Key takeaways
- An interest-free in-house payment plan is usually the safest option for patients; medical credit cards and loans move the balance off your books but can cost patients far more.
- The CFPB found the typical medical credit card APR was 26.99%, and deferred interest was charged on 20% of healthcare purchases made with these products.
- If a practice charges a finance charge or allows more than four installments, and does so regularly, federal Truth in Lending rules can apply.
- Check insurance and financial assistance first, never sign patients up for credit during care, and explain deferred interest in plain words.
Why financing questions are growing
Patients are carrying more of the bill. US out-of-pocket health spending grew 5.9% to $556.6 billion in 2024[1], and the average deductible for covered workers with single coverage and a general deductible reached $1,955 in 2026, rising to $2,624 at smaller firms[2]. Another 7.9% of people were uninsured for all of 2025[3]. A visit, a procedure or a set of tests can leave a patient with a balance they cannot pay at once.
Practices want to be paid, and patients want time. There are three main ways to bridge the gap: an in-house payment plan, a third-party medical credit card, or a third-party installment loan. Each has a different cost for the patient, a different risk for the practice, and different rules.
The options side by side
| Feature | In-house payment plan | Medical credit card | Third-party installment loan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who holds the debt | The practice | The card issuer | The lender |
| Cost to patient | Usually no interest or fees | Often a promotional period, then high interest; deferred interest may be charged back to the purchase date | Fixed interest rate, which varies with the patient's credit |
| When the practice is paid | As the patient pays | Soon after the charge, minus a merchant fee | Soon after approval, minus any fee |
| Risk of non-payment | Stays with the practice | Usually moves to the issuer | Depends on recourse terms in the contract |
| Admin work | Statements, reminders, tracking missed payments | Application at or before the visit; little afterwards | Application; little afterwards |
| Main patient risk | Low | Deferred interest and high APR after the promotion ends | Interest cost; credit report effects if payments are missed |
Many practices offer an in-house plan for smaller balances and mention a third-party option for larger ones. That can work, as long as the patient understands the difference and the practice is not steering them toward the costlier product.
What the CFPB found about medical credit cards
In 2023 the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau published a report on medical credit cards and financing plans. It found that the typical medical credit card carried an APR of 26.99%, compared with a mean of about 16% for general-purpose credit cards[4].
Source: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 2023[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Typical medical credit card | 26.99% |
| General-purpose cards (mean) | 16% |
Deferred interest is the feature that hurts most. With a deferred interest promotion, a patient who has any balance left when the promotional period ends is charged all the interest that would have accrued since the original purchase date[4]. The CFPB found that from 2015 to 2020, people incurred interest on 20% of their healthcare purchases made with deferred interest cards or loans, and on about 34% of purchases for people with credit scores below 619[4]. From 2018 to 2020, patients used these products for almost $23 billion in healthcare expenses and paid $1 billion in deferred interest[4].
20%
of healthcare purchases on deferred interest cards or loans were charged interest, 2015 to 2020[4]
The report also raised a concern that matters at the front desk: patients who should be eligible for reduced or free care through a financial assistance program or their insurance may instead be signed up for a medical card or loan[4]. Once a balance is on a card, disputing an incorrect bill becomes harder, because the patient is now dealing with a lender as well as the practice.
Running an in-house plan without becoming a lender
In-house plans are simple when they are interest-free and short. Under federal Truth in Lending rules, a creditor includes a person who regularly extends consumer credit that is subject to a finance charge or is payable by written agreement in more than four installments, not counting a down payment[5]. A person regularly extends credit if it did so more than 25 times in the preceding calendar year[5]. A practice that charges interest or fees on plans, or routinely sets up plans with five or more payments, may be taking on disclosure duties under those rules. State laws can add more. Have your attorney review the plan design before you roll it out.
- Write a one-page policy: minimum balance for a plan, maximum length, minimum monthly payment, what happens after a missed payment, and who can approve exceptions.
- Use a short written agreement for every plan that lists the balance, the schedule and the contact for questions. Give the patient a copy.
- Keep plans automatic where possible, with card-on-file or bank payments on a fixed date, and send a reminder a few days before each payment.
- Apply the policy the same way to everyone. Ad hoc deals create fairness complaints and make collections harder later.
- Review aging monthly. A plan that has missed two payments needs a call, not another statement.
Protecting patients when you offer third-party credit
Check coverage and assistance first
Before mentioning any credit product, confirm the balance is correct, insurance has processed, and the patient has been told about any discount or financial assistance you offer.
Offer the in-house plan first
If the balance fits your in-house rules, offer that option before any third-party product, and say clearly that it has no interest.
Explain deferred interest in plain words
Say: โIf any balance is left when the promotional period ends, the card can charge interest on the full original amount back to the first day.โ Give the patient the issuer's written terms.
Never apply on the patient's behalf
Patients complete applications themselves, on their own device or a private screen. Staff should not fill in applications, and no one should be signed up while sedated, in pain or mid-treatment.
Do not charge for care in advance without a clear reason
Charging a card for a full treatment plan before services are provided leaves the patient owing for care they may never receive. Charge for services when they are delivered, unless your policy and the patient's written agreement say otherwise.
Keep the practice out of the issuer's sales pitch
Use neutral language and written materials, and do not pay staff incentives for applications.
Example: two patients, two choices
Example (fictional). A dermatology practice has a policy: balances from $200 to $1,500 can go on an interest-free in-house plan of up to four monthly payments; larger balances can use a third-party installment loan. Patient A owes $900 after insurance for a procedure. The front desk lead confirms the claim processed correctly, mentions the practice's financial assistance policy (she does not qualify), and sets up a four-payment plan on her card on file. No interest, no lending paperwork.
In the same example, Patient B is planning a $4,000 cosmetic procedure not covered by insurance. The front desk lead explains the in-house limit, then hands him the written terms for the third-party loan the practice offers and points out the interest rate. She mentions that some patients use a medical credit card instead and explains how deferred interest works. He decides to pay half up front and finance the rest with the installment loan, which he applies for on his own phone.
In both cases the practice was paid, the patient knew the cost, and nobody was signed up for credit they did not understand.
Choosing what to offer
A small practice with mostly modest balances can often rely on an in-house plan alone. Practices with large elective services may add one third-party option to avoid carrying big balances. When you compare vendors, ask for the full fee schedule, the recourse terms (whether the practice must refund the lender if the patient stops paying), whether the product uses deferred interest, how disputes are handled, and what the vendor reports to credit bureaus. Choose products with simple, fixed terms over deferred interest where you can.
Put the choice in writing for staff. A short decision guide works well: if the balance is under your in-house limit, offer the plan; if it is above the limit, offer the plan for part of it, a deposit, or the third-party option; if the patient mentions hardship at any point, stop and route them to whoever handles financial assistance or discounts. Train every person who takes payments on the same guide, including evening and weekend staff, so a patient does not hear a different offer depending on who answers. Then review the results each quarter: how many plans were set up, how many finished on time, how many patients chose third-party credit, and whether any complaints mentioned financing. If complaints rise, look first at how staff are explaining the terms.
Whatever you choose, connect it to the conversations that come first: clear estimates (see answering cost questions), payment at the desk (see HSA and FSA payments), and a fair process for credit balances (see overpayments and refunds).
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to offer a payment plan or a medical credit card?
For most balances, an interest-free in-house plan is cheaper for patients and simpler to explain. Third-party products shift the risk of non-payment off the practice but can cost patients far more, especially with deferred interest.
Does an in-house payment plan make us a lender?
Possibly. Federal Truth in Lending rules can apply to anyone who regularly extends consumer credit with a finance charge or payable in more than four installments. Interest-free plans of four or fewer payments avoid that definition, but have an attorney check your design and your state's rules.
What is deferred interest?
It is a promotional term where no interest is charged if the balance is paid in full by the end of the promotion. If any balance remains, interest is charged on the original amount back to the purchase date.
References
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) โ
KFF (2026). 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey (opens in a new tab) โ
U.S. Census Bureau (2026). Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2025 (Current Population Reports P60-291) (opens in a new tab) โ
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2023). Medical Credit Cards and Financing Plans (opens in a new tab) โ
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 12 CFR ยง 1026.2 - Definitions and rules of construction (Regulation Z) (opens in a new tab) โ