Call Coverage and Answering Services

Answering Service vs Voicemail for a Medical Office

What voicemail loses on urgent calls and new-patient bookings, when it is still acceptable, and a two-week test to decide for your own line.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. What a voicemail box can and cannot do
  2. Urgent callers: a greeting can only point
  3. New patients rarely leave a message
  4. Every message becomes a callback
  5. When voicemail is still acceptable
  6. If you keep voicemail, keep it to a standard
  7. What an answering line adds
  8. Put a number on the new-patient calls
  9. A two-week test before you decide
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
Call Coverage and Answering Services: Answering Service vs Voicemail for a Medical Office56.3%: of US emergency department visits in 2022 arrived outside weekday business hoursCALL COVERAGE AND ANSWERING SERVICESAnswering Service vsVoicemail for a MedicalOffice56.3%of US emergency department visits in 2022 arrivedoutside weekday business hoursAva Medical IntakeInsightsCall Coverage and Answering Services: Answering Service vs Voicemail for a Medical Office56.3%: of US emergency department visits in 2022 arrived outside weekday business hoursCALL COVERAGE AND ANSWERING SERVICESAnswering Service vsVoicemail for aMedical Office56.3%of US emergency department visits in2022 arrived outside weekday businesshoursAva Medical Intake
Figure source: CDC National Center for Health Statistics, 2022[1]

Key takeaways

  • Voicemail records whoever chooses to talk. It cannot judge urgency, answer a simple question or keep a prospective patient from calling the next practice.
  • Every message turns into a callback, and eight in ten adults say they generally don't answer calls from unknown numbers[2].
  • Voicemail can still work for short gaps in low-volume practices if the greeting gives 911, 988 and an on-call route and the box is cleared on a schedule.
  • Before deciding, measure two weeks of calls: calls received, messages left, callbacks that reached the patient.

What a voicemail box can and cannot do

Voicemail does one job well: it records whoever decides to speak after the tone. Everything else a ringing phone needs, judging whether the call can wait, answering a simple question, getting a new patient onto the schedule, is postponed until someone plays the messages back. For a practice that closes at 5 pm and reopens at 8 am, that is fifteen hours of postponement every weeknight, plus the weekend.

Care needs do not keep office hours. More than half of US emergency department visits in 2022, 56.3%, arrived outside Monday to Friday, 8 am to 5 pm[1]. Not every one of those patients tried a practice first, but every practice's after-hours line hears from some of them, and from many more people with questions that would never need an emergency room. And for a large share of patients the phone is still the real front door, portals and automated reminders notwithstanding[3].

When US emergency department visits arriveShare of 2022 visits by arrival time. Business hours = Monday to Friday, 8 am to 5 pm.
When US emergency department visits arriveDonut chart. Outside business hours: 56.3%; Weekday business hours: 43.7%.Outside business hours: 56.3%Weekday business hours: 43.7%2022
  • Outside business hours 56.3%
  • Weekday business hours 43.7%

Source: CDC National Center for Health Statistics, 2022[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Outside business hours56.3%
Weekday business hours43.7%

The comparison below looks at three kinds of callers voicemail serves poorly, the situations where it is still a fair choice, and a two-week test that settles the question for your own line instead of in general.

Urgent callers: a greeting can only point

A good greeting does real work. It tells anyone with an emergency to hang up and call 911, gives the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, which takes calls, texts and chats around the clock[4], and gives a way to reach the on-call clinician. That covers the clearest cases. What a recording cannot do is notice that the caller who says “my dad seems a bit confused tonight” needs the on-call physician now rather than a callback tomorrow.

With voicemail, callers judge their own urgency, and they do it at the moment the recording plays. Some will head to the emergency room because the greeting offered nothing in between. Some will leave a message about something that should not wait until morning. Many will simply go elsewhere: in 2024, 27.6% of people in the US visited an urgent care center at least once[5], and among adults aged 18 to 34, 12.2% name an urgent care center or retail clinic as their usual source of care[6]. A caller who hears only a beep has plenty of other doors.

Order of an after-hours recording: emergency instruction first, crisis line second, on-call route third, office hours and callback times last. Callers who need the first three should never sit through the fourth. Wording for each piece is in after-hours voicemail greetings for a doctor's office.

New patients rarely leave a message

An established patient will usually leave a message, because they already have a relationship with the practice and expect a call back. Someone choosing a new doctor has no such reason. They are often working down a list, and a recording is the cue to dial the next number on it. New patients accounted for 16.8% of physician office visits in 2019, about 173.9 million visits[7]: a modest share of calls, but most of a practice's growth.

Patience on the phone runs short even for callers who intend to book. In an audit of Texas primary care offices, researchers posing as new patients hung up whenever hold reached five minutes, and 42 of their 1,081 calls ended that way[8]. Voicemail asks more of a caller than a hold queue does. It asks them to wait until tomorrow and to trust that someone will ring back.

You can put a figure on that loss with the calculator further down. What missed calls cost a medical practice covers the daytime version of the same problem, when calls roll to voicemail because everyone at the desk is busy.

Every message becomes a callback

Voicemail does not remove work. It moves it to the next morning and turns it into outbound calls, which is where many messages quietly die. Eight in ten US adults say they generally don't answer their cellphone when an unknown number calls; only 19% say they generally do[2]. Pew found younger adults, Hispanic and Black adults and lower-income households more likely than others to pick up[2], but for most patients a call from an unfamiliar number rings out.

  • Call back from the main practice number the patient dialed, never from a staff mobile or an unlisted line.
  • Say in the greeting when callbacks happen, for example “between 9 and 11 tomorrow morning”, so patients expect the call and keep the phone close.
  • Leave a short, privacy-safe message with the main number and the hours someone will answer; what you can say in a voicemail to a patient covers the limits.
  • Log every attempt, so the second try goes out on schedule instead of when someone remembers.

Even with all four habits in place, a voicemail-first line produces a morning queue of callbacks that competes with the 8 am rush for the same people. Clearing the voicemail queue daily keeps the queue honest. It does not make it shorter.

When voicemail is still acceptable

Voicemail is not always the wrong answer. It is a fair trade when three things hold: few calls arrive in the gap, the callers who do arrive have a clear route for anything urgent, and the box is cleared fast enough that nobody waits long.

A rule of thumb, not a standard. Malpractice carriers and payer contracts may set their own after-hours access requirements.
SituationVoicemail acceptable?Conditions
Lunch hour in a low-volume practiceOftenGreeting says when the line reopens; box checked the moment staff return; urgent route still given
Solo physician who carries the on-call phoneSometimesGreeting gives the on-call number directly, and the physician accepts the calls that brings
Specialty with few clinical after-hours issuesSometimesPost-procedure patients get a live number; the box is cleared first thing every morning
Primary care, pediatrics, OB-GYN or surgery after hoursRarelyClinical calls are frequent enough that callers expect a person or a clinician
Overflow while the office is openNoCallers expect a person during clinic hours, and voicemail at 10 am loses bookings

If your practice sits in the last two rows, the question is not whether to answer after hours but who answers, which answering service vs in-house after-hours coverage works through option by option.

If you keep voicemail, keep it to a standard

Voicemail costs nothing on the invoice, which is why it survives long after a practice has outgrown it. Its costs show up elsewhere: in callbacks, in new patients who never left a name, and in the occasional message that should have reached a clinician hours earlier. If the numbers say voicemail is still right for some of your hours, hold it to the same discipline you would demand from a paid service.

  • A mailbox that cannot fill up. Check capacity and maximum message length; a full box at 9 pm on a Saturday is the worst version of voicemail there is.
  • A named owner for each check. Who listens at 8 am, at lunch and before close, and who covers when that person is off.
  • A weekly test call from an outside phone, after hours, to hear exactly what patients hear, especially after a holiday schedule change.
  • A log for every message: time received, time returned, outcome.
  • An on-call number that a person answers, tested every month. A greeting that sends callers to another voicemail box is not an on-call route.
  • Holiday greetings recorded in advance and taken down on the first working day afterwards.

A practice that cannot keep all six going is usually a practice whose phones have already outgrown voicemail.

What an answering line adds

The same five callers, two ways
VoicemailAnswering line
Caller with an emergencyHears 911 in the greeting, if they listenHears 911 the moment they describe it
Question about hours or insuranceLeaves a message and waits for a callbackAnswered on the call
Prospective new patientOften hangs up and calls elsewhereGets answers and a clear next step
Patient who needs the on-call doctorMust redial the number in the greetingPut through to the on-call line
Next morningCallbacks to people who may not answerCalls already closed or sorted

An answering line can be a staffed service or an automated one; what matters is that a call meets a response, not a beep.

A staffed answering service and an SI Employee both fill the right-hand column, in different ways. Operators at a service take messages and page by your rules, and can work under a business associate agreement. An SI Employee answers on a forwarded line: it gives office and new-patient answers from information you approve, reads your 911 wording when a caller describes an emergency, and puts patient-specific calls through to the number you choose, such as the on-call line, without taking health details. If nobody picks up that transfer, the caller is told so plainly and an urgent message is saved. Recordings, transcripts and summaries are waiting in the morning (how it works).

Example: a 7:40 pm call to a forwarded line
  • Caller
  • System
  • SI Employee
  1. 01Caller

    Patient calls the office

    The office closed at 5 pm; forwarding is switched on for the night.

  2. 02System

    Line forwards

    The practice's phone system sends the call on, as configured.

  3. 03SI Employee

    Greeting and 911 line

    Names the practice, gives the recording notice and the emergency instruction.

  4. 04SI Employee

    Answers Saturday hours

    Reads the approved hours and the Saturday clinic address.

  5. 05Caller

    Caller mentions a fever

    No symptom questions; offers the on-call clinician.

  6. 06SI Employee

    Transfers to on-call

    Puts the call through to the on-call number the practice approved.

  7. 07System

    Summary by morning

    Summary emailed to the office; recording and transcript kept in the account.

Example. The practice approves the greeting, the answers and the transfer number before any real call is forwarded.

Put a number on the new-patient calls

The calculator estimates new-patient value that reaches voicemail each month. It leaves out urgent calls, which are a safety question rather than a revenue one, and the staff hours spent on callbacks, which come on top.

ExampleExample: new-patient value reaching voicemail after hours
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Calls a week that reach voicemail35
Share from prospective new patients16.8%
Share who would book if answered40%
Revenue from a new patient's first visits$180
After-hours calls a month152
From new customers25
Bookings if answered10
Monthly after-hours value$1,833

How it is worked out: After-hours calls a week × 4.33 weeks × new-customer share × booking rate × average value.

Assumptions

  • New patients made up 16.8% of US physician office visits in 2019; your share of calls may be higher or lower than your share of visits.[7]
  • The 35 calls, the 40% booking share and the $180 value are invented for this example; use your call log and your own first-visit revenue.

Example. Swap in your own numbers; the point is the order of magnitude, not the exact figure.

A two-week test before you decide

  1. Count the calls

    Pull every call that arrived outside office hours or rolled to voicemail for two weeks, from the phone system's call log, not from the mailbox.

  2. Count the messages

    Compare calls with messages left. The difference is the callers who hung up at the beep.

  3. Sort the messages

    Tag each one: urgent, new patient, appointment, refill, billing, office question or other.

  4. Track the callbacks

    Record how many reached the patient on the first attempt and how long each took to close.

  5. Decide on the numbers

    If most callers leave no message, new-patient calls turn up every week, or any urgent message sat until morning, voicemail is costing more than it saves.

The orthopedic after-hours example shows the kind of thing the test turns up. In that modelled practice about three in ten after-hours calls were office questions that waited for a nurse the next morning, and physician callbacks from an unfamiliar mobile number rang out. For small practices weighing the next step, is an answering service worth it takes the decision further, and handling after-hours calls covers the written policy behind whichever option you pick.

Frequently asked questions

Is voicemail enough for a doctor's office after hours?

For some low-volume specialties with few clinical after-hours issues, it can be, provided the greeting gives 911, the 988 crisis line and an on-call route and the box is cleared first thing. For primary care, pediatrics, OB-GYN and surgical practices, clinical calls are frequent enough that a live route is the norm.

What should an after-hours voicemail greeting say first?

The emergency instruction: if this is a medical emergency, hang up and dial 911. Then the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline[4], then how to reach the on-call clinician, then office hours and when messages will be returned.

Why do so many callers hang up without leaving a message?

Prospective patients usually have other options and call the next practice on their list; established patients often hang up and try again in the morning. Compare total after-hours calls in your phone log with messages left to see your own rate.

Do patients answer when the office calls them back?

Often not. Eight in ten adults say they generally don't answer calls from unknown numbers[2]. Call back from the main practice number, at a time the greeting promised, and leave a short message with that number.

How fast should after-hours messages be returned?

Set a window in the greeting and keep it, typically within the first two hours of the morning, with anything urgent handled the same night through the on-call route rather than the mailbox.

References

  1. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2022). National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2022 Emergency Department Summary Tables (Table 3) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Medical Group Management Association (MGMA) (2026). Phones are still a bottleneck costing medical practices time they can't afford (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) (2026). 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2024). Urgent Care Center and Retail Health Clinic Use: United States, 2024 (NCHS Data Brief No. 562) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2024). Source of Usual Health Care for Adults Age 18 and Older: United States, 2024 (NCHS Data Brief No. 558) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2019). National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2019 National Summary Tables (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. JAMA Network Open (via PubMed Central) (2020). Association of Simulated Patient Race/Ethnicity With Scheduling of Primary Care Appointments (JAMA Network Open) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo