Key takeaways
- Most practices saw portal message volume rise, and inbox work already takes a large share of physicians' EHR time.
- Route each message type to a named pool before it reaches a clinician; many messages are non-clinical and can be closed by the front office.
- Publish a reply-time standard and an emergency warning in every auto-reply and on the message screen.
- Track volume per 100 active patients, same-day closure and how many messages bounce between pools.
Why the inbox keeps growing
Portal messaging is now part of everyday care. When MGMA polled medical groups about 2024, 70% reported an increase in patient portal message volume, 29% said it was about the same and only 1% reported a decrease[1]. As more patients use portals, and 65% of US individuals were offered and accessed their online record or portal in 2024[2], volume is unlikely to fall on its own.
- Increased 70%
- About the same 29%
- Decreased 1%
Source: Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), 2024[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Increased | 70% |
| About the same | 29% |
| Decreased | 1% |
The cost lands on clinical time. A study of primary care physicians found inbox management took 85 minutes a day, 23.7% of their total EHR time, with clerical and administrative tasks taking nearly half[3]. Much of what arrives in a clinician's inbox does not need a clinician: appointment changes, form requests, billing questions, refill status checks. Fixing the route is the front office's biggest contribution.
Route by message type, not by provider
In many practices every message goes to the patient's provider, who forwards most of it to someone else. Reverse that. Sort messages by type at the start, either with the portal's category picker or by a front office team member who reads the first line, and send each type to a pool with a named owner.
| Message type | Pool and owner | Target response | Can the front office close it? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appointment request, change or cancel | Scheduling pool; scheduling lead | Same business day | Yes |
| Forms, letters, school or work notes | Forms pool; medical records lead | Acknowledge same day; complete within your published time | Yes, if no clinical judgment is needed |
| Billing and insurance | Billing pool; billing lead | 1 business day | Yes |
| Refill request | Refill pool; nurse or medical assistant per protocol | Within your published refill time | Status questions yes; approvals no |
| Test result question | Clinical pool for the care team | Same or next business day | No |
| New or worsening symptoms | Clinical pool, flagged for triage | Same day; urgent ones immediately | No: route at once |
| Records and privacy requests | Records or privacy lead | Acknowledge same day | Yes, under your access policy |
Write the routing table into the portal settings where possible, and into the front office manual where not. Review it monthly using the misrouted-message count described below.
Set expectations with patients
Much message volume is follow-up: patients writing again because they do not know whether the first message was seen. A clear expectation cuts that. Put a short notice on the message screen and in every auto-reply.
Sample auto-reply: Thank you for your message. Our team reads messages during office hours, Monday to Friday, and replies within one business day. Please do not use messages for urgent problems. If you have a medical emergency, call 911. For urgent questions during office hours, call us at [number]. After hours, call [number] to reach the on-call clinician.
- State office hours for messages and the reply time you can actually keep.
- List what not to send by message: new chest pain, trouble breathing, thoughts of self-harm, anything urgent.
- Say whether some messages may become a visit or an e-visit, and that some may be billed under the patient's plan, so nobody is surprised.
- Explain how to request refills and forms through the dedicated forms rather than free-text messages.
A daily inbox routine for the front office
First hour: sweep and sort
One person reads the first line of every new message, corrects the category, and flags any symptom or urgent wording to the clinical pool immediately.
Close what you can
Scheduling, billing and form-status messages are answered by the front office the same day, using saved replies adapted to each patient.
Convert when needed
If a message really needs a visit, reply with an offer of times rather than a long explanation: “Dr. Lewis would like to see you about this. I can offer Wednesday at 10:15 or Thursday at 3:40.”
Midday check
Re-check the clinical pool for messages waiting more than four hours and nudge the owner.
End of day
Confirm every non-clinical message has a reply. Note anything carried over, with a reason, for the next morning's sweep.
Saved replies that save time without sounding robotic
Saved replies cut typing, but a reply that ignores what the patient wrote creates a second message. Keep each saved reply short, leave a slot for one personal sentence, and sign with a name.
- Appointment change: “Hi [name], thanks for letting us know. I've moved your visit to [day, time]. You'll get a reminder the day before.”
- Form request received: “Hi [name], we've received your request for [form]. It will be ready by [date], and we'll message you when it's in the portal.”
- Refill status: “Hi [name], your refill request was sent to [pharmacy] on [date]. If they don't have it by tomorrow afternoon, please let us know.”
- Message that needs a call: “Hi [name], this is easier to sort out by phone. When is a good time today to call you at the number on file?”
Some practices also use software to draft replies. In an AMA survey, 19% of physicians said they use health AI to generate draft responses to patient portal messages[4]. If you try this, keep a person reviewing every draft before it is sent, and write a policy first: only 20% of medical groups told MGMA they have AI governance or a formal AI-use policy[5].
Metrics to watch
| Metric | Definition | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Messages per 100 active portal users | Monthly messages ÷ active users × 100 | Shows true growth, separate from portal adoption |
| Same-day closure, non-clinical | Non-clinical messages answered the day received ÷ all non-clinical | Front office responsiveness |
| Clinical pool wait | Median hours from arrival to first clinical reply | Patient safety and clinician load |
| Misrouted rate | Messages moved between pools ÷ all messages | Whether categories and sorting work |
| Repeat-message rate | Patients sending a second message on the same issue within 48 hours | Whether expectations are clear |
Help patients write messages that can be answered once
A vague message such as “Call me about my meds” forces a reply asking what the patient means, which doubles the work. Put three prompts above the message box: what is the question, which medication or appointment it is about, and the best time to reach you. Some portals let you add these as fields; if yours does not, add them as placeholder text.
Give patients specific forms for the commonest requests, such as refills, appointment changes and form requests, so those never arrive as free text. Mention the forms in your after-visit summary and in the portal welcome message. Each request that arrives in a structured form can be routed automatically and answered with a saved reply.
Staff the inbox like a phone queue
Messages are a queue, just slower than calls. Count them by hour and day for a month and you will usually see peaks on Monday mornings and after results are released. Staff the sweep for those peaks, and give the inbox a named owner on every shift so nobody assumes someone else is watching it.
- Protect inbox time on the schedule; messages answered in gaps between calls are the ones that get forgotten.
- Cross-train at least two people per pool so leave and sickness do not stall a queue.
- Release batches of results when staff are available to handle the follow-up questions, not at 4:55 on a Friday.
When volume is a symptom
A sudden rise in one message type usually points to a broken process elsewhere. A surge of refill-status messages may mean the pharmacy interface failed; a run of billing questions may follow a confusing statement. Read a sample of each month's fastest-growing category and fix the cause, not just the reply time.
Example: taking pressure off one provider
Example. A fictional family physician receives most of the practice's messages because her patients are the heaviest portal users. An audit of one week finds that a large share are scheduling, forms or billing questions. The practice turns on category routing, adds a front office sweep at 8:30 and 1:00, and puts the auto-reply above on the message screen.
Within a month, fewer non-clinical messages reach her inbox, repeat messages drop because patients know when to expect a reply, and the clinical pool's median wait falls. The practice keeps the audit as a quarterly habit, because message patterns shift with seasons, new services and staffing.
Keep the phone and the portal in step
Patients often send a message and then call to check on it. Give phone staff a view of the portal inbox so they can say “I can see your message; the nurse has it and will reply by 3 p.m.” instead of starting over. For deciding which requests belong in which channel, see portal, phone or text, and for growing portal use without overloading the inbox, see getting patients to use the portal.
Frequently asked questions
How fast should a practice reply to patient portal messages?
Set a standard you can keep, commonly within one business day for non-urgent messages, and publish it on the message screen and in the auto-reply. Urgent wording should be flagged for same-day clinical review.
Who should answer portal messages?
Route by type: the front office closes scheduling, forms and billing messages; nurses or medical assistants handle refills under protocol; clinicians answer results and symptom questions.
Can practices bill for portal messages?
Some portal exchanges that meet the requirements for online digital evaluation and management services can be billed. Check payer rules and tell patients in advance that some messages may be billed.
References
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2024). Ensuring accurate coding and billing for patient portal messages as e-visits (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ASTP/ONC), HHS (2024). Individuals' Access and Use of Patient Portals and Smartphone Health Apps, 2024 (Data Brief No. 77) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Annals of Family Medicine (2017). Tethered to the EHR: Primary Care Physician Workload Assessment Using EHR Event Log Data and Time-Motion Observations (Annals of Family Medicine, 2017) (opens in a new tab) ↑
American Medical Association (2026). More than 80% of physicians use AI professionally: AMA survey (opens in a new tab) ↑
Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). AI governance in medical group practices: Rules for the humans in the loop (opens in a new tab) ↑