Key takeaways
- Self-pay patients include the uninsured and insured patients who choose not to have a claim sent to their plan, and both groups are covered by federal good faith estimate rules.
- Pick one pricing method, such as a multiple of Medicare or cost plus margin, and apply it to your most common services first.
- Publish the notice that estimates are available, train staff to treat any cost question as an estimate request, and keep the price list current.
- A bill at least $400 above the estimate lets the patient start a federal dispute, so estimates must be realistic and complete.
Who pays cash, and why the number matters
Self-pay patients are not only the uninsured, although that group is large: 26.7 million people, 7.9% of the US population, had no coverage for the whole of 2025[1]. They also include insured patients with high deductibles who decide that a cash price is simpler than a claim. In 2026 the average deductible for workers with single coverage and a general deductible was $1,955, and workers at smaller firms averaged $2,624[2]. A patient facing a deductible that size may pay the full allowed amount anyway, so a clear cash price can be the better deal.
Source: KFF, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| All covered workers (single coverage) | $1,955 |
| Smaller firms | $2,624 |
| Larger firms | $1,772 |
Out-of-pocket spending in the US grew 5.9% to $556.6 billion in 2024[3]. Patients are paying more of their own money and asking more questions about price. Practices without a ready answer lose these patients to clinics that publish one.
The federal good faith estimate rules define an uninsured or self-pay individual to include someone who has coverage for the service but does not seek to have a claim submitted to that plan[4]. So an insured patient who chooses to pay cash triggers the same estimate duties as an uninsured patient.
Five ways to set a cash price
| Method | How it works | Strengths | Watch-outs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Multiple of Medicare | Set each price at a fixed multiple of your local Medicare rate for the code | Simple, defensible, updates each year | Medicare may not reflect your costs for some services |
| Cost plus margin | Estimate cost per visit or procedure, then add a target margin | Grounded in your actual costs | Needs a cost model; harder for rare services |
| Discount from charges | Apply a fixed percentage discount to your standard charges | Easy to administer | Standard charges are often arbitrary, so the result may still look high |
| Market-based | Match or beat published cash prices of nearby clinics | Competitive for price shoppers | Can drift below cost; competitors' prices change |
| Bundled packages | One price for a defined episode, such as a physical with standard labs | Easy for patients to compare and accept | Must define exactly what is included and what is not |
Most practices combine two methods: a multiple of Medicare or cost plus margin for the price list, and bundles for a handful of high-volume services that patients shop for, such as new-patient visits, annual physicals, sports physicals and common procedures. Whatever you choose, write down the method and the date. A documented, consistent method is easier to explain to patients, payers and auditors than a list of numbers with no history.
Check your contracts and payer rules first
- Read your commercial payer contracts for clauses about charging patients for covered services outside the plan or about your lowest offered rate. Some contracts limit cash arrangements with their members.
- For patients with Medicare, participating providers generally must submit claims for covered services. A cash price list is not a way around Medicare billing rules.
- If you participate in Medicaid, you generally must accept Medicaid's payment as payment in full for covered services, so cash prices apply only to patients not using Medicaid for that service.
- Avoid prompt-pay or hardship discounts that are applied inconsistently. Write the eligibility rules down and apply them the same way to everyone.
- When an insured patient pays in full out of pocket and asks you not to tell their health plan about that service, HIPAA requires you to agree to that restriction for payment and operations disclosures[5]. Make sure billing knows not to send the claim.
Build the price list in six steps
Pick the services
Start with the 25 to 50 codes that make up most of your visits, plus the services price shoppers ask about most. You can add rarer services later.
Calculate each price
Apply your chosen method to each code and round to whole dollars. Note any service where the result looks too low to cover cost and adjust it by exception, with the reason.
Define bundles
For each package, list what is included (visit level, specific labs, follow-up call) and what is not (additional tests, imaging, specialist referrals). Unclear bundles cause disputes.
Set the payment terms
State when payment is due, which methods you accept, and whether a payment plan is available. Keep terms the same for everyone in the same situation.
Load it everywhere staff look
Put prices in the practice management system and on a one-page sheet at every scheduling station, so the person on the phone can quote without hunting.
Approve and date it
Have the owner or administrator sign off, record the effective date, and schedule a review every year and whenever Medicare's fee schedule changes.
Good faith estimates: what the rules require
The No Surprises Act rules set specific duties when uninsured or self-pay patients schedule care or ask about cost. The practice must tell them that estimates are available, in writing and orally: a notice prominently displayed on the website and in the office, and spoken aloud when scheduling or when cost questions come up[4]. Any discussion or inquiry about potential costs must be treated as a request for an estimate[4].
- Timing: when a self-pay patient schedules at least three business days ahead, the estimate is due within one business day of scheduling, or within three business days if the service is ten or more business days away[4]. When a patient simply asks for an estimate, it is due within three business days of the request[4].
- Contents: patient name and date of birth, a plain description of the service, an itemized list with diagnosis and service codes and expected charges, the name, NPI and tax ID of each provider, required disclaimers, and information about the right to dispute[4].
- Records: the estimate becomes part of the patient's record, and the patient can ask for a copy of any estimate issued in the last six years[4].
- Disputes: if the final bill is at least $400 more than the total expected charges on the estimate, the patient can start the patient-provider dispute process, generally within 120 calendar days of receiving the bill[6].
Your self-pay price list makes estimates fast and consistent. The estimate should match the list, plus any services you reasonably expect for that patient, such as labs you routinely order for that visit type.
Example: a primary care price list
Example (fictional). A three-physician primary care practice decides to price at a fixed multiple of its local Medicare rates, with bundles for its five most-requested services. The administrator pulls the practice's 40 most common codes, applies the multiple, and rounds. Two procedure prices come out below the practice's supply and staff cost, so she raises them by exception and records why.
She creates a new-patient bundle that includes the visit and a standard lab panel, and a sports physical bundle that includes the form. Each bundle sheet lists exclusions in plain language. The website gets a short page that says self-pay prices are available on request and that patients who are uninsured or not using insurance have the right to a good faith estimate. Front desk staff get a 15-minute training on treating any cost question as an estimate request.
Three months later, the practice reviews the results: self-pay estimates are going out within the required time, and fewer self-pay balances have gone unpaid, because patients agreed to a known price before the visit.
Keeping prices current and talking about them
Prices that are years old lead to estimates that miss and bills that trigger disputes. Review the list every year, after Medicare's annual fee schedule changes, and whenever you add a service or a provider. Keep each old version with its dates so you can show what price applied on a given day.
Train staff to quote the price, the inclusions and the payment terms in the same order every time: “Our self-pay price for a new-patient visit with standard labs is $210. That includes the visit and the basic blood panel; any extra tests the doctor orders would be separate, and I'll send you a written estimate today.” The figure in that script is an example; use your own. For the phone conversation when patients have insurance, see answering cost questions on the phone, and for patients who need time to pay, see patient financing options.
Frequently asked questions
Do we have to give insured patients a good faith estimate?
If an insured patient chooses not to have a claim sent to their plan, they count as self-pay under the federal rules, and the estimate duties apply. For patients using their insurance, other rules and plan tools apply.
Can our cash price be lower than what insurers pay us?
Sometimes, but check each payer contract first. Some contracts restrict cash arrangements with their members or reference your lowest offered rate. Medicare and Medicaid have their own billing rules.
What happens if the bill is higher than the estimate?
If the bill is at least $400 more than the total expected charges on the estimate, the patient can start the federal patient-provider dispute process, generally within 120 calendar days of receiving the bill.
Should self-pay prices be posted on our website?
The rules require a prominently displayed notice that good faith estimates are available. Posting prices for common services as well makes it easier for patients to compare and reduces phone calls.
References
U.S. Census Bureau (2026). Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2025 (Current Population Reports P60-291) (opens in a new tab) ↑
KFF (2026). 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey (opens in a new tab) ↑
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 149.610 - Requirements for provision of good faith estimates of expected charges for uninsured (or self-pay) individuals (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 164.522 - Rights to request privacy protection for protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 45 CFR § 149.620 - Requirements for the patient-provider dispute resolution process (opens in a new tab) ↑