Key takeaways
- Track every authorization in one log with the approved codes, units, date range, clinician and location, not just the authorization number.
- Use a fixed set of status values so anyone can see at a glance what is pending, approved, used up or expired.
- Set alerts for decision deadlines, expiry dates and remaining visits, and review the log every week.
- Log denials and appeals too; most denials are never appealed, yet most appeals succeed.
Why approvals lapse
An approval is not a yes that lasts forever. It covers specific service codes, a number of units or visits, a date range, and often a named clinician and location. When any of these changes, or the date range passes, the approval no longer covers the service, and the claim denies even though the practice did everything right at the start.
Volume makes this hard to manage by memory. Physicians report an average of 40 prior authorizations a week, and 32% say requests are often or always denied[1]. In Medicare Advantage, nearly all enrollees, 99%, are in plans that require authorization for some services[2]. A practice running hundreds of open approvals needs a log that tells staff what to do next, not a folder of faxes.
The tracking log
Keep one row per authorization request. If your practice management system has an authorization module, use it; if not, a shared spreadsheet with locked column headings works for most small practices.
| Column | What to enter |
|---|---|
| Patient and plan | Name, date of birth, plan and product, member ID |
| Service and codes | Service description and the exact codes requested and approved |
| Ordering and rendering clinician | Names and NPIs; note if the approval names a specific clinician |
| Location | Where the service will be performed |
| Dates | Ordered, submitted, decision due, decided |
| Reference and authorization numbers | Payer reference on submission; authorization number on approval |
| Approved units or visits | Number approved and number used so far |
| Valid from and to | Start and end date of the approval |
| Status | One value from the fixed list |
| Next action and owner | What happens next, who does it and by when |
The last column is what makes the log work. Every open row should have a next action and an owner. A row without one is a request nobody is watching.
Fill the log from the payer's approval letter or portal screen, not from memory or a phone note, and attach a copy of the approval to the patient's record.
Status values that keep the log honest
Free-text statuses such as "waiting" or "sent?" hide problems. Use a short fixed list and do not allow anything else.
- Not required: checked, with the source of the answer recorded.
- To submit: authorization needed, documentation being gathered.
- Submitted: sent to the payer, with a reference number and decision due date.
- Pended: the payer asked for more information; the request and due date are noted.
- Approved: authorization number, codes, units and dates recorded.
- Partly approved: fewer units or a different code approved; clinician informed.
- Denied: reason recorded and sent to the clinician.
- Appealed: appeal or peer-to-peer requested, with date.
- Used up or expired: no remaining units or past the end date; closed or renewed.
Alerts to set
- Decision due: for Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and CHIP, and federal Marketplace plans, set the due date at 72 hours for urgent and seven calendar days for standard requests, the maximum decision times those payers have had to meet since January 1, 2026[3]. For other payers, use their stated turnaround.
- Expiry approaching: fourteen days before the end date for any approval with remaining visits or a planned service.
- Visits running low: when two or fewer approved visits remain and more are scheduled.
- Schedule outside the approval: any appointment booked after the end date or beyond the approved number of visits.
- Code or location change: any time the clinician changes the planned code or the service moves to another site.
- New plan year or new plan: approvals often do not carry over when coverage changes.
The most common lapse is a schedule that runs past the approval. Link each recurring appointment series to its authorization so the scheduler sees the end date and visit count while booking.
Visit-count limits
Therapy, behavioral health, chiropractic and injection series are usually approved for a set number of visits. Count visits used at check-in, not at billing, so the number is current when the next visit is booked.
Example: A fictional patient is approved for 12 physical therapy visits between March 1 and May 31. After visit 10, the log shows two remaining and an alert fires. The coordinator asks the therapist for a progress note and submits a request for more visits, so a decision can arrive before visit 12 rather than after it.
Watch for approvals that count units rather than visits. An injection approval may cover a number of drug units across several visits, and a change in dose can use the approval faster than the schedule suggests. Record units approved and units used in separate columns.
Track denials and appeals too
A tracking log is also your denial record. Payer data shows why it matters: Medicare Advantage insurers denied 7.7% of prior authorization requests in 2024, only 11.5% of denials were appealed, and 80.7% of appeals were partly or fully overturned[4].
Source: KFF, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Requests denied | 7.7% |
| Denials appealed | 11.5% |
| Appeals partly or fully overturned | 80.7% |
Add a column for the denial reason and another for the outcome of any appeal. After a quarter, sort by payer and service: the patterns show where documentation needs strengthening before submission, and where appeals almost always succeed.
A weekly review routine
Filter past-due actions
Show every open row whose next action date has passed, and work these first.
Check decisions due this week
For each submitted or pended request due in the next five business days, confirm the status with the payer if there is no decision yet.
Review expiries and low visit counts
List approvals ending in the next fourteen days or with two or fewer visits left, and decide renew, close or reschedule.
Match the schedule to approvals
Compare next week's appointments needing authorization against the log, and flag any visit without a valid approval.
Close finished rows
Mark completed or expired approvals as closed so the open list stays short.
Note patterns
Record any payer or service that caused repeated problems this week for the monthly review.
In most practices this takes under an hour once the log is current. Put it on the calendar for the same time each week and name a back-up for holidays. Eligibility and prior authorization already top the list of time-consuming phone tasks for staff, at 45% in an MGMA poll[5], so the review should replace ad hoc chasing rather than add to it.
Worked Example: an injection series
Example: A fictional ophthalmology practice gives monthly injections to a patient whose approval covers six injections over six months. In month five, the plan changes the preferred drug for the new year. The weekly review flags the coming plan year for every patient on a series, and the coordinator checks each plan's new list in early December.
Example: For this patient, the new plan year requires a fresh request. It is submitted in mid-December and approved before the January injection, so the visit goes ahead as scheduled and the patient never hears there was a change.
Tell patients where their approval stands
The log also lets anyone answer a patient's status call in one look. Train staff to give the status, the next step and a date, and to avoid guessing what the payer will decide.
Script: "Your request went to your plan on Tuesday, and they have until next Tuesday to decide. We check every day. As soon as we hear, we will call you, and if your appointment needs to move, we will offer you the next available time."
When an approval is about to run out, tell the patient before the last approved visit, not after: "You have two visits left on this approval. We have asked your plan for more, and we will let you know before your next appointment."
Spreadsheet or system?
- A shared spreadsheet is enough when one or two people handle authorizations and open approvals number in the dozens.
- Move to a system module when several people share the work, when recurring series are common, or when you need alerts tied to the schedule.
- Whatever you use, protect it as patient information: role-based access, no copies on personal devices, and no patient details in email subject lines.
- Keep the same columns and status values if you switch, so history carries over.
For the steps before an approval reaches the log, see the prior authorization process. Referrals need the same tracking; see HMO referral authorizations.
Frequently asked questions
What should a prior authorization log include?
Patient and plan, service and approved codes, clinician and location, key dates, reference and authorization numbers, approved and used units, valid dates, status, and the next action with an owner.
How far ahead should we renew an authorization?
Start when about two weeks remain or when two or fewer approved visits are left, whichever comes first, so the payer's decision arrives before the approval runs out.
Does an authorization carry over to a new plan year?
Often not, especially when the patient changes plans or the plan changes its rules. Check each plan's requirements before January for every patient with an ongoing approval.
Who should own the tracking log?
One authorization coordinator, with a named back-up. Schedulers and check-in staff update visits used, and clinicians are told about denials and partial approvals.
References
American Medical Association (2026). AMA survey: Prior authorization reform pledge falls short with physicians (opens in a new tab) โ
KFF (2026). Medicare Advantage in 2026: Premiums, Out-of-Pocket Limits, Supplemental Benefits, and Prior Authorization (opens in a new tab) โ
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). CMS Interoperability and Prior Authorization Final Rule (CMS-0057-F) fact sheet (opens in a new tab) โ
KFF (2026). Medicare Advantage Insurers Made Nearly 53 Million Prior Authorization Determinations in 2024 (opens in a new tab) โ
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Phones are still a bottleneck costing medical practices time they can't afford (opens in a new tab) โ