Key takeaways
- A call becomes a telephone solicitation when it encourages someone to buy a service; recalls and reminders without a pitch usually are not[2].
- The established business relationship lasts 18 months from a visit or purchase and 3 months from an inquiry[2]. After that, scrub the registry.
- Anyone who asks your practice to stop calling goes on your own list within 10 business days and stays there for 5 years[2].
- Federal calling hours are 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. at the patient's location[3]; Florida cuts that to 8 p.m. and caps calls at three a day[4].
When a recall call turns into a sales call
Most calls a practice places are not marketing at all. Confirming tomorrow's appointment, chasing an overdue mammogram, asking a patient to reschedule a missed visit: none of that is selling. Trouble starts in two places. One is the call list that came from somewhere other than your own schedule. The other is the script that drifts from “you're due for your annual exam” to “we've just added cosmetic injections and have an introductory offer”.
The FCC rules turn on that drift. A telephone solicitation is a call or message made to encourage the purchase or rental of, or investment in, goods or services. Three kinds of calls are excluded: calls made with the person's prior express invitation or permission, calls to someone with whom you have an established business relationship, and calls by or on behalf of a tax-exempt nonprofit[2]. That relationship has a shelf life. It rests on a purchase or transaction in the 18 months before the call, or an inquiry or application in the 3 months before it[2].
So a patient seen last spring can be called about your new sleep clinic even if their number is on the national registry. A patient last seen three years ago cannot, unless you check the registry first or have their permission. The same goes for the web inquiry that came in four months ago and never booked.
Two rulebooks, one call
Practices answer to HIPAA as well as the telemarketing rules, and the two use the word “marketing” differently. HIPAA's marketing definition excludes communications for treatment and those describing the practice's own health-related services, unless a third party pays the practice to make them[5]. When a communication is marketing, HIPAA requires the patient's written authorization, with narrow exceptions for face-to-face conversations and promotional gifts of nominal value[6]. A call can pass one test and fail the other.
| Call | HIPAA | Do Not Call rules |
|---|---|---|
| Recall for a patient seen 10 months ago | Treatment communication, not marketing | Usually not a solicitation; the 18-month relationship covers it anyway |
| New service offer to a patient last seen 3 years ago | Own health-related service, no authorization needed | Solicitation with an expired relationship: scrub the registry first |
| Web inquiry from 2 months ago | Often not yet a patient | Inquiry within 3 months: relationship exists |
| Health fair sign-up sheet | Not health information if only contact details | Permission only if the sheet asked to be called; otherwise scrub |
| Purchased or rented list | Not patients | Pure solicitation: scrub against the registry and your own list |
| Product a manufacturer pays you to promote | Marketing: written authorization naming the payment | Solicitation: relationship or permission still required |
Recorded or artificial voices add a third layer: telemarketing robocalls need prior express written consent[7], and that includes voices generated by software, as covered in the FCC ruling on AI voices. Texts have their own pitfalls, set out in TCPA and marketing texts. This article stays with live calls made by staff or an agency.
Why patients report medical calls
The registry is large and people use the complaint form. The FTC counted 258,515,050 active registrations in fiscal year 2025[1]. Medical and prescription calls were the third most reported complaint topic that year, behind debt relief and imposters, with 129,076 robocall complaints and 75,236 about live callers[1].
Most of those complaints are about scam operations, not doctors' offices. That is the point: patients are primed to hear an unexpected medical sales call as a scam and to report it. A practice calling lapsed patients about a cash-pay service sounds, to a tired person at 8:30 at night, a lot like the medical-alert and pharmacy calls they already resent. The same wariness is why your own practice lines attract spam robocalls and why patients ignore numbers they do not recognize.
Scrubbing against the national registry
259 million
active registrations at the end of FY2025[1]
5 area codes
free to download before any fee applies[8]
31 days
maximum age of the registry copy you scrub against[3]
10 business days
to honor a request to stop calling[2]
5 years
how long that request must be honored[2]
Federal rules. Some states run their own lists and tighter limits.
Access is cheaper than most managers assume. The first five area codes are free; from October 1, 2026 each additional area code costs $85 a year, up to a maximum of $23,425 for the whole country[8]. Most organizations stay in the free tier: of 9,725 that accessed the registry in FY2025, 7,182 took five or fewer area codes[1]. A practice drawing patients from two or three area codes pays nothing to scrub its lists.
Scrubbing also protects you when something slips. The FCC's safe harbor for honest mistakes requires written procedures, trained staff, a maintained internal list, and a process that uses a copy of the national registry obtained no more than 31 days before the call, with records showing you did it[3]. Registrations do not expire: they are honored indefinitely until the consumer cancels or the number is removed[2]. The rules apply to mobile numbers as well as landlines[2], so “it's a cell phone” is not an exception.
Your own do-not-call list
The internal list matters more than the national one for a practice, because it binds even patients you have a relationship with. If you make telemarketing calls at all, the FCC requires a written do-not-call policy available on demand, staff trained to use the list, the request recorded at the moment it is made, and the request honored within a reasonable time of no more than 10 business days, then for 5 years. Callers must give their own name, the practice's name and a phone number or address[2].
- Example, the request: “Please stop calling me about this.”
- Example, staff reply: “Of course. I'm adding your number to our do-not-call list now. That stops calls about new services and offers. We'll still call about your own appointments and results unless you'd like those to stop too. Which would you prefer?”
- Example, the record: date, time, number, name if given, who took it and what the patient chose. Enter it in the calling system the same day, not on a sticky note.
The question at the end of that reply is worth the extra ten seconds. A patient who wants no sales calls almost never wants to miss a call about an abnormal result, and asking avoids guessing. Requests arrive by every route: on outbound calls, on the main line, at the desk, in the portal. Each route needs to reach the same list.
The written policy does not need to be long. One page that answers these points is enough for most practices, and it doubles as the training handout:
- Scope: which calls count as telemarketing at this practice, with local examples like the rows in the table above.
- Registry: who downloads it, how often, for which area codes, and where the file and each scrub record are kept.
- Internal list: how requests are taken on every channel, who enters them, the same-day target and the 5-year hold.
- Calling rules: hours by the patient's time zone, attempts per day and per campaign, and how callers identify themselves.
- Vendors: agencies and calling tools must scrub before calling and send opt-outs back to the practice.
- Training: at hire and once a year, with dates and attendees recorded.
Calling hours and state rules
Federal rules bar telephone solicitations to residential subscribers before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m., local time at the called party's location[3]. Location is where the patient is, not the area code. Patients keep numbers when they move, and winter residents answer from another time zone.
States can be stricter. Florida bars commercial telephone solicitation calls before 8 a.m. or after 8 p.m. in the called person's time zone, and more than three calls to a person on the same subject in 24 hours[4]. Florida's exemption for calling existing customers under the same business name does not lift those two limits[9]. Other states keep their own do-not-call lists and registration rules, so check every state your patients live in, and keep the timing rules for non-marketing outreach in step with legal calling hours for patient outreach.
A simple house rule covers most states: marketing calls only between 9 a.m. and 7 p.m. in the patient's time zone, no more than one attempt a day and no more than three in a campaign.
Getting it wrong is expensive. The TCPA lets people sue for their actual loss or $500 per violation, whichever is greater, and courts may increase damages for willful or knowing violations[10].
Running a reactivation campaign the right way
- System
- Your team
- SI Employee
01System
Pull the list
Patients last seen 18 to 36 months ago, with last visit dates.
02Your team
Split by relationship
Seen within 18 months: call. Older: scrub before calling.
03System
Scrub both lists
Registry copy under 31 days old, plus the internal do-not-call list.
04Your team
Call in the window
Scripted calls in the patient's time zone, caller and practice named.
05SI Employee
Return calls answered
Office questions answered; stop-calling requests noted in the summary.
06Your team
Opt-outs recorded
Every request entered on the internal list the same day.
Example sequence for live staff calls. Numbers removed by the scrub can still get a letter.
Example: a dermatology practice wants to tell 400 patients last seen two to three years ago about a new skin-check program. Their relationship has lapsed, so every number is scrubbed. Suppose 70 are on the registry and 12 are on the internal list: those 82 come off the call list and get a letter instead, and the remaining 318 are called between 9 and 7 local time. Staff log every opt-out the same day. The practice keeps the scrub file and the call log with its patient reactivation records, so it can show what it did if a complaint arrives.
Campaigns create return calls, often at awkward times. A practice that forwards its main line to an SI Employee for overflow and evenings gets those answered: it handles office questions from approved information, and a caller who says “take me off your list” has that request in the call summary emailed to the person you choose, ready for staff to add to the internal list. See what it does for the full picture. The physical therapy example shows where freed desk time can go: outbound work to existing patients, such as filling cancellations.
If an agency runs the calls, the rules still reach you, because calls made on your behalf must name your practice[2]. Put scrubbing, calling hours and opt-out handling in the contract; questions to ask a healthcare marketing agency covers the rest of that conversation.
Frequently asked questions
Do appointment reminder calls count as telemarketing?
Not when they only confirm or remind. The do-not-call rules apply to telephone solicitations, calls that encourage someone to buy goods or services[2]. Keep offers and new-service announcements out of reminder calls; reminder rules are covered in TCPA rules for appointment reminders.
Can we call a patient on the registry who was seen last year?
Yes, for the national registry: a visit or purchase within the previous 18 months creates an established business relationship, which takes the call outside the definition[2]. If that patient has asked your practice to stop calling, your internal list wins.
Are nonprofit health systems exempt?
Calls by or on behalf of a tax-exempt nonprofit are excluded from the definition of telephone solicitation[2]. Many physician practices are not tax-exempt nonprofits, so check your own status, and HIPAA's marketing rules apply either way[5].
Does the registry cover mobile numbers?
Yes. The national and internal do-not-call rules apply to telephone solicitations and telemarketing calls or texts to wireless numbers[2].
How often do we need to download the registry?
Scrub against a copy obtained no more than 31 days before each call, and keep records showing you did, to qualify for the safe harbor[3]. Monthly downloads are the simplest routine.
References
Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book, Fiscal Year 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 47 CFR § 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (opens in a new tab) ↑
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR) (current). 47 CFR 64.1200 - Delivery restrictions (calling hours and do-not-call safe harbor) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Florida Legislature (Online Sunshine) (current). Florida Statutes § 501.616 - Unlawful acts and practices (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR § 164.501 - Definitions (marketing) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR § 164.508 - Uses and disclosures for which an authorization is required (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Communications Commission (2024). FCC Makes AI-Generated Voices in Robocalls Illegal (news release) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2026). FTC Announces 2027 Telemarketer Fees to Access the National Do Not Call Registry (opens in a new tab) ↑
Florida Legislature (Online Sunshine) (current). Florida Statutes § 501.604 - Exemptions (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (current). 47 U.S. Code § 227 - Restrictions on use of telephone equipment (opens in a new tab) ↑