Key takeaways
- Give each step of prior authorization a named owner and a deadline, from the moment a service is ordered to the day it is performed.
- Check whether authorization is needed at the point of ordering, not at scheduling, and submit complete requests the first time.
- Plan around payer decision windows: for Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and federal Marketplace plans, 72 hours for urgent and seven calendar days for standard requests.
- Treat denials as a routine with steps, including a peer-to-peer review and an appeal where the clinician supports it.
Why prior authorization needs a written process
Prior authorization is one of the largest administrative loads in a practice. In an AMA survey released in 2026, physicians reported completing an average of 40 prior authorizations a week, consuming 13 hours of physician and staff time, and 40% employed staff who work only on authorizations[1]. In an MGMA poll, eligibility and prior authorization together topped the list of time-consuming phone tasks, named by 45% of practice leaders[2].
The cost is not only staff time. In the same AMA survey, 95% of physicians said prior authorization delays access to necessary care, and 26% said it had led to a serious adverse event for a patient in their care[1]. When nobody owns a step, requests sit in an inbox, approvals expire and visits are cancelled the day before. A written process with an owner for each step fixes most of that without new software.
The process at a glance
| Step | Owner | Deadline | Output |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Order placed | Ordering clinician | At the visit | Order with diagnosis and service codes |
| 2. Check if authorization is needed | Authorization coordinator | Same business day | Required / not required, with source |
| 3. Gather documentation | Coordinator with clinical staff | Within 1 business day | Notes, test results, prior treatments |
| 4. Submit request | Authorization coordinator | Within 2 business days of order | Reference number and submission date |
| 5. Schedule the service | Scheduler | After step 4, outside the decision window | Appointment linked to the request |
| 6. Follow up | Authorization coordinator | At the payer's decision deadline | Decision or escalation |
| 7. Record the approval | Authorization coordinator | Same day as decision | Number, dates, units, codes in the record |
| 8. Handle a denial | Coordinator and clinician | Within days of the denial | Peer-to-peer, appeal or new plan of care |
| 9. Confirm before the service | Scheduler or check-in | 2 business days before | Approval still valid for the date and code |
In a small practice one person may own several steps. That is fine, as long as the steps are written down and someone covers when that person is out.
Step by step: from order to approval
Capture a complete order
The clinician records the service, the diagnosis codes and the clinical reason in the note at the visit. Missing diagnosis codes are a common reason requests stall before they are sent.
Check the payer's requirement at the point of ordering
The coordinator checks the payer's authorization list or portal for the specific service code and plan. Record the answer and its source, even when no authorization is needed, so the question is not asked again.
Gather documentation once
Pull the notes, test results, imaging and record of earlier treatments the payer's criteria ask for. Many payers publish their criteria; read them and match the documentation to each point.
Submit through the fastest channel
Use the payer's portal or electronic submission where possible, and fax or phone only when required. Save the reference number, the submission date and a copy of what was sent.
Schedule outside the decision window
Book the service for a date after the payer's decision deadline, and tell the patient the visit depends on approval.
Follow up on the deadline
If there is no decision by the deadline, call or check the portal that day. Requests left pending for weeks are often missing a document the payer asked for.
Record the approval in full
Copy the authorization number, approved service codes, number of units or visits, and start and end dates into the patient's record and the appointment.
Handle a denial quickly
Send the denial reason to the ordering clinician the same day, and agree whether to request a peer-to-peer review, appeal, or change the plan of care.
Confirm before the service
Two business days before, check that the approval covers the date, the code being performed and the location. Changes in any of these may need a new request.
Decision windows to plan around
Since January 1, 2026, Medicare Advantage organizations, Medicaid and CHIP programs and their managed care plans, and plans on the federal Marketplace have had to send decisions within 72 hours for expedited requests and seven calendar days for standard ones, and to give a specific reason for any denial[3]. Those payers must also offer an electronic prior authorization interface starting January 1, 2027[3].
Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), 2024[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Expedited (urgent) request | 72 hours |
| Standard request (seven calendar days) | 168 hours |
Other commercial plans set their own timelines, and some states set limits for state-regulated plans. Put each major payer's standard turnaround on your cheat sheet. For Medicare Advantage the requirement is almost universal: 99% of enrollees are in plans that require prior authorization for some services[4].
What a complete request contains
- Patient and plan details exactly as on the eligibility response, including member ID and product.
- Ordering and rendering clinician names and NPIs, and the location where the service will be performed.
- Service codes, number of units or visits, and the planned date range.
- Diagnosis codes that match the clinical note.
- Clinical notes that address each point in the payer's published criteria.
- Results of earlier tests and treatments tried, with dates and outcomes.
- Whether the request is urgent, with the clinician's reason when it is.
Mark a request urgent only when the clinician judges that waiting the standard time could seriously harm the patient. Overusing urgent requests slows payers' urgent queues for everyone.
Handling a denial
- Read the stated reason. Missing information is often fixed by sending a document, not by appealing.
- Send the reason to the ordering clinician the same day with the payer's criteria attached.
- If the clinician disagrees with the decision, request a peer-to-peer review within the payer's window.
- If the denial stands, file an appeal with a letter from the clinician addressing each criterion.
- Tell the patient what happened and what the next step is, and log the outcome for your denial review.
Physicians report denials are common: 32% said requests are often or always denied, and 74% said denials had increased over the past five years[1]. Log each denial by payer and service so you can see which requests need fuller documentation up front.
Worked Example: an MRI order
Example: On Monday, a fictional orthopedic surgeon orders a knee MRI for a patient on a Medicare Advantage plan. The coordinator checks the plan's portal that afternoon, confirms authorization is required, and pulls the visit note, the X-ray report and a record of six weeks of physical therapy.
Example: The request goes in on Tuesday through the portal as a standard request. The scheduler books the MRI for the following Thursday, nine days later, outside the seven-day window, and tells the patient it depends on approval. The approval arrives on Friday; the coordinator records the number, code and date range, and the check-in team confirms it two days before the scan.
Talking to patients while they wait
Patients often blame the practice for the wait, and some give up: 79% of physicians said patients abandon treatment because of authorization problems[1]. A clear message at ordering and a call when the decision comes in keep patients on track.
Script at ordering: "Your plan needs to approve this before we can schedule it for certain. We will send the request in the next two days. Most answers come back within a week, and we will call you as soon as we hear. If you do not hear from us by next Friday, call this number and ask for the authorization desk."
Many practices are looking at automation for this work: 16% of practices using AI and automation to improve access named prior authorization as their focus in an MGMA poll[5]. Whatever tools you add, the owners and deadlines above are what they need to support.
Cover absences and handoffs
Authorization work stalls when one person is out. A process that lives in one coordinator's head fails the first week of their vacation. Make it visible and shareable.
- Keep every open request in one shared log or work queue, never in a personal inbox.
- Name a back-up who has logins for every payer portal and practices the routine at least monthly.
- Write a one-page guide for each of your top payers: where to check requirements, how to submit, and the turnaround to expect.
- At handoff, walk through every request due in the next five business days.
- After any absence, review denials and late decisions from that period to see whether the cover worked.
Measures to review monthly
- Days from order to submission, by payer.
- Days from submission to decision, compared with each payer's stated turnaround.
- Share of requests pended for missing information.
- Denials and appeal outcomes, by payer and service.
- Services cancelled or rescheduled because approval was missing or expired.
To keep approvals from lapsing between visits, set up an authorization tracking log. For the national picture on burden, see how much time prior authorization takes practices.
Frequently asked questions
Who should own prior authorization in a small practice?
Name one coordinator who owns the requirement check, submission, follow-up and recording, with a named back-up. Clinicians own the order and the clinical documentation, and schedulers own booking outside the decision window.
How long does prior authorization take?
It depends on the payer. Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and federal Marketplace plans must decide urgent requests within 72 hours and standard requests within seven calendar days; other commercial plans set their own timelines.
Should we schedule a service before authorization is approved?
You can book it for a date after the payer's decision deadline, as long as the patient knows the visit depends on approval and you confirm the approval two business days before.
What is a peer-to-peer review?
A call between the ordering clinician and a clinician reviewer at the health plan to discuss a denial or pending request. Request it within the payer's stated window, and give the clinician the denial reason and criteria beforehand.
References
American Medical Association (2026). AMA survey: Prior authorization reform pledge falls short with physicians (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Phones are still a bottleneck costing medical practices time they can't afford (opens in a new tab) โ
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). CMS Interoperability and Prior Authorization Final Rule (CMS-0057-F) fact sheet (opens in a new tab) โ
KFF (2026). Medicare Advantage in 2026: Premiums, Out-of-Pocket Limits, Supplemental Benefits, and Prior Authorization (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Automatic for the people: AI moves for medical practices to boost the front office and access (opens in a new tab) โ