Insurance and Front-Desk Billing

Should Your Practice Accept Medicaid?

A decision framework for owners: Medicaid reach, payment against Medicare, admin load, partial-participation options and front desk scripts.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing7 min read

On this page
  1. What you are really deciding
  2. How often physicians say yes
  3. Payment: the number most owners start with
  4. The factors to weigh
  5. Options between yes and no
  6. How to make the decision
  7. If you say yes: running a Medicaid panel well
  8. What the front desk says
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References
Insurance and Front-Desk Billing: Should Your Practice Accept Medicaid?Article coverINSURANCE AND FRONT-DESK BILLINGShould Your PracticeAccept Medicaid?Ava Medical IntakeInsightsInsurance and Front-Desk Billing: Should Your Practice Accept Medicaid?Article coverINSURANCE AND FRONT-DESK BILLINGShould Your PracticeAccept Medicaid?Ava Medical Intake

Key takeaways

  • Medicaid covered 17.1% of people in 2025, so the decision shapes who in your community can see you.
  • Physicians accept new Medicaid patients less often than new Medicare or private patients, mostly because of payment and paperwork.
  • Nationally, Medicaid fees averaged 75% of Medicare's in 2024, and 66% for primary care, with wide variation by state.
  • The choice is rarely all or nothing: practices can limit plans, services or new-patient volume, but they must apply the rule consistently and tell patients clearly.

What you are really deciding

Whether to participate in Medicaid is a decision about mission, money and workload at the same time. Medicaid covered 17.1% of people in the US in 2025[1], and Medicaid spending reached $931.7 billion in 2024, 18% of national health expenditure[2]. In many communities, especially for children, pregnant patients and low-income adults, a practice that does not take Medicaid is unavailable to a large share of the neighborhood.

At the same time, Medicaid usually pays less than other payers, and the administrative work of enrolling with managed care plans, keeping up with eligibility changes and meeting prior authorization rules is real. Owners who decide well tend to look at their own numbers rather than national averages, and they consider partial participation as well as a yes or a no.

17.1%

of people in the US were covered by Medicaid in 2025[1]

How often physicians say yes

MACPAC's analysis of the National Electronic Health Records Survey found that in 2017, physicians were significantly less likely to accept new patients with Medicaid (74.3%) than new patients with Medicare (87.8%) or private insurance (96.1%)[3]. Acceptance varied widely by specialty and by state.

Physicians accepting new patients, by type of coverage, 2017
Physicians accepting new patients, by type of coverage, 2017Comparison. Private insurance: 96.1%; Medicare: 87.8%; Medicaid: 74.3%.96.1%Private insurancePrivate insurance: 96.1%87.8%MedicareMedicare: 87.8%74.3%MedicaidMedicaid: 74.3%Physicians accepting new patients, by type of coverage, 2017Comparison. Private insurance: 96.1%; Medicare: 87.8%; Medicaid: 74.3%.96.1%Private insurancePrivate insurance: 96.1%87.8%MedicareMedicare: 87.8%74.3%MedicaidMedicaid: 74.3%

Source: Medicaid and CHIP Payment and Access Commission (MACPAC), 2021[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Private insurance96.1%
Medicare87.8%
Medicaid74.3%

Secret-shopper studies show what that means for patients trying to book. A meta-analysis of 34 audit studies found that Medicaid coverage was associated with a 1.6-fold lower likelihood of successfully scheduling a primary care appointment, and a 3.3-fold lower likelihood for specialty care, compared with private insurance[4]. If your practice does accept Medicaid, being easy to book is itself a way to stand out.

Payment: the number most owners start with

KFF's Medicaid-to-Medicare fee index compares what fee-for-service Medicaid pays with what Medicare pays for the same services. For the US as a whole in 2024, the index was 0.75 for all services, 0.66 for primary care and 0.88 for obstetric care[5]. In other words, Medicaid paid about three quarters of the Medicare rate overall and about two thirds for primary care, and state results range far above and below those averages.

Two cautions apply. First, most Medicaid enrollees are in managed care plans in many states, and those plans negotiate their own rates, so the state fee schedule is only a starting point. Second, Medicare itself is not a generous benchmark: adjusted for inflation in practice costs, Medicare physician payments fell 33% from 2001 to 2026[6]. A Medicaid rate at 75% of Medicare is 75% of a number that has been shrinking in real terms.

Example (fictional). A family practice estimates that a typical established-patient visit costs it about $95 to deliver. Its average commercial payment for that visit is $140, and Medicare pays $110 locally. If its state's Medicaid managed care plans pay roughly two thirds of Medicare for primary care, the visit brings in about $73, so each Medicaid visit runs at a loss before counting any extra admin time. The practice then looks at whether vaccine programs, care management fees, value-based payments or a state primary care rate increase change that picture before deciding.

The factors to weigh

Factors owners commonly weigh before deciding on Medicaid participation
FactorQuestions to answerWhere to find it
Community needWhat share of local patients, especially children and pregnant patients, have Medicaid? Who else nearby accepts it?State Medicaid enrollment reports, hospital community health needs assessments
PaymentWhat do the managed care plans in your area pay for your top 20 codes, compared with your cost per visit?Plan fee schedules, your billing system, a cost-per-visit estimate
Admin loadHow many plans would you enroll with? What are their prior authorization and referral rules?Plan provider manuals, colleagues already contracted
Eligibility churnHow often will patients' Medicaid plans change, and who will re-verify?Your own eligibility run results after a pilot
Schedule capacityDo you have open new-patient slots, or would Medicaid patients displace others?Third-next-available appointment, new-patient wait times
Other revenueAre there programs that apply only to Medicaid patients, such as vaccine supply, care management or quality bonuses?State Medicaid agency, plan incentive programs
Mission and reputationWhat do your physicians and community expect from the practice?Partner discussion, patient feedback

Avoid deciding from a single month of data. Model a year, include the cost of credentialing with each managed care plan, and talk to a practice of similar size in your state that already participates.

Options between yes and no

Many practices choose a middle path. Each option has trade-offs, and every one depends on what your state rules and plan contracts allow, so confirm with the plans and your health care attorney before you announce a policy.

  • Contract with some Medicaid managed care plans and not others, based on payment and administrative burden.
  • Keep established patients who move onto Medicaid, but close to new Medicaid patients while capacity is tight.
  • Accept Medicaid for some services or providers, such as pediatrics or obstetrics, where community need is highest.
  • Set a schedule cap, such as a fixed number of new Medicaid slots per week, and publish the waiting list process.
  • Partner with a nearby community health center for referrals in both directions.

Whatever you choose, apply it consistently and document it. A rule that the front desk applies differently depending on who calls is a compliance and reputation problem.

Once you participate, Medicaid rules generally require you to accept the program's payment as payment in full for covered services, apart from any allowed cost sharing. That means no balance billing, so staff need to know which services are covered before quoting anything to the patient.

How to make the decision

  1. Pull your numbers

    List your 20 most-billed codes, your cost per visit, and what each local Medicaid plan pays for those codes.

  2. Estimate demand

    Count calls in the last three months from patients with Medicaid you turned away. Your phone log or scheduling notes are often the only record.

  3. Price the admin work

    Estimate staff hours for credentialing, eligibility checks, prior authorizations and plan changes, using a practice already in the program as a reference.

  4. Choose a model

    Pick full participation, a limited model from the list above, or non-participation, and write the rule in one sentence staff can repeat.

  5. Pilot and review

    If you start, review after six months: visit volume, denial rates, days in accounts receivable by plan, and staff time.

If you say yes: running a Medicaid panel well

Practices that participate and stay satisfied with the decision tend to treat Medicaid as its own workflow rather than one more payer in the list. The work is front-loaded: once the plans, rules and checks are set up, the day-to-day load drops sharply.

  • Keep a one-page sheet per managed care plan with the plan name as printed on cards, the eligibility portal, referral and prior authorization rules, the claims address and the provider services number. Update it when the plan sends a bulletin.
  • Verify the plan, not just the program, before every visit. Enrollees can switch or be reassigned between managed care plans, and a claim sent to last month's plan is denied.
  • Watch renewal dates. Medicaid eligibility is renewed periodically, and patients who miss a renewal letter may lose coverage without realizing it. A reminder at the visit to open mail from the state agency saves denials later.
  • Track no-shows separately for Medicaid patients and look for causes the practice can fix, such as transportation. Many Medicaid plans offer a non-emergency transportation benefit, and telling patients how to book it is a small step with a direct effect on attendance.
  • Review days in accounts receivable and denial rates by plan every quarter. If one plan is consistently slow or denies more, raise it with the plan's provider representative, and reconsider the contract at renewal.
  • Keep the schedule rule visible. If you cap new Medicaid slots, show the remaining slots in the scheduling system so staff are not guessing.

Finally, revisit the decision every year. State rates, plan contracts, your own capacity and the needs of your community all change, and a policy written three years ago may no longer fit.

What the front desk says

If you accept Medicaid: β€œYes, we see patients with Medicaid. Which plan are you in? The name is on the front of your card.” Then verify the specific managed care plan, because accepting one plan does not mean accepting all of them.

If you accept some plans: β€œWe're in network with two of the Medicaid plans in our area. Can you tell me which plan is on your card? If it isn't one of ours, I can give you the plan's member services number so they can find a doctor for you.”

If you do not participate: β€œWe aren't able to see patients with Medicaid at this time. Your plan's member services line can tell you which practices nearby are taking new patients, and that number is on the back of your card.” Keep a short list of local clinics that accept Medicaid so callers leave with a next step. For the way coverage order works when a patient has Medicaid and another plan, see coordination of benefits.

Frequently asked questions

Can a practice limit how many Medicaid patients it accepts?

Often yes, depending on state rules and plan contracts. Common approaches are contracting with only some plans, keeping established patients only, or capping new Medicaid slots. Check your contracts and apply the rule consistently.

How much does Medicaid pay compared with Medicare?

KFF's fee index put Medicaid at 75% of Medicare for all services and 66% for primary care nationally in 2024, but state rates and managed care plan rates vary widely.

Can we charge Medicaid patients the difference between our fee and Medicaid's payment?

Generally no. Participating providers must accept Medicaid payment as payment in full for covered services, apart from allowed cost sharing.

Does accepting Medicaid mean accepting every Medicaid plan?

No. In states with managed care, each plan contracts separately. Staff should verify the specific plan on the card, not just that the patient has Medicaid.

References

  1. U.S. Census Bureau (2026). Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2025 (Current Population Reports P60-291) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) (2024). NHE Fact Sheet (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Medicaid and CHIP Payment and Access Commission (MACPAC) (2021). Physician Acceptance of New Medicaid Patients: Findings from the National Electronic Health Records Survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Inquiry: The Journal of Health Care Organization, Provision, and Financing (via PubMed Central) (2019). Medicaid Patients Have Greater Difficulty Scheduling Health Care Appointments Compared With Private Insurance Patients: A Meta-Analysis (Inquiry, 2019) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. KFF (2024). Medicaid-to-Medicare Fee Index (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. American Medical Association (2026). June 18, 2026: National Advocacy Update (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo