Key takeaways
- Paper copies may cost no more than 75 cents a page, and never more than the provider's actual costs[1].
- For a patient's own copy, HIPAA's cost-based limit usually brings the real fee far below the cap[2].
- No charge for records that support a claim or appeal for any government benefit, and no denial solely because a person cannot pay[1].
- Patients get a chance to inspect within 10 days of a written request; copies are due within a reasonable time, so HIPAA's 30 days is the working outer limit[1][2].
The cap and the costs behind it
New York writes its copy-fee rule into the Public Health Law in plain numbers: a provider may charge a reasonable amount for copies, no more than the costs it incurs, and paper copies may not exceed 75 cents a page[1]. Most offices stop reading at the 75 cents. That figure is a ceiling on paper, nothing more. The actual-cost limit applies to every copy, and when patients ask for their own records HIPAA narrows the fee further, to the labor, supplies and postage involved[2].
The gap between the two is not small. On a long paper chart the 75-cent ceiling runs to a few hundred dollars, while the cost of printing it is a fraction of that. Price every request at the ceiling and a practice can be over the legal limit on nearly every patient request without anyone noticing, until a complaint arrives.
Source: New York State Senate, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Pages copied | Maximum charge |
|---|---|
| 10 pages | $7.5 |
| 50 pages | $37.5 |
| 100 pages | $75 |
| 250 pages | $187.5 |
| 500 pages | $375 |
Read the chart as an upper bound for paper only. The statute gives no per-page figure for electronic copies, so the costs-incurred test is the whole rule for them[1], and HIPAA's labor-only approach for a patient's own request means most portal exports cost very little to produce[2].
Who can ask under sections 18 and 17
New York has two access statutes that front desks tend to blur together. Section 18 covers inspection and copies for a qualified person, and that list is specific: a properly identified patient, a court-appointed guardian, a parent of a minor, a distributee of a deceased patient who has no personal representative, and an attorney who holds a power of attorney explicitly authorizing them to request the records[1]. Section 17 covers a patient's written request to send x-rays, medical records and test results to another physician or hospital, with the physician's personal notes excluded[3].
Both sections carry the same 75-cent paper cap, both bar refusing a release solely because the person cannot pay, and both waive the charge for government benefit claims[1][3]. A lawyer writing with only a signed patient authorization is not on the qualified-person list. Handle that as a third-party release and run it through the checks in records requests from attorneys and third parties. Transfers to a doctor taking over care look different from the receiving end; getting prior records for new patients covers that side of the same exchange.
Ten days to inspect, thirty days to copy
New York sets a short clock for one thing. After a written request, the patient must be given an opportunity to inspect their records within ten days[1]. For copies the statute says only within a reasonable time[1]. Where state law names no number, HIPAA's limit is the one that binds: act within 30 days of receipt, with one 30-day extension if you send a written reason and a completion date inside the first 30[2]. A state rule that gives patients greater access is not displaced by HIPAA[4], so the ten-day inspection window stands alongside the federal copy deadline. The full federal workflow is in patient records requests and the 30-day right of access.
Day 0
A written request arrives. Log the date it reached the practice, not the day records staff opened it.
Day 10
Last day to offer the patient a chance to inspect their records under section 18.[1]
10 days
If access is denied and the person asks for a review, the file goes to the state review committee within ten days of that request.[1]
Day 30
HIPAA's outer limit for copies, with one 30-day extension backed by a written reason.[2]
Day counts run from receipt of the written request, except the review step, which runs from the request for review.
When the charge is zero
Two rules either remove the fee or stop it from blocking access. First, no charge may be imposed for patient information requested to support an application, claim or appeal for any government benefit or program[1]. That covers the Social Security disability packets that land in every primary care and specialty office, and it applies to section 17 transfers as well[3]. Second, a qualified person may not be denied access solely because they cannot pay[1]. You can still bill the permitted charge. You cannot make the copy wait for it when the person cannot afford it.
Build both rules into the workflow so they do not depend on memory. A checkbox on the request log for a government benefit claim stops an invoice from going out by habit, and one line in the desk script about inability to pay stops a well-meaning receptionist from telling a patient the records will go out once the payment clears.
Pricing a copy the way the law expects
Example: a three-physician internal medicine practice in Rochester receives a patient's signed request for a 140-page paper copy, mailed. The section 18 ceiling is $105, 140 pages at 75 cents[1]. Printing, checking and packing takes a receptionist about 35 minutes. At the New York State median wage for receptionists, $20.71 an hour in May 2025[5], that labor costs about $12.08. Add the paper and postage the practice actually pays. That total, not $105, is what the patient can be charged[2]. If the patient takes a portal download instead, ten minutes of export time costs about $3.45, and many practices simply charge nothing.
Requests from people other than the patient change the arithmetic. A transfer to another physician or hospital under section 17 is limited to a reasonable charge, with paper capped at 75 cents a page[3]. For the patient's own request, though, the HIPAA cost-based fee sits on top of the state cap[2]. That is why one per-page rate for everyone almost always overcharges patients. The permitted cost categories are broken down line by line in what you can charge for record copies.
| Request | Statute | Most you may charge |
|---|---|---|
| Patient wants a paper copy of their own records | Public Health Law 18 and HIPAA | Actual labor, supplies and postage, never above 75 cents a page |
| Patient wants an electronic copy | Public Health Law 18 and HIPAA | Labor to produce it, plus media only if the patient asked for it |
| Records to support a government benefit claim or appeal | Public Health Law 18 or 17 | Nothing |
| Patient asks you to send records to another doctor or hospital | Public Health Law 17 | A reasonable charge, paper capped at 75 cents a page |
| Attorney holding a power of attorney that authorizes the request | Public Health Law 18 | Actual cost, paper capped at 75 cents a page |
| Attorney or insurer with only a signed authorization | Outside the qualified-person list | Follow your third-party release policy |
Where New York fee schedules go wrong
- One per-page rate for patients, lawyers and insurers alike. A patient's own request carries HIPAA's cost-based limit on top of the state cap[2].
- A per-page charge on electronic copies, carried over from the paper schedule. The 75-cent figure is written for paper[1].
- Search, retrieval or processing fees added to patient requests. HIPAA's patient fee covers labor for copying, supplies, postage and an agreed summary, and nothing else[2].
- An invoice on a disability or other government benefit request that should have gone out free[1].
- A copy service whose default rate card was built for attorney requests and never adjusted for patients.
- Holding a section 17 transfer to a new doctor until the fee clears, when a release cannot be refused solely for inability to pay[3].
Each of these shows up in a quick review of last month's invoices. Pull ten requests, recompute every fee from the schedule and the statute, and fix the template that produced the error rather than the individual bills. If an outside copy service handles requests for you, ask it for the same ten recalculations; its rate card goes out under your practice's name.
Denials and the review committee
Access can be refused only on narrow grounds: when reviewing the information can reasonably be expected to cause substantial and identifiable harm to the patient or others[1]. The person must be told about the denial and about their right to a review at no cost. If they ask for one, the provider sends the information to the state's medical record access review committee within ten days, and the committee decides in writing[1]. The front desk's job is to recognize a request, log it and route anything unusual to the privacy officer, never to make the call itself.
Physicians have a licensing reason to take this seriously. Failing to give qualified persons access in line with section 18 is listed as professional misconduct in the Education Law[6]. That sits alongside federal HIPAA enforcement, and alongside New York's separate breach and data security duties, which are covered in the SHIELD Act guide for medical offices.
What the phones should say
Fee questions reach the phone long before the request reaches the records desk: how much will my records cost, can you just email them, do I have to come in. A clear, approved answer prevents the two most common problems, a patient quoted a per-page price for a PDF and a patient told to pay before anything is released.
Script: You can request your records in writing, and you can choose paper or an electronic copy. An electronic copy through our portal costs little or nothing. Paper copies are priced at our actual cost, never more than 75 cents a page, and there is no charge if the records are for a Social Security or other government benefit claim. We will tell you the total before we send anything.
Answers like these are office information a practice signs off once, which makes them a good fit for whatever covers the phone during the morning rush, including an SI Employee that takes no health details and passes patient-specific requests to the staff line the practice chooses. The modelled family practice morning-rush example shows office questions such as the fax number being separated from calls that need a person, and AssistCall's overview shows how the forwarded-line setup works.
A New York fee schedule in six steps
Split requests by type
Patient copies, section 17 transfers, government benefit requests and third-party releases each get their own line on the schedule.
Time the work
Measure how long a paper copy and an electronic export really take, for a short record and a long one.
Price paper at cost, then cap it
Labor, supplies and postage, then confirm the result never exceeds 75 cents a page.
Price electronic copies at labor
No per-page figure. Many practices set portal delivery at no charge because the fee would cost more to collect than it brings in.
Mark the zero-fee cases
Government benefit claims are free, and inability to pay never delays a release.
Write it down and review it
Put the statute citations on the schedule, train the desk to quote from it, and recheck it every year and whenever the records system or copy vendor changes.
Frequently asked questions
Can a New York doctor charge 75 cents a page for an electronic copy?
The 75-cent figure caps paper copies[1]. Electronic copies are limited to the provider's actual costs, and for a patient's own request HIPAA allows only the labor, any portable media the patient asked for and postage[2].
Can a practice refuse to release records until the patient pays?
A qualified person may not be denied access solely because of inability to pay[1], and the same applies to transfers to another physician or hospital under section 17[3].
Are records for a Social Security disability claim free in New York?
Yes. No charge may be imposed for patient information requested to support an application, claim or appeal for any government benefit or program[1].
How long does a New York provider have to send copies?
Section 18 says within a reasonable time[1]. HIPAA sets the outer limit at 30 days from receipt, with one 30-day extension if you give a written reason[2]. Inspection must be offered within ten days of a written request[1].
Do lawyers pay the same 75 cents a page?
An attorney holding a power of attorney that explicitly authorizes the request is a qualified person under section 18, so section 18's limits apply[1]. A lawyer with only a patient authorization falls outside that list; handle the request under your third-party release policy.
References
New York State Senate (2026). New York Public Health Law § 18, Access to patient information (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2014). 45 CFR § 164.524, Access of individuals to protected health information (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York State Senate (2026). New York Public Health Law § 17, Release of medical records (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2013). 45 CFR § 160.202, Definitions (more stringent state law) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics: receptionists and information clerks, New York State, median hourly wage (series OEUS360000000000043417108) (opens in a new tab) ↑
New York State Senate (2026). New York Education Law § 6530, Definitions of professional misconduct (opens in a new tab) ↑