HIPAA and Compliance

Google Voice and Free Phone Apps: HIPAA Risks

Why free Google Voice and other calling and texting apps fall outside a practice's BAA, what they store, and safer ways to call patients from a mobile.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. How free numbers end up in a practice
  2. What these apps keep
  3. Conduit or business associate
  4. Free Google Voice versus Voice under Workspace
  5. Other free apps staff reach for
  6. What a penalty looks like
  7. Questions to put to any calling app vendor
  8. Safer setups, step by step
  9. Where an answering layer fits
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References
HIPAA and Compliance: Google Voice and Free Phone Apps: HIPAA Risks$73,011: minimum HIPAA civil penalty per violation for uncorrected willful neglect (2025 adjustment)HIPAA AND COMPLIANCEGoogle Voice and Free PhoneApps: HIPAA Risks$73,011minimum HIPAA civil penalty per violation foruncorrected willful neglect (2025 adjustment)Ava Medical IntakeInsightsHIPAA and Compliance: Google Voice and Free Phone Apps: HIPAA Risks$73,011: minimum HIPAA civil penalty per violation for uncorrected willful neglect (2025 adjustment)HIPAA AND COMPLIANCEGoogle Voice and FreePhone Apps: HIPAARisks$73,011minimum HIPAA civil penalty perviolation for uncorrected willfulneglect (2025 adjustment)Ava Medical Intake
Figure source: Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text), 2025[1]

Key takeaways

  • Google lists Google Voice in its business associate agreement for managed Workspace users only[2]; a free personal account sits outside it.
  • A phone carrier that only carries calls is a conduit. An app that keeps voicemails, transcripts or texts for you is a business associate[3].
  • Encryption helps but does not change the vendor's role; the questions are who stores the data and whether they will sign.
  • Fix it in order: inventory the apps staff use, move calls to a practice-owned line under a BAA, retire the free numbers, then train.

How free numbers end up in a practice

The free Google Voice number usually arrives for a sensible reason. A physician wants to return patient calls from her own phone without giving out her private number. A new practice needs a second line before the phone system is installed. A billing coordinator would like texts about payment plans off her personal mobile. Somebody sets up a free account in ten minutes, and two years later half the patient callbacks run through it.

Every staff member carries the hardware to do this. About 91% of US adults own a smartphone[4], and the calling apps on them are polished, free and familiar. The problem is not the call itself. It is where the call log, the voicemail, its transcript and the texts end up, who controls that account, and whether the company holding them has promised anything to your practice.

This article covers the free consumer apps: personal Google Voice, consumer messaging apps and second-line apps. The wider checklist for a practice phone system is in what makes a phone system HIPAA compliant.

What these apps keep

Most people think of a phone call as gone once it ends. Calling apps keep a surprising amount, and in a free consumer account all of it sits in the employee's personal account, not the practice's.

What a typical free calling and texting app stores. Check each app's own settings; features differ.
DataWhere it sitsWhy it matters
Call logThe app account and the phonePatient numbers, call times and durations show who called the practice
Voicemail audioThe vendor's serversPatients leave names, birth dates, medicines and symptoms
Voicemail transcriptThe vendor's servers, often emailed tooThe same details as text, searchable and easy to forward
Texts and photosThe vendor's servers and the phonePatients send pictures of rashes, wounds and insurance cards
Call recordingsThe vendor's servers, if recording is onFull clinical conversations under a personal login
Contacts and backupsPersonal cloud backups of the phoneCopies survive after the app is deleted

Google's own description of Voice for business says voicemails are transcribed to text automatically[5]. That is convenient, and it means a patient's voicemail about a medication exists in two forms on a vendor's servers. When the account belongs to an employee, the practice cannot audit it, cannot keep it when they leave and may never know it exists.

Conduit or business associate

HIPAA draws the line by what the vendor does with your data, not by what the product is called. A business associate is anyone who creates, receives, maintains or transmits protected health information on your behalf, including data transmission services that need routine access to it[6]. A practice may use one only with satisfactory assurance, in a business associate agreement, that the vendor will safeguard the information[7].

There is a narrow exception for pure carriers. In the 2013 Omnibus rule, HHS said the conduit exception is limited to transmission services, including temporary storage incident to that transmission, and that an entity that maintains protected health information for a covered entity is a business associate, not a conduit, even if it never looks at it[3]. Your mobile carrier carrying a call from one phone to another is the classic conduit. An app that keeps the voicemail, the transcript and a year of texts is not.

The test for any calling or texting app: does the vendor store anything about our patients for us, and will it sign our business associate agreement? If the answers are yes and no, the app should not carry patient calls or texts.

Encryption is a safeguard, not an exemption. A vendor that keeps patient information for you is still in a business associate role even when the data is encrypted, because the deciding fact is that it maintains the data. Some staff also remember the pandemic notice that allowed FaceTime, Facebook Messenger video, Google Hangouts, Zoom or Skype for video visits. That flexibility applied only during the COVID-19 public health emergency[8], and it is no longer a basis for using those apps.

Free Google Voice versus Voice under Workspace

Google does offer a route. Its HIPAA documentation lists β€œGoogle Voice (managed users only)” among the Workspace services included in its business associate agreement, and tells customers to enter into that agreement[2]. Voice for business is sold as an add-on that requires a Google Workspace plan, with call recording and retention through Vault among its premium features[5]. Managed users are accounts the practice's administrator controls, which is exactly what a free personal account is not.

Two kinds of Google Voice
Free personal Google VoiceVoice for managed Workspace users
Who owns the accountThe employeeThe practice's administrator
Business associate agreementNot coveredListed in Google's BAA once accepted
Settings and securityWhatever the user choosesSet and enforced by the admin
When someone leavesNumber and history leave with themAdmin keeps or reassigns the number
Retention and discoveryPersonal account history onlyVault available on premium plans

Coverage depends on the plan, the accepted agreement and how the admin configures it. A signed BAA does not configure anything by itself.

Accepting the agreement is the start, not the finish. The administrator still has to require two-step sign-in, decide whether recording and transcription are on, set how long records are kept and bring the setup into the practice's security risk assessment. The same applies to any phone or texting vendor; the vendor BAA checklist lists the questions to ask.

Other free apps staff reach for

  • Consumer messaging apps. Popular because patients already use them. The vendor is not your business associate, and chats sync to personal backups and other devices.
  • Built-in phone texting. Messages sit on the employee's phone and its cloud backup; nothing is visible to the practice and nothing can be retrieved when they leave.
  • Second-line and burner apps. Cheap or free numbers that ring on a personal phone, often with voicemail transcription and texting that the practice never sees.
  • Free video tools. Fine for a staff meeting, not for visits or patient calls without an agreement. Use the telehealth platform the practice has signed with.
  • Caller ID blocking. Dialing star-67 from a personal phone hides the number and keeps the call on the ordinary carrier service, so it avoids the app problem, but the call log stays on the personal phone and many patients ignore blocked numbers.

Texting is where these apps cause the most trouble, because patients send photos and staff reply in the moment. The rules for what a practice may text, and how, are in texting patients and HIPAA, and leaving messages is covered in voicemails for patients.

What a penalty looks like

Civil money penalties rise steeply with what the practice knew. Under the 2025 inflation adjustment, the minimum per violation runs from $145 when the practice did not know, to $1,461 for reasonable cause, $14,602 for willful neglect corrected within 30 days and $73,011 for willful neglect left uncorrected, with a calendar-year cap of $2,190,294 per provision[1].

Minimum HIPAA civil penalty per violation, by tier (2025)Inflation-adjusted minimums. Calendar-year cap per provision: $2,190,294.
Minimum HIPAA civil penalty per violation, by tier (2025)Column chart. Did not know: $145; Reasonable cause: $1,461; Willful neglect, corrected: $14,602; Willful neglect, not corrected: $73,011.$0$20,000$40,000$60,000$80,000Did not know: $145$145Did not knowReasonable cause: $1,461$1,461Reasonable causeWillful neglect, corrected: $14,602$14,602Willful neglect,correctedWillful neglect, not corrected: $73,011$73,011Willful neglect, notcorrectedMinimum HIPAA civil penalty per violation, by tier (2025)Column chart. Did not know: $145; Reasonable cause: $1,461; Willful neglect, corrected: $14,602; Willful neglect, not corrected: $73,011.Did not knowDid not know: $145$145Reasonable causeReasonable cause: $1,461$1,461Willful neglect, correctedWillful neglect, corrected: $14,602$14,602Willful neglect, not correctedWillful neglect, not corrected: $73,011$73,011

Source: Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text), 2025[1]

Show the data
Culpability tierMinimum per violation
Did not know$145
Reasonable cause$1,461
Willful neglect, corrected$14,602
Willful neglect, not corrected$73,011

The tiers are the practical point. A practice that never knew a physician was texting patients from a free app is in a very different position from one whose manager noticed, said nothing and let it run for a year. Once anyone in authority knows, the clock is effectively running, so the inventory below is worth doing even if it surfaces something awkward.

Questions to put to any calling app vendor

Whether the candidate is Google, your phone system's mobile app or a specialist healthcare calling tool, the same short list separates a real option from a free app with a healthcare landing page.

  • Will you sign our business associate agreement, and which products and plans does it cover? Get the list in writing.
  • What do you store about our calls and texts: logs, voicemail audio, transcripts, messages, recordings? For how long, and can we change that?
  • Who controls the accounts: our administrator, or each user?
  • Can we switch off transcription, recording and forwarding of voicemails to personal email?
  • What happens to a number and its history when we remove a user?
  • Where are the audit logs, and can we export them when we need to show who accessed what?

If the inventory turns up patient texts and voicemails in personal accounts, do not simply delete them. Ask the privacy officer to judge whether anything was exposed, for example on a lost phone or a shared login, under the breach notification steps. Copy anything that belongs in the medical record into the chart, then close the account.

Safer setups, step by step

  1. Inventory what people use

    Ask every clinician and staff member, without blame, which apps and numbers they use to call or text patients. Include personal mobiles, second-line apps and messaging apps.

  2. Choose a practice-owned route

    Use a business phone system or calling app with a signed BAA that rings on staff mobiles and shows the practice number, or Voice for managed Workspace users under Google's agreement.

  3. Configure before anyone uses it

    Require two-step sign-in, set a phone lock, decide on recording and transcription, set retention and remove personal call forwarding.

  4. Retire the free numbers

    Change the free number's greeting to point to the main line, stop texting from it and close it once callers have moved. Do not delete history the practice may need.

  5. Write it down and train

    Add one line to the policy: patient calls and texts go through practice-approved apps only. Train it, and apply your sanctions policy if it is ignored.

Example: a three-physician practice finds that two doctors return after-hours calls from free Google Voice numbers and the nurse texts lab reminders from her own phone. The manager moves all three onto the practice's business phone app, which rings on their mobiles, shows the main number and is covered by the phone vendor's BAA. The old Voice numbers get a greeting giving the main number, and texting moves to the practice's reminder system. Passwords and two-step sign-in follow the workstation rules, and the whole change is recorded as a risk analysis update.

Where an answering layer fits

Many practices adopt free numbers because the main line is overwhelmed and clinicians start working around it. Fixing the overflow problem removes the reason for the workaround. When a practice forwards its main number to an SI Employee for overflow or after hours, callers get office answers immediately and anything patient-specific goes to the staff line the practice chooses.

Be clear about the boundary. AssistCall does not sign business associate agreements today, so the SI Employee is set up to answer hours, directions, insurance-accepted and new-patient questions and hand everything else to staff without taking health details. Clinical callbacks should stay on a line covered by your phone vendor's agreement. The after-hours specialty example shows that split, and the product overview explains how forwarding is set up.

Frequently asked questions

Is Google Voice HIPAA compliant?

No app is compliant by itself. Google lists Google Voice for managed Workspace users in its business associate agreement[2], so a practice can use that version once the agreement is in place and the account is configured. A free personal Google Voice account is not covered.

Can a doctor return patient calls from a personal Google Voice number?

Not safely. The account belongs to the doctor, voicemails and transcripts sit with the vendor outside any agreement with the practice, and the history leaves when the doctor does. Use a practice-owned calling app with a BAA that shows the practice number.

Does turning off voicemail transcription solve the problem?

It reduces what is stored but does not change the vendor's role. Call logs, voicemail audio and texts are still kept, and a vendor that maintains patient information for you is a business associate even if it never views it[3].

Is our mobile carrier a business associate?

A carrier that only transmits calls falls under the conduit exception, which covers transmission and temporary storage incident to it[3]. Extra services that store data for you, such as visual voicemail or cloud messaging, need a closer look.

What about texting patients from an iPhone or Android?

Messages sit on the employee's device and personal backup, where the practice cannot see, keep or delete them. Move patient texting to a practice system covered by a business associate agreement[7].

References

  1. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (2025). 45 CFR Β§ 102.3 - Penalty adjustment and table (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Google Cloud (2026). HIPAA compliance on Google Cloud and Google Workspace (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2013). Modifications to the HIPAA Privacy, Security, Enforcement, and Breach Notification Rules (Final Rule, 78 FR 5566, January 25, 2013) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Pew Research Center (2026). Americans' Use of Mobile Devices in 2026 (Mobile Fact Sheet) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Google Workspace (2026). Google Voice: a flexible cloud phone system (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR Β§ 160.103 - Definitions (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations text) (current). 45 CFR Β§ 164.502 - Uses and disclosures of protected health information: General rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights (Federal Register via GovInfo) (2020). Notification of Enforcement Discretion for Telehealth Remote Communications During the COVID-19 Nationwide Public Health Emergency (85 FR 22024) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo