Key takeaways
- Only 19% of adults generally pick up calls from unknown numbers, but 67% check voicemail when one is left[1]. The voicemail is your real first contact.
- Tell patients before they leave who will call, from which number and in what window. An expected call from a saved number is not an unknown call.
- Call from the number printed on your cards and signage, never from a blocked line or a staff member's own phone.
- A short text naming the practice and the calling number turns a stranger's call into an expected one, within the FCC's limits for health care texts[2].
- Plan for the call back: it should reach a person or a clear next step, not a full voicemail box.
The call nobody picks up
The usual pattern runs like this. A referral coordinator calls a patient at 2:10 pm, hears the voicemail greeting, leaves a message and moves on to the next name on the list. The patient sees a number they don't know, lets it ring and listens to the message at 6:40, after the phones have closed. The next morning both sides try again, and the referral slips another day.
That is the normal outcome, not bad luck. In Pew Research Center's survey of 10,211 adults, only 19% said they generally answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers. Another 67% said their habit is to let the call go and check voicemail if one is left, and 14% ignore the voicemail as well[1]. A consumer survey cited by the FCC in 2025 found 90% of consumers uncomfortable answering unidentified calls, and 78% said they had missed an important call in the past month for that reason[3].
- Generally answer 19%
- Don't answer, check voicemail 67%
- Don't answer, ignore voicemail 14%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2020[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Generally answer | 19% |
| Don't answer, check voicemail | 67% |
| Don't answer, ignore voicemail | 14% |
Health calls carry extra suspicion. Medical and prescription pitches were among the most reported topics in Do Not Call complaints in fiscal 2025, with 129,076 complaints about robocalls and 75,236 about live callers[4]. Scammers also fake real health numbers: the HHS Office of Inspector General has warned that callers alter caller ID so their calls appear to come from its published phone numbers[5]. A patient who lets your call ring out is doing exactly what they have been told to do. The fix is to make your call expected, recognizable and easy to return.
Who you are actually calling
Nearly every patient you call is holding a mobile phone with call screening one tap away. In the second half of 2024, 78.0% of adults were wireless-only, with their own cellphone and no landline at home. That held for nearly nine in ten adults aged 25 to 44 and for 57.9% of adults 65 and older[6]. The landline in the kitchen that an older patient answered out of habit is disappearing too.
Pew found adults under 30, Hispanic and Black adults, and people in lower-income households somewhat more likely to pick up an unknown number, but no group came close to a majority[1]. Plan the outreach as if voicemail and text are the main channels and a live answer is a bonus.
Start with the number on file. Ask at every visit which number and which channel the patient wants, as set out in capturing patient contact preferences. A patient may also ask to be reached only at a particular number or by a particular method; a covered provider must accommodate reasonable requests of that kind[7], and handling confidential communications requests covers how to flag them so nobody calls the wrong phone.
Tell them the call is coming
The cheapest fix happens before the patient leaves the building. Whoever closes the visit tells the patient who will call, from which number and roughly when, and asks them to save the number. The call that arrives on Thursday then shows a name on the screen, or at least a number the patient was told to expect.
Example checkout script: “Dana from our referral desk will call you by Thursday afternoon about the specialist appointment. The call comes from 555-0142, which is our main number. Could you save it now as Brindle Lane Family Medicine? Then you'll know it's us.”
- After-visit summary: print the callback number and the window (“between 1 and 4 pm tomorrow”), not “we'll be in touch soon”.
- Portal message: when a result or referral is pending, post a line saying a call is coming and from which number.
- New-patient confirmations: put the practice number in the email and the paper welcome letter, with a request to save it as a contact.
- Front desk: keep a card or sign with the main number at checkout so patients can add it while they wait.
- Pending callbacks: note in the chart what the patient was told, so whoever calls keeps the promise.
Show a number they recognize
Call from the number on your website, signage and appointment cards. Many phone systems send each extension's direct line as caller ID by default, so the nurse line or the billing office shows up as a number the patient has never seen. Set outbound caller ID on every extension that calls patients to the main number, or to a department number you print on visit summaries, and check that the number rings somewhere useful when the patient calls back.
| Setup | What the patient sees | Where the call back goes | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main practice number on every extension | The number on cards, signage and the website | Main line, then its after-hours path | Default for most outreach |
| Department direct line | A number they have never seen unless you printed it | That desk, often its voicemail | Fine if printed on the visit summary |
| Staff member's own cellphone | A personal number they may save and reuse | That person's phone, at any hour | Avoid |
| Blocked number (*67) | “No Caller ID” or “Unknown” | Nowhere | Avoid |
| Toll-free number | A number that reads as a call center | Wherever it is routed | Only if patients know it |
Carriers do check the number you display. Since June 30, 2021, voice providers have had to run STIR/SHAKEN caller ID authentication in their IP networks[8], which lets the receiving carrier confirm that a caller is entitled to the number it shows. The name is less dependable. The FCC says the caller name databases most phones rely on are not reliably accurate and can be manipulated[3], so don't assume the practice name appears. When it does, it helps: in a survey the FCC cited, 73% of consumers said they would answer if the caller's name were shown, 76% with a name and logo, and 78% if the reason for the call also appeared[3]. Ask your phone vendor what name display and branded calling options it supports.
If patients tell you your calls show up as “Spam Likely”, that is a separate problem with its own fixes, covered in why practice calls get flagged as spam. And if clinicians return calls from their own phones after hours, read calling patients from a personal cell phone before the next on-call week.
Send a text before or after the call
A short text bridges the gap between an unknown number and a trusted one. For automated health care texts to a patient's mobile number, the FCC's exemption sets the frame: send only to the number the patient gave you, state the practice's name and contact details, stick to purposes such as appointment reminders, lab result notices, post-discharge follow-up and prescription notifications, keep billing and marketing out, stay within 160 characters and one message a day or three a week, and offer a STOP opt-out[2].
Example heads-up text: “Brindle Lane Family Medicine will call you today between 2 and 4 pm from 555-0142 about your recent visit. Reply STOP to opt out.” Example follow-up after a missed call: “Brindle Lane Family Medicine tried to reach you. Please call 555-0142, Mon-Fri 8-5. Reply STOP to opt out.”
Texts go out from a registered business number, which is its own project; 10DLC registration for medical practices explains what carriers check. Collect consent and the preferred number together at registration, as in text consent at registration, and keep the reason vague: “about your recent visit”, never the test or the diagnosis.
Voicemail that gets a call back
Two-thirds of adults screen the call and then listen to the message[1], so the voicemail is where most outreach actually lands. Write it as a script the whole team uses rather than improvising it twenty times a day. What a message may contain is covered in leaving voicemails for patients under HIPAA; the steps below are about getting the call returned.
Lead with the practice name
“This is Dana calling from Brindle Lane Family Medicine.” The practice name in the first five seconds is what keeps the message from being deleted as another sales call.
Give a reason that reveals nothing clinical
“I'm calling about your recent visit” or “about the appointment you asked us to arrange”. Never the test, the result or the specialty.
Say the number twice, slowly, with hours
“Please call 555-0142. That's 555-0142, Monday to Friday, 8 to 5.” Use the same number the call came from, or patients will doubt which one is real.
Name who to ask for and how long it takes
“Ask for Dana in referrals. It takes about two minutes.” A short, specific task gets done; an open-ended one waits.
Add a deadline only when there is one
“We need to hear back by Friday to hold the slot with the specialist.” Invented urgency teaches patients to ignore the next message.
Say what happens next
“If we don't connect, we'll send a message in your patient portal tomorrow.” The patient knows where to look, and you have a second channel ready.
Example full message, about 20 seconds: “Hi, this is Dana from Brindle Lane Family Medicine, calling for Maria about her recent visit. Please call us at 555-0142, that's 555-0142, Monday to Friday, 8 to 5, and ask for Dana in referrals. If we don't connect, we'll send a portal message tomorrow. Thanks.”
A contact sequence that respects the patient's day
- Your team
- System
- Caller
01Your team
Pre-announce at checkout
Who will call, from which number, and the window, before the patient leaves.
02System
Heads-up text
Practice name, call window and the calling number, sent that morning.
03Your team
Call from the main number
One attempt inside the promised window, with the scripted voicemail.
04Caller
Patient calls back
Returns the call at lunch; the main line rings the referral desk first.
05Your team
Second try, new time of day
If still unreached: next day, different hour, then a portal message.
Example sequence. Document every attempt in the chart, including the channel and what was said.
Vary the time of day on the second attempt. Someone on a daytime shift cannot pick up at 2 pm but may answer at 8:05 am or after 5. Stay inside your own calling hours and any state limits; calling hours for patient outreach sets those out. Decide in advance how many attempts each kind of message gets before it is closed out with a letter or portal note, the subject of how many times to call a patient.
One more reason to keep voicemails neutral: numbers change hands. A patient who switched carriers or let a line lapse may have left you with someone else's phone, and reassigned numbers explains how practices check before automated outreach.
Make the call back count
All of this fails if the patient's return call hits a busy signal or a full mailbox. Returned calls bunch up at lunch and in the first hour after work, exactly when the desk is thinnest. Put the staff member's first name and department in every voicemail so whoever answers knows where to send the call, keep the day's open outreach list where the front desk can see it, and close the loop as described in building a patient callback system.
Some practices forward the main line to an SI Employee for lunch, overflow and after hours so returned calls are always answered in the practice's name. It answers office questions from the information the practice approves, puts patient-specific calls through to the staff line you choose and takes no health details. If nobody picks up the transfer, it tells the caller plainly and saves an urgent message with their name and number, which reaches your inbox by email with the recording and transcript (what it does). The family practice morning-rush example shows how that overflow is set up and which calls stay with staff.
Frequently asked questions
Should we block our caller ID when calling patients?
No. Carriers must honor *67 as a request to withhold your number[9], so the patient sees “No Caller ID” or “Unknown”, the kind of call most people already ignore[1]. It also leaves them no number to call back. Show the main practice number instead.
How many times should we call before giving up?
Set the number by message type and write it down. A common pattern is two or three calls at different times of day plus a portal message or letter, each documented. Our guide to contact attempts before closing out covers the policy.
Can we text instead of calling?
For many routine messages, yes, if the patient gave you the number and your texts stay within the FCC's health care exemption: practice name and contact details, a permitted purpose, 160 characters or less, limited frequency and a STOP opt-out[2].
What should the voicemail say about the reason for the call?
As little as possible: “about your recent visit” or “about the appointment you asked us to arrange”. Leave out tests, results and specialties. See voicemails under HIPAA for the rules.
Will patients see our practice name on their screen?
Sometimes. Name display depends on databases the FCC describes as not reliably accurate[3], so tell patients the number and ask them to save it rather than relying on the name to appear.
References
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (National Archives) (2026). 47 CFR 64.1200: Delivery restrictions (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Communications Commission (2025). Advanced Methods to Target and Eliminate Unlawful Robocalls; Call Authentication Trust Anchor (FCC 25-76) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Federal Trade Commission (2025). National Do Not Call Registry Data Book, Fiscal Year 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General (2025). Fraud Alert: HHS-OIG Telephone Numbers Used in Scam (opens in a new tab) ↑
CDC National Center for Health Statistics (2025). Wireless Substitution: Early Release of Estimates from the National Health Interview Survey, July-December 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 45 CFR § 164.522 - Rights to request privacy protection for protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 47 CFR § 64.6301 - Caller ID authentication (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 47 CFR § 64.1601 - Delivery requirements and privacy restrictions (opens in a new tab) ↑