in your care
The harder conversation is with an established patient whose new plan does not include you. They may be mid-treatment, attached to their clinician and surprised by the change. Raise it as soon as the January check, or any re-check, shows the new plan.
- Call rather than message, and explain what you found before the next visit, not at check-in.
- Ask the plan whether it offers continuity of care for patients in active treatment, and how to request it.
- If the clinician supports it, ask the plan for a single-case agreement for the current course of treatment.
- Offer to send records to an in-network clinician if the patient decides to move.
- If the patient chooses to stay as out of network or self-pay, give the cost range or estimate in writing.
Record the conversation
- The plan and product checked, and the source of the network answer.
- What the patient was told about benefits and the cost range, in plain words.
- The option the patient chose, and any estimate sent with its date.
- The staff member's name and the date and time of the call.
Many of these questions arrive before anyone has looked up the patient. An SI Employee such as Ava can tell callers which plans the practice participates in, from the list you approve, and pass anything about a specific patient's coverage to your staff line.
Frequently asked questions
Do we have to tell patients we are out of network?
Telling them before booking is the fair and practical approach, and many state laws and payer rules expect clear disclosure. Check your state's requirements with your compliance lead.
Does the No Surprises Act stop out-of-network bills from a physician's office?
Its balance-billing protections for non-emergency care apply at hospitals, hospital outpatient departments, critical access hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers. Ordinary office visits are generally outside them, although self-pay patients are entitled to a good faith estimate.
Can an out-of-network patient choose to pay us directly?
Yes. A patient with coverage who does not want a claim sent to their plan is treated as self-pay under the good faith estimate rules, so give them a written estimate on time.
What if we are in network but the clinician is not yet credentialed?
Tell the patient before booking, offer a credentialed clinician if one is available, and do not promise in-network billing until the plan confirms the credentialing date.
References
KFF (2023). KFF Survey of Consumer Experiences with Health Insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 149.30 - Definitions (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 149.610 - Requirements for provision of good faith estimates of expected charges for uninsured (or self-pay) individuals (opens in a new tab) ↑
KFF (2026). 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey (opens in a new tab) ↑